Mile Hollow, New Jersey
1173 customer reviews
Richea Jones
Good food but the service is not the best...
Reviewed on Facebook
Floyd D Harvey
Great meal wonderful service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jim Matthews
Great Food and service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Auburn Trommetter
Portions are well worth the price. Took out several "doggie" bags. Also has a bakery and a bar. Food was good.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lindsay Brenner
We drop by about once a year when we plass through new Jersey and keep being impressed with this place. Well worth the short detour from the turnpike. My son bumped his head and they came over with a giant cookie to cheer him up. It's the small gestures that make a HUGE difference More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rick Meredith
Wonderful food and excellent service
Reviewed on Google Maps
kevin kilmartin
Service was great, portions were big, food arrived fast and correct.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Gavriella Kaplan Weinreb
It's delicious but they need to include vegan and vegetarian options.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lorraine Artura Gakin
huge portions, caring wait staff, food came hot and quickly. a dish wasnt satisfactory and it was rectified immediately and dessert was comped for that person. classy. very reasonably priced. we'll be back! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
PrinceOfTheRealm
This place was really classy. The food here is really good. I ordered a side salad, and literally thought they brought me an entire meal, so you DEFINITELY get your money's worth.
Reviewed on Google Maps
kevin kauffman
Best cheese bread in the World!!!Great Diner with numerous choices to eat.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ryan McGowan
There are probably more than 200 items on the menu, it's kind of overwhelming. The portions are enormous. The restaurant food is pretty good. The bakery is very good.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ron Battle
VERY GOOD FOOD
Reviewed on Google Maps
Pedro Quinones Jr
Great food!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amanda Reiser
My extended family with over 15 members is always welcomed here with open arms. With a variety of food preferences (including vegetarian), we are all able to get something at Mastoris that we enjoy
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Brennan
Food was excellent, staff was friendly and would absolutely go back.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Pat Gaug
Losing some of its flair. Prices getting high
Reviewed on Google Maps
Debbie Fowler Silvers
Great food served family style, salad, mixed veggie, pasta with sauce & delicious cheese bread & cinnamon bread!!!!! Then your Entrée. ... we each got chicken Parmesan with a large baked potato. It was such a large portion we each could only eat half and still brought home a full meal. The you leave through the beautiful bakery!!!! FANTASTIC!!!!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
susan daddio
Went for Thanksgiving enjoyable dinner
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jersey Tarheel
Great cheese bread.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michael Carn
Simply love the food, huge servings!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lady Peachena
Good eating while watching NFL football game on TV! My broiled salmon was deeply satisfying. Butter-creme cake was finger-licking good. Yes, I ate it with my fingers. No fork needed! A winning meal! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Eric Williams
Clean and food is great. Just passing through from Connecticut
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matthew Mctamney
Haven't been there in yrs but my father took me there as child, great memories
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jules Mermelstein
Good food, great improv entertainment.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lee Bonniwell
Great service and food and the Bakery goods are outstanding!
Reviewed on Facebook
john kellert
GREAT place
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mrej Baisas
Big portions
Reviewed on Google Maps
Caroline Hurley
Always fantastic breakfast
Reviewed on Google Maps
Chawanda Richardson
Over the years, I've only heard both negative and a few positive stories about the place. I have always never been a fan of diners, too. However, this was my first time eating at Mastoris. It was beyond excellent and exceeded my expectations. The place has had a makeover, from what I was told too. Everyone was pleasant and patient with our bridal shower party attendees. The food came out with the right temperature and nothing was rushed. There was in fact so much food that everyone took home to-go plates. I would definitely recommend this place and the chicken parmigiana as well. Thanks for making the bridal shower party a blast!!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Diane Calloway
Love, love, love this place!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Maria Rivas
My favorite place to eat the food always delicious especially the specials.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Scott Fisher
Service ok, the specials menu food was great.. had the porkchops
Reviewed on Google Maps
Susan Apgar Franko
Good food and excellent waitstaff.
Reviewed on Facebook
Brian Mitchell
Great food good service
Reviewed on Google Maps
jeromey kuchen
I use to go to Mastoris Diner years ago. So we finally visited the restaurant again. The quality is the same.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joseph Ferry
Always great food and service.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ray Forte
This is one of those diners that you can order the rack of lamb and expect greatness. Never had a bad meal here, always big portions, and variety is great. Try the complimentary cheese or cinnamon breads. Mastori's catered our wedding and everyone raved about that too! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Diane Mancine
Great food and bakery to die for
Reviewed on Google Maps
friargreg75
Great place and great food. Plenty to choose from.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Pamela Khairallah
Go out of your way to experience this bedt of genre NJ diner. Cheeses bread that comes before your meal is an amazing treat. Save room, or just go for the house baked desserts. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Richard Rodriguez
Comfort food in big portions.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Austin 110306
It was good I went with family the waiters were respectful and were nicely dressed
Reviewed on Google Maps
BZ NAGY
Loved the lunch I had here. Loved the the sweet breads they put on each table.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Guye Craig
Prime rib was great, service was very good.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Betsy Hall
Good food , good service, clean. Very crowded
Reviewed on Google Maps
Stew Willey
Great dinner.the bread to start off is good enough.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Steven Cross
Good food and atmosphere the baked goods are there specialty
Reviewed on Google Maps
brian white
Awesome
Reviewed on Google Maps
J Janceski
huge portions and options
Reviewed on Google Maps