Midtown Pizza
Oberlin, Pennsylvania
(74)
Oberlin, Pennsylvania
(74)
74 customer reviews
Tyler Jazz
The food here is really good and the takeout options are pretty great as well. A variety of alcoholic beverages and menu options. But the restaurant itself is pretty bland when it comes to the overall look of the place More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nina B.
Midtown Pizza will always be my preferred pizza place near home, or even bar when I am in the mood for a drink. The staff is always super friendly no matter where you sit. We were waited on by Sherry who happened to be the only server/bartender on the floor - the bar was packed and two booths were full. Sherry did her absolute best to provide us with a good experience, which is appreciated. I also took a friend for her first time and she is excited to come back! Thank you, Midtown! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Carmen la Fata
I love this place i can ‘t wait to go when i get to usa I have been there many Times and apart from eating good food ,kindness and sympathy, beautiful evenings spent in good food and pleasant conversation.
Reviewed on Facebook
Tusa Adriano
Loved the food an staff is excellent! Will definitely go there again. Best cheesesteak in town ! Good bread!
Reviewed on Facebook
Matthew Ondo
I go to their bar next door, mugs, which serves their food. Great place and food!
Reviewed on Google Maps
tommy sager
Good food, cheap drinks
Reviewed on Google Maps
Johnna Thomas
Just want to say the food was good but most was cold on the buffet.. the chicken was dry but had great flavor. The pizza was dry but the kids liked it. There was plenty to choose from. The prices for the buffet I fell where kinda high for the children I feel children under 2 should be free or 1.99. My two year old can not eat much so paying five bucks for 1 slice and a few corn fritters I felt was kinda high. The waitress was amazing she was fast and so nice and kid friendly. The owner I’m assuming was kind he asked if we needed anything. I think we had great service just wish the food was hot and not dried out. Only fresh food that was put out was shrimp fries and corn fritters. We drove from annville just for the chicken wings witch where very very dried out and hard to eat. But again I think I would try again and definitely will be back maybe just not for the buffet More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sommer Perez
My family and I come here all the time! If something is wrong, I’ve never had an issue with either Dave or Max himself fixing it. Pizza is amazing and so are the subs! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Dani Beth
amazing!! great service! super friendly! prompt!
Reviewed on Facebook
Kathleen Matthews
Pizza and Italian hoagie was super delish!
Reviewed on Google Maps
peter bitter
Pizza good
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ken Hudson
Pizza was delicious! Large selection of alcohol.
Reviewed on Facebook
AL WMS
Awsome pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Craig A. Daub
The pasta specials here are a great deal. Had a huge portion of lasagna and it came with salad and garlic bread made from a large sub roll. The waitress was extremely helpful and friendly. If you haven't yet eaten here, I highly recommend it! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
CJ’s INFO
Friendly staff, delicious pizza for decent price! Thanks!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Irish Creme
Order calzone and cheese steak stromboli. The "small" size were huge. And very good. Nice and cheesy. They had no issue with me adding an upcharge of mushrooms to the stromboli. Very casual jeans and t-shirt kind of place. Beer to go or drink there. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Suburban Huskies
They make a good pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Paula L.
My favorite pizza shop! They not only make great pizza; everything we have had is delicious. We dine in or order out, and have been so pleased. We ordered 9 dinners to be delivered and our guests loved the food. One last thought, best cheese steak ever! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Ryan Austin
The Slices are the Best !!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Samuel M.
Great pizza I only got 2 slices felt like I was eating 4 the pizza slices was huge and the fries was great the place was nice it's connected to a bar with pool tables l. The employees was nice and friendly More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Ryan Clark
Nice workers, decent beer selection in that fridge, and they deliver everything, including beer. That’s a great idea, one of the few places that do that. The pizza has too much sauce and not enough cheese. My only complaint. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tonito O.
Love this place its a great place For Food great services I been coming here for Years keeps getting better lots of changes I love to see a reasturant grow
Reviewed on Yelp
Casey R.
We have visited this place a few times now and it is our favorite pizza! We had no issues with customer service like previous reviews, it's more of a sit down on your own and refill your own water kind of place. I definitely plan on returning when we are Portland again. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Cathy N.
Excelente! Usualmente visitó más el lado del bar q tiene por nombre "Mugs" pero pertenece a la pizzería Carlos es de los mejores bartenders q e conocido. Los precios son buenos y el ambiente es excelente! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Charles B.
We ordered online for pickup. We ordered a plain cheese New Yorker and garlic butter wings. Everything was very good the pizza was huge, the wings could have used more garlic.
