Loading...

Please wait ...

A Piece of Cake logo
A

A Piece of Cake

Green Valley, Indiana

(36)

Reviews (36)

Leave a review
D
28 April 2019

Great place good deals
Especially the cake trash deals

L
20 March 2019

I cannot say enough good words about this long-established, trustworthy, and extremely creative cake shop! They made our beautiful wedding cake 22 years ago, multiple birthday cakes, creative cakes for baptisms/1st communion, and also made our daughter's wedding cake. Never had any issues. Completely satisfied! More...

F
20 March 2019

Really kind people, pretty responsible and great product, they made the cake for my son and it was a major hit

A
18 February 2019

Wonderfully decorated cakes. Always consistent in taste. Don't just stop in to pick up a cake. They book up sometimes several weeks during their peak seasons. They also give you a to go pack of napkins, plates and forks to match! More...

B
19 January 2019

I love a piece of cake. They wwnt above and beyond for me on my baby shower cake. It turned out beautiful and they even worked with me on pick up when my baby shower was rescheduled due to the snow storm we had last weekend. Thank you so much to the cake experts. They have hearts of gold and truly aim to please their customers. More...

S
21 September 2018

Wonderful experience. Ordered a cake on phone for my nephew in Indiana. 100% satisfied. Highly recommended and trusted bakers.

P
21 September 2018

They are amazing! I will never go to another place to get a cake again! The ladies in there are so personal and understanding. If you want it one way they don’t complain and do it right away. The cake itself tastes amazing to! I would recommend them 100%! More...

C
21 September 2018

Just get one cake here and you’ll never go to a grocery store bakery ever again. We got my sons Birthday cake here and while his choice of flavors wasn’t my favorite, the cake was outstanding! Very nicely decorated, great price and delicious. This will be our go to bakery for cakes from now on. Just need to try the pies now. More...

C
25 July 2018

Cakes tasted amazing and looked great. Will be coming here for all cakes from now on.

L
25 July 2018

Thank you for such a beautiful and delicious cake!

M
25 July 2018

The best cake. We have ordered from them for several years, and it's always been phenomenal.

M
25 July 2018

The cake pops.. a HUGE hit for my wedding we celebrated in October!!

C
25 July 2018

My husband order a yellow cake with fudge filling covered with flowers for my birthday. It was amazing! Everyone loved it! Thank you so much for such a wonderful cake. More...

K
25 July 2018

Absolute best!!! Every event we have has a Piece of Cake!

A
25 July 2018

A Piece of Cake made the most delicious & beautiful cake for my husband's military ceremony. We received so many compliments on it and everyone wanted to know where it came from. We will definitely be returning customers for birthdays and other celebrations we will have in the future! More...

E
25 July 2018

A Piece of Cake Bakery did a fantastic job on my daughter's 6th birthday cake for a fair price too!! I will never go anywhere else. And the staff was so lovely to interact with. Thank you for such a great experience. I look forward to doing future business with you!! More...

K
25 July 2018

I am very impressed with the cake I received for my daughters 5th birthday. Everyone asked where I got it from! I couldn't believe how inexpensive it was. Just about the same price at Wal-Mart, Meijer and target and taste 10xs better! The icing was actually edible and not to sweet! More...

C
25 July 2018

We ordered a cake for my uncle's 90th birthday party tomorrow they did a really awesome job

A
25 July 2018

Beautiful, delicious cake! One of the most delicious cakes I've ever tasted! Will be ordering cakes in the future for sure! Friendly customer service!

R
25 July 2018

We got my daughter's graduation cake from here. It was beautiful & so delicious! Everyone loved it too because there was none left at the end of the party.

M
25 July 2018

Ordered a Red Velvet from Phