Overtime Pizzeria and Sports Pub

Wow!  Have been here 3x and have not been disappointed yet.  What a value!  Great menu options staff is attentive and if you like your sports you will love the amount of TVs!  Will be coming back to try the pizza next More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The food is pretty good, but when you are seated in the TV section it tends to get a little loud. Try their food I usually get the same thing everytime and it's been pretty good.

Reviewed on Yelp

The best staff and food in SW Cape! And staff!Shrimp and grits are the best. Happy hour great.

Reviewed on Yelp

Oh my gosh. So glad to find this place. It's become one of our favorite spots. The pizza is amazing. Dough tastes like sour dough and that's a GOOD thing. It actually has flavor. Thin crust, extra crispy and some spirits. You won't walk out broke either! The Mussels with white wine and garlic are ridiculously good. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Cauliflower pizza crust is delicious!! We've never had a bad meal here and the service is always great!  Our portions were pretty hearty, we all took a box home, even my 21 year old son who usually finishes all of his meal and then some.

Reviewed on Yelp

You can always count on Overtime to have great food & friendly service!  So happy we live close & get to go often.  The entertainment is awesome too!

Reviewed on Yelp

We went to this establishment for the first time tonight and we will definitely be going back there again. The food was awesome the service was outstanding it was just an all around great meal and experience.

Reviewed on Yelp

I always have the Philly cheesesteak and it's always amazing never let down so for that it gets 5 stars

Reviewed on Yelp

Wow!! Everything from here is great! The wings are meaty with great flavor and sauce. The sweet potato fries are good! The Italian sandwich is another great option. An incredibly amount of tv's. Some booths have individual TVs for the table. Good service, even when busy during a major soccer game. Would recommend to all family and friends! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Food was good quality for the price.  Staff is usually on-point with service and speed.  Beer is cold & sports are plentiful.  I would definitely recommend this place for a large party. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Dined here with my husband after he checked the place out a couple of times.  Have been very disappointed with pizza here in Cape Coral I was reluctant to give it a try-but very glad I did.  Great pizza, we both had a large Margherita which we split and had leftovers to tote home.  The pizza was hot and made fresh with just the right sweet tomato to cheese ratio, crispy crust-not soggy.  We also had the cold antipasto salad which would be more than enough for a meal for one person.  Mounds of fresh Romaine lettuce, fresh mozzarella, provolone, capicola, Genoa salami and Kalamata olives, topped off with a yummy garlic knot.  The only negative I would give Overtime is that the level of noise is only tolerable for a short time.  It is a sports bar atmosphere after all and with that being said would be a lively spot for all sports enthusiasts.  Would definitely return for stellar pizza. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

This is not your regular sports bar. Got to give this place 2 thumbs up. I have ordered a couple different pizzas and enjoyed them very much. The margaritas as well as bruschetta. The Italian grinder sandwich and Ahi tuna is delicious . Great staff and atmosphere with a nice selection of draft brews at the lowest price anywhere in SW Florida. Live music on Friday too. My go to place even though I live 6 miles away. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

You really can't beat this place for a variety of tasty food, cold beer, and excellent service. We've had sandwiches (try the ahi tuna or Italian wrap. ..soooo delicious), pizza, Greek salad, and other food items. The portions are generous, and everything we've sampled has been delicious. The service is very good, especially when Gina is working behind the bar. She is so kind, friendly, and efficient. Go check out this place! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Great place to watch college football the atmosphere is awesome and food is great plus the service is and A+service will come back soon

Reviewed on Yelp

Living in the sw Cape finding good pizza is not easy.  I've had pizza from every pizza slinger in the sw cape and overtime is the best.  Maybe some day they'll deliver too. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Stopped for late lunch/early dinner with group of 6. Two pizzas were great - both deluxe with mini or tweaks which were made with no problems. Medium to thin crust and sauce was great. One order of fish and fries - done very well. The eater was from Wisconsin and she gave it a thumbs up! Our waitress was really nice and knowledgable.tons of TVs all over. Plenty of space. Will definitely go back when we visit again. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Great caprise salad , Rueben. Huge chicken fingers. Everyone was very pleased with the quality and quantity..  the server was very attentive as well as who I would presume was the manager/ assistant.  I was pleased because this is a vet busy sports bar and didn't expect such quality service and food. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I love pizza.  This is really good pizza.  It is all we had, so I can not comment on the other food, but I will say we have several friends to give high marks to all parts of the menu.  Crust and sauce make a pizza.  This place has really good crust and sauce.  We went to watch some baseball and have a few beers, and did not realize how large this place is.  It was pretty full for a weekend night in the summer.  We will 100% go back, in fact I was just talking to a good friend yesterday, and we made plans to head back next week.....for the PIZZA!!!! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The bartender, Bobby! Great service and knows his alcohol- make sure you sit with him at the bar for good tips too