Reviewed on Yelp
Sandy Myers
Tonight I had dinner with my grandson at your restaurant. After eating, which was lovely, we went shopping at Giant, where we realized that a large amount of cash had fallen out of my wallet. I called your restaurant and immediately was told that they had my cash and would hold it. I love you guys. Your food is great, your servers are outstanding, and you make me happy to live in your neighborhood!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Misty Moseley
The staff is pleasant and respectful. Clean, comfortable atmosphere..I'd definitely recommend it to friends and family.. .the food was well prepared and delicious..not a long wait time and the wait staff was very attentive.. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Alli Wintz
Max the owner is amazing and always so helpful. I have never had a bad experience and eat here about one a week. Totally recommend!
Reviewed on Facebook
Rachael Smithers
Great relaxing atmosphere. Wonderful service and absolutley delicious italian food. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for good italian food.
Reviewed on Facebook
Brian Smith
As someone relatively new to the area I stopped in here one day and I have to say the bar staff and the servers are absolutely outstanding! The food is absolutely incredible and every single thing I've ordered was a generous portion for a great price and for this reason I've become a frequent regular there. Plus if you want to stop in for some beers over happy hour and watch sports, just say the word and they'll turn it on. Love Midtown Pizza and have nothing negative to note. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lisa Crater
The food here is amazing!!! By far my favorite pizza shop in middletown. The staff is amazing too! We had Jackie wait on us. She was friendly, speedy, and professional. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jackie Elizabeth
Lots of changes have been made and it's by far one of the best pizza shops in the area. The staff is amazing, and anytime you need to speak your opinion the manager or boss are right there to listen and help. It is great to know they care what you think. Definitely will eat here again. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Patrick Stone
Every since my girlfriend Jackie told me to eat here I've been hooked! I can't believe the food is so good! I get the wings and hickory burger, they're my favorite! My family always orders here because I make them! lol and we couldn't ask for better service. The drivers are so nice, the cashier's are nice! They all are always willing to help. If there's a problem or question the boss fixes it and leaves you happy and satisfied! I used to eat at JJ's, but now it's Midtown Pizza all the way!! Best place in Middletown no matter what your looking for!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Audrey Wright
Ordered from the Eisenhower Blvd restaurant. I can say that it was the best food ever. Quick delivery, quantity and price was good. The service was excellent the person taking the order all the way down to the delivery driver was so nice. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jarrad Rice
Every time I am on that side of town I just have to stop for the Chicken parm sandwich and the loaded fries. It is simply the best in town along with a friendly staff and owner, you can never go wrong! Keep up the great work guys!
Reviewed on Facebook
Kimberly Heffron
I order from there frequently and the food is always delivered quickly. On the rare occasion that something is incorrect, they fix it quickly and are apologetic. The portions are generous and worth the cost. I would recommend Midtown to anyone!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Bob Bakaric
Lots of changes were made and is back to being one of the best pizza shops in the area. After I voiced my experience I was heard a Max and staff responded. It is great to know they care what you think. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jenna Uselton
We love Midtown! My family has gone there since Max's dad was running it and I was a kid. We are always running there for lunch pick ups for the ladies in my office. And Max is as friendly and accommodating as they come! Midtown will always get my business! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Scott Kemp
Excelllent food and drink friendly staff
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cedric Milberry
Good food. Nice bartender...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dylan Sutton
Place is great lots of activities,, great assorted crowd,, good vibes,, carlos the bartender is the bomb,, only dislike is could use better ventilation for the cigarette smoke.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Debra Robinson
Great food. Nice ha g out..I'm stuffed Carlos is nice and Cute. Good bartender...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michael Karli
Ordered the veggie pizza. Delicious. No delivery during lunchtime
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joseph Musa
Great New Yorker Pizza! Also sell beer, and there is a bar right beside them (Mugs)
Reviewed on Google Maps
frederick simmons
I HAD A GREAT EXPERIENCE THERE,THEY HAD GREAT SERVICE AND THEY CAME AROUND EVERY SO OFTEN 2MAKESURE I WAS OK....SO 2ME THEY DESERVE 5 ⭐
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bud Weiser
The food is always freshly prepared, very tasty, and offered at a reasonable price..... and they also have ice cold beer to go!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Carlos Olmeda
Great food and service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Katie Zimm
No matter what you get its Awesome & Fresh
Reviewed on Google Maps
Augustine Wojcik
Fantastic Sicilian Pizza! I would highly recommend you get your next pizza from here. Great food and even better customer service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rachel Fox-Hamlett
Friendly staff, fun atmosphere and they allow in-house smoking
Reviewed on Google Maps
