New York Pizza Pub

Pizza is very good, we have gotten several different options and they have all been delicious. Staff is friendly and attentive. We usually go on a night with live music. Always have a great time. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Enjoyable. We ordered pizza, chicken fingers, and the appetizer sampler. All of which were very good. Service was exceptional. The atmosphere was good. This was one of the few places we went to on vacation that didn’t give off a tourist vibe, which was a breath of fresh air. Would definitely go back. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

The wings SLAPPED. I ordered them hot and extra crispy. As someone who went to college in central New York, I’ve had my fair share of wings; these were top 3 I’ve ever had. Pizza is great too, but I wish the crust was more light/crisp. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

One of the best Italian Restaurants on The Outer Banks of North Carolina. The staff, prices and food here is great followed by with some awesome late night clubbing with sweet bands and musicians. You gotta swing by and check it out today. The New York Pizza Pub is all around an overall great restaurant for family, friends, locals and or tourists vacationing here. Make this one of your stops while your in the area, I promise you won’t regret it! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Pizza was yummy

Reviewed on Google Maps

Never disappointed

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good pizza

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great food

Reviewed on Google Maps

Yummola!! My husband and I stopped in for our first visit last week and thought this place was a great find. Delicious food oh, good beer and a fun atmosphere even in the off-season! Would definitely recommend and eat here again. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

We ordered the Chicken Pesto pizza, it was so flavorful from the crust to the cheese and toppings. The salad was really good too. They were very busy tonight but it was definitely worth the wait. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Food and drinks were very good but service could be better

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great Pizza.....best in months !!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best pizza I ever had... honestly...so much cheese...the best ever

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great pizza great service clean place

Reviewed on Google Maps

Stayed a week on the OBX.Went to New York Pizza, it was amazing!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great pizza crust was thin but not dry

Reviewed on Google Maps

Needed a place that served Gluten Free pizza. $14 for a small which is pretty standard anywhere. My son enjoyed it very much! I placed a pickup order & was told 25 minutes. When I arrived 25 minutes later, it was just coming out of the oven piping hot. Will return! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

We love New York Pizza PubWe go there every time we are in the Outer Banks Great food Very nice people And very clean

Reviewed on Google Maps

Fun atmosphere, decent pizza

Reviewed on Google Maps

Came in for dinner as we have done many times over the past years while down visiting and were extremely pleased to see the friendly face of a waitress who had waited on us numerous times before, Alana. She wasn’t there the past two years we have been down, we were told she had moved on to another restaurant but she’s back and it was a pleasant surprise. The menu had changed as far as salads and pastas. Sad to see our favorite Greek salad wasn’t listed but Alana did inform us there was a Greek salad special with tuna. We passed on that and chose two small house salads instead. The pizza I had was delicious and the pasta my wife ordered seemed to make her happy as well so a thumbs up from us! The food is always good when we go but I do have to say, it’s the service you receive that makes all the difference in an ok meal and a great one. Alana is always friendly with a smile, positive, upbeat attitude and helpful suggestions. I don’t normally do this online thing but after coming back to that level of service deserves praise. Thank you for a wonderful evening and meal and we can’t wait to return again soon! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

The waiters from ny and the food

Reviewed on Google Maps

First time to try and it was beyond delicious. The restaurant was clean and the staff friendly. The young man who waited on us took the time to explain the pizzas to us. Will definitely be returning.

Reviewed on Facebook

Great pizza friendly staff.

Reviewed on Facebook

Best pizza on the barrier islands, hands down.

Reviewed on Google Maps

As a longtime visitor to the outer banks sometimes you want something else besides seafood. This place hit the spot! Very good pizza. Friendly staff is always a plus!

Reviewed on Facebook

Great pizza and friendly staff

Reviewed on Google Maps

If I was on a fence and had to describe this play by which side that fence I fell on it defenietly wouldn't be the Italian food side

Reviewed on Google Maps

excellent pizza, excellent friendly service

Reviewed on Google Maps

Very friendly staff, great food, especially the garlic knots!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great food and friendly service. We will enjoy dinner here again.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Food is delicious. Service was excellent again. We visit every year on vacation, the consistency is appreciated. We probably be in one more time this week to try something different. Well Done.

Reviewed on Facebook

Very good food and service

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good food!!!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

The food was excellent but the service was horrible. We got more help from a waitress who wasn’t ours than we did our own.

Reviewed on Facebook

Great meat lovers pizza, this is one place that the vegetarians will despise.

Reviewed on Facebook

My boyfriend, his friends and I went for about a hour and it was a good time....it was really great when we got to watch the band playing get a show too while they played. ..sure hope that lady that peed on the speaker didn't mess it up! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

This is our second visit. The first visit last year wasn't great as far as service. It took us over 1 hour to get our food but a big order of 20 to 40 pizzas had been placed and they didn't do ours before that. Our waitress was great and apologized a ton but just the managing of the orders by the kitchen, etc. was bad. They did give us free desserts for the trouble which were decent. The pizza almost a 5 star. We can understand this was a freak incident. Our second visit went smooth. Great friendly service. Good water. I ordered a strawberry smoothie that was more like a strawberry slushie and I was expecting more like Panera Bread consistency. It tasted OK but not something I would order again. The pizza the same as the first time almost a 5 star! Great cheese, pepperoni, sauce, and crust. Great atmosphere with several tables on the first and second floor, sports on TVs (I think at least 6 TVs downstairs where we sat), etc.Plenty of parking. We will stop by again for this pizza. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Pizza was really delicious. Staff was friendly. Food came promptly.

Reviewed on Google Maps

nice place, nice atmosphere, nice staff, very clean wish we were here for more than pizza but that’s all we have time for. so far the best pizza i’ve had in NC More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great pizza! If you like hot wings the nuclear wings are brutal!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great pizza, go there every time we are down there

Reviewed on Google Maps

Food and service is fantastic. We visit every time we come to the Outer Banks. Highly recommend!!

Reviewed on Facebook

great service, very friendly!!

Reviewed on Facebook

Good food

Reviewed on Google Maps

Wings and pizza are great

Reviewed on Google Maps