Pizza Brutta Madison
Middleton
(32)
Middleton
(32)
32 customer reviews
Priscilla R.
Awesome pizza and artichoke deep.Prize were good and pizza was prepared quickly. I highly recommend
Reviewed on Yelp
K.J. B.
My kids can eat a whole pizza making this place a little unaffordable for our family- but it's dang good.
Reviewed on Yelp
Mackerton D.
Pizza Brutta is always a good choice. Their authentic Neapolitan pizza is absolutely delicious. Select from their recommended topping combinations or build your own. A smaller kids size is available as well. They also have a choice of salads to accompany your pie. It's a premium taste, so expect to pay a little more...but it's well worth the treat. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Marc T.
After the game we stopped here for a bite. Great little pizza place with a nice staff and good food.Every pizza is a large personal size. We had an americano and a carbonara pizza. They were both very good and we washed them down with a local beer.Will definitely be back if in town in again! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
William B.
Excellent authentic brick oven pizza. Everything you can want from great salads to thin crispy crusted dinner plate sized pies. Can't recommend this neighborhood staple enough More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Michelle B.
Not worth the stopIf you like traditional pizza this is like fancy Domino'sOnly place that gave my husband food pot
Reviewed on Yelp
Piz Brutta Is Ass L.
Sh7t was overpriced, pizza had no cheese and like 2 pieces of pepperoni, small asf, guy making it didn't even have gloves on and was touching everything. made me suicidal
Reviewed on Yelp
Andrew W.
High quality ingredients and tasty, authentic pizzas! Independent and family-owned. You will not be disappointed!
Reviewed on Yelp
Erin K.
Thin crust but not cracker-like and dry. Charred from the oven but not burned, just enough to add flavor. The pre-invented pizzas are all interesting. I love Calabrian peppers and they have them. It would be amazing if the pepperoni could be the little crispy cup and char kind instead of flopping like salami but it makes it easy for me to forgo the meat, so that's a good thing. And, the staff is always cheerful. You can taste in the pies that it must be a good place to work. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Amin S.
Excellent pizza Had the margharita and the pizza blanco. Both well made and my 8y old thought they were extremely good. Service is friendly and prompt. It's a laid back place.
Reviewed on Yelp
Maeghan N.
Cute place on Monroe Street. The ingredients are fresh and pizza is cooked in woodfire oven right in front of you. Online ordering was quick and convenient. Kind of wish they had a larger size than personal, the Pies are tasty buy tiny for the price! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Shona M.
As a New Yorker, my dad is something of a pizza snob. He loves a great thin crust, and he's all about classic toppings - something that's excellent in its simplicity like a margherita. When I first moved to Madison in 2014, my dad & I came to Pizza Brutta together. We were impressed! Flavor was amazing, the crust was good. Overall great quality food, and the service was friendly too. After our meal, he told me that now that I'd found a good pizza place, I'd have everything I need to survive in this new city on my own. I still live in Madison, and I still love Pizza Brutta. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Mark V.
Good Tuscan style pizza, friendly staff, surprisingly fast service despite being busy. It's just tough giving any pizza outside of NYC 5 stars after living there.
Reviewed on Yelp
Molly Suzanne J.
On a Madtown adventure we were famished and just happened upon this gem. We are gluten free, and as soon as I saw heirloom tomatoes on the menu, I was sold. Hands down the BEST pizza joint I've ever had the pleasure of dining in. Staff was friendly, quite informative about the area, and Jack knows how to make a damn good pie. We will be back! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
tom t.
Wood fired pizzas and delicious salads, you can eat inside, or you can eat out back. Highly recommended
Reviewed on Yelp
Eja L.
I normally love going here, friendly staff, barely any wait. No complaints here up until the last time. I normally get a personal size margherita pizza. The last time I got one it was sad and limpy :( Like literally I regretted spending the money on it. I've been coming here for a while and sadly I don't know if I'll be returning. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
R A.
It's been a while since our last visit, but finally made it back after a visit to the zoo and before stocking up at Trader Joe's. The pizza is great! Chewy, thin crust with a slight char from the oven. My kind of pizza. Focaccia that comes with caprese salad is also very good yet I would not call it focaccia but rather a naked pizza dough cooked with rosemary, salt, etc. did I mention the caprese?! Probably best I've ever had. Served warm-ish, possibly due to the blistered cherry tomatoes that it's topped with, but it makes the cheese, and whole dish really, just so much more flavorful vs the usual cold, water experience of fresh mozzarella. Fast and casual, perfect for dining w kids. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Virginia A.
