Mc Gillicuddy's
New Paltz, New York
(295)
New Paltz, New York
(295)
295 customer reviews
cray cray kid
Excellent wings and service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joan Sweeny
Great burgers, good staff, fun Irish pub and rowdy at night!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jason Weiss
Classic in town; best Shepard's Pie. Can get very crowded
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shia Nussbaum
Nice atmosphere and good drinks, the long Island ice tea was different but still tasted good
Reviewed on Google Maps
Glenn Roberts
your standard Irish bar food. Tasty but not exceptional. Nice beer selection including Guinness on tap. Very friendly staff and warm environment. Plenty of sports on the many TVs
Reviewed on Google Maps
Steph W.
I've been coming here for over 20 years! I love the wings and the spinach dip/chicken bowl. It's always a great time!
Reviewed on Yelp
Raymond Zingale
Awesome place!!! The best nachos on the planet!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Aisha Riaz
Good service. Great buffalo wings.
Reviewed on Google Maps
P B
Great bar and food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Pauline Okrent
Great food. I had the fried mac and cheese bites for an appetizer. Nice and spicy. I had the shepherds pie for dinner. It was pretty good. However, they did change it a little. Put potato chips on top. Great service and good atmosphere. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nerida Rivera
Waitress was very sweet and accommodating. Food was excellent.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike Kelly
A fantastic meal, great staff and family friendly. We stopped into McGillicuddy's for lunch and were not disappointed. One of the best burgers I've had in a long time and a huge portion for everyone. Very affordable too! Our server was very nice and she couldn't have done more to accommodate us and make sure we were satisfied with our meal. We will definitely be back soon! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rosa Noesi
It was a chill place with nice music. The crowd is older.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Roberto Rivera Jr
Wings are awesome! A staple in New Paltz for visitors old and new alike.
Reviewed on Google Maps
plasm90
Fast food service and great beer on tap!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Patricia Pagano
Stopped after apple picking. The five of us enjoyed our meals and service was great.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dan Leonard
Another very busy New Paltz restaurant . Service and food were very good. Margarita just ok just had one then switched to beer. Good came out in reasonable time, prices are fair. Will give another try. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Angela Lane
The best wings , great atmosphere and our waitress Breanna was awesome .
Reviewed on Google Maps
Gideon H
Super good good!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nixon Hancock
I just enjoy their dishes. I always get awesome service there. The place is well kept and the cashiers are always very friendly. I highly recommend this place.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kristina V.
Great place to watch sports while having a couple of beers and appetizers. Their new beer list with local breweries featured is awesome. Nightlife is always packed, but that's what to be expected when there's only 3 Main bars and a bunch of college kids. Overall, Cuddy's is a solid choice for any night of the week. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Sincere Hopkins
I eat in this great spot quite often! This is the best place to to have a good dinner. I visit this place routinely. The meals are very tasty, the staff members are courteous and the rates are reasonable. I like going in this restaurant over a good lunch. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joe Staff
Fun place good service and great music and drinks
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amanda Rodriguez
A great bar to come with your friends on the weekend and listen to great music and dance the night away! All the music they play is current and are top hits- so much fun. There is always a small cover charge to get in, so bring cash! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
michele bennett
Had the pulled pork sandwich, it was fantastic!Waitress was awesome too!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amy Dutot
Great food!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Natalia Santana
Great food in the afternoon and great parties at night. I like the music and the drinks are very affordable. Four bucks for a well drink in a nice place is not bat at all.
Reviewed on Google Maps
David Joo
Great food and tap selections.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Melissa Rice
Awesome Sauce chicken wings are my favorite.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Guyetri P
Good quality food and large portions.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christina C.
Do yourself a favor and try out McGillicuddy's - they always make sure to keep their menu diverse and change it up every once in a while. You will be doing yourself an injustice if you don't try their spinach dip in the bread bowl, their wings, mac and cheese bites or the weekly specials. Monday's are wing night so your best bet would be to get there early and make it a point to try the gold rush sauce and habanero honey buffalo. If you are more of a salad person, they have different options to make any leaf lover happy. Try out the cobb salad with blackened salmon and you will thank me. There are happy hour specials on food and drinks daily at the bar, and you won't want to leave without trying a brownie sundae for dessert More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Susan McCarl
Very surprised from the last time I went, the Ahi tuna salad was great.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kevin Broomell
Really cool bar with great staff and pretty delicious food!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Leanna Draper
Food and service is great, esp. The spinach dip
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sarah Schapira
Food was good, service was great. My boyfriend and I split an appetizer and an entree. Everything was delicious
Reviewed on Google Maps
Travis W Keyes
Good wings and a relaxed atmosphere
Reviewed on Google Maps
james noon
Always a great time. Whether getting lunch or stopping by.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tamás Pócs
Can get drunk easily, if you spend all your money.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Franz Bizo
A fun place, and full of college kids when w visited. Service was excellent, and we both enjoyed our burgers with waffle fries. Good pub menu!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tayler Kissam
The wings are amazing & the bartenders are so nice. The blueberry mojito is my favorite drink!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sierra Frasier
Amazing wings!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Peter Ivanov
Great burgers, nice staff
Reviewed on Google Maps
Miguel Roldan
Food came out super fast
Reviewed on Google Maps
Melody Smith
Good service, large sandwiches, so glad they had veggie choices!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Theresa Nolan
Garlic parmision fries are to die for!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
John Youmans
good place to get a drink and some bar food.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Luke Strothenke
Food is good, circle bar is great, great staff!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Esteban Colón
Great food, good people
Reviewed on Google Maps
Venetia Murray
Garlic Fries and Sangria!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sue Davis
Food is great and the waitresses are suburb
Reviewed on Google Maps
