Garden City, Pennsylvania
469 customer reviews
Mike Mignogna
Good food but a little pricey.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Linda Eng
Great service, good food and friendly waitresses.
Reviewed on Facebook
Renee Moore
Excellent service. Great food. Friendly staff.
Reviewed on Facebook
Terra Wright
The food is absolutely delicious!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ross Heilman
Loved it
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bill Nott
Excellent food great service very nice evening
Reviewed on Facebook
Jenna Wolfe
Great service and excellent food. Always a wonderful experience
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kari J
Great food and atmosphere
Reviewed on Google Maps
wendy dunlap
The food is great and the service was above and beyond!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kevin Jupena
The atmosphere was nice gave you the feeling that it's a nice upscale restaurant. The Pasta Primavera, seemed a little on the bland side of things. It tasted as if they used regular oil like granola oil or vegetable oil not olive oil. It leads me to really consider another try. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cheryl Kuntz Bronowicz
10/16/2019 We had a small wedding in the private dining room at the beginning of October and were very pleased with everything. Kaitlin and her team did an amazing job! Kaitlin was very helpful with the planning and the servers were very attentive to our guests. The drinks, appetizers and dinner were served with great timing and everyone enjoyed their meal. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone planning a private event. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
ウイーバー アマンダ
My boyfriend and I had a reservation last weekend and the food was PHENOMENAL! The staff was very friendly, helpful, and professional as well. We will definitely be back. You guys just made yourselves 2 new customers. God bless! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
69er
This was our 1st visit to The Wooden Nickel, & we were disappointed. The entrees were very different from other restaurants. There wasn’t a great choice of vegetables or potatoes. The waitress seemed distracted and kept forgetting to get us refills on our drinks, we had to ask for bread, etc.Sadly the place was fairly empty. Maybe a Sunday night was a bad choice to go there. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
Maya
We had a perfect experience both times we went to this restaurant.You can be sure the food will be great.
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Staff was extremely attentive. Food was good but no vegetarian selections
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
It was a lovely experience we had a great table, our waitress Kim was knowledgeable about the menu and extremely friendly and attentive.
Reviewed on Opentable
TedK
Fine restaurant.xxxxcccccccccxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Reviewed on Opentable
Michelle Dambrosio
Thank you Kim for your wonderful service this evening ! My family and I really enjoyed everything!! It really was fantastic Thank you Mary Lou for taking some pictures for me ! ! Thank you Victor and whoever else was in that kitchen !!! Food was delicious More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Keisha Lucas
Food was delicious. Staff is friendly and accommodating.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Raymond
Service was just right. Prompt, but not intrusive. Food was very good. The Wooden Nickel was not to crowded so we were able to have 2 1/2 hours of conversation in a very nice atmosphere. I'd go back again.
Reviewed on Opentable
Martha Price
Excellent food and service. Definitely worth the copper penny.
Reviewed on Google Maps
NathanL
Amazing food service and environment. Plenty of food for the price.
Reviewed on Opentable
KTAM
Lovely place...good service. The food was good, but not exceptional.
Reviewed on Opentable
Michele Roper
Iconic Monroeville restaurant. Great place for a casual drink or head on over to the dining room for date night. The wine flights always change and offer a fun way to sample new offerings. I totally loved the scallops, seared to perfection. We were very lucky, Judi Figel and Dave Crisci were performing in the lounge. Love it when they have entertainment. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jarrett Manhart
One of the best fine dinning places. There wine diners and and other special events are awesome
Reviewed on Google Maps
Frederick Kuehner
A nice place
Reviewed on Google Maps
Wayne Palmer
Great Service...Great Food
Reviewed on Facebook
Elise Evangelist
Great food, service and atmosphere!
Reviewed on Google Maps
GinnyP
Lunch with a friend, wanted a place to have quiet conversation, this was perfect. Food was excellent and service was great. I really enjoy this restaurant, and love their house vinagrette salad dressing. Staff is wonderful, easy to get to, easy to park and get inside. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
Bre5
Great service. Great food. Great birthday lunch or dinner location. Beautiful interior decorations and design.
Reviewed on Opentable
EarlK
Exceptional food and service. A little loud but not a deal breaker.
Reviewed on Opentable
Charlotte Davis
Service was beyond great. The food was excellent and atmosphere calming.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Terry Sullivan
Jen does a great job and brings in the best people!
Reviewed on Google Maps
hungrydoc
We both enjoyed our meals and the service was good. This is an expensive restaurant for the Pittsburgh area and you can find similar fare at a lower price.
Reviewed on Opentable
GinnyP
We celebrated Father's Day at Wooden Nickel with a family dinner. Everyone found something that was perfect for their tastes. The special that night was lamb chops - pricey, but well worth it. The best lamb chops we've ever had, and the portions were huge, cooked to perfection.I've always loved their salads and the house dressing, a champagne vinegrette that is one of my favorite dressings of any restaurant. For those who ordered seafood, it was super fresh, and cooked just right.It's a great old world style restaurant, with white table clothes, excellent service and an incredible meal. A great place to celebrate any special occasoin. The service is truly impeccable. We'll be back for the next celebration. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
mike joseph
Great service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joann Parme
Service was great... Food was delicious.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ronna Adams
Food and service was great...Thank you kim for such wonderful service !!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Heidi Blick
Food was really good! Staff was nice
Reviewed on Google Maps
peter hansen
Gret service qnd fantqastic food. Nice wine selection
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nicole Bledsoe
Loved the service, bartender was great!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
John Hughes
Good food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Golfer1
BirthdayFood and staff were great
Reviewed on Opentable
AbbyGG
We had reservations for 11:00 am on a Sunday. There was confusion with the opening and we didn't get seated for about 15 minutes or so. As we were in no rush, we just waited. Not a complaint, actually, just an observation. Certainly no complaints about the service or the food. We were the only customers in the place for a while and it was great to be able to relax, chat, eat very good food. Will definitely go back again. There were three of us who each drove 35-45 minutes to get there; it was worth it. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
PattiW
Excellent meal and excellent service! They made a point of mentioning that we were celebrating our anniversary and they could not have been more attentive.
Reviewed on Opentable
BlakeC
My girlfriend brought me here for my birthday, I had never been to the wooden Nickel. I was pleasantly surprised, the outside of the building is deceiving. Once I got inside I was surprised how nice it was. Honestly it was the best steak I’ve had and the service was fantastic. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
CandaceO
Service was great and we were all happy with our meals.
Reviewed on Opentable
Rhonda Rocco
yes we had a great dinner and wonderful service!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jason Gentilcore
great food and service. Will definitely keep coming back.
Reviewed on Facebook
LavonneW
I love The Wooden Nickel; I used to think it was our secret place..but now it’s become very popular which is great!!! Great food & atmosphere!!
Reviewed on Opentable