Pasquale's Pizzeria III
Hendrickson Corners, New Jersey, monmouth
(52)
Hendrickson Corners, New Jersey, monmouth
(52)
Pasquale's Pizzeria III Restaurant is an Italian restaurant located in Middletown, New Jersey, serving Italian food for lunch and dinner and offering delivery and pick-up options, along with dine-in service. Our catering include Pizza, freshly made Italian dinners,seafood, six foot hot & cold subs, appetizers, and salad.
Show more
52 customer reviews
Phyllis P.
Delicious vegan pizza! Very tasty crust, sauce and cheese. I ordered a whole pie for lunch. Very reasonable. They have Beyond burgers, too! Nice to have a place with vegan options close to where I work. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Nancy Horvat Voll
Ive been ordering for years but ever since New Ownership you can definately taste the difference in quality ingredients. We order min once a week usually twice and everything from Pizza, Subs, Dinners are fantastic. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Christina Schack
Our go to pizza spot! Everything is great, our favorites include the grandma pie and the cheeseburger pizza!
Reviewed on Facebook
James Horan
Best pizza and I love all of you people so much.
Reviewed on Facebook
David Dwight
Today's Lunch brought to me by Pasquale's III, actually we drove there between calls. So just like a certain person "If the mountain will not come to Muhammad, then Muhammad must go to the mountain" Selection for today, Plain, Sicilian and a Grandma Slice. The later 2 we're the better, crispy, fluffy interior. The Plain was soggy and limp like a wet noodle. The taste of the crust, sauce, cheese and basil were delicious. Next time will request the freshly baked Plain be thrown back into the oven for crisping. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jimmy Burgess
the CBD Oil on your Pies is really thoughtful. it really does wonders, im a Cancer Survivor and had NO side effects during the Radiation of my Treatment as i took this Oil during that time and presently.
Reviewed on Facebook
Lara Bethany
Hands down...best taco pie ever
Reviewed on Facebook
Qathy B.
Great pizza, ordered delivery for lunch at work and they were right on time and the pie was delicious! Will definitely order from Pasquale's again.
Reviewed on Yelp
Mike C.
Pasquales is always a solid choice for some good local pizza. Buffalo chicken is what they're known for, and it's not for no reason.
Reviewed on Yelp
Phil B.
Pizza is very good. They have a lot of different options on the menu. The food comes out quick,hot and delicious. I recommend this place for a quick slice to eat but not to have a full dinner.
Reviewed on Yelp
Mary E Filomena T.
Mmmmm! Loved it here . We always order here and it serves it s purpose , to supply me with some Italian food last minute. People are nice that work here ! We will continue to eat food from here !!! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Douglas J.
After living and traveling in New York and New Jersey my whole life. I have enjoyed pizza my whole life and Pasquales's lll has provided a great place to have Italian food. The pizza has the right amount of sauce and plenty of cheese. The entrées are delicious and plentiful. This is more than just a local pizzeria! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Ben Y.
Best pizza place in Middletown. The food is also amazing and they have the best gourmet slices around.
Reviewed on Yelp
Richard Gaynor
Great food and great people there! Do a lot for the community as well!
Reviewed on Facebook
Stacey O-Donn
Amazing food and friendly staff! We had the best experience having a pizza making party! The kids had a blast!!!! And the good was absolutely delicious! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Reviewed on Facebook
Sam M.
Awesome quickest delivery ever! Pizza was good, slightly undercooked but super hot and lots of toppings on Hawaiian. Happy we tried them out. .we'll order again for sure but we found the pies were SMALL for the price..this box is half the size of a regular pizza box for the same price of a large pie elsewhere More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Saeed S.
Best Buffalo chicken pizza in New New Jersey! My wife loves their cheesesteak sandwiches
Reviewed on Yelp
Danielle Manning Mucciolo
Great food!! Staff is always friendly and the food is always fresh and delicious!
Reviewed on Facebook
Nikki L.
Their pizza is excellent! I tried rice balls for the first time and they were AMAZING!!!! We had a party of 5 and we each ordered different items, from pizza to baked rigatoni. Everything we ordered was so delicious, and the prices are very reasonable, especially with the large portions they gave us!! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
K R.
Good pizza, delivery is under an houd. I really order here for the Zeppole "fries" - they are addictive!! These are made with real zeppole dough not like other pizzerias in the area that just fry up pizza dough and put powdered sugar on them.
Reviewed on Yelp
Brooklyn A.
Good was excellent - hot, ready exactly when they said it would be. My only complaint probably petty but what annoyed me was the bill was $170. 02 and rather than saying forget the .02 cents I got .98 cents change... for a $170 bill at a pizzeria does .02 really matter for a regular customer More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jess S.
