Loading...

Please wait ...

Caked Up Cafe logo
C

Caked Up Cafe

New City, New York

(187)

Get a free quote from this professional

Get a free quote from this professional

Photos (10)

See all

Reviews (187)

Leave a review
5/5

187 customer reviews

Loading...
11 December 2019

I have been looking at their page for months on IG.  Since I work in White Plains on Saturday, I thought I'd take a detour and head up that way before coming back to Connecticut. I did make a pitstop at another location which I will also review. Upon entering, I noticed that it was a delightful boutique style bakery. Very cute. They had a decent selection although it looks as if they were sold out of a lot of items. I knew I wanted to try to flavors that I naturally gravitate towards. Something with strawberry and something with a chocolate peanut butter combination. They had a strawberry cheesecake cupcake option and a strawberry shortcake cupcake option. I went with the shortcake. I asked the nice gentleman behind the counter if they had anything with chocolate and peanut butter and he said "no, but we can make you something". I thought that was great! He returned with a chocolate cupcake topped with a chocolate and peanut butter frosting and half of a chocolate peanut butter cup. It was very decadent. The strawberry shortcake was good.  If I found myself in Rockland county again, I would definitely go back... More...

Reviewed on Yelp

23 November 2019

Amazing! They made a fall themed cake for my vow renewal in October. My guests are still talking about it. It was beautiful and totally delicious. They were very patient and wanted to give me exactly what i wanted. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

27 October 2019

The only place to buy a specialty cake...not only are their cakes beautiful but they are soooo delicious. My favorite filling is the chocolate chip cookie dough. I also love their cupcakes, crumb cakes and cookies...pretty much everything they make. These two cakes were done this month October 2019. Thank you Denise, Kevin and crew for always exceeding our expectations...you are the best! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

12 October 2019

My kid absolutely loved the Godzilla cake they made . Their macaroons are THE best !!

Reviewed on Facebook

1 October 2019

Success! Thank you Denise everyone enjoyed the cake both inside and outside. You and your staff did a fantastic job. Made my daughter and fiancee so happy. Thank you again.

Reviewed on Yelp

17 September 2019

I ordered a cake for my baby shower and it was not only beautiful but it was oh so very delicious. Thank you so much for doing such a wonderful job, so many people loved it!

Reviewed on Facebook

15 September 2019

We were recommended to Caked Up Cafe by our wedding venue Views at Mt Fuji after having a bad experience with a prior vendor. I can say that we are so thankful that we decided to make the switch and that everything was perfect! We worked with Denise and from the very beginning we could tell that everything was going to be great. The cake looked amazing and was so delicious. We would definitely recommend them for any wedding and we just want to say thank you! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

15 September 2019

Although the frosting is a bit on the overly sweet size, the cupcake flavors are all unique and beautifully decorated. Very cute storefront and very kind staff that patiently lets kids decide which cupcakes they want. Unique fixings and combinations, will be back to sample more flavors and perhaps their cupcake shake concoction! Flavors we've had thus far and loved in Order of preference are churro, pancake, French toast, banana streusel, cheesecake, chocolate devil or something More...

Reviewed on Yelp

9 August 2019

Ordered my daughter's Sesame Street themed birthday cake here. The staff was lovely and super helpful. The cake was so cute and beyond delicious, and the look on my daughter's face when she saw it was priceless! We got so many compliments on the look and taste. Thank you so much! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

29 June 2019

Items are so unique in this sweet bakery! Started following them on Instagram and finally ventured up to check their treats out all the way from Westchester. They did not disappoint. Super creative cupcakes and so delicious! Highly recommend checking them out! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

18 June 2019

Called Inquiring on a cake for a Birthday. I was looking for a S'mores cake and wasn't sure if they made them, sure enough I was in luck. Denise was excellent at helping me get my order together which included the cake, a few Cupcakes, Cookies, and Macaroons. Having never had interaction with Caked Up before I didn't know how they were going to be but based on reviews I figured I would be good to go. The Cake was outstanding inside & out, more than what I could have expected and beyond pleased. I was unable to make it over to pick up the items myself but was informed the shop is perfect. Would highly recommend and looking forward to making a trip to the storefront. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

30 May 2019

Caked Up Cafe has some really good cakes, my favorites are the chocolate ones and also their coffee.

