Nick's Italian
Historic Fort Collins High School, Larimer County
(430)
Historic Fort Collins High School, Larimer County
(430)
430 customer reviews
Jim Felix
Great REAL Italian
Reviewed on Google Maps
Caleb Crowe
pretty epic pizza and pasta
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jeneane Malone
Best darn Italian I have found since moving from back east 22 yrs ago. Pizza is to die for and wings whete delicious!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Robert Russom
Great food reasonably priced fantastic service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kaytlyn Kooyers
Some of the BEST Italian we have ever had. They make their Alfredo sauce by hand (off the menu) and it is exceptionally tasty! Wait time wasn’t too bad, typical on a Friday night. Would definitely suggest trying Nick’s out if new to FoCo. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brian Andes
Excellent Italian food. We sat in the bar area and had great service from Nick (not the owner haha) We had the lasagna and the spaghetti dishes and both tasted marvelous. We will definitely suggest this restaurant to our friends and we can't wait to come back to try other dishes. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
C S
Food was fabulous! The waiter was patient and took great care of us.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Katherine Matzke
Lovely, warm atmosphere. Our bartender was so kind, friendly, and energetic. She was so ready to help and give suggestions! The food was delicious as well!
Reviewed on Google Maps
M HARTMANN
Had the eggplant parmesan and it was fantastic ! would definitely do it again service was friendly and quick atmosphere was wonderful definitely give them a try.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sarah Crutchfield
Always great! Always busy! Great happy hour
Reviewed on Google Maps
Chad Bradley
Fantastic pie and salad. Great menu and staff is always smiling.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Evan Gordon
Hands down top 3 places to get pizza in Fort Collins. Move aside Super Number 1 Chinese buffet, this Italian place is here to stay. Want to skip the busy downtown scene and get great food? Well this is the restaurant for you! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Richard Schierl
Amazing food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Asma Salek
I really liked this place. The most important thing for me is hospitality and I would give 5 stars for that. Besides great service and nice and welcoming atmosphere, the food quality was good too. We had a eggplant Parmesan and a shrimp pizza. The pizza was one of the best pizzas I have had. The eggplant parmesan was OK,it was a little too oily. The bruschetta was different and delicious. The portions are big so the prices are kind of reasonable. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jennifer Wagner
Best Italian in Fort Collins
Reviewed on Google Maps
Adam Z
The. Best. Pizza. In Fort Collins.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Linda Vidales
Delicious, and they have great servers
Reviewed on Google Maps
Royce Simpson
Above average.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Vincent AhSam-Kreiter
Good place to try. Ate outside in the patio.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Phillip Christy
Surprisingly some of the best food we had on our trip across Colorado! Truffle oil mushroom pizza was awesome and the server brought us by some red sauce to dip it in genius
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matthew Pulc
Pizza and burger are good. The burger is better than the pizza in my opinion. The meat seemed fresh and full of flavor.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Justin Thompson
One of my favorite places in town to take my daughter's. Amazing food and great atmosphere!
Reviewed on Google Maps
sara Bowman
If you are picky, I hope you like burgers (theirs is fantic thiygh!)
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dana Lipfert
Wow! Best Italian and Nick said hi!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Carol Jordan
Great place...great food. .service also very good. I would recommend to others.
Reviewed on Google Maps
samuel casad
Great pizza, happy hour, and bartenders! Good parking too.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tracey Dutcher
This place has the best pasta in town! Hands down one of the best restaurants in Fort Collins.
Reviewed on Google Maps
John Hatfield
Amazing great food. Our first time and we will go back!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Stephanie Crowley
Excellent food and great service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Diana Serviss
Clair is the best !
Reviewed on Google Maps
Laura Bishop
The food is delicious, we've never had a bad meal at Nick's. Staff is friendly, atmosphere is casual and modern. Good bar menu with variety as far as beers, wine, and cocktails. But seriously, the food. The food is so good. A scoche on the pricey side, but totally worth the extra bucks for some solid Italian dishes. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sam Strong
Not a huge selection but very good still
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kailey Wilson
Great food!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Erik Devlin
Great experience & food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Timothy Hollaman
Tatra gave us wonderful service and the food was amazing.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Patrick Bauers
Great food, friendly staff.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Paul Davidson
So.. first off, the food is excellent.The wait staff did a great job for... Making up for massive failures in kitchen execution. We ordered two apps, drinks, a salad, and four entrees- three pastas and a pizza. The drinks came out a little slow, followed by the apps. Then, three entrees and the salad all at once.After we were all done.. the pizza. The waiter was very good, the manager comped the pizza.. all good. But mistakes were made. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amanda Nebelsick
My first time here and it is very good Italian food in a great atmosphere. I liked that it wasn't too noisy or crowded together. I order chicken parmigiana as the standard for "can they do a basic easy dish" and the answer is yes. Wonderful marinara, not too sweet, not too herby, could taste the tomato. The chicken was a bit overcooked around the edges, but it was big enough that I could avoid edges and still be full. Generous cheese and lots of fresh basil was amazing. The garlic bread was pretty good, but a little dry. Worth the extra money? Not sure yet. I would love to see more wines available by the glass. I think there were only 4 reds listed by the glass and one or two were blends, which I avoid. I will 100% go back with family, friends or a date night. Looking forward to the ricotta gnocchi! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lisa Perkins
Food and service were great! Prices are average. Would definitely go again.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amber Williams
Such, such good food, get the house specials, you'll never be disappointed
Reviewed on Google Maps
SequoiaElisabeth
Great Lasagna!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Travis Brandsma
Good food, had the Italian sub and chips tasted good. Staff were nice And will be going back to try more
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jake Ward
Great Italian. I got lasagna and was very impressed. It wasn't super hearty and fattening like most lasagnas. It tasted very authentic and unique.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dixon Dick
Really friendly staff excellent food and beer. Great conversation with local people.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Grant Rasmussen
Great for a first date
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christy Moriarty
First time here. Have always wanted to try it. Delicious, comfortable atmosphere, lovely service. Kudos to your cook, Nick, for preparing and recommending the GF pasta with chicken piccata ... #LOVED
Reviewed on Google Maps
Vivian F
Best date night ever! Food was amazing and old fashioneds were on point! Best bar tender/server.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alicia G
Best food and service we had on a 2 week trip to Colorado! One word = YUM!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Adam Colorado
LOVE this place. Been there a handful of times now and every time I’ve been the food is great, the wait staff is friendly and accommodating and the atmosphere is great. The carbonara and Brussels Caesar is a must. Will definitely be back More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christine Sizer
Great food, great service. Loud - don't expect to hear without raising your voice.
Reviewed on Google Maps
