Hampton Bays, New York
105 customer reviews
Germain Smith
Scotto's is the best!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kathleen Fitzgerald
We ordered two four foot heroes for the Friday after Thanksgiving ..great job. The cold cuts were fresh and plentiful, the bread delish and they were cut and placed in two separate platters. ..Reasonable and fair price...will go back again for sure. Thanks.. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
ca dz
Always, what you would expect! Great service, great food, friendly faces!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Greg R.
Stopped on a Friday evening and had a wonderful meal. I ordered some rigatoni and side of meatballs. Everything was fresh and hot. My server was super friendly and very attentive. Will be back again before I leave town. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Helene Heller
variety. tasty desserts. lunch and dinner specials
Reviewed on Facebook
Ilir Haxhaj
So friendly always feels like home!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Heidi Vanleer Mcclain
The food and customer service is fantastic!
Reviewed on Facebook
John K.
Stopped in and we split an Italian Hero - very good would definitely come again. Â Their meats looked great as well.
Reviewed on Yelp
George Worth
Check it out
Reviewed on Google Maps
D. A.
great food! more than pork meat
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brian S.
Good food- Rebecca, our server was a sweet young lady, Â and the owner was very personable. Will definitely be back.
Reviewed on Yelp
Benny G.
Wow! I'm all about the service, and these guys got it down! Plus the food is amazing ! Definitely authentic! You can't miss with this spot. Definatley a must!
Reviewed on Yelp
Hugo Ayala
Sells a variety of fresh and prepared meats, along with sandwiches, salads and Pizza. Good for grabbing a quick lunch, or a pair of steaks to grill later. The prepared salads are good. The eggplant panini is excellent. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Al Weinhofer
Best Italian takeout in the area. Homemade salads. Fresh sausage and meats. Pizza heros and entrees are all quality. Wine bar on premises .
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marc Titus
It is clear that high quality ingredients are used in the food here. Their Venetian pasta salad is one of the best foods on this Earth. I also have had their eggplant rollatini and although it was good, it had the unmistakable taste of have had being previously frozen. Normally this wouldn't bother me too much but with the very high prices at this store one would expect all the food to be fresh. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
William Mitchell
Awesome food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ann Colletti
Great food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joseph Dell
This is a must go to for anyone in the Hamptons. We drive over from Westhampton for the amazing cheeses, breads, olives, pastas, meats etc etc. This place is literally heaven in the Hamptons. Much love to everyone at Scotto’s. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
sphhwy115
Great food but pricey
Reviewed on Google Maps
Caiden Rivera
I regularly come getting some food in this place. I like the rapid customer service and well prepared food. They never disappoint.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Louis De Kerillis
Great steaks!! Food is all terrifice
Reviewed on Google Maps
Maria Angelica Diaz Torres
Lindo
Reviewed on Google Maps
D Cooper
Absolutely the best and freshest meats and hoagies in Hampton Bays. Can't recommend them highly enough and it's so nice to see something that isn't a chain
Reviewed on Google Maps
donna christina
Best food on the East End hands down!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Aparna Miano
It’s the real deal, man.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tommy D
Good cold and hot sandwiches, italian specials and desserts. Pizza isnt great but good enough for a quick bite. They even have a little bar in there serving up cold peroni on tap. Overall pretty good place!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Frank Rella
Yummy .....
Reviewed on Google Maps
Manpreet Landau
Has really good Italian food(pizza &sandwiches )
Reviewed on Google Maps
Meegan Dowling
Catered our wedding and did an outstanding job! Everyone is still raving about the food. We had and outdoor/indoor venue and they handled it flawlessly!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Maria Minguzzi
Food is great
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jorge Patino
Bonito Lugar y Atencion.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kaitlyn K.
Their spicy and regular sausages are so tasty!! My family always craves it and we are always making sausage and peppers
Reviewed on Yelp
Kim Cannon
The food is excellent!!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Elaine Meyn
3xcellent food both take put and eat in. Added a bar area for dining in. Inexpensive.
Reviewed on Google Maps
0273Philip .
This is THE place for a delicious Italian lunch or takeout. Great food, friendly service and good prices. A newly installed bar for wine or draft beer with a huge TV. Give it a try...you will not be disappointed.Cap’n Phil. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jack Mazzola
Great Italian food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ivo Roosi
Great pizza and wings. Prices do not bite, Friendly staff :)
Reviewed on Google Maps
Gina K.
On the regular pick up routine! Â Always fresh, always nice service. Â Pizza is probably the best around and it's good! Â That said we all know the local pizza kinda sucks so this is a nice surprise (white pizza is my fav). Â Love the Paninis, breads, brownies are awesome! Really don't like their meatballs at all which is a bummer but all in all a great spot to stock up for the weekend, easy dinner, etc! Â They have good soups and fresh pastas and fresh sauces for a whip it together kinda dinner! Â Always free samples on the counter too for a quick bite More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jordan Sutphen
Amazing pizza-even at the end of the day. They let us in and gave us a seat at the bar even as we arrived at closing time! Great place with some fancy Italian options! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Eric Malave
Was just there nothing but nice people there food amazing
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rick de Lyra Jr
One of the finest examples of Italian cuisine done right. While at first glance it may appear to be just a pizzeria. If you their fresh selection of meats will have you feeling like your at an old school Brooklyn butcher shop. Don't get me started on there mouth watering pasta dishes...if I could I would give them seven stars More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Robby C.
Awesome selection of items. So many good things that you won't be able to decide what to get. Surprised this place is not highly reviewed by more people. Would recommend coming here for a slice, fresh eggplant and mozzarella sandwich, or take out plates. Awesome and friendly staff too. Has nice seating area on side of deli. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
gregg g
Excellent place.....
excellent food ..
wonderful people !
it's a must visit....
Reviewed on Google Maps
Daniel Galvin
Great food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Frank Pressimone
Great food and ambiance, service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Robert Gahagan
Great authentic Italian salumeria
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matthew Sullivan
I love this place. My favorite sandwich in the Hamptons. The pizza’s great too.
Reviewed on Google Maps
A A
Food is so fresh and delicious i recommend everything!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michael Falzarano
Food is delicious
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bob Heizman
Great food. Friendly staff.
Reviewed on Google Maps