Sicilia's Pizzeria

I ordered the cheese-stuffed pizza from grubhub and I was blown away. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Highly recommend!

Reviewed on Facebook

Really enjoyed the stuffed pizza we ordered. Got an order of the Buffalo wings , and minestrone soup which were also good. This place has been a staple for me since my college days. They've remodeled the inside, which looks good. I will definitely be back. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

5 stars on delivery service alone! The driver got stuck in the snow on a hill (I felt awful because I didn't know it was supposed to snow). They walked my order the rest of the way... not sure how far it was! Food was delicious, and didn't take too long... not many great local RI pizza places deliver- so major points for that!Good pizza, good wings, good salad, delicious desserts!THANK YOU TO THE CHAMPION DELIVERY DRIVER!!! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I've been ordering from this place for years I love them and I always order the pizza I'm very picky about my steak and cheese subs I hate dry subs After like 4 to 5 years of ordering I ordered a steak and cheese for the first time. I like it steak and mushroom with extra American cheese lightly toasted mayo lettuce extra ketchup no one ever puts enough ketchup or enough cheese so are usually ask for catchup on the side this time I did also But I didn't have to use it I took a bite into that sub and OMG Sicilia's's pizza did it everything I've had so far is been great on that menu I love you guys More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Ordered take out -- a small cheese stuffed pizza and an extra large pepperoni pizza with regular crust. Their stuffed pizza is absolutely delicious! For a small order, it definitely packs a punch. The regular pizza is ok, but I love the crust! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Was the worst pizza I have had in RI. I brought a few friends from Europe and pizza dough was clearly out of the freezer.

Reviewed on Yelp

I found the pizza to be one of the best I've ever had my fiancé agrees. Sicilias is very good on delivery but I find very expensive almost twice as much for a pizza as anywhere else it is twice as good but you're paying for every bit of it. Last night we had all baby pies stuffed 1. Stuffed cheese#2. Stuffed cheese and pepperoni #3 stuffed Meat lovers... sausages, beef , bacon and pepperoni.our 3 Newfoundland dogs enjoyed it as well More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Ordered delivery once so far. I was pretty impressed by the quality of the pizza, the order was hot and the wing dings were delish too. I don't have any complaints. Got my picky child to even try the pepperoni pizza and he enjoyed it as well. Cheese on the pizza was melty and stringy, sauce was perfect not too tangy and dough was fresh! Wing dings were a little soggy because they were packed up fresh so I assume the steam caused them to become soggy. I'd definitely order here again! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I love Sicilia's! This was one of the first places that a friend took me to when I was visiting Providence before moving here in 2003. She told me about the famed "stuffed pizza" and it is still my favorite pizza on "the Hill" to this day. One slice is an entire meal and you will be stuffed! My favorite is the spinach version, but be prepared to wait 45 minutes for it to come to your table. You will not be disappointed though! We went yesterday and the staff were delightful and friendly (especially to my 2 little kids) and the dining area has been completely renovated. The bar looks super chic and the women at the front phones were super busy taking orders, so it looks like their to go & delivery orders are still going strong, which was great to see. Excited to see the positive renovations and go back to this great restaurant! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Took the 1 hr drive down from Malden, Ma. again. The new sign and beautifully renovated interior along with the Best Pizza on the Planet made it worth every minute but I cannot say enough Great things about the Awesome waiter we had. I'm horrible with names but I believe it was Wayne. Very attentive and extremely personable. My 8 yr old son thought he was Hilarious. We'll be back again. Soon! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I ordered pizza for delivery through Uber Eats, but the lack of stars is all the restaurant's responsibility I promise. I put in my order at 8pm. The estimated arrival time was between 8:30-8:50. I check the app at 8:45, still says restaurant is preparing order. I call to check in. Restaurant says they are "extremely busy" and couldn't give me an estimate as to when my order will be ready.I wait till 9:40pm. Finally get a call from the delivery driver saying that they've arrived. Side note, the restaurant did not use an Uber Eats driver. Rather, they had their own driver so the app never updated and I was close to calling again since it still said they were preparing the order lol. So fine, it was almost 2 hours later but at least I got my food. Here's the kicker: they got my order wrong! I ordered a stuffed pizza with sausage, PEPPERONI, mushrooms and garlic. The pizza arrived with green peppers instead of pepperoni lol. The pizza also lacked flavor and was very lackluster. The inside of it was kind of watery? The only thing I can say positive things about was the crust. If I hadn't added the garlic I think it would've tasted even plainer. I called the restaurant to see if I could get my money back and they offered a $10 restaurant credit. I said yes to that because I didn't want to deal with it anymore, but TBH I don't think I'll ever be going back there. There's soooo many other pizza joints in Providence, even just federal hill, that can handle busy times by putting out orders on time and getting your order right. The person I spoke with at the store and the driver were all nice and courteous, but the quality of the pizza, getting the order wrong, and the horrendous wait times are not worth it. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Best pizza! We got the stuffed pizza and it did not disappoint! Newly renovated and the staff are all friendly and overly welcoming. We love going here!

Reviewed on Yelp

First time visit the steak & cheese sandwich was delish!!

Reviewed on Facebook

Decent place to grab a slice but I wasn't overly impressed. Maybe I was expecting a bit more given the Federal Hill location. It was good but nothing exceptional. What was great though was that we walked right in, were quickly helped, ordered the slices and they appeared super fast. Nice open air seating in the window with some good people watching. Slices are big and thick. Unless you're really starving you're probably good with just one. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Really disappointing...their Margherita had no sauce, and I asked for no ham on my Hawaiian pizza and still put ham. Spent 35 on 2 pizzas that I ended up not eating :(

Reviewed on Yelp

I love the pizza but it just cost a lot I get just a pizza and some fries and it was $31 for delivery online through yelp otherwise Annette I love the pizza it was really really good and my grandson love the fries I will definitely order again but I will call not go online.

Reviewed on Yelp

We were looking for a different pizza of sorts and I came upon their online recommendations.  So I went in and ordered a Famous Stuffed Pizza to go.  Although it was beautifully prepared and presented, the pizza just lacked depth of flavor.  And even though we got the Meat Lovers version, we could not taste any of the meat as all we tasted was the sauce and cheese.  Gonna have to continue searching. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The online ordering system is a scam. They said they never got my order, didn't even apologize, then they tried to charge me for the order they took over the phone, claiming I would be reimbursed for the money I paid on the website. It's been over a month and still no reimbursement. The pizza itself is decent but unimpressive. Unprofessional, disorganized, apathetic - in Providence you can do MUCH better. I recommend Nice Slice, Antonio's, Fellini, or Providence Coal Fire. Figidini also has great Neapolitan style pizza. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The pizza is okay. I ordered a pepperoni pizza to try this place out and it was decent, but this won't be my new regular pizza place.

Reviewed on Yelp

Worst customer service and delivery services I’ve ever received. Ordered food at 10:00pm they told me 30-45 minutes. At 11:00 I call to check in on the order and it still hadn’t left and this is when they decide to tell me they’re short drivers and I will have to wait another HALF HOUR at most. I try to be patient but two hours later at 12am I call and ask to speak to a manager. He says the food is still there and there’s nothing they can do so I said I’m not paying for it and canceled the order. He said “ sorry I don’t know what to tell you were short drivers” and then hangs up!! Never ordering from here again. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Great pizza! Highly recommend the margherita. Crispy and also the right balance of sauce and cheese. Baked to perfection not too burnt or anything. Recommend this place for a good slice & some interesting pizza types. More...

Reviewed on Yelp