Loading...

Please wait ...

B

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza

Berkley

(54)

Reviews (54)

Leave a review
4/5

54 customer reviews

Loading...
24 July 2021

Amazing! We were from out of town and did a quick search for good pizza - This place came up with great reviews and I admit I was skeptical when we drove up and it was right next to an old gas station. The pizza was fantastic! The guy that was serving us from behind the counter was so helpful, offering great suggestions and telling us all about the various ingredients. My family got the spicy Hawaiian and the Times Square slices and loved them! I ordered a salad with chicken, and the produce was so fresh! Candied walnuts and perfectly cooked chicken breast. So glad we stopped and had lunch there! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

26 June 2021

Best pizza around. I love the pepperoni pinwheels. I get them during lunch at work, because they're just an even easier way to eat a piece of pizza. 10/10 recommend this place for yummy Italian food. Staff is very nice and charming. 5 stars for sure More...

Reviewed on Yelp

21 June 2021

Ordered from here last night and it was fantastic! I wish I had gotten a pic of the pizza I ordered because it looked amazing, but I guess I was too hungry lol. I got the meat lovers loaded pie called The Godfather, and it was fire! Also had to get an order of garlic knots, which were also legit, and topped it off with their tiramisu! All fantastic! Highly recommend if you are in the area! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

12 June 2021

I got charged an extra $8.88 3 hours after I got my food for topping when the website never mentioned anything about additional charge for toppings.

Reviewed on Yelp

9 June 2021

Incredible food, great service. Couldn't recommend this place enough. Best Stromboli I've ever had. Amazing pizza, great pinwheels. Can't wait to try more

Reviewed on Yelp

8 June 2021

I was born and raised in Brooklyn, so I had to give "Brooklyn's Finest Pizza" a try for the first time. Hey folks, where the heck is the cheese on this pizza? Pizza joints that skimp on the cheese don't last a New York minute in Brooklyn. For $18.49, you ought not to be hungry after ordering a pie. For that price in Brooklyn, I would have been stuffed and able to share a couple of slices with a homeless soul in the hood. The crust is right and admirable, but they need to notch up the cheese content a bit. A little olive oil might also help. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

31 May 2021

I have been a repeat customer but no more. paid close to $18.00 maybe $19 for a large, only to have very skimpy toppings.

Reviewed on Yelp

20 May 2021

Love this pizza. They have my favorite type of pepperonis - the little cup type! Yum! Their crust is thin and put on the perfect amount of sauce. I've ordered from them 2x now and it's been consistently good, correct orders and on time. I'm from NY so I'm pretty picky about my "NY Style" pizza. For the neighborhood, I think they are the best. One of my top three NY pizza stops in Denver area - Famous Original J's (in five points) Original Pizza (in Broomfield) and Brooklyn's finest. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

18 May 2021

Nice you can get a single slice. Good and thin and crispy on the bottom and chewy inside. Food and eat. Beer selection was sub par. Cans and bottles but not much of a selection and not enough local brews.  Not much seating and it's in a strip center. Not the best for sitting outside view wise More...

Reviewed on Yelp

9 May 2021

Recently moved here from Jersey and this is my go-to pizza spot. Super fresh and tasty signature pies. I ordered the Brooklyn and the, NY, NY and also some delicious breaded wings that had a great spice to them. Staff is always friendly, it's cool they ask you if you need any packaged crush red pepper or other spices when you grab a pie. I'll have to give a couple other spots a try but this place is definitely my go to! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

15 April 2021

First time here today! Really enjoyed their pizza! A patient of mine recommended this place so I took his word being from NY and i must say amazing!! Will be back! Thank you guys

Reviewed on Yelp

3 April 2021

One of my favorite pizza spots. Good creative options and good quality and consistency!

Reviewed on Yelp

24 March 2021

Best Stromboli I have ever eaten. This place is incredible and a must try! We ordered the sausage and pepper and a build your own. Perfect crisp and flavor.

Reviewed on Yelp

17 March 2021

This is what you want from a neighborhood pizza joint. Let's face it, New York style pizza is the superior art form (don't come at me! ). After one visit to Brooklyn's Finest Pizza, I'm convinced they're a legit homage to their namesake. The name alone has enticed me since moving to Denver. It's one of the first places I bookmarked. It may have taken me nearly two years to get here, but boy I'm glad I did.Speaking of the name of the restaurant. Pretty ballsy move. These cats must be from Brooklyn! As the only member of my immediate family not born and raised in New York's favorite borough, I can smell a New Yorker a mile away. "Alright Matt, how was the 'za already? Stop beating around the bush."18" inch pie, half cheese, half pepperoni. Order of 6 garlic knots. Slice of cheesecake. This is one of the quintessential takeout meals in my opinion. Brooklyn's Finest does it right. A no frills pie with a sauce to cheese ratio that'll please the masses. Crisp crust, nice fold. Reheated well the next day. Even though I'm cold pizza junkie I had to test the waters. Ya know, for science! Consider me impressed.To me, this is the textbook definition of New York style pizza, specifically takeout pizza. Brooklyn's Finest has potential to be upgraded to 5 stars after another visit. Great things happening at this hole-in-the-wall joint! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

2 March 2021

in the last 6 months they've really perfected their to-go process, and I've had 100% accurate orders. And as always, the food is still delicious!

