Loading...

Please wait ...

Priory Fine Pastries logo
P

Priory Fine Pastries

Mount Oliver, Pennsylvania

(140)

Get a free quote from this professional

Get a free quote from this professional

Photos (10)

See all

Reviews (140)

Leave a review
5/5

140 customer reviews

Loading...
23 December 2019

We ordered 30 dozen customized cookies for gifts and they turned out spectacular! Very friendly to deal with!

Reviewed on Google Maps

23 December 2019

I like it here, great food & service. Service is consistently good.

Reviewed on Google Maps

2 December 2019

Wonderful pastries and donuts. They make awesome cakes for different occasions.

Reviewed on Google Maps

14 November 2019

Good flavors.

Reviewed on Google Maps

31 October 2019

I was fortunate enough to stumble upon this small bakery since I live so close to it. It's very bright and there are two sides of the bakery packed with pastries. One wall there's donuts and then a case full of cookies in front while the adjacent case has cupcakes and other fancy pastries. The pastries are very good! Typically I get bored of eating cut out cookies but there is something about Priory Fine cookies that keep me coming back. They are slightly flaky, with a melt in your mouth texture and buttery flavor. Cookies are also cheap starting at $.70! Most of the pastries are no more than $5. I've never been disappointed with anything that I have tried here. I also appreciate how the bakery tries to minimize food waste by selling day old donuts for $.50. The service is also amazing. Everyone that I've interacted with here have been so hospitable and helpful while answering my questions. This is a Northside gem and it makes me happy whenever I see someone else walking in. This establishment definitely deserves all the love. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

28 October 2019

Great I love this place and the Baker Mckenzi does a wonderful job they all do I really appreciate them

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 October 2019

Delicious creme horns and friendly staff!! I miss coming here.

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 October 2019

We got our wedding cake through Priory Fine Pastries as part of our package for having our wedding at the Grand Hall at the Priory. Our cake was absolutely gorgeous and tasted even better. Thank you so much! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 October 2019

I had a wonderful experience with these guys, specifically Ali. Absolutely excellent bakery. I ordered my daughter's birthday cake here. I must have emailed Ali ten times back and forth to get all the details I wanted figured out. She was so nice and helpful and answered every email quickly- just took the stress and worry right out of it for me. And they nailed it. The cake was beautiful and even more importantly-DELICIOUS! My daughter loved it. Everyone did! Thank you Priory! Excellent work! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

1 October 2019

Ordered my favorite - a white cake with raspberry and custard filling....right? It was amazing. I will get all my cakes here.

Reviewed on Yelp

22 September 2019

The BEST

Reviewed on Google Maps

22 September 2019

Very good pastries, deserts, and donuts at a reasonable price

Reviewed on Google Maps

15 September 2019

Although I personally do not have much of a sweet tooth, I rely on Priory when I have to pick up baked goods and do not have time to bake myself. Most all of their desserts have been fantastic and I really enjoy the breakfast pastries I have sampled. Everything consistently tastes fresh and the prices are great. Priory is a staple in the neighborhood. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

12 September 2019

Great pastries! Cannot say enough good about the kolaches, peanut butter blossoms and buckeyes. The donuts are good too, but I think these novelty items are just so much more interesting :) Been here twice in the last month and planning on coming back for more!

Reviewed on Yelp

30 August 2019

Very good pastries and cake I really enjoyed it but but the person who served me she had a little attitude

Reviewed on Google Maps

23 August 2019

Best cake ever

Reviewed on Google Maps

9 August 2019

Their cupcakes and donuts are pretty good. Service was never short of friendly and timely. I wanted to order a cake once and they were pretty upfront about the prices and times (decided not to go with them). Reason for the 5 stars is they're open 6 AM and they have the best cinnamon rolls I've come across. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

9 August 2019

Wow, they have the most beautiful pastries and cakes. This place has high end baked goods and the prices are a bit high. You get what you pay for. Scrumptious. Beautiful cakes too. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 July 2019

Cannolis are the best

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 July 2019

Delicious and fresh

Reviewed on Google Maps

18 July 2019

Excellent Cupcakes!! !   I ordered a few dozen for the office today and they were a hit. So much easier than a big cake.   I had the carrot cake gourmet flavored cupcake ..  it was like a dream.  Delivery available too ! Thanks Priory Fine Pastries! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

30 June 2019

Awesome place

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 June 2019

Everything is delicious!! No matter what you choose you can't go wrong.