It's always been an ongoing dispute between Middletown residents: Pasquale's vs. Villa. I'm not going to choose one in this review, simply because I can't. Sometimes I'm in the mood for Villa- I go there. Likewise, I'll switch it up and head to Pasquale's. Both establishments have the market cornered and have managed to stay in business despite their proximity. The buffalo chicken pie at Pasquale's is an added bonus which Villa does not do as well, so I will say there's that. I've never had much of an issue there in all my years going. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Christine C.
by far best pizza in the area- must try the grandma slice. very friendly/timely service. owner is very personable and accommodating. definitely my favorite spot.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jessica D.
Never had a problem! I love them! Great food and a staple of NJ! Their garlic knots are amazing for one thing!
Reviewed on Yelp
Katy M.
Food is epic. Counter girl is very nice! Everything looked so good! I had the buffalo chicken pizza is was the best I've ever had! I wish they delivered to my house in Cliffwood! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Amanda L.
Best buffalo chicken pizza. Also eggplant parm stuffed garlic knot!!!! I wish I lived closer!!!
Reviewed on Yelp
Jim T.
If only Pasquale's would deliver to Red Bank! Then we'd have a good pizza place in town. Their Buffalo Chicken slice is the best I've ever had, exactly like all the other reviews said. It's a must try for anyone who has never had it. This past trip I had a white slice and a Buffalo, the white was good the Buffalo was great. I've had some other slices here but will always go back just for the buffalo slice. 5+ stars for the Buffalo slice and 3.5-4 stars for the other items I've tried. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
maria r.
Classic pizzeria, large selection of specialty pizzas. Service was very friendly, a tad bit of a wait to get food, but it was prime dinner time so it's understandable. Price was average. Fresh bread was the highlight! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Kelly H.
My brother turned me on to this place. He stops in almost everyday to try out another gourmet slice of pizza. They always have a great selection of specialty slices that change often. One of the best places in the area for delicious pizza. Always friendly service too! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Allya B.
Just had the best white slice ever and the pizza man Joe is so friendly and always quick to help. I moved to the area 2 weeks ago and been here 3 times already. Def. recommend it !
Reviewed on Yelp
ISell H.
I moved into Middletown about 5 years ago and discovered the most delicious slice of pizza here - the cheeseburger slice! Pizza is always awesome and service with a big smile! Keep up the great work!
Reviewed on Yelp
Bryan B.
Pasquale's pizza is the best around. The manager Joe is always making new pies and concoctions every single day. New deep dish stuffed pizzas are amazing !
Reviewed on Yelp
Joe F.
There's an old saying, "all good things are worth waiting for". I rarely do reviews, but after last nights order (stuffed garlic knots. . 1 with Chicken, the other with eggplant) I came to give this place a review. When I saw the ones that gave this place bad reviews because "I waited too long", before writing your review, did you stop to wonder why The food here is freaking awesome. Coming from New York (Staten Island), where there is a pizzeria on every corner, this place could go toe to toe with their best. Actually, the pizza here is better than any place on the island. Obviously the secret is out, and thats why they are so busy and why you might have to wait a little longer, plus the owner is a real friendly dude. And yeah, I've called, and the workers sound a little overwhelmed at times, but if you ever worked in a real busy place (again, they are busy for a reason), you'd totally understand why, but the minute you go inside, they are the nicest bunch of people you'll ever meet. I still can't believe I live this close to this little gem of a restaurant. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Lauren M.
This was REALLY good pizza. Husband and I moved out of jersey years ago and look for legit food of various varieties every time we come back to visit family. On a thanksgiving eve approaching 10pm, babysitting nephews, our hopes were small of getting a good dinner, but we called Pasquale's because they were, you know, open. I initially requested delivery, but upon realizing that they were actually nearby, just went and got the pizza myself. They WERE willing to deliver, though, after closing time and again, ON THANKSGIVING EVE. Bonus points for that. Staff was friendly when I showed up. Again. Closing time. Thanksgiving eve. Bonus points.The pizza was fantastic, and not just because we'd just driven down from New England and were starving. I told my sister and brother in law to try this place, which is a couple of miles from their house. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jess M.
Huge kudos to Pasquale's! I was with my family for the night, and as usual, they wanted to order pizza. Unfortunately, I have food allergies, so I was the odd guy out. I figured a salad would suffice, with modifications, and my mom was very explicit on the phone that the salad have no cheese on it. When the food arrived, my salad - womp - was covered in cheese and thus inedible. I'm never one to complain, especially with a history of working in food service, but I was starving and at least wanted them to know what happened. The manager was incredibly kind and apologetic and insisted on sending me a new salad, free of charge. It arrived very promptly and was delicious! Even the delivery guy said he was sorry!! I know pizza places can be super busy on weekends, so the kindness was certainly not lost on me. Thank you for making an odd girl out feel a little more included on pizza night! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Tiffany I.