Reviewed on Yelp

22 February 2021

Without a doubt, top 3 pizza in Denver. Very authentic New York style pizza, not like the other wannabes. You guys should definitely open a location up north or maybe Boulder.

Reviewed on Yelp

20 February 2021

I also ordered online like the previous person below me on a Friday night. I also was confused if they actually got my order or not since I didn't even put my phone number in so I called to confirm. They did end up calling me when it arrived which was fine. But okay, I paid 20$ for the TINIEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD. I mean it was 4 TINY slices. Plus they got my order wrong, I wanted half pepperoni and half mushroom instead they put it all on one side. I'm from NJ/NY and I'm used to larger amounts of pizza when you spend 20$. I was still hungry afterwards and very disappointed. The taste, I mean it was okay, it was crispy and the pepperoni was good. But again hard to gage because I was still hungry afterwards. Super disappointed not sure if I would order again because I'd be scared to know how much a large would cost for what you actually get? More...

Reviewed on Yelp

20 February 2021

Sadly they don't deliver to me, but the 17 minute drive was well worth it the pizza and calzone were on point! I'd recommend them 100%

Reviewed on Yelp

19 February 2021

I have been here many times and the food has always been very good.  The service is always good, too.  Being from back East, it's not always easy to get really good pizza in Colorado, but this is one of my go-to places.

Reviewed on Yelp

13 February 2021

I'd never been to or ordered from Brooklyn's;  I don't spose I will again.  Ordered at 5:20;  an hour later I called to check.  I had made the order online;  they could not find the order.  After some time looking, they DID then find the order;  they said it was almost done and would be out the door in ten or 15 minutes.It was pretty clear they had just lost the order.  So we finally got the slightly warm, not hot, pizza an hour and 40 minutes after the order.   I've read of other issues like this with the store, and in those cases they were re-imbursed for their trouble,  or other pizzas delivered, etc.  Not in  my case.  No apology at all, just "it'll be on the way in a few minutes". More...

Reviewed on Yelp

28 January 2021

For a non-vegetarian to rave about a veggie Stromboli.. you know it has to be delish. Only place outside of NY I've been able to get one, and it is delicious. Get extra ranch because that is also the best I've had outside of NY. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

24 January 2021

Poor customer service. Overpriced. Fresh ingredients but lacked flavor. Sauce was minimal. Disappointing. Had better store-bought pizzas.

Reviewed on Yelp

7 January 2021

One word defines Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Lowell: outstanding. It's a fun ambience to be in, and the menu and service is pretty great. Everything we ordered was great and the menu itself was to die for. Staff is really friendly and definitely will help you with anything. A must go to Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Lowell for sure. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

1 January 2021

Awesome pizza ,  the people and ease of ordering was so nice that I wouldn't want to give them less than 5 stars. Pizza was ready on time and delicious

Reviewed on Yelp

19 December 2020

I liked the first pizza, but didn't love it.  The sausage calzone was amazing though. I also loved the different pin wheelsI have had too. Pizza - 3.5Pinwheels - 4.25Sausage/Jalapeño cream cheese calzone: 4:75 More...

Reviewed on Yelp

14 December 2020

Love, love, love their pizza. Wings and salads are also delicious, fresh. They always get my order right and deliver on time. Won't order pizza from anyone else, they've ruined me. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

11 December 2020

The pizza was amazing. Super delicious. I ordered through Yelp and my food came speedy and hot. Can't wait to have it again. Thanks for the great service.

Reviewed on Yelp

26 November 2020

I ordered a pizza and they said ready in thirty minutes.  Went there and they never put in the order.  Placed the order and a additional thirty minutes it was ready .  The cardboard box was heavier than the pizza.  Quality of pizza was very average.  Never again will I order from this place More...

Reviewed on Yelp

19 November 2020

Hits the spot for "New York" style pizza. I appreciated the extensive authentic toppings choices including all kinds of peppers- we got ricotta, roasted yellow tomatoes (yum) and kalamata olives.  I also liked that the cheese was not overly oily. The veggie stromboli was tasty too and was nice size for the price. We gambled and got the tiramisu dessert which came in a cupcake-like format and was tasty. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

15 November 2020

Super easy to order and to pick up, great local neighborhood spot! Their pizza is good with great flavor and toopings with a perfect NY crust.

