Bell Heights, Wisconsin
92 customer reviews
Brittany Voigt
The best cookies, coffee, salads, and sandwiches in the area! You won't be disappointed!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Al Solowicz
A pleasant surprise.....everything is fantastic!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Scott Servatius
Great sandwiches and friendly staff!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tara Joy
My first time here today, ordered a french dip and a soda, 11.01 was my total. Imagine my dismay when the sandwich was half super super rare. I brought it up to the counter though and the girls were amazingly friendly and explained that some cuts are just really rare and remade the whole thing for me, I dont know if it was the owner or manager but she was incredibly friendly and polite and the sandwich that they remade for me was absolutely delicious! Some places if they need to remake will get snotty or rude but this place has a great crew. I will be back. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Roger Trovato
Very good sandwiches and sides.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michelle & Matt Storma
One of our favorite places to eat
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rayne Coe
I've seen a lot of restaurants behind the scenes in my life, and never have I seen one so clean and fresh before in my life. Freshly sliced meats and veggies make it so that all of the food is delicious. Definitely deserves its Golden Fork awards. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tim Pingel
This was my first visit; the restaurant was very clean and well decorated. Friendly service-oriented staff Very easy to place your order. I had the Zito panini which was very good. The bread was evenly grilled and light crispness to it. The sandwich was perfect temperature and packed very well for a to-go order. I will be back for sure. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christie McCowen
Mmmm! So tasty. I ordered a panini and it came out perfect, just the way I wanted it. I can't wait to try more of their sandwiches in the future!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dale Seefeldt
Always great food. Been here many times. Friendly staff, but the delivery is a little slow. But if you are prepared for that the food is well worth the wait, seriously. Great location, easy in and out, outside dining. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Yolanda Weber
Always fresh and yummy. Make the sandwiches how you like and staff is awesome.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Megan Sjoberg
We love New York Deli! They have some delicious sandwiches!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Structured Knowledge
Quick service with clean and professional environment.
Reviewed on Google Maps
James Ball
Great warm Reuben.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Steve Heuser
Good sandwiches!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matt Bos
Awesome chicken cordon blue panini! Served on gluten free bread. What a great place to grab a sandwich!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dawn Bessette
I went in looking for a specific Boar's Head ham and they didn't have it. However, they offered to order it in for me. We travel all over & love the Garlic Peppanero Ham but can't find it outside of Publix. So excited!
Reviewed on Google Maps
SQL 4FUN
I had New York Deli cater my future daughter in law's bridal shower. I have never received so many compliments on food before. The fruit, vegetables and salad selections were so fresh. The meats were awesome and the cheese was great. I had the homemade rolls and the man of the house loved them. I would definitely recommend New York Deli for any catering you need. And they deliver! How awesome is that?! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Johnnie Lynn
Awesome little deli with delicious food made to order. Kind of iff the beat path to the mall but a very good choice if your looking for something different away from all the mall traffic.
Reviewed on Google Maps
kathy Stevens
It was the best sandwich. Boars head delicious!!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Janet Marie
Delicious sandwiches and super friendly staff!
Reviewed on Google Maps
James Blackburn
Love this place. Great for lunch.
Reviewed on Google Maps
C S
Always good food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jennifer Grizzle
Excellent food every time we order lunch!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ezra Schoonover
Tasty daily specials. Absolutely wonderful cookies..
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alice Martin
The lines move very fast and the goods are of high quality!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
DOMINICK GORDEN
The Dominator wrap is the best sandwich I have ever eaten, it is hot but not too hot as to where it is not nice to eat 10/10 would recomend
Reviewed on Google Maps
eric nelson
Great sandwiches, nice and clean atmosphere. They use BoarsHead meats and cheeses which are awesome!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Scott Bonovich
This is one of my favorite places to enjoy lunch. The deli sandwich selection is fantastic and the food is outstanding! The atmosphere is friendly and the service is second to none. If you're trying to decide where to go for a great lunch experience, New York Deli should be top of your list! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
lucas ice
First time visitor, I walked in just before closing without realizing it, the two working there were exceptionally friendly even though I kept them almost 20 mins late, (thanks guys) great atmosphere & excellent panini, will definitely return!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jeff Fallona
I can't believe I only recently found out about this place. The sandwiches are to die for. My girlfriend and I will definitely be visiting here more often. The only down side is this place closes by 3pm which is unfortunate because I would love to go here for dinner. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jeffrey Wisch
Very good food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Gregory Gray
Great meatball sandwich
Reviewed on Google Maps
Steve Vignali
Great lunch spot. Food is fresh and the service is fast and friendly.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michael Charron
Best lunch by the airport, really like this place! Lots to choose from on the menu.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brenda Gresl
There sandwich are wonderful and full of flavor!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lauren Marshall
Excellent food and friendly staff, great atmosphere and homemade soups!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Emily Scott
Great sandwiches and service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Patricia Katzman
Our favorite place for lunch. This time of year is when we like to go for the seasonal Turkey & Cranberrry sandwich. There is always plenty for us to share with a bag of chips & a soda. Comfortable atmosphere & friendly service. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Scott
Best subs in the valley
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christopher Klaus
Not quite up to NY, NY standards; but for the Midwest this is an great deli! I'll look forward to visiting again. :)
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sweat N Sand Workouts
One of the best Greek salads I've ever had!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ben Mortier
Had the Bronx Bomber, corned beef and pastrami, super tasty.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nathan D.
Amazing. Best place in Appleton, without a doubt. Friendly, great atmosphere, and best sandwiches in the Fox Valley.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marcus Schuh
Very clean and inviting inside. The food is excellent and is made to order. All of the sandwiches I've had we're carefully made And didn't fall apart.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lou Judge
Nice place and good food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Peter Bielmeier
Excellent sandwiches
Reviewed on Google Maps
Eric Allen
Clean place they have boarhead available for purchase.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Luke Garrow
Solid food with out chain feeling
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jami Buchanan
Fast, friendly, & fresh. Sandwiches, salads, soup, desserts. Very good.
Reviewed on Google Maps