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 June 2019

Everybody Raves about the cupcakes I get from here. I just wish they would have a container that held two of them securely.

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 May 2019

My Granddaughter's Birthday cake was amazing! Customer service was great. The counter guy carried the cake and cupcakes to the car for us. I would use them again in a heartbeat. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 May 2019

Pricey

Reviewed on Google Maps

25 May 2019

Great bakery and tons of option! Kathy is awesome!

Reviewed on Facebook

25 May 2019

Had our cake tasting today, everything was delicious and the options are endless! Kathy, the assistant manager, was an absolute pleasure to work with made the experience fun. Highly recommend!

Reviewed on Facebook

14 May 2019

Awesome donuts! Way better tasting than the corporate donut shop that is dunking and less money

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 April 2019

Delicious goodies!! Once you get in there, you kind of want one of everything and you should go ahead and indulge yourself. There isn't a bad pastry in that shop. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 February 2019

Very nice looking cakes!

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 February 2019

Lika sum boooooody

Reviewed on Google Maps

27 February 2019

I'm in construction and I work all over the city . I enjoy some good sweets for my morning coffee break ... The Priory is by far the best and I've been to every Bakery there is in Allegheny County if I'm anywhere near North Side I make my way over and enjoy

Reviewed on Google Maps

27 February 2019

Great local bakery! Skip the franchise places and get a tasty coffee beverage and delicious pastry here. You won't be disappointed!

Reviewed on Google Maps

13 February 2019

We have bought a few cakes from this bakery and I will say this they are to die for. The cakes are so fresh and soft the icing pairs well with the cake as well. If you get a chance check them out

Reviewed on Facebook

9 February 2019

Had a wonderful wedding cake tasting this morning! Got to taste everything. The chef is great to work with. So excited for the cake!

Reviewed on Yelp

30 January 2019

Great donuts and cinnamon rolls

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 January 2019

High quality bakery foods and pastries. Extremely polite staff and great customer service. Christmas cookies and the best scones around. They bake high wedding and all occasion cakes as well. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

10 January 2019

Our first experience at getting a cake from Priory Fine Pastries far exceeded my expectations! I never had a cake so moist. And the icing was delightfully less sweet than the other regular BAKERY where I used to go. But all the flavor was all there! And the detailing in the artwork was so pretty and delicate. Your BAKERY is now my favorite place to get cakes! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

31 December 2018

I was in the area and sore the sign for pastries and I think my car parked itself.The Priory Fine Pastries has an excellent selection. Te staff are friendly and helpful and very nice.I had a cupcake and a cannoli.Both were excellent and extremely tasty.I would say pricing was a bit higher than some other bakeries.If I was in the area I would defiantly stop in againI would recommend to all my fellow yelpers to stop in and give them a shot. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

30 December 2018

nice little pastry shop. good donuts and danishes.

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 December 2018

Delicious and friendly staff!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 December 2018

I grew up south of Pittsburgh and haven't been back in a long time. We went to Pittsburgh for a football game and seen the bakery on line so I wanted to stop in. The bakery case was full of all the flavors of home. The bakery really took me back. We called them Lady locks but the cream horns tasted like my aunt made them. The nut rolls were great. Mom made those. The pastry dough was very nice and flaky. Yes I ate a dinner plate of sweets with coffee while I was there. If in Pittsburgh there are a lot of good bakeries but this one is on the top of my list. Thanks Bruce More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 November 2018

Supurb. Probably very finest bakery in Pittsburgh. Not as wide a daily selection in the cases as some, but a vast menu of options for order ahead items, and they were able to customize their carrot cake recipe for our wedding cake to leave out the nuts.

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 November 2018

Always a pleasure to be there, such professional and artistic bakers

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 November 2018

Love this place......

Reviewed on Google Maps