Reviewed on Yelp

7 November 2020

Really tasty pizza and Stromboli! But if you're ordering delivery, good luck if you order any extra dressing and marinara (which they charge for). 3 delivery orders in a row i didn't get my extra marinaras and dressings. Only out a couple dollars... but still frustrating. Still, delicious food. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

29 October 2020

The guys at the counter were great! Ordered my pizza quickly and it was ready as soon as I arrived to pick it up. Although I prefer more breading to my pizza I still enjoyed it! The pepperonis are my favorite little crispy ones! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

29 October 2020

I don't post reviews very often anymore, but this place deserves it. I had a truly delicious meal, and not a bit of the attention to detail or flavor was lost on a meal to go. I've sampled many a pizza on many a continent, and this was truly a triumph. It's clear that a passion for great food is infused into everything on the menu.I started with the spinach salad. The presentation was beautiful, and the toppings plentiful. This could have been a meal in itself, but I saved room for the main event: the Little Italy. Turning an olive oil sauce pizza into a showstopper takes skill, because the flavors have nowhere to hide. The garlic shone through beautifully and was complimented by the perfect amount of cheese and finished with gorgeous tomatoes. I slowed down to savor every bite.I have no doubt that Carlo has fulfilled his vision of making the best New York pizza Denver has ever tasted! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

28 October 2020

The crust is really the highlight of the pizza for me. Not a fan of meat they used and the cheese was pretty light, but overall I enjoyed it.  6.75/10

Reviewed on Yelp

25 October 2020

Wings game breaded which I was not aware of, they also seemed semi under cooked after biting into a few

Reviewed on Yelp

17 October 2020

If you're looking for a pizza made with love, this place definitely has it. I work at a pizza place myself and have nothing bad to say about the food. Plus they make that sh*t dank, just ask for the boy Justin. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

11 October 2020

This is my go to pizza spot! Everything is so yummy. My favorite is the garlic knots and the specialty pizzas/slices. I also really like the staff. ..Cory and Jesus always make me feel like I'm a regular and I love that! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

10 October 2020

Brooklyn's Finest is hands down the best Pizza Spot in Denver. This is real NY style pizza. I also have to mention the garlic knots, OMG. They are so good. We generally order pepperoni or pep/sausage pizza. The Time Square is our favorite specialty pizza, the jalapeño cream cheese is a real treat.  Enjoy! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

10 October 2020

From the reviews I wanted to try this place, I was pleasantly surprised! I'm pretty picky about pizza. I don't love too many toppings, I don't like too much sauce, I love a good crust, not too thick, not too thin. I got my husband and dad a jalapeño sausage medium to share, I got myself a small Hell's Kitchen. They killed theirs ( should have got them a large) they finished the rest of mine lol. This place is good, a little pricey, not huge portions but decent. I would get it again, and I want to try the other options!! The apps look amazing!! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

9 October 2020

Love this pizza! As a native New Yorker I take my pizza very seriously. I am also now gluten free and their gluten free crust allows me to fulfill that craving with delicious quality ingredients. Love the pepperoni and the white pizza. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

2 October 2020

We wanted to give this spot a second chance since it has so many great reviews. The first time, last year & pre-covid, we ordered the bomber and were so underwhelmed that we avoided trying this restaurant again until tonight. I ordered through Grubhub around 6:30 for a pickup and they let me know it was ready for pick up at 7:04. I had called to make sure I could add the free garlic knots if I checked in at the restaurant and whoever helped me on the phone was great. I got there around 7:15 and the associate with bright pink hair seemed peeved that I wanted to add the garlic knots to my order. I waited inside for about 5 minutes then went to my car to wait. Someone brought out just the garlic knots and I informed him I had a pizza and salad as well. He said "oh," went inside, and I proceeded to wait another 10 minutes. I went inside to inquire and they said it would "probably 10 minutes." I asked for a refund and left around 7:45. The associate who helped with my refund(Jesus?) was very very helpful and apologetic. Don't order from this restaurant if you want to eat within the next hour and a half. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

18 September 2020

Great Pizza !This pizza is so good definitely recommended the pepperoni!Their service was nice and quick great for a quick bite to eat definitely recommend

Reviewed on Yelp

14 September 2020

The best pizza! We ordered in late in the evening on our road trip. It was delivered earlier than expected and the taste was amazing!

Reviewed on Yelp

7 September 2020

So good! The pizzas are a little small but they are delicious. Do yourself the favor and make sure to order the wings. We will be back just for those alone!

Reviewed on Yelp

7 September 2020

Since we recently moved here from the north east, I was really happy to have found this new york style pizza spot. I've ordered here twice so far, one of which was a large order to feed a bunch of friends during a get together. The pizza was delicious both times. The Little Italy is my favorite on the menu so far! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

5 September 2020

spaghetti was plain, meatballs were great, garlic knots were banginnnnnn; if i didn't live in aurora i'd come back just for the meatballs and garlic knots

Reviewed on Yelp