Reviewed on Google Maps

22 May 2019

WOW! That is all I could say. My boyfriend and I walked in before we went for lunch to see what they had because we were trying to waste time before the restaurant we went to for lunch opened and boy was I happy we did. We were so overwhelmed with the choice of cupcakes that we wanted them all. They have such a big variety of flavors of cupcakes including chicken and waffles, maple bacon, cannoli, and wayyy more. They even have macarons, loaf cakes, rainbow cookies, whole cakes, etc. We decided to go with the mini cupcakes that came in a pack of 12 which include 2 cupcakes of each flavor (oreo, death by chocolate, lemon, strawberry shortcake, dulce de leche, and cookie jar). They were all so great but I really enjoyed the lemon and oreo. We also had some pistachio macarons which were sooooo good. If I am ever in the area, I will definitely go back. I'll probably want to try some of those alcohol infused cupcakes too. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

15 May 2019

Just simply amazing. I have been going to their New City, NY location for years. Love them to pieces.

Reviewed on Yelp

14 May 2019

Cakes Up Cafe made my son's Communion cake and it was amazing. Not only did it look beautiful, but it was delicious. My guests raved about it. They were so easy to work with. Offered many design ideas and even provided an extensive tasting session during my consultation.  Would highly recommend for any occasion!!! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

30 April 2019

They are the best cake, treats, and cookie that I have had. There macaroons are awsome.

Reviewed on Google Maps

24 April 2019

They are awesome !! That staff is incredibly accommodating and the cupcakes are to die for. We had recently shared "Easter" festive cupcakes for the family and it was nothing but a pleasure ! !! Beautiful decorated like out of magazine. We will definitely be back ! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

21 April 2019

Amazing little cupcake/bakery spot.  So cool to see the amazing cupcakes that are so unique. I got chicken and waffles cupcake and couldn't imagine it being good lol but IT WAS !!!  I'll be back

Reviewed on Yelp

20 April 2019

Cute shops - the whole staff was friendly and happy. I was instantly smiling and laughing with the crew upon arrival. I shocked to find this pleasant surprise in the heart of herald square. They serve various desserts from cupcakes, crumb cakes, cookies. There personality seems to be in the cupcakes- theres chicken&waffles; chocolate coconut, etc. These aren't your basic vanilla cupcake. They also have an upstairs section to eat.I can't wait to go back to indulge my sweet tooth more. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

18 April 2019

These are the most delicious cupcakes I've ever had. Have been so lucky to have this pop up across the street from our office for the past few months, but have just heard they will be shutting next Friday. Extremely sad to hear that - please come back to NYC soon! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

13 April 2019

I got my daughters 8th birthday cake here and I can tell you I was not disappointed.  We went in for a consultation a month in advance.  Yes they appear to get many custom cakes orders and if you go too close to your event date, you probably won't be able to order.  My daughter requested a confetti cake with vanilla buttercream.  The design of the cake was a unicorn...colors were soft pink, purple and blue.  When I went to pick up the cake, it was ready and i didnt have to wait long.  The cake was beautiful.  Everyone had to comment on how pretty the cake looked.  It tasted amazing.  Best custom cake I've had by far!!!   Definitely recommend this place.  My daughter loved her cake and that smile was all I was looking for.  Thank you caked up! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

7 April 2019

Amazing cupcakes! I'm sort of obsessed with cake & cupcakes - I am top tier for Sprinkles rewards program if that says anything. These are great! The flavors are extremely original & are not gimmicky. They work. Favorites are any of the ones with cinnamon cake/sugar - the churro one and the Nutella French toast were two amazing flavors one day. Cookie dough hits the spot for cookie dough flavor + cake. Peanut butter chocolate was good too. It's a denser cake but always moist.  And American buttercream (i.e. confectioners sugar "buttercream") which is my favorite - similar to Sprinkles, Magnolia, Billy's, etc.  So definitely sweet but that's a good thing!! Only complaint / suggestion to the owners - please consider non-plastic containers for the cupcakes.... Hope your pop-up becomes permanent!! ;) More...

