Nikoli's Pizza and Catering
Shiremanstown, Pennsylvania
(37)
Shiremanstown, Pennsylvania
(37)
37 customer reviews
Pearl Girlforver
I give Nikolis a 4 because most times they do an awesome job and deliver quickly. Today I give them 0 stars. I ordered lunch and I asked for a chicken Cesar wrap with no croutons (said no croutons 3 times). The lady who answered didn’t seem to be focused in work or something because it took me 10 mins to order and the order had to be repeated multiple times. And when I said no croutons she said oh it doesn’t come with them (according to the website it does) and she had to ask her coworkers if it did. When I got my food fairly quick I was extremely disappointed to find the wrap thrown together sloppy and there were 10 croutons in my wrap and barely any Cesar dressing on it. The worst service I’ve ever had from them. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Priscilla Herd
Excellent food! Especially the homemade breads and dough! Great customer service too!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Charles E
The best pizza in Mechanicsburg Pa.! I have to say there are a lot of choices in thr area when it comes to pizza and subs but this place by far exceeds the rest. My company brings it in for lunch regularly and it's where I first experienced it and now it is my go to when I'm at work and feeling like pizza and apparently I'm not the only one. When ordering for delivery at lunch time order early in the day as they ge quite busy and delivery times can get long as they also do catering. When eating in you order your food as you come in, grab a table and they bring it out to you. Service inside is fast and the employees are friendly and accommodating. The inside is older but appears very clean. I will definitely be back for more! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sean Barron
Love their pizza and wings! It's been my family's go to pizza place since we lived down the street from it. Even after we moved to the Carlisle Pike, there hasn't been a pizza place to replace the quality or the price.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Derek Staley
The best pizza I've ever had. The stromboli is even better than the pizza. I have to stop by here every time I'm in town. If you've never been here before you won't be disappointed if you do, promise.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tadd Keefer
My favorite pizza in Camp Hill Harrisburg area. They have really good calzones as well. I can't drive by this place without grabbing a slice of pepperoni pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
linda thompson
best subs in the USA! such nice employees... mannerly, efficient and conscientious with every order. quality of meats and amount given is appreciated.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Britany A
I’ve seriously never had a bad meal here! My husband has been a customer for years and he turned me on to this place when I first moved to Camp Hill 4 years ago. Great pizza, delicious cheeseburger subs, and when I was pregnant the only thing I could keep down were their cheese fries lol! Plus they deliver. Would highly recommend! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Wendy Luther Dickey
The food was great... On our way home from Hershey back to MD... This past Friday..And you made my son Wyatt's day .. There aren't enough words to thank you :)
Reviewed on Facebook
Chris Pahlman
I love their pizza and wings but this is not a jumbo wing! Wish they were bigger for .89!
Reviewed on Facebook
Gina Birch
The pizza was delicious and the service was great.
Reviewed on Facebook
Joe Swank
Love this place. Mom and pop pizza shop. Best pizza in camp hill area by far and they deliver also.
Reviewed on Facebook
Christine White Pahlman
Best pizza, food and staff! Great for lunch and dinner! Highly recommend! Wonderful family business!
Reviewed on Facebook
Scott Loomis
Nikoli's is one of my favorite places for subs. They have great food and really support their local community, an all around great place!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jessica Markley
Great service and excellent food!!! No matter what you order it's fantastic!! Great for subs for parties also and terrific fundraising ideas!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Mary Clayton
I frequently get Nikoli's for lunch and it is always amazing! Try the Buffalo Chicken Boli! Everyone is always nice and great to work with. Had an amazing catered lunch today too! Nikoli's always does a great job! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
John Broody
Great staff and always willing to make the trip out to our house for pizza! One of the best places in the area!
Reviewed on Facebook
Christopher Notestine
I don't get here as much as I'd like since my office moved across town. Rick and his crew are the nicest and you can't beat their chicken salad or meatball subs. Hungry just thinking about it.
Reviewed on Facebook
Sarah Barr
We absolutely love Nikoli's! It's my number one go to choice for lunch. I have also used them for several catering jobs for a variety of events. The food is excellent and the staff is always friendly. The owners are great people and are really involved with the community. They are great at making recommendations if you are undecided with what you want to eat that day. The other night we went in for dinner with my 2 year old niece. We ordered a slice of pizza for her. They brought her slice to the table and without even asking... their employee asked if we would like that sliced in bite size pieces for her. I was so impressed that they even thought to offer doing that for us! Happy happy customer! :-) More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Glenda Dauberman
Pizza night!! Since we moved here we have wanted to try the pizza place by our house... Finally got to try it tonight... HIGHLY recommend it! So delish AND fast FRIENDLY service....Bonus we walk out with a dozen roses too! So sweet...TY!!! ♡ More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Ella Banella
Thank you so much for vegan pizza!!! If you carry it again I will most definitely come back many times! Delicious, thanks!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Valerie McCartt
BEST meatballs in the whole wide world!!! Subs have huge portions of meat, and the rolls are perfection. Love love love the cheesy garlic bread. Great customer service, you can tell this is a shop that genuinely cares about their business. Thank you for an awesome pizza shop! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kirk Lee Nace
I was in PA Sunday night and stopped for a bite. The food was great as always and when my son left a balloon inside the restaurant the staff actually ran out to us in the parking lot to see if he wanted it . .. truly serving others is a rare thing ... throw in great pizza and you've got a winner! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kimberly Istvan
Thank you for feeding 30 Cumberland Valley Boys Basketball players and coaches yesterday. Everyone loved your sandwiches, chips and cookies. You made the process easy and affordable for our booster club. Much appreciated! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Gary R Hunter
Amazing food and great people. One of the best shops around!
Reviewed on Facebook
Marty Dumic
I love Nikoli's pizza. I've bought many a pizza there. Tried the all you can eat spaghetti today. The spaghetti was very good. But, I can't give 5 stars because I had to come find someone to get refills, and the picture shows a meatball. When I asked why no meatball on the plates , I was told the meatballs are extra. The young girl didn't say anything about this when I paid for it (you have to pay before - not after). She didn't even ask if we wanted meatballs. She seemed to know nothing about this special at all. These were the only down sides to the evening. But, the food is very good, so I'd go back again. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lee H
This place is a decent pizza shop with really nice people.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rick Harhigh
EXTREMELY friendly staff. Great meals and prices. I can't say enough good things about this business to accurately display how pleased I am with them.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Debbie Jo Raith
We were at a baseball tournament and Nikoli's was fairly close to where we were & we were hungry! We went there as a fairly large group & they accommodated us quickly and with a friendly attitude. The food here was absolutely wonderful! In fact we had day 2 the following day and we went back to Nikoli's Pizza for lunch again! If that doesn't tell you how good the food is, nothing will! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jon Ward
Good subs and pizza but the stromboli is the best in the area, tastes great and good size for the money, regular size will definitely feed two and the large is good for 4.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Hunter A
The food is great but the service can be kinda rude sometimes
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sharon Alvord
I had their french bread pizza which has a sweet tasting sauce instead of the watery tasting kind you get from the average pizza place. Their food very good.They have the usual pizza sub joint standard fare such as strombolies, cheese steakes, cold subs, itallian dinners, a good deluxe pretzel hamburger with bacon, pickels, thousand island dressing,cheese,onions,lettuce, tomatoes that is a large burger.There is also a senoir menue which is nice.They make their own deserts. Large orders of onion rings, mushrooms, mac & cheese bites pluse all kinds of fries that are a meal in itself. You cannot go wrong with this pizza sub place. Delivery also! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
David Runkle
Subs were excellent and the Mac and cheese bites were amazing!
Reviewed on Google Maps
ezbread
My coworker and I order here frequently.. Walt always has our food here quickly! Unbelieveably fast sometimes.. under 10 minutes.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Luke Cantando
Incredible pizza. Also got some subs and entrees here and they haven't disappointed yet. We always get delivery so can't speak to the actual service.
Reviewed on Google Maps
E G
Good food to end an overly busy day. Was in from out of town and wanted fresh hand tossed pizza. This place is good.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jacob Foster
Nikolis not only has the best pizza around, but also the best service. The boy who took my order at lunch time this afternoon was super polite and asked me if I needed anything several times! I want to go back in just to see him! Great food and great man behind the counter! His name was Michael I believe! The rest of the staff was great as well and like always the pizza was as good as pizza can be imagined to be! My favorite place by far More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