Reviewed on Yelp

The food was good the service was okay. I would come back again. The food was not awesome, but it was good. Me and friends had a good time while we were there and I would come back again. The crab nachos are worth trying again. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Attentive waitstaff, great food, clean bathrooms, and great atmosphere are all attributes of this Cape Coral gem. GreatPlace for a family night out or to sit at the bar with friends. Definitely a place we will be dining at again. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Great food, service and family friendly atmosphere. Something for everyone.hi highly recommend this place.

Reviewed on Yelp

Great good good always consistent. Most of all great staff! Prices super reasonable. Mgmt keep up the good work we will be back!

Reviewed on Yelp

This is my second review of Overtime.  Sometimes a restaurant changes as it get more popular. Overtime has consistently maintained waitstaff and bartenders who do a great job. They really sem to care that the customer has an enjoyable experience. The food is always good. Much more than just pizza...however their pizza is really good. And lastly the beer selection will satisfy thlse that prefer the standards and those who prefer micros/craft beers. Full liquor bar. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

We've lived in Cape Coral for four years now and since moving here we've been trying to find a pizza joint that would even come close to the delicious pizza we've become accustomed to back home. Like the Lewis & Clark in search of the perfect pizza, we've been on a mission. Well unlike explorers before us, we've finally completed our mission without death nor injury. This place is head and shoulders above any pizza we've eaten since being in the sunshine state. I had a feeling I was in the right place when I pulled into their parking lot and had a little difficulty finding parking on a Sunday night at 8:00 PM. We ordered their thin crust pizza with double cheese, mushrooms, and sausage. It was cooked perfectly with the outside crust slightly crispy and the rest of the pizza deliciously moist and flavorful. Being from the Chicago area and finding a pizza of this caliber was a lot of work but our quest is finally over. You can't go wrong with this pizza joint. Our large pizza cost about $17.00 and was well worth it. (Sorry about the one slice pizza picture, we couldn't stop eating it) More...

Reviewed on Yelp

This is ok. We used to come for the music of a gentleman who no longer plays which is sad. It is wing night but I have a favorite place for wings now so it's ok. The bartenders are nice and make a friend of mine a great Lemon martini she likes. Love the owner mike he is personable with the guests keep it up mike More...

Reviewed on Yelp

A weekly regular spot for us. The food is good & service is excellent! We loved Wednesday night special for a large pizza one topping 9. 95$! Drinks are cold and at a reasonable price! Love that there is such a fun place close to home. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I went here after hearing such great things by word of mouth and I was not disappointed. I loved it. I sat in a booth with its own personal TV and the waiter was extremely funny and interactive. The menu has quite a variety and has everything. If you and whoever you are with, can't agree on what kind of food to eat, come here because they have everything from wraps to philly cheese steak! Love how welcoming and caring the staff is. 100% recommend!!! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Very nice place. Been here 3 times in the past couple weeks due to my normal place being closed. Good food good service. More of a sports bar than a pizza place in my opinion. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The name is deceiving as this place offers much more than pizza. We had heard good things about Overtime so Monday night we stopped in. If you're a sports fan the tv setup is terrific. I selected the Prime Rib special, it came out as ordered, rare, but was a bit tough. The wife had the Crab Mango salad and she loved it.The service was great as was the atmosphere.  We both recommend giving them a try. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I like this place. They call themselves a pizzeria but you don't get that vibe here at all. It's really a sports bar where they have live entertainment most nights. Their pizza is pretty good as are their sandwiches, burgers and wings. I was there one night (I think Monday) when they offered Prime Rib for $13.95. It was delicious and a very large portion. Our server was excellent and the drinks were great (Deep Eddy vodka served here).  She explained they have specials just about every night - kids eat free one night, pizza for $9.99 one night etc.Great spot for families as well as a fun hang out later in the evening when the music begins. Certain nights I think you need to make reservations if you want to be in the room with the music. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

My fiancé and I came here on a Sunday night to watch the NBA finals. Overall, we had a great experience here. We ordered onion rings for an app, which were good but nothing special. For dinner, I ordered the penne vodka pasta with chicken, and my fiancé ordered the stuffed grouper. My dish was excellent- a huge portion with an abundance of chicken. The side Caesar salad was very good too, nice and crisp and not overly dressed. My fiancé just raved about his stuffed grouper and said it was his favorite dish he has had in Cape Coral. Our server was friendly and attentive, and the manager stopped by twice, which is always appreciated! I am taking off a star because the hostess wasn't very friendly and seemed annoyed when we wanted to switch tables to be closer to the bar/tvs. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

This place has FANTASTIC burgers! Great place to go to watch a game and enjoy Great Food! Not your everyday sports bar. I will definitely be visiting this place again!

Reviewed on Yelp

We had dinner there tonight and the food was really good. Sarah waited on us and her service was excellent. She had a very pleasant attitude and really did a great job. Ask for her if you go there to eat, you will be glad you did! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Large sports bar, great happy hour & the best pizza in Cape Coral!

Reviewed on Yelp

Good sports bar, plenty of tvs for your viewing pleasure. Had their pepperoni pizza which was delicious. Fast and friendly service, would definitely go again. Check it out!

Reviewed on Yelp

Amazing food and drinks! Service is always above expectations! Best restaurant in southwest Florida hands down!

Reviewed on Yelp

We've been here several times and the food, service and quality has been consistently very good. Atmosphere is always pleasant and the prices are reasonable. We always look forward to our next visit.! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

This was our first visit tonight, thanks Yelpers for a great recommendation..it was a Friday night and we waited for about 10 minutes, exactly what we were told. What a lively atmosphere, there was live music which was playing some great songs!  We ordered the deluxe pizza and while there was a mixup on our order the owner was awesome, she was nice and was genuine about making it right. Pizza was very very good! Beer was cold and great tvs all around. We will definitely be back, give it a night out More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Good food. Never had a bad meal.  Brittany has been our waitperson twice. She is absolutely the best. Tries to make your experience perfect.

Reviewed on Yelp

Awesome sicilian style pizza. Also had the thin. Both were great but I prefer the deep dish. Great happy hour specials, wine, rail drinks and taps and our servers were amazing. 2nd time here and we will be back on our next vacation to Cape Coral.Had a lounge singer who was very talented as well.HIGHLY recommend! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Pizza is perfect for my taste buds. Price is a little high, but we did ala carte on some items.I want to try other items other than pizza next visit to try out. Check out the place for sports on tv and bands. Check out their website for band schedules.Gatlin on Monday's is a must see. They are not only a great band, but put on a show. Country, rock, elvis, ballads, broadway, mixture of music.Check this place out on Monday. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

We have been here a few times and I want  to share with all of you out there what a great restaurant this is. I have had previously the coconut shrimp. It was plentiful and fantastic.  Today my husband and I went and shared between us the nachos and the 12 pc bourbon bbq wings. Well first I must say service was impeccable and Susie was just so nice and friendly. I love that if you sit in a booth you have your own TV right there. When the food arrived I could stop eating my share. It was the best nachos I have had in a long while. They didn't skimp like some places do. The wings tasted fresh and not frozen, and the taste was out if this world. I also had a spicy bloody mary at great price. (Happy hour $3) okay I had two for that price. LoL. Made to perfection.It's a nice enough place to bring your kids and you don't have to dress up. Prices are very reasonable and I'm hoping they'll add soup to their menu. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Courtney was our server. She was high energy. Adorable. We enjoy this restaurant. Fun place to dine. We live in the Cape. My husband wanted to find here tonight.  Super!

Reviewed on Yelp

Let me get right to it.  If you are new to living in Florida, the two words you do NOT say is, " Up north....".  That can cause serious bodily injury.  Why do I say this?  Pizza is the one major concession that all Floridians agree upon when it comes to, "up north".  So, why settle on what we used to take for granted?  For this reason, Overtime was born.  Bar none, this is the best pizza you will ever enjoy and I've lived here for 32 years.  Believe me.  .  Perfect Philly cheese steaks as well....and it's all original.  Right down to the rolls.  A full liquor bar, with desserts to die for.  So, what's your excuse?  Enjoy the pizza, just like, well, you know what. More...

Reviewed on Yelp