Reviewed on Yelp

6 April 2019

I purchased my 30 birthday bday cake from this bakery and it was nothing short of amazing!! The detail of the cake was spot on to the photo that I provided. They were very nice during our consultation and attentive to what I wanted. I was more than happy when it was delivered to our venue and even more pleased at the taste of the cakes. Each tier was a different flavor. My favorite was the French toast layer . So good!! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

28 March 2019

Oohh my sweet tooth, what did I do This adorable little cupcake shop just opened up by my office and I kept walking by it trying to come up with an excuse to drop in. Well, today was the day. And my life changed forever!I swung by to get a few cupcakes for a friends birthday and ended up getting two for me and my husband as well. There are a lot of fun flavor choices from the conservative confetti cupcake to the adventurous chicken and waffles cupcake. The sizes are about midsize... not too daunting to share or indulge in yourself. The cake is moist, the frosting is fluffy and isn't too sweet. And each cupcake is decorated festively making them the perfect little presentation. I liked how they had carry out plastic containers for 2, 4, 6, 8 and 12 cupcakes! Perfect for grab and go in NYC. The shop is small so not the place it grab and eat, more the place to grab and go. Pricing is fair ($4 per cupcake) and aside from cupcakes, they had a few cute little "cup in a jar" to go. It looked like they offer custom cakes too! I'm a fan and probably in for a serious addiction because of its location. Already checking my calendar for my next excuse to drop in! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

10 March 2019

Bought my boyfriend 6 cupcakes for Valentine's Day and he loved them. They were so cute and delicious

Reviewed on Yelp

28 February 2019

Got an explosion cake here for a gender reveal it was amazing ! Everyone loved it and tasted amazing !!!! They also took me in last minute great customer service

Reviewed on Yelp

24 February 2019

I had the pleasure of having a cupcake brought to me at work, best cupcake of MY LIFE !!!I love cupcakes, this cupcake was absolutely delicious. I can't wait to visit the actual location. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

17 February 2019

Yum. Delicious cupcakes. Interesting combinations. Cute shop. Pricey but a nice treat. I definitely prefer the cupcakes from this place. I've also had the surprise cake (a little too sweet for me). More...

Reviewed on Yelp

30 January 2019

If you live anywhere within driving distance to New City, New York and love cupcakes, this is the place to be! Went for the first time today and omg, the varieties of cupcakes to choose from are amazing and so delicious. They also have macaroons, half pound cookies, pound cake and make custom cakes along other things. Definitely check it out! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 January 2019

I finally got the chance to visit caked up cafe ! And all I have ever dreamed of came true ! It is a foodie instagramers heaven ! Everything was beautiful and everything we purchased was delicious. We came in Around 1 on a Sunday afternoon to pick out a cake and some other treats for a family gathering. They have a whole fridge of beautifully decorated cakes that you can carry out and buy that day, which I thought was great because a lot of the Times cakes that look similar to that at other places would have to be a custom order. We got a cookie dough butter cream chocolate drip cake and it was as amazing as it sounds. We also tried a Reese's cookie and the rainbow cookie crumb cake ... and let me tell you the rainbow cookie crumb cake is really something special ! I can't wait to get a chance to head back and try more of their baked goods. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

27 January 2019

I just ate a birthday cake from Caked Up and it was beautiful and tasted great. Enjoy

Reviewed on Yelp

17 January 2019

First time in there!  Omg! I'm so glad a co worker of mine recommended this place.  I'm not sweets person...but let me tell you somethin' The chicken and waffle cupcake was delicious. ...Never new there was such a thing!  The carrot cupcake was Awesome too!  Yes the people are super friendly !!!! I'll be back.... More...

Reviewed on Yelp

14 January 2019

Got our sons baptism cake here it came out very nice, they are a little on the expensive side but they made our very short time frame work. We got the funfetti cake on one layer and cookie dough on the other layer... it was delicious!!!!!! Great job caked up! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

13 January 2019

AMAZING cakes and cupcakes and TOP NOTCH service.  Have used t bug em for 3 events and was always 100% satisfied!!  Highly recommend.  More pricey than some other places...but we worth it! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

5 January 2019

So good!! Maple and bacon pancake cupcake was the best thing I've ever eaten! Can't wait to go back and try the Chicken and waffles!