The BEST buffalo chicken pie you will ever have! The service here is quick and you will not be dissappointed in any choice of pizza. The owner is very personable and makes an effort to meet all of his customers. It is definitely the best pizzeria in Middletown NJ. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Abu H.
Solid. The best thing about PP3 is the owner, Pat. He's down-to-earth, polite, and just an all-around great human being. The food speaks for itself.
Reviewed on Yelp
Marc M.
Ridiculously good specialty slices! You gotta check this place out if you appreciate great pizza! You will not be disappointed.
Reviewed on Yelp
Michael G.
Ordered food on a Saturday night and it was delivered to us in Hazlet in under an hour, nice and hot. The chicken franchise was awesome. Their grandma pizza the best. Great stop. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Art B.
This place has the BEST Buffalo pizza ever. It's not too hot but it's amazing. Almost tastes like Buffalo Dip. The assortment of Pizza they have is amazing. They seem to have new creations weekly. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Michelle B.
As I was deciding on lunch today, I figured I'd search Yelp for something near my job. I saw the reviews for Pasquale's and settled on pizza. I walked in and there were plenty of options to choose from, by-the-slice. I remembered some of the reviews and went with a buffalo chicken slice and a vodka slice. I went to the cooler, grabbed a beverage and waited. The young female behind the counter was extremely sweet as she handed me my food. I immediately noticed the size of the slices, which were bigger than average. They DID NOT skimp on chicken by any means. As I folded my vodka slice, pieces were falling out. The bottom of the pizza crust was nice and crunchy just how I like it. It was really good. I had to grab a fork to finish up the chicken. However, the star of the show went to the buffalo slice. IT WAS THE BEST SLICE OF PIZZA EVER. All the components were in perfect harmony. As I mentioned before, the crust underneath was crunchy. The chicken was moist, the sauce was absolutely delicious. I can already tell I'll be craving that slice again soon. The best part was that two big "specialty" slices and a tall boy can of Brisk iced Tea was $8 and change. I am thoroughly impressed....and full. LOL. I would definitely recommend Pasquale's and I'll certainly be coming back here for lunch. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
R R.
Hands down best buffalo chicken pie in NJ. They have some of the best pies outside of NYC. My favorite pizzeria.
Reviewed on Yelp
Cheryl R.
First time we ordered from here. Good was good. Garlic knots were great. Loved the funnel fries. Cheesesteak was very good. Delivery took awhile but overall very enjoyable More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Brian R.
Very good order delivery through my eat app which is very handy ..... The buffalo chicken wrap very good , little messy but filling. Cheesesteak my wife had was very good ... I had a bite to try. The French fries had with mozz cheese was so so and fried ravioli my wife had could have been better as in more crispy. The funnel Fries were so good a must again next time I order More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Drew H.
I came from the West Coast to do some work for super storm Sandy and we came to this pizza place for lunch about six times over two weeks. authentic staff authentic people at authentic pizza. Could not of been treated better by people from out of the area great stopping place for lunch. Prices were fair food was fresh and the variety was outstanding. Remember they use real pizza oven so that slices hot let it cool down for a minute before you put it in your mouth. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Matthew C.
I love around the corner so this is usually where I get my pizza. They have very friendly service and great food. The pizza is, by far, the best in the area. They have a large selection and the food quality is great. They make new pies throughout the day and always make them fresh when you order a whole pie. The floor and tables are also clean. They usually have someone sitting by folding boxes that cleans the tables when someone is finished. So if your in the area and looking for pizza, this is the place to go. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Liz B.
Insane variety of pizza even by the slice. Always came for the buffalo chicken pizza but now I've tried the cheese burger pizza. Nothing will ever be the same. Best thing I've ever eaten. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Matt S.
The pizza here is fantastic, the cheese steaks are really good, as are the Italian pasta dishes. The bacon cheese burger pizza it's the most disgustingly unhealthy thing ever, but oh my goodness is it delicious! I live close to here and order delivery all the time (I'm lazy, haha). They usually tell me 40 minutes, but it's here in 20 most of the time. Definitely my go to place when I don't know what else to eat. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Mark M.
Famed for their buffalo chicken pizza this place also makes a decent regular slice. Sandwiches aren't too bad but I haven't had enough to justify a rating for them. If you like speciality slices this is the place to go. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Margaret W.
There are 1000 pizza places in our area. Pasquale's is not close to my house, and they do not deliver to my town, but I will make the trip to get their Buffalo Chicken Pizza! It's a messy pizza, but it's delicious...and if you have any left over heat it up the next day, its even better! You can even get slices of the specialty pizzas--my husbands favorite is the Cheeseburger Pizza! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
