Over the Top Cookies
Chattel Number 5, Utah
(63)
Chattel Number 5, Utah
(63)
63 customer reviews
De A.
These cookies are as good as they get, but the owners are pretty awesome people and really make this cookie store special! We ordered 2 dozen decorated sugar cookies for a Halloween party. The cookies looked and tasted fantastic! They were not cheap, but they were worth every penny, and somehow we ended up with a bunch of free cookies to try on our way out the door. Wowzers! Damn good cookies! I'm a fan! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Daniel Smurthwaite
Best cookies
Reviewed on Google Maps
Johnny Boy
Came here to fix a leak in the roof. The lady working here is amazing and such a kind hearted soul.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bill McFarland
These cookies are the best!! My Grandson calls this place 'The fancy Cookie Store'
Reviewed on Google Maps
Justin D.
I stopped in with my daughter after eating cheesesteaks at DP Cheesesteaks. The guy explained how every worked and gave us all a cookie to try. He gave us a pumpkin chocolate chip cookie. It was amazing. I purchased a dozen more just to be sure. They also have caramel apples in various flavors and gift baskets. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Wendy Horton
Yummy and unique cookies that you can't find anywhere else! The owner even took a lemon head cookie from the case for me to try before I bought some. Great customer service.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Justin Carter
They make some fun and fantastic treats. I always get at least 10 cookies when I stop by.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marie W
Wonderful cookies and great customer service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Steph H.
I am OBSESSED. And that's an understatement. My favorite is absolutely the lemon one. I also got chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, and one with caramel and chocolate drizzled across it. All were fantastic!I also ordered a rice krispie treat with fruit loops because I was intriguing and it was actually great!I am from California and flew in for the day. I'm salivating thinking about the next time I am there and loading up to bring back! If you even remotely enjoy cookies and are withing an hour drive, go to this place. You will not be disappointed. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Amy Turnbaugh Naylor
I absolutely love the cookies here! I wish they had more locations. I recommend the and the grasshopper cookies.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Junk Things
Delicious cookies! I highly recommend! Amazing snickerdoodles, sugar cookies, s'mores cookies! And lots of other treats too, chex mix, caramel corn, and caramel apples! Yummy!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ashley Stich
Some of the best cookies ever! I love the lemon and the s'mores cookies the most! The staff is always super friendly and caring. Cookies are cooked fresh every morning and you can call and order custom cookies! They also have more than just cookies too! They have rice crispies, fancy popcorn and even cute aprons for sale and more! I will continue to order cookies for all my events through Over the Top cookies! Just look at these cookies they just made for an order! ❤❤❤❤❤ More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dr. Ken Andersen
The BEST cookies ever!!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jon Raulston
Delicious cookies and great caramel apples! Very friendly owner.
Reviewed on Google Maps
sam oa
Really good cookies. I see it all the time going to the library just behind it so I finally stopped by to help support a local business and just to try a few random cookies. I was not disappointed, loved em all. I'm not really a sweet toothed person but if you are stop by and give it a try, I'm sure they'll have something in your flavor range. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Andrew McKeon
Friendly staff, delicious treats.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dan Knutilla
Absolutely love the cookies here. I had the peanut butter cup cookie today and it was amazing. The owner was so friendly. I would definitely recommend them if you are in the area and want an extremely flavorful cookie and to fill like you are part of the family there. Thanks for the great experience.
Reviewed on Google Maps
John C.
Never knew this place was here next to DP Cheesesteaks, had to run in and check out their selection.Warm greeting right when I arrived and the lady helping me explained every ingredient in the cookies I had questions on. A big plus in my book. I tried 6 different cookies, the gingersnap type cookie with frosting was by far the best tasting one. It had a kick to it and was very pleasant. :-)For sure will return when in the neighborhood. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Gina G
Darling little cookie shop! My mouth totally salivated the minute I saw the smores cookie lol. I love the atmosphere very clean and decorated very well for the upcoming Halloween holiday. Very friendly cashier and just a delightful experience. Yummy little cookies! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
brandonchristiansen1 Smoking
This place has awesome cookies and miraculously, even better costumer service. My wife and I took our two kids (5 and 3) to pick out a cookie a piece. Well, not surprising, both kids had a difficult time deciding what cookie they wanted. When The employee, Joe I believe, recognized the delema he unsolicitedly asked my kids what cookie they were thinking of getting and gave them each a cookie to see if it was what they liked it. I was so impressed with Joe that I tried to pay for the cookies he had given them and he would not allow it. He stated it was important that his customers got exactly what they wanted. Please stop in and give this local business some support. They definitely deserve it. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Emma Brasher
Very enthusiastic and awesome people! They do other gourmet treat baskets too! Adorable store :) Definitely worth a stop in!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sarah Mego
Soooo amazing and great service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Skyler R.
Their cookies are the bomb! The Reese's peanut butter cup ones the snicker doodles. We got them fresh out of the oven. The owners are really cool. Totally worth a stop especially if you have kids. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Aaron Wallick
Amazing cookies you have to try the lemon cookie. I have never had anything like it.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nina Walker
So good!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matthew Busi
Great cookies. Nice owners. Cute shop!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Arwen York
We love this place. We particularly love the lemon lime cookies and the caramel corn! It’s a cute mom and pop shop, so shop here to support local business!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Emily Long
Best place to get cookies! Great service. They are ready to help as soon as you enter the store. Always welcoming. If you order in advance, they have gluten free cookies. Also, they have a door bell if you need help if they aren't in the front yet. I LOVE this place. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Danielle Poulter
Their cookie/treat baskets make great client gifts. Everything is so delicious and they really go above and beyond to make it look nice for a great price.
Reviewed on Google Maps
chambrey Ferguson
Really good , very nice owners. My daughter walked out happy as could be so happy momma
Reviewed on Google Maps
J. Adam Cleverley
Amazing cookies!! Amazing service!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
M B
The owners are amazing! Their cookies are to die for! I love this place! Sugar cookies are out of this world!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Britta King
I LOVE these cookies! The Lemon one is my favorite. They have great service and are such kind people. I journey out to their shop (45 minutes drive) just to get me some amazing cookies!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Annabella Patty
Love these cookies! The lady who owns it is super sweet. I love coming here and ordering too many delicious cookies ♡♡♡
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nico M.
Not only are the cookies amazing, but the owners are super cool. Thank y'all for making my mother-in-law's birthday extra special! Anytime I need cookies, I'm definitely making the trip to South Jordan from now on, no questions asked! Only thing that could possibly make this little shop any better is having an "Over The Top" movie themed cookie. Maybe something that looks like this . Haha think about it...P.S. their gluten free cookies are freaking good! They don't taste like chalk. That gets its own 5 stars right there More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Marie Holderness
So so yummy! I adore their sugar cookies, and their little ones are the perfect size. I will most definitely be coming back!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kyna Sorensen
Our favorite place to go for cookies. They made an awesome platter for my daughters birthday and everyone loved it. They are always super friendly and kind. Love it!!!! The double dippers my favorite. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Liz
Really good cookies... especially the no-bakes. Kathleen is a doll. She works so hard and has made a really beautiful shop.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dallas Howard
Good cookies!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amy Poyer
Great little shop with nice people. Love the dipped chocolate chip cookies.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lorri Frame
Very nice clean shop in the town center of South Jordan. Lady behind the counter was sooo nice! Cookies are unbelievable ✨ ✨
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sandy D.
We stumbled upon this place, randomly, on our way to the frozen yogurt place. So I had to go in. I bought a Reece's and a frosted sugar cookie. But I really wanted to buy about 6 more!! They all looked amazing and they were quite tasty!! The lady who helped us was extremely nice!! Excellent customer service!! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Anna L.
I was pleasantly surprised to find a gluten free selection of cookies. The m&m cookie was absolute perfection. It didn't crumble in my hands and had the perfect amount of m&m's to balance the soft, doughy texture of the cookie mix. I'll definitely return to this location to satisfy my sweet tooth cravings; perhaps with a glass of milk. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Lisa B.
The cookies and treats are out of this world delicious! Customer service is top notch - they definitely aim to please. Perfect after dinner treat. The owner is hilarious and wants everyone to leave happy and satisfied. I'll be back! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Devin L.
Ok, I'm pretty picky when it comes to cookies, and feel my secret homemade recipe is the best, but I'm pretty sure I've just eaten the best cookie I've ever had in my life! It's hard to say which is better, the Reese's PB cup, or their original iced sugar cookie. It's no wonder their wall is lined with "Best In State" awards from every single year. If there is a better cookie out there, I would be very surprised! Wow! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Coco S.
My husband always wants to stop in here after getting a sandwich from DP next door. I think it's mainly the fact that they have candy all over their cookies, but really the cookies are quite good. Most of what makes these "original" is just that they put candy on top, but I LOVE their snickerdoodles (they have cinnamon chips in them I think) and their s'mores cookies are awesome. The service is always great here as well. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Joannie C.
The owners of this cute cookie shop are absolutely amazing! I received wonderful customer service and will be a customer for life. Their cookies are not only amazing to look at but just as wonderful to eat. Kathleen did an amazing job on these little wedding cake cookies I had ordered! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Rebecca D.
Fun spin on traditional bakery cookies. Good selection and gift basket options are nice. I like that they offer small cookie options as well as full sized.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jesse Y.
Sometimes in life you need a pick me up. Sometimes you are tired of eating a your candy bar out of a wrapper. Sometimes you want a cookie or you just cant decide. I have found a place that has the solution.Over the top is a excellent name for these cookies. No bad choices from the excellant sugar cookies to candy bar covered cookies. They have a smore cookies that looks out this world. I think there a cookie under there?The only complaint I have is that they use the left twix on the twix cookie and the right side version. Still good. They have big and small version of their cookies. Grab a few of the small ones to try and then buy the big one you enjoy. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Eric Slaughter
These cookies are fantastic. They have a great variety and they have great flavor. I had the opportunity to meet the owners while I was shopping for cookies. They are very nice people and I will continue to buy their cookies. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
