Fireside Inn Baldwinsville

Great place to see a show

Reviewed on Google Maps

Nice venue ..

Reviewed on Google Maps

Was there for a private event.
Nice set up. Good food

Reviewed on Google Maps

It was decorated so nicely for our prom

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great food at a reasonable price, plenty of free parking, the nite we were there the Country Band was good with a rude lead singer, but overall place was fun & I will return, just to a different band!

Reviewed on Google Maps

For a baby shower. Nice and spacious. Sunny room.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Held my daughter’s wedding reception here. The staff was wonderful to work with. Very accomodating. The food was excellent. Also went there last year for Mother’s Day brunch. Once again, did not disappoint More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Had are work Christmas party at the fireside.food was great and the band was awesome.

Reviewed on Google Maps

We brought our son, daughter-in-law and two grandsons Friday evening for dinner. We had made reservations for 6:30 and were told that the band would be starting at 7:00. We were seated right away and the staff were amazing! They took care of us and two littles under 3 years old. There wasn’t an empty table to be seen! The kitchen was so busy they worried we would be upset so they brought complimentary fries for the kids. We will definitely be back again! So very happy with the service and the food. The band was Brass Inc and they were amazing even our 3 year old got up to dance! Wishing you continued success in the future! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Changed my review ...went back a second time food and service was greattt

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good food, wonderful stage and dance floor! I wish this place would book better bands like Mere Mortals, Billionaires, Or Prime Time! Come on Fireside! You could be hitting home runs with the right bands that have followings... More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Had my wedding reception there the first weekend of October and I cannot say anything bad about this place!! Joanna and the rest of the Fireside Inn staff are nothing short of amazing! Always friendly and Joanna is SO helpful, which made the wedding planning so much easier. Anything I needed or if I had a question, she was always right there to help. Even on the night of the reception her and her staff never stopped working to make our night amazing. If I ever need to throw a party somewhere or need a venue place again, this place will the the very first spot I call. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

My favorite place in baldwinsvile .. awesome prime rib

Reviewed on Google Maps

Lovely location for a wedding, food was good , staff was great.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good food, very busy Friday night. Band started at 7 pm so conversation was hard to hear.

Reviewed on Google Maps

The food was good and servers were very friendly an accommodating. The chocolate cake was really good!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Awesome time! Great food, Great staff and the inside looks amazing. Just don't ask for a dirty martini when it's open bar, dirty looks will follow.

Reviewed on Google Maps

I recently had my wedding reception at the Fireside Inn. I am prudish and fussy about food and service, plus I have a bride who has high expectations. We had 175 guests and several unique traditional requests that the Fireside Inn had never before encountered. Therefore, I am not ashamed to say that I had my reservations about how everything would turn out. In short, they exceeded my expectations on every level and at every turn. Fran [owner] assured me that I would be pleased and he was not exaggerating. I will go into detail for any reader who would like to understand the lengths that the Fireside staff will go to to make your event special.First, there is the manager Joanna, she was the point person for EVERYTHING! I swear she works 24/7. From linens to layout, food, service, bar, billing, special requests...yeah...everything. It goes through her. It is so nice dealing with only one person who knows what is going on and truly cares as much as you do. I chuckle as I recall her frequently confused expression and furrowed brow as she would often respond, “Umm...I think we can do that. Let me check and get back to you.” And she promptly would reply with an answer. A 20ft Pittsburgh cookie bar? Yep, they did that. A Rochester Garbage Plate bar rolled out at 9:00PM? They did that too! A giant birthday cake, two wedding cakes, full open bar, full buffet, a photo booth, a memory table, a sweetheart table, 175 guests, and keep the dance floor open...mission accomplished!Second, the food. I wanted GOOD food, not golf banquet fare. The food was excellent. The Chicken French was moist, fresh and tender. The Roast Beef Au jus was not over-cooked yet tender and full of flavor. The vegetables were perfectly cooked (minor complaint: the rosemary was a little heavy on the roasted potatoes). Everything was fresh and well presented. Great job! (Special Note: My Rochester friends said the garbage plates were spot on! Some went as far as saying they rivaled Nick’s )Last, but definitely not least, the staff and service. Unless you have worked in food service, you can’t appreciate how hard it is to be everywhere you are needed, exactly when you are needed, while never being in the way and doing it virtually unnoticed. This staff was exceptional. The wait staff, the bar staff, the cook staff, all were examples of true professionals. Example: One guest mentioned that garbage plates are eaten from to-go containers with plastic cutlery (although I disagree, paper plates work just as well). A staff member overheard, and immediately brought out to-go containers and plastic ware. The staff was tested that day and they excelled. I tried to thank you all individually, but if I missed, “Thank You so much!” More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Very classy nightclub with excellent entertainment on the weekends.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Newly remodel n great food

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great music great place to dance good food

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great remodel, very clean and great space for large weddings, only have a historic photo

Reviewed on Google Maps

Used to be great local landmark, newly reopened, hoping for the best !

Reviewed on Google Maps

Went to the prime rib buffet. Very good and plenty of other options on the buffet.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Food was excellent, almost worth the large price tag!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Went to see the band perform last night, very big then you! I was impressed with the size of the place the only bad thing was when I walked in the place it smelled terribly of fish. Probably the Friday night fish fry but they should do something about ventilation with a bar and a room that big! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Wondering about reviews for events, weddings, showers

Reviewed on Google Maps

Pricey service for food was a 2 hour wait and cold when arrived maybe not serve when bands are playing

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great event venue. Band's every weekend.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Remodeled and looking and feeling better than ever. Great entertainment too!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great food and service. Beautiful banquet room with 3 fireplaces. A stage for live entertainment and a great dance floor. Perfect for weddings, private parties too

Reviewed on Google Maps

Prime rib buffet and wait staff were superb! Highly recommend you try it!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Any cover charge for bands?

Reviewed on Google Maps

Went for Easter Brunch. Service was prompt and courteous. Food was great. Might have to check out that Prime Rib buffet.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Very nice, historic venue in Baldwinsville, NY

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best brunch ever.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Newly remodeled very elegant interior

Reviewed on Google Maps

Coming back for flat iron steak. Wonderful, comfortable elagence. One of my favorite places.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great place to have a venue

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good buffet

Reviewed on Google Maps

Place looks great and the food was excellent

Reviewed on Google Maps

It was a great experience. The food was hot and very good. Not lots of choices but for the money and what you get is good food. You have a few different options for the buffet. You can do one trip or many. You can even add on desert for a little more. I would recommend and will go here again. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Excellent food along with great service. Would suggest this place to anyone.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Beautiful dinning and delicious food.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Beautiful renovations. Great band. But, MOBBED and no parking.

Reviewed on Google Maps