Simply the very best pizza in Madison. Yelp is making me write more but there just isn't anything else that needs to be said. :)
Reviewed on Yelp
Richard H.
This place is great. I've only been a few times but today's visit really sealed the deal. I got the Margherita and it was perfection. The mozzarella was creamy, the sauce was tangy and tasted of fresh tomatoes, the Basil was aromatic but truly it was all about the crust. Perfectly baked in a brick oven, the crust had lovely little black blisters, a pleasant crunch on the outside, and a doughy, slightly stretchy inside.Loved it! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Breanna R.
It's good pizza. What's really nice is all of the options for toppings, half toppings, and glass bottle Coca Cola.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jade A.
Just looking at the menu made my mouth water so I just had to try something from this place and it made my mouth water. The beet salad was a perfect side to the pizza I ordered. The dough was cooked perfectly and the actual contents/toppings worked in perfect harmony. Would definitely come back just to try more of their menu. I ordered one pizza and a full serving of the beet salad but shared it with a friend and it was perfect to fill the both of us. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Elio A.
Pizzas are great, Fresh tomato sauce and cheese!! I would come back to have more, highly recommended.
Reviewed on Yelp
Marcy K.
Fabulous sandwiches!!!'Great locally owned pizza restaurant.Has a cute vibe, great food o fun Monroe Street.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jane H.
I'm from Minneapolis and love Punch pizza. This is the closest thing to it in Wisconsin. Great service and amazing food. They also have great salads (Gorgonzola and the Beet Salad are fantastic). I also recommend ordering a side of hot honey with your pizza. They have a cute back patio in the warmer months. Definitely check this place out if you're in Madison. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Abby H.
Love this place! Especially on Badger game day!! Relaxed atmosphere. Great location. Love having it in the neighborhood.
Reviewed on Yelp
Max M.
Went to Pizza Brutta on Pi Day for dinner. I am a huge fan of their service and pies. The service is very quick and streamlined -- we were able to get through a pretty long line and order our food within 5 minutes. The two pies I ordered took only 10 minutes to make. The pies themself had a nice thin and crisp base. I got a mix of meats (sausage, bacon, ham etc.) and they tasted very fresh and were very savory. Overall Pizza Brutta is a very nice spot to visit if you're looking to grab a quick snack or sit down dinner with family/friends. I am a huge Trader Joe's fan and that's right across the street, so it's a no-brainer. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Julie S.
Always a hit with our family! The pizza is delicious! I love the Margherita and the Fungi is also a favorite of mine. I especially love the arugula that can be ordered to be added after cooking. The salads are all great...the lettuce is super fresh and the dressing tastes homemade. I have never had anything here I didn't love. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Max M.
Pizza Brutta is my go to for a quick bite during dinner when you don't want to have to wait in line for long. They usually have seating in booths available and the pizzas come out very quickly. I enjoy their selection of fire baked pizzas and they're very affordable. Overall would recommend to anyone who likes pizzas made over a fire and enjoy traditional pies. They're sausage and broccoli rabe pizza is my favorite. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Alexander S.
Pie crusts blackened much too much. Pies were tasty but quite pricey with delivery charge given that they were no more than 8 and a half inches in diameter (roughly the size of two slices of pizza from a 16 inch pie). Pi times radius squared will show you these pies are 1/4th the size of a 16 inch pie. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Steve L.
Wood fired pizza is our favorite and it is difficult to find in S WI. Pizza Brutta is in a cute spot with plenty of nearby street parking. The selection, service and food were all fantastic. Next time, we will order extra meat (bacon) but none the less we had a wonderful pizza and salad meal. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Aly H.
Stopped by on a Saturday afternoon and was not disappointed. Great pizza, friendly staff, and short waiting times. After ordering at the counter, you're free to sit in any booth, and your food is dropped off at your table when ready. Smooth and easy process! Definitely recommend trying the Mike's Hot Honey on any pizza More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Connor S.
Great food, great bread, great service. Some of the best pizza I've had in a long time!! One of the best pizza's in the USA
Reviewed on Yelp
