Anthony's NY Pizza Estero
Council, Florida
(19)
Council, Florida
(19)
19 customer reviews
Teresa Isabella
Love love love Anthony’s! I so wish there was one in SW cape. We would order a pizza right now!! Instead I am stuck with pork chops for dinner�
Reviewed on Facebook
Rachel Gosselin Reynolds
Great pizza and even better service! The cook was slinging dough, and started to teach our 5 and 8 year old boys the trick of the trade with their own dough. They LOVED it! Thanks to the 2018 St.Patrick’s Day crew!! You made our day! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Robert Stevens
Had dinner last night and tried the rice balls, antipasto salad and pizza. It was a great food and perfect pizza!! Will be back! ! A wonderful addition to our neighborhood . More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Burt Van Buskirk
Awesome pizzas. April 2017 I even had them make me an uncooked Stromboli to take to Germany. You can’t get good pizza or Stromboli in Germany! Needless to say I didn’t get a piece. LOL. It was worth it. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Bobby Cloxton
The best meatballs in SWFL...period! Their pizza is fantastic too. Being from the Northeast, I know my Italian food and this place is top notch. I can't recommend it enough.
Reviewed on Facebook
Joe Sheehy
We tried Anthony's for the first time last night. We are from Connecticut, just up 95 from the Bronx so we know good pizza and Anthony's makes a great pie/ Thin crunchy crust and a fantastic sauce. My wife would have liked more sauce on the Pie and for me, I love wine with my pizza. They will have to do better thatn serving less than a half of glass of wine next time. I don't care what they charge but don't insult me with a big glass that is less than half full when you serve it. The new place at the corner of 41 & Old 41, Carini's ( used to be Pizzaro's) charges $8.00 a glass but its full to the brim when they serve it. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Rachel Hill
Love this place!!!! The calzones are huge and the pizza is great... the people are awesome too!!! But don’t forget to try a sub or pasta! ! It’s a MUST try! You won’t be disappointed. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Allegra Maria
The owners are great people and provide excellent service.
Reviewed on Facebook
Laurence Jacks
The test was if it was as good as Little Vincent’s in NY. Yup, perfect. Best around in 7 years here full time. Could dress up the tables a bit, happy hour on beer and wine and this will be huge. Some tables with Cinzano umbrellas for visibility outside. Yes loved it More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Amanda Hughes
Quality food whether you’re grabbing a gourmet slice from the takeout counter or sitting down for an authentic Italian meal. The staff makes you feel like family stopping home for one of your Italian momma’s meals, truly great all around! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lisa Ferrazano Bisignano
We ordered for delivery Margherita Pie and Chicken Parm Hero,first day they opened, Thought they maybe off because of getting the business going but pleasantly surprised both were excellent! Sauce is one of the best around! True NY taste.. We are recommending this establishment to everyone we know here. This is going to be our go to place, thats for sure.. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Marlene Ginsberg
We just arrived back in Estero after being gone 8 months and noticed the new ownership of the restaurant near Winn Dixie.. Decided to go there for a casual dinner..WOW...The eggplant part sandwich was humongous..I actually had to take half home..My husband had the chicken parm platter which was delicious. The caesar salad was as good as a fine steakhouse would serve and bread delicious. Staff very friendly and accommodating and NICE... I am looking forward to going back to get some pizza...many types...when my husband eats all the leftovers...Excited to have this new, great place at our doorstep in The Brooks. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lisa Marie
We ordered delivery tonight and we were not disappointed. The pizza was fabulous. The sauce tasted like home! It's nice to have a NY style pizza in our little village!
! And delivery to boot!!! Definitely will be a regular custome!!
Also, due to not knowing the area, they were a little late on our delivery and the driver gave my son a USA flag, he was estatic, thank you!!
More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jeff Miller
We have eaten here twice and love the Calzone! Rachel is an awesome server and we really enjoy the atmosphere. The whole staff is friendly and fun. Highly recommended!
Reviewed on Facebook
Julia Bitzel
Ordered for lunch after hearing such great things. I was not disappointed! The food is delicious! The lunch options are not only convenient, but also really fresh. Garlic knots were awesome as well as the zeppolis! I called ahead and was helped very kindly and professionally. Great atmosphere inside too. If I could give more than 5 stars I would! Thanks Anthony and staff! I will absolutely be back soon! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Larissa Kneipher Ilhan
My husband and I went to Anthony's on Sunday for dinner. Delicious would be an understatement and definitely worth the wait. You definitely can't rush perfection. The pizza was thin crust, golden brown and crispy, the salad was huge, made with crisp and fresh vegetables, fresh dinner rolls were warm and delicious and lasagna was to die for. The waitresses were warm, friendly and attentive as well. This will definitely be a go to for us in the future. Can't wait to return. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Billie Porter
... the food is amazing.... they are always happy to accommodate a large order when I’m the “gopher” for the office... and they remember you by name after only a few visits... I love this place!
Reviewed on Facebook
Marisa Rivera
Best pizza � in Estero and in the whole SWFL region !! Chicken parm pizza is the bomb! All the soups are homemade and delicious and the salad is the best salad I have ever eaten! Highly recommend it is great for take out and a casual dinner spot!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Nancy Rosario
I like of the taste of the slice of cheese of pizza pretty close to New York's pizza me being from New York but I give it a four star only because the slice of pizza the dough is way to thin, New York's pizza is not thin and soggy so that's a draw back and everytime I order a slice not some much soggy but very thin.
Reviewed on Facebook
