Westerville, Ohio
Kelly Jo makes magic! Tasty, tasty, magic. Marriage is a cause for celebration of the highest order and crafting confections as unique as your love story is truly her passion. She creates delicious, custom desserts using only the finest ingredients.
Show more
15 customer reviews
Sue Saunders Janowski
Kelly Jo does an amazing job! If you think the pictures look great, just wait until you taste her delicious treats
Reviewed on Facebook
Becky Bennett Keske
Everything Kelly Jo makes tastes amazing! There is one problem though... Her goodies are so beautiful that you don't want to eat them!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jan Corey Hawk
Sweetie Girls Treatery made the PERFECT cake for a very special octogenarian's birthday. The cake was elegant, festive, and delicious! Highly recommend this creative, talented, caring baker! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Cheryl Schieferstein Yeager
Kelly Jo at Sweetie Girls Treatery made a GORGEOUS cake and cupcakes for my daughter's Tiffany-themed wedding. The cake looked just like a Tiffany gift box and bow, and the cupcakes completed the presentation. We chose several flavors, and each one was DELICIOUS! Creativity, beauty, and taste...Sweetie Girls Treatery has it all! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Merilee Stienecker Wale
KellyJo made the most beautiful wedding cake for us: it was Lemon with a cream frosting and she then incorporated fresh flowers in the design. She is very talented and creative and I would use her again in a second! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Tracey Mengerink
I love absolutely everything! I was lucky enough to have Kelly Jo make my wedding cake. Each tier was a different delicious flavor. I had to eat them all! The mint chocolate cake that she made for my husband's birthday was out of this world! It was gone by the next day. The cookies always look too cute to eat, but we always manage to! If you have not experienced her treats yet, you are missing out! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kathryn Wright Poturalski
Not only are the items from Sweetie Girls impeccably decorated, they are delicious also. I have never found a design or custom request they could not provide. I would highly recommend them for all your bakery needs. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sandy Matsick
I had Sweetie Girls Treatery bake cookies as favors for my daughter's baby shower. The theme was a "Little Man's" shower. The cookies were decorated to fit the theme in bow ties, ties, and little man signs
. Everyone commented on how beautifully decorated the cookies were! Not only were they adorable, but delicious as well.
Since I live in Pennsylvania, I was very impressed with the way in which they were packaged. Every cookie was packed individually and had extra packaging so they arrived safely.
If you need cookies for a special occasion, I highly recommend.....Sweetie Girls Treatery!!
More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Taryn Bargainnier
Absolutely Delicious!!! My Baby Shower cake was so beautiful and exactly what I was looking for! All of my guests raved about how yummy it was and Kelly Jo was a dream to work with! Overall I would recommend Sweetie Girls Treatery to anyone looking for a cake or any other sweet treats! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Ericka Lynn
I absolutely loved seeing all these beautiful cakes on the Facebook page and decided to order one for a birthday party. It was so amazing. Not only did it exceed our expectations on how it looked, but it tasted wonderful! I would definitely recommend! Thank you again for our wonderful cake! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jenny Lutz Koenig
All the treats I have ordered have been out of this world delicious and stunning to look at! So much to choose from..birthday cakes, cookies, cheesecakes, wedding cakes and so much more. Anything you order you will not be disappointed! Thank you for ALL of my yummy treats More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kelly Pendergast Martino
I have had a number of amazing treats made by Sweetie Girl Treatery! Everything she makes is so pretty it's hard to eat it. However, once you try something, there is no holding back! Kelly Jo has made 4 cakes for my kids birthday and every one of them have surpassed my expectations!! I'd use her for every event!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Shannon Seyer-Shisler
I have used Sweetie Girl Treatery for several occasions and I am NEVER disappointed! Kelly Jo is so creative, talented and easy to work with plus her treats are absolutely fabulous in both flavor and in presentation! We lost a wonderful person and a fantastic baker when Kelly Jo moved to Florida, but Ohio's loss is Florida's gain. So "treat" up Florida and give Kelly Jo your business. You will not be sorry and will probably gain a friend in addition to a few pounds :) More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Erica Lippincott Bicknell
Sweetie girls treatery made my son's first birthday cake which was circus themed. It was everything I envisioned it to be and more. The cake itself was delicious and so was everything else on it as far as the little animals and circus tent shaped out of rice krispies, yes we tried it all! Thank you for relieving me of the stress of making it and also providing the beautiful center piece, until we devoured it! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Tessa Bargainnier Berg
At Sweetie Girls Treatery everything really is as good as it looks! I take that back, it's better! My baby shower cake was absolutely gorgeous and the white almond sour cream cake with raspberry filling was to die for! Custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes, cheesecakes, scones, etc... You really can't go wrong! It makes my mouth water just thinking about placing an order! :) More...
Reviewed on Facebook