Brady Street, Wisconsin
598 customer reviews
Ralph Tyrone
Great lunch specials and food is always fresh
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tommy Sciano
Good food. Only bad thing is there's only 1 small TV at the bar.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kurt Meyers
Love their pizza thin crust
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amy Gottheardt-Muench
Had our Christmas work dinner here in the fireplace room. 25 people with a salad, pizza, pasta buffet. Food was delicious and the atmosphere was excellent. Service was spot on. Would highly recommend! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
David Hi
Very consistent, quality food! Make reservations on the weekend!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Andy Nuck
This was my first time at Pizza Man. I really liked the pan pizza but felt the calamari was too chewy. This could just be personal preference. The pizza crust was crisp, yet chewy. Definitely will be back More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Steve H-M
Had my big bro's burfday party there - great pasta and pizza! Barkeep mixes a delicious Rye Whiskey Manhattan!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cedric Pulliam
Goid service and food and they have wonton cheese sticks
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lexi Miller
The pizza was delicious, the building was beautiful, & they were very careful with food allergies. The only negative is that it is expensive.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jennifer Ball
Love the calamari and thin crust pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ash Renteria
I started going here a while back when they had the buffet, however, I cant get enough of this place! I literally go here every 2 weeks. The food is amazing and the staff is so nice! Our last waitress this past Saturday, I think her name was Amanda, was so accommodating! I will definitely go back! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Glen Wayer
Tasty pizza with service a bit slow and price a bit high.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Stephen Weyer
Great pizza and wonderful beer selection. Wonderful location for catching up with family and friends
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Meyer
Great pizza in fun, modern atmosphere.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jean King-Catt
Good place for pizza, especially when you dine in on Wednesdays they have a buy one large pizza get one free. Try the eggplant fries appetizer! Yum!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Loryn Denney
A little pricey, but worth it for the amazingly thin crust and delicious flavors!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Annie Wise
Really enjoyed Pizza Man. Very good eggplant fries and the pizza was delicious. We had a very good server who also turned out to be the bar tender. Great cocktails. Great atmosphere. Will definitely go back! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
John Christ
Great pizza, cold beer,and friendly service .
Reviewed on Google Maps
mannu sanghi
Just regular new york style pizza.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Russ Medenblik
Great pizza!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tom Riddle
Great pizza, wonderful atmosphere. Service is always top notch, and their Wednesday BOGO special makes it a no brainier.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cindy Johnson
Salads are outstanding and the pizza even better. Pizza is crispy crust with a great array of toppongs. My sausage-pepperoni loving hubby fell in love with the BBQ chicken pizza, and I couldn't agree more.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Denise Cole
Excellent ingredients, real food.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike Parrish
They recommend a reseveration. We went at a not so busy time. If there is room, they will seat you. The pizzas were very good and the crust wasn't doughy. The service was great.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mary-Catherine Nimphius
Great service, and wine specials
Reviewed on Google Maps
Maria Ditchev
Great food and delicious Tiramisu good service too
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ronald Harris
Perfect Pizza every time.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Zach Dobson
Excellent service and awesome pizza!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Greg J Ginter
Excellent take out
Reviewed on Google Maps
Liz Edmondson
Had a great time, very friendly staff, food and wine was great. Really enjoyed it. 10/10 would go again.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jonathan Woodley
Excellent experience! My pizza was great and my waitress was wonderful. Definitely will be visiting this establishment again in the near future.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alyssa Delforge
The staff here is amazing, but we are extremely disappointed that the onion strings and the pizza garlic sauce option are off the menu. But everything was still delicious
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sandy Lindquist
Good atmosphere, good friendly service good hidden creste Pizza good fried eggplant
Reviewed on Google Maps
P Strass
Good pizza, fun wait staff, bad date. So take someone special!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Gregg Wolf
Good pizza and service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Pamela Giarrante-Rohs
Pizza man has the best crust always has.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tom Warden
Never knew there was a Pizza Man in Oak Creek .... The suburbs have improved
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sam Castillo
Upscale, classy little place tucked away in the upcoming section of town.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jeff Thiele
Good pizza, good atmosphere. Had a great dinner with friends
Reviewed on Google Maps
olivia schanandore
I gave it another try. My order was not incorrect this time. I had a complicated order last time. It should be good as long as I order basic pizzas.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mary Block-Merkel
Pizza is the greatest
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joey Sellhausen
It was very good but expensive $$$
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brittany Daul
Best pan pizza ive had hands down crispy yet buttery crust! will be coming back for sure
Reviewed on Google Maps
Juliene Hefter
Always fabulous! The cauliflower crust is amazing.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marie B
Excellent pizza and pretty good service. Plus, the decor is rustic and upscale. Inviting environment.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Wendie Moss
The food and atmosphere are always great here but it is pricey.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Wayne Berg
Honestly, the best carnivoro pizza I've ever had. Jesse, the manager did everything to make my picky crew extremely happy. Customer focused, friendly and passionate about our experience. Thank you Jesse for your above and beyond service! We'll be back, definitely! Previous review (Cynthia P) deleted... it was just that good an experience! Shout out to Joyce! Awesome hostess!Awesome pizza, Awesome drink selection, Awesome ambiance! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jamie Bernard
Great pizza and location. Went on a date night with the wife and had an amazing time. Awesome wine selection too. Be sure to ask if they have any wines on clearance!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tim Olszewski
Great pies and reasonable prices...good service also
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike Anzalone
Great food and great service
Reviewed on Google Maps