Reviewed on Yelp

1 January 2019

Stopped by this pop-up location last week! Grabbed 4 cupcakes- so delicious and sweet. I tried the baileys chocolate cupcake, strawberry cheesecake, chicken & waffle and banana bread Nutella! Each one was full of sweet flavor, the cheesecake had a graham crackers crust on the bottom and the Nutella cupcake was filled with Nutella goodness. They are pretty big so great to share! I spent a little over 4$ per cupcake but thought they were delicious and so soft/moist. Highly recommend! The pop-up on 7th should be there till March 2019 as of right now... More...

Reviewed on Yelp

30 December 2018

Great cakes and customer service. Denise is such a nice person and is really passionate about what she does. You can tell just from her cakes! She made a bridal shower cake for me and it was so delicious, so many rave reviews from my guests. I went into her shop for the first time at almost closing time and she was so accommodating with my cake ordering. Also one of the best rainbow cookies I have ever had! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 December 2018

I celebrate just about everything with these cupcakes, but today was my first cake order. OMG!!!! My mom loved it so much she refused to let us cut it! It was a sewing themed cake. She played with it! She actually threaded the needle with the thread lol. Amazing place!!!! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 December 2018

The cupcakes are delicious and they have a good selection. Not to mention they usually come up with different flavors for holidays.

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 December 2018

One of my favorite bakeries of all time. Their baked goods are both beautiful and delicious. We use them for all of our bakery needs - birthdays, engagement parties, random cupcake runs - they're the best. The service is incredible and the staff is always gracious and smiling. Highly recommend! Also, try the piñata cakes - they're the coolest! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 December 2018

I ordered a 6in cake and 120 mini cupcakes for my sisters 40th birthday prty. They did an absolutely beautiful job. They accommodated the gluten allergy and everything was delicious. They made it so easy from the tasting to the delivery. I definately recommend using them or just going in to get yourself a treat. We will be using them again in the future. Thank you Caked Up Cafe. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

23 December 2018

The cupcakes are really yummy!  The maple bacon cupcake with the pancakes on top is just so delightful!  Yummy and beautiful!  We also tried the liquor infused cupcakes and those were yummy too!  We will be back! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

18 December 2018

Spotted their pink striped awning from the Vamoose Bus stop.  Am I ever glad I did!  Chose 2 from their amazing array of cupcakes. .. Reese's peanut butter cup and a gingerbread flavor.  Moist and delicious.  Great job, bakers and icers!  Hope to visit again next trip on the Vamoose Bus from Washington DC. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

11 December 2018

YES YES YES!!!!! This is our favorite cupcake place ever, I always get this for special occasions. I used to work in New City and would always pop in to get a dozen cupcakes for special events. I still make trips down to rockland JUST to get these cupcakes! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

30 November 2018

Highly recommend Denise from Caked up Cafe for any cake need. We met her business through our wedding venue (The Views at. Mt Fuji) and She was so friendly and easy to work with. She delivered our dream cake and not only was it delicious but it was beautiful. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

30 November 2018

NOTE: this is a review of the pop-up store in Manhattan! YES!! Caked Up has a location in Manhattan!If you live in Rockland County, then you can enjoy Caked Up whenever you want. Those of us that live in the City can't so easily......and if you enjoy the New City location, and if you also come into the City, then you need to go to the 7th Ave location and tell all of your friends to go too. Why?Because these are the best cupcakes anyone will ever enjoy! Because they're the best, we'd like to keep the location here in the City. That means we should all do our best to support it! Let's convert the pop-up to a permanent location!The consistency of these incredible creations is perfect. Not dry, not messy or "wet"...just perfect. The sweetness is dialed in and spot-on. The textures create a blend of flavors that is literally sublime!"C'mon, Jay, it's a cupcake. You describe it like it's a work of art or something..."These incredible, brilliantly created, masterfully finished miracles ARE more like works of art than cupcakes! The attention to detail is amazing. Amazing!Hopefully you're getting the idea...we have enjoyed good and great cupcakes all over the City. I could send you a list of places ranked and all are good or better than good. Some are great.But on the top of that list will be Caked Up. They're miles ahead of everyone else!The NYC location is 345 7th Avenue (across the street and just south of Madison Square Garden). Tell everyone you know!Caked Up cupcakes are The Best! Everyone else is fighting for second place. You really need to go.GO! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps