Fireside Pizza Walnut Hills
Peebles Corner, Ohio
(282)
Peebles Corner, Ohio
(282)
282 customer reviews
Andrew Kirk
Great food. Parking could be better
Reviewed on Google Maps
John Cox
Awesome wood fired pizza made from scratch every day. Laid back atmosphere with cool/unique vibe and artwork. Bathroom art is worth the trip itself! Wonderful, passionate staff. Eli’s BBQ pizza is a favorite! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rob Johnson
Interesting choices, great atmosphere
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ellen Marshall
Hidden gem!
Reviewed on Google Maps
latoya grayson
The pizza is so yummy great to take a friend or two
Reviewed on Google Maps
Charles Gray
Great homemade pizza spot with a good atmosphere. Really cool building.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shawn Everett
Excellent pizza. Have had this pizza both at the Madeira Farmers Market and at the restaurant on McMillan. The Margherita pizza is very good, the Meats pizza rocks and I highly recommend the Eli's BBQ pie - it is absolutely amazing. Great decor in the restaurant and very good service. Get the lunch special, pizza, drink and an awesome cupcake for $11. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amelia Lewis
Orginal fire station serving delicious pizza, salads and cupcakes. Kid friendly & full bar
Reviewed on Google Maps
James Booth
My favorite pizza in the city. The pepperoni and spinach is perfect
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bill Smith
The Elis pizza is FIRE
Reviewed on Google Maps
J & M Koize
Low key, good beer selections and great pizza!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lance McAlister
Love the brick and old firehouse feel. Pizza was excellent. Don't sleep on the breadsticks. Order at the bar. Place has a shelf with classic board games to play at table.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christian Gastaldo
Really awesome place! The pizza was incredible, as well as the drinks list was pretty extensive. They also offer good tasting gluten free options which is very difficult to find. Will defintely be back soon!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Anna Reed
My companion and I came here around the end of July on a random weekday getaway. They had a special braunsweiger appetizer with locally baked pretzels that were to die for. We had a few beers and took the pizza back to our Airbnb. The pizza crust was amazing, the staff was incredibly friendly and courteous. We will definitely be back next time we are in town! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Barry Snyder
Now THIS IS A GREAT pizza place..I would go there twice a week if it weren't 5 hours away.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matt Schaller
Pizza was amazing! Super cool atmosphere!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Wesley Rose
Decent atmosphere. Went for trivia, which was a blast!! Highly recommended
Reviewed on Google Maps
Luke Kuhner
Pizza is best I've had in Cinci. Good beer selection as well and a cool atmosphere. 10/10 would recommend.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nathan Jeffries
Tasted awesome! Great crust. Highly recommend the Eli's BBQ pizza...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shirlee Koehne
The white pie is to die for. I like to add calamati olives
Reviewed on Google Maps
Aidan
pretty good
Reviewed on Google Maps
Paul Sullivan
Terrific brick oven pizzas with top notch ingredients and an exceptional drink menu set in an historic firehouse.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Amick
Delicious, thin and fire oven crispy crust. Good beer list. Quick cook time and reasonable prices. Home made ranch was great. Cool location and friendly staff.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Katie Dreyer Hotze
The pizza here is the best!
Reviewed on Google Maps
thewizardofcovington .
Delicious pies.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Kinne
I love the white pie with bacon! I've been going here since they were a brick oven on a trailer down at Findlay Market
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Wilkins
Pizza was good, beer was cold and the trivia was challenging.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Troy Long
Great pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dean McHone
Honestly, it's closer to 4.5 stars, but solid pizzas and a short list of solid beers, plus dope staff makes it 5 on the Google review scale. Pizza needs a little work to get above a 3.5, but All Trumps, when done right, can definitely be really good. A little lacking on cornichone development and tomatoes used for sauce, but it's pretty flavorful, just not "honest tomato forward" and crust is nice and chewy. If you dig Dewey's pies, you'll have a hard time having something to complain about. Especially for the affordable price of a pie. Definitely recommended! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Wanda Vawter
Love the pizza! Located in an old fire station. Friendly staff and laid back atmosphere! Mix of traditional and innovative pizzas.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alex Dieterle
Great pizza and lots of choices for toppings with different seasonal flavors too.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Audrey Brand
Gluten free accomodations!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Drew Watson
Really cool building and fun pizza!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Richard Liu
Delicious pizza baked fresh. Surprisingly empty for a Wednesday lunchtime.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dan Merhar
I can't say I've ever had a bad experience here. The food is solid, the employees are super friendly, and the general vibe and atmosphere are a nice mix of neighborhood and historical landmark (it's an old firehouse). Highly recommend their seasonal pies, or the pesto plus with your favourite topping. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Melinda Jackson
Best Pizza in town.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sahar Heydarifard
Really awesome food, great staff!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jack Morgan
Inside of a old firehouse and it's so cool
Reviewed on Google Maps
Roger Vorherr
Tasty pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ginny S
Great pizza, music and drinks!
Reviewed on Google Maps
James Kuchle
The pizza I got was delicious. The place had a great aesthetic. Bar tender was good. I ordered the Eli's Barbecue pizza. I wanted to eat half, but ended up downing the whole thing very fast. I look forward to eating here again. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ginny Schumacher
Great pizza, friendly staff, casual atmosphere.
Reviewed on Google Maps
anthony harris
What is the best island taste here in Cincinnati but it's not New York
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ryan Riddell
Always great food at Fireside!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michael
Great place for pizza.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dan Scheid
It's tasty, fire baked Italian ish. Nothing too crazy, little long wait wise but I'd say it's worth it
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dennis Cecil
Great meal, cozy atmosphere, friendly staff!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Julie Sanchez
The pizza was delicious and the ambiance was incredible!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Justin Jones
This place was awesome. Great atmosphere. The wait staff was polite and it's some of the best pizza I've ever had.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bobby JJ
Great place to either get in and out, or hang out for hours on end...
Reviewed on Google Maps
