Wauwatosa, Wisconsin
150 customer reviews
Goodeater
We appreciate the friendly service. Lasagna was good, Caesar salad was good and the regular pizza was good. Unfortunately, this time the drinks were a disappointment. I did not get my martini the way I asked for it and 2 others at the table were not impressed with their cocktails either. My drink that was straight up came with so many ice chunks it was not enjoyable to drink. The gluten free pizza crust was not very tasty. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
NicoleW
Excellent food and service. This restaurant is a favorite of mine to celebrate special occasions.
Reviewed on Opentable
Karen
Had the pasta special which included several types of seafood! It was scrumptious!!!!
Reviewed on Opentable
JanisK
Always great food, service and atmosphere!
Reviewed on Opentable
Anniezoo2
Our dinner was excellent as always. We love going to Il Mito however the noise is a bit much. Also, the tables are very, very close together and it was very hard for my husband to get comfortable.
Reviewed on Opentable
JamesP
Loved the relaxed feel of IL Mito - we will be returning. Our server - Chris - was excellent. We hadthe salmon special - it was wonderful. Next time we want to try a pizza or some pasta. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
KarinV
We both had lamb shanks, done to PERFECTION!!!! Everytime we visit, we enjoy the fine dining!
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Mushroom Tortellini with cream sauce was amazing!!!!
Reviewed on Opentable
StephanieS
Pumpkin ravioli was amazing, would go back just for this dish. My husband found the Bolognese a little too spicy, maybe from the Italian sausage. Sat near the door during cold weather, fairly drafty. Service was outstanding. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
AnneM
Great place to dine. The food is consistently good. Our server was attentive and friendly.
Reviewed on Opentable
TosaGirl74
A delightful dining experience, as always! Luis was our server and he is simply awesome, attending to every detail with grace and a smile, and the food was divine. My husband and I both had specials (he the shrimp pasta and me the salmon with a modified side of parmesan polenta rather than the crab pilaf due to my shellfish allergy), and they were outstanding. Always a fun evening out there. Cheers! More...
Reviewed on Opentable
SJ66
The combination of very good food and a great ambience make for a very enjoyable dining experience.
Reviewed on Opentable
JeanL
Cozy ambiance, friendly and knowledgeable waitstaff, delicious meal and great wine selection
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
We have been enjoying this restaurant for many years and we've recommended it to several in our circle. Their dishes are the type that taste so wonderful that you have to share them. I would highly suggest making a reservation on Friday and Saturday. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
ScottM
Staff is so friendly. Service is outstanding. I will be back
Reviewed on Opentable
LouiseM
We went with an couple who had never dined there before. They loved it. My husband and I call it our favorite restaurant and that’s saying something considering the great restaurants Milwaukee has to offer. The only disappointment was no cappuccinos after dinner, apparently the machine was broken. Oh well, we’ll be back. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
Whoyou
Great food, service and ambiance, especially for date night or girls night out but unfortunately, not for business! I will not bring business associates unless the antiquated billing process is updated. It’s pertinent for business professionals to have itemized receipts for expenses, something this establishment can’t provide which forces is to go to other local establishments; a shame, especially for those of us who entertain often. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
ChurchLady
One of the best meals e have had! Have been good to Il Mito for years.
Reviewed on Opentable
Kirk Gramoll
Our favorite restaurant in Wauwatosa. Before we became vegetarians, the Bolognese was to die for. Now we are a fan of dishes like Pumpkin Ravioli. Good service and a quaint place that feels like a second home to us. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
OpenTable Diner
Food was amazing. They could have done a little something since I told them we were celebrating our 30th anniversary. But other than that the experience was superb.
Reviewed on Opentable
JamieW
Great service. Our order came up fast which was nice. I had to bolognese which was so flavorful and a little spicy - which is different than I have had other places. I loved it. The others with me had the rissoto and were equally happy with their choice. Il Mito is a reliable choice for good food, nice atmosphere, and great service. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
LesleyR
I loved the ambiance as soon as we walked in... so cozy and romantic! My husband ordered the bolognese and I had the seasonal pumpkin ravioli. .. both were delicious. The only thing is that I would have liked a small side salad along with it. Delicious cocktails and wine, and the water was topped off often (a big selling point with me). Will absolutely go again the next time we are in town! More...
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Great selection of food and beverage. We had risotto and spaghetti bolognese which were both very good.
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Great time out at IL MITO with the usual high quality food and drinks.
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Everything was wonderful. The specials this evening wee exquisite.
Reviewed on Opentable
TBG1
Love all of Chef Feker's restaurants. 2Mesa, Il Mito, Zesti. Cannot wait for Americas to open in Delafield
Reviewed on Opentable
KalpaV
This restaurant is a family favorite - they are always willing to accommodate for vegetarian substitutions!
Reviewed on Opentable
KristinD
We love that iil miito has safe homemade gluten free food for our daughter to eat. We love the chance to try new foods at a fun place and a great value. Chef Fecker and the chefs at ill mito and zesti are our heros More...
Reviewed on Opentable
CreativeOT
The food and service was exceptional!
Reviewed on Opentable
PaulJ
Great meal and even had gluten free bread for dipping in the olive oil.
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
It was great
Reviewed on Opentable
TimW
Always a good experience. The food was very good, the staff was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was lively!
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Amazing food and great service. Never had a bad experience.
Reviewed on Opentable
SSamis
It's always a pleasure to dine at Il Mito's. The nice weather permitted us to sit on the patio, which was just that much better.
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Truly exceptional!
Reviewed on Opentable
SusanE
Enjoyed being able to carry on a conversation without having to yell. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Will definitely recommend to friends.
Reviewed on Opentable
GerryP
Food and service were superb. The salmon was perfectly medium rare.
Reviewed on Opentable
Mokie
Delicious calamari! Recommend the caprese salad. We tried the salmon, beef ribs, tortellini. Everything was tasty. Found the eggplant appetizer especially good. Duck was tender!It was a bit too cold in restaurant. More...
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Great as always!
Reviewed on Opentable
JeffK
This was our second visit to It Mito and they did not disappoint! Our waiter Luis was exceptional, and the entire staff is extremely attentive without being intrusive. As much as I wanted to try something new, I stayed with my favorite and ordered the Spaghetti Bolognese . I am already craving it again! More...
Reviewed on Opentable
Bill Frey
Excellent food, service and value for the money!
Reviewed on Google Maps
HayleyS
Wonderful service and delicious food. My date was pretty spectacular too.
Reviewed on Opentable
BryanK
Ate on the patio. Really nice wine selection
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Great food, friendly and attentive service. Nice atmosphere. Would recommend to anyone who likes Italian food!
Reviewed on Opentable
OpenTable Diner
Always a good time here. Delicious food, ambiance Is perfect and great service.
Reviewed on Opentable
Patrise Selkey
the food is wonderful and the service is the best ...
Reviewed on Facebook
Nicholas Pascarella
Great spot! Everything I have tried has been fantastic but especially the lasagna bolognese and caprese salad. Everytime we've been here we've also had good service.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alexus Onyetwenye
Il Mito does not disappoint. I've eaten here several times and had a good experience each time. First, I love the atmosphere. It has a really cosy vibe with the dim lighting. I've been here when the restaurant is full and busy, and never felt like the wait for a table, or drinks or food took long. The bruschetta is very tasty-it's 3 pretty big pieces that can easily be cut in half to share. The split-pea soup is phenomenal! I absolutely love it and it's beautifully presented. Pasta dishes and pizza are all good, as are the various nightly specials. I have a difficult time choosing an entree because everything is so good. They have a nice selection of wine too. In summer they have a few tables outside. I don't think I'd take kids here, but it's perfect for a date or business dinner. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ruth
I always enjoy dining at old mito. Excellent food and service and a cozy atmosphere!
Reviewed on Opentable
JRPMD
After dining at IME we walked out wondering why it took so long to try it. The food was very well made and we were served by the house manager who was a joy and was passionate about every dish on the menu. We enjoyed the beefsteak Florentine, the short ribs braised with Mediterranean flavors, and veal done in a piccata style. Each was delicious and we traded several bites. I want to return and try some of their pastas. More...
Reviewed on Opentable