East Ithaca, New York
25 customer reviews
Emma Elizabeth
I am still eating the amazing cupcakes Amy made for our wedding! The cake is so delicious and everything was so beautifully crafted, it added the perfect accent to our special day. Amy took the time to listen to what we wanted and was so accommodating if we needed to make changes. I would HIGHLY recommend her cake to anyone! We will certainly return in the future. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Elizabeth Goodwin
Wedding planning is stressful; working with Amy is NOT! Amy is so sweet (like her cakes) and easy to work with. Whatever your dessert dreams are, Amy will say "YES" and the results will look & taste amazing. Our aesthetic taste in wedding cakes turned out to be pretty off-beat; imagine a two-tiered tree stump adorned with moss and mushrooms...yep, Amy does this. She incorporated flour from my husband's grain farm into the cake, which was very important to us. She also made a smaller gluten and dairy-free cake to accommodate our family members with allergies. Amy does it all - she is the rock star of bakers. Look no further than Darling Cake!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Mim Hafler
So yummy. Her wedding cakes are not only stunning but incredibly delicious. I have used her for my daughters wedding baby shower and birthdays love love love her stuff
Reviewed on Facebook
Trisha Williams
I have had the pleasure of working with Amy a few times now and let me tell you...shes fantastic across the board! Professional, FUN, talented, quick, easy to work with. Her creations blow my mind! Her cakes are a pleasure to the eyes and the taste buds! I highly recommend! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kayleigh Exner
Amy did a small cake and cupcakes for our wedding. We had a Halloween theme and she absolutely nailed it! Between the flavors, decorations and colors it was absolutely beautiful and she understood our vision to a T. Thank you again Amy!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jill Whalen
I can never adequately put into words how positive the experience of having Amy make our wedding cake was. From the beginning, her communication was prompt and she was enthusiastic about our design. She listened to every single one of my ideas and clearly depicted the way that the final cake would look based on her technique and abilities. I was stunned by the simple beauty of the resulting cake, which was truly edible art. The tasting at her home during the planning phase was gracious and fun! We chose champagne cake with strawberry buttercream (such genuine strawberry flavor from real fruit!) and chocolate cake with caramel buttercream for our flavors, with an outer covering of vanilla butter cream. I WILL NEVER FORGET THE TASTE OF OUR WEDDING CAKE, and the compliments I received on the design and flavor were countless. I could cry just thinking about it! When Amy was setting up the cake at our venue 30 minutes before guests arrived, there were dozens of people asking me questions. Amy never bothered me with a single word, just gave me a warm smile I will never forget and gestured to the absolutely gorgeous cake of my dreams while I bustled by. We ate the leftovers for a week and they somehow tasted even better in the days that followed. I wish I could eat nothing but Amy's buttercream for every meal the rest of my life. Bless you, amazing baker, for being a bride's dream! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jordan Johnson
Nothing beats Darling Cake!
Reviewed on Facebook
Kaelyn Carroll
We could not recommend Darling Cake more! Amy made an assortment of desserts for our wedding as well as a smaller cutting cake. Several weeks later and our guests are still raving about the desserts we had. She was so accommodating through the entire process and delivered beyond any of our expectations. She also made an incredible three-tiered sports-themed "groom's cake" for our rehearsal dinner that was amazing but also so delicious guests requested to take some home. Amy and Darling Cake will definitely be our go-to for any future events, we cannot wait to use her again! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Solara Calderon
Are you getting married in the Ithaca area Hire Amy to make your wedding cake immediately. From the minute I stepped into Amy’s house for the cake tasting and took a bite of her delicious cake, I knew that she would be able to make the wedding cake of my dreams! Amy is so lovely to work with. Always available, always friendly and caring, always helpful...I emailed her photos of my ideas and she was more than happy to make it happen! On the wedding day itself, she could not have been more professional. She arrived on time and I walked into the room as she was setting up the most beautiful cake I’ve ever seen. And it was so delicious, too. We chose vanilla cake and spice cake with vanilla buttercream and raspberry preserve. Our guests raved about the cake (literally I heard this over and over: “this is the best wedding cake I’ve ever had”) and they told us they sought out second and third slices. Could you really ask for anything more than that? Thank you so much, Amy! You are truly incredible. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jen Grahmann Albright
Amy made a cake for my nephews baptism. I am a cake snob from Texas AND it was the best cake I've ever had! Do you mail to Texas The lemon cake was delicious. Thank you Amy!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Doug Levine
I'm normally not much of a cake guy. I usually take a bite or two and then I'm good. Amy made a gorgeous "Philadelphia Flyers" cake for my 10-year-old son's birthday and not only did it look AMAZING it tasted EVEN BETTER! Seriously, I had two big pieces that night and pretty much hoarded the last few that were left over. It's only been 2 days since my son's birthday and I'm already thinking about when we can order another Darling Cake! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sarah Tavelli Andree
DarlingCake did it again! I wanted to cheer up a friend who is battling stage IV Cancer.... DarlingCake sent the most beautiful box of treats to the rescue! Thank you for turning TX pink and for lifting a wonderful man's spirits up! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kylee Jaynes
Amazing job!!!! We were very satisfied and the guests LOVED the cupcakes!
Reviewed on Facebook
Olivia Moore Nicoletti
Amy from DarlingCake made our wedding cake - it was absolutely delicious and beautiful! We also wanted a dessert bar of mini desserts and she went above and beyond to search for cake platters for the display. It was absolutely beautiful! Amy was a joy to work with - very responsive and positive. She also had us over to her home for a tasting with our parents. Highly recommend!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Betsy Suits
Amy's cakes are out of this world good!!! Had wedding cakes done by her and they were all so delicious and beautifully displayed! Added bonuses: Amy is sweet, kind, and overly accommodating. Highly recommend and will definitely be using Amy for any future cakes needed!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kaitlin Koroschetz Laws
Loved getting my box of goodies in GA! So delicious and and pretty. My dogs also we're very excited to get their dog treats!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jenni McGrogan
The best delivery of goodies to come to my door! The popcorn was gone in 2 days- my kids and I love it. Pretzels done in a day. And the oreos were absolutely to die for! You can't go wrong with any of her treats. Not only do they taste amazing and incredibly fresh but they are gorgeous to boot! First of many orders! �� More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lindsay Lustick Garner
I knew what I wanted but Amy made a cake that surpassed my expectations!!! A show stopper -- thank you!!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jessica Elizabeth
Her cakes are exceptional and no detail is ever left untouched!! Her work is truly UNMATCHED and her talents far exceed the status quo! There's nothing she can't do or create! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Siana Santos
4.15.17 mermaid cake made for my daughter. Made to perfection. It was everything i thought of and more!! I was so in love with it!!! Thank you!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Desarae Edwards
Amazing!!!! My sons first birthday cake was the best plus more! Love Amy, her work, her character; everything!! 10 stars!
Reviewed on Facebook
Karen Lowe Eldredge
Amy's cakes are the most beautiful and delicious cakes I have ever seen and eaten!! I can't stress enough how lucky we are to have her in the Ithaca area. She could easily be killing it in NYC or another big city. She is also one of the sweetest people you could ever know and work with, so the whole experience will be perfection! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Mark James
I cannot stress enough how amazing Amy was to work with! I ordered a two tier cake for my 1 year old niece, i requested it be somewhat mermaid themed in the green/teal family and the rest was up to her. When i met her to pick up, IT WAS BEAUTIFUL and way better than anything i had pictured!! It had glitter dusted scales in an ombre of perfection, and was very personalized for my neice! I'm still so in love with this cake months later!! She is not only extremely talented, but extremely easy to get a hold of and very responsive. I have vowed to never use another person for any of my cake needs. I forgot to mention how amazing and moist her cake was!! the flavor is the most important part and its delicious, with many options to chose from!! SHE IS FANTASTIC!! You wont regret using her!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kirsten Elrod Morey
I wouldn't use anyone else for cakes! Amy is amazing!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Tiffany Marie
Darling cakes are super yummy!! Amy is so fun and easy to work with and if a cake can taste as good as it looks.....it's worth it!
Reviewed on Facebook