Simeon's Ithaca
Ithaca, New York
(100)
Ithaca, New York
(100)
100 customer reviews
Saqib Hussain
Great place to bring your loved ones and enjoy variety of delicious dishes. The chicken parmigiana is especially to be had. Staff is courteous and attentive.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alfonsina S.
We are in town for a conference and this place is pretty much across the street from my hotel. I had the steamed mussels and the kettle chips with cheese fondue. My server was quick friendly and kept checking in on me to make sure I had everything that I needed. The food was very tasty. Definitely want to go back. A true gem More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jose Luis Bastidas Gaviria
Exelente
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark M.
Tasty brunch with good service and lots to choose from. Outside seating on the commons was great (except for the bees!).
Reviewed on Yelp
Bunny Oliver
Absolutely wonderful! We had the iced shellfish plateau and shared it with the kettle fries. Delicious! !
Reviewed on Google Maps
Adam D.
Dad and I went here for dinner. What appeared to be the fanciest place in town certainly met our expectations. The ambience is pretty intimate with a nice clean white and blue look. The service was pretty good, the food fantastic, and the prices slightly outrageous for Ithaca, New York. I get that Ithaca is home to a private college and Ivy League university, but Simeon is getting away with charging Manhattan prices, with apparent success. We split a dozen oysters to start. They have quite a selection and they let you order individually, so we tried two of three different kinds. Delicious, but how can you screw up oysters? Dad had the cup of chowder and red curry mussels as his main. I tried both and could easily see why he was in love. The chowder was on point and the mussels had a nice kick.I went with the seabass topped with artichoke over mashed potato and broccoli. The sea bass was cooked perfectly, but I wasn't blown away by the creativity or flavor profile for $42.Overall, the food was very good and the service was more friendly that attentive, but my biggest gripe is the acoustics in the main dining room a half-level up to the right of the entrance. It gets so loud to the point where you can't even hear. Kind of a shame that in a nice place like this it's hard to enjoy a conversation. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Kyle Schweizer
Delicious Lobster Mac & Cheese.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Winds Tsai
氣氛佳！餐點好吃！
Reviewed on Google Maps
Patty Zapata
Love the atmosphere. The cream of cauliflower was absolutely delicious.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Thorsten Lotz
Very good
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dawn Sellers
Great food! Excellent service. They opened early for a family brunch the day after my nephew's wedding. A little hard to find parking cuz we were from out of town.
Reviewed on Google Maps
David Behrmann
They did a great job with the repairs and interior redesign following their tragic accident!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shinequa Gonzalez
Love the food and the people ,, amazing restaurant- definite must try!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lyndsay A.
My friend and I went to Simeon's on our last night in Ithaca for a nice dinner and we had a great experience. We had a reservation for 7pm on a Saturday and I would definitely recommend that - it was very busy. We were quickly seated in the oyster room and greeted by a very friendly server. I ordered the ginger pear martini and it was one of the best martinis I've ever had. We started with half a dozen black point oysters that were fresh and salty just how we like them, as well as the meat & cheese board that came with a cheddar, bleu cheese, pickles, honey, and jam. When there's only two cheeses, I don't love when one of them is bleu, but it was still delicious. We finished with the vino blanc mussels and the kettle chip cheese dip. The mussels were excellent and I loved the sauce. The kettle chips were lackluster and were drizzled with cheese, meaning most of them were just dry. We finished the night with a pistachio cannoli and a peach cobbler, both of which were excellent. Overall, a wonderful experience and I would love to go back and try more things! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Richard Bryant
Everything was excellent. The service was great and the wine recommendation was spot on. I had the raw oysters for an appetizer and they were amazingly fresh and delicious. I had the steak for my entree and it was a tasty high quality cut of meat. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
David Syracuse
Great bartender! She was knowledgeable and friendly, and makes an excellent series of drinks. Thanks!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Asmo Sama
Great food and atmosphere
Reviewed on Google Maps
Paul T
Beautiful place, great atmosphere, amazing food. High quality joint to say the least. Definite go if you're in town. Also prime location, right in the commons. You won't be disappointed and you will be back More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
La Juana M
Located on The Commons complex in Ithaca NY , there was nothing ordinary about our meal or the service. We had a wonderful steamed mussels appetizer that was enough to satisfy our party of 4. Entrees did not disappoint - a couple of blended burgers, a lobster roll special and a club sandwich. Everyone was very pleased with their choices. We also had a fantastic waitress who made the occasion just that much more enjoyable. Highly recommend this restaurant!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Harry Wachob
Nostalgic visit to a good natural wonder outside of Ithaca.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Manny Soltero
Simeon's was a quaint restaurant with an awesome ambiance for dinner. The drinks were good and the Chilean Sea Bass was good as well. Also, their artichoke appetizer was a nice surprise. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shawn Loucks
Great food. Oysters were wonderful.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mary Button
Great food & meeting spot.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Natasha Bratkovski
Always great service, delicious food, and you can't beat the atmosphere! The special cocktail was exceptional.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Horacio Ramirez
Gut
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tushaar Bedi
One of the best restaurants, if not “the best” Ithaca has to offer.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Aazral
Great and delicious food, all in all a good experience with incredible stature to the restaurant, a truly amazing dining experience all in all.
Reviewed on Google Maps
V Shank
Pretty much always a good meal here. Great place for a variety of oysters. There creamy polenta was amazing and I am not usually one to like polenta.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jerry Zhu
It's a high end restaurant for Ithaca but the quality of food is there. The seafood is the highlight. The oysters were exceedingly fresh and delicious.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jeffrey Elletson
Great spot! Good food, nice atmosphere and great service, recommended! Nice to see their oysters are from Cape Cod!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Thomas Bowen
Mmm good oysters
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alex Zamsky
The place is simply outstanding. The NY Stake strips were wonderful. I do not know what they put on their sause, but it was great. We loved clam chouder. Nice selection of wine and draft beer. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rocky Conte
I went with a few people to have dinner for the first time. We were all very impressed with the food and atmosphere. The menue is limited but the food was fabulous. The soup of the day was New England clam chowder and was the best I ever had. My pork chop dinner was superb especially the side of vegetables and how it was prepared. We will all plan on going back. I highly recommend. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Laura Siurano
Great service, food was great.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shannon Kauderer
Come here if you want seafood done right! Everything we had was top notch with high quality ingredients in every bite. Highly recommend the beef tartar and any of the desserts!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Chad Benenfeld
Great specials and they went above and beyond on Christmas Eve by opening on a Monday which is usually the day they are closed. The chef sent out a special home made Irish cream for dessert that was excellent. I had the short rib special with horseradish mashed potatoes which were perfectly seasoned! What a great experience and a special Christmas Eve we had. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matt Hoobler
Great homemade pasta and seafood dishes!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Laura Winter Falk
Great place to bring your family for a special occasion. Always delivers a great experience, especially in the upstairs room where your group can get more privacy
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Ferguson
Good food.
Reviewed on Google Maps
D0C7
Just went to this place. All the places in the commons were so busy but decided to try here and see if our luck was meant for this restaurant. The hostess was genuinely caring and trying to accommodate the five of us which she did. They seated us in a nice quaint area of the restaurant. They had to get an extra chair which they did. The waitress was excellent, sincere and thorough. The food was excellent. We ordered the steak and the salmon for our main course. Kettle chips and the dip for our appetizers. The desserts were to die for. We all thoroughly enjoyed the experience. Definately will visit again soon. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Benjamin Taylor
Amazing. Beautiful, newly-renovated interior space with very professional staff and amazing food. Making reservations is a quick and easy phonecall. Not sure you could go wrong with anything on the menu. Amy at the bar is amazing. A little on the pricey side but totally worth it for a fine dining experience. One of the best restaurants on the Commons! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
ken whalen
A+
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ann McAllister
Lovely decor and amazing service and food. Takes me back to France.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Roberto Cabiati
Tried the seafood platter, crab cake,Caesar salad and lobster mac and cheese. Delicious food, friendly waitress nice ambiance (elegant but not an overkill) and good value for money. Nice!
Reviewed on Google Maps
chang Demi
By far the BEST restaurant in Ithaca. I come here almost every week since I discovered this place last semester. Taste is so balanced! They make basic comfort food with a slight twist. Even the side dishes are made with care and paired specifically to the main course and changes according to the season. Even their simple local greens salad is well thought out, balanced, and extremely tasty. Can always discover something new on the special menu. Service is always always good. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Casey Patridge
THE best place to eat in Ithaca. The best service, the best owners and most importantly, the best food! Thank you, Simeon's!
Reviewed on Facebook
John Sculley
Dean and Rich have done a fantastic job in the renovations. Menu is perfect 1 page but very diversed. The best dish is the Chicken Parm, oysters are out standing. And the staff is the best , professional , friendly and very knowledgeable. DONT miss Simeon's when in Ithaca. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Marie Brooks
Brunch was great! The biscuits and gravy are tasty. I was happy that it came in two sizes so I could still get eggs and not be over full. Will go back to try more of the menu More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lauren Hering
Remodeled and with care and love maintained the original feel and decor. A lovely memorial plaque to Amanda in place with the color blue, her favorite throughout. Touching.
Reviewed on Facebook
Nickolas Tabel
Consistent with their dishes as far as temperature, medium rare is always medium rare, service is always friendly and calming. Wonderful place to sit outdoors! The octopus small plate is the most tender I've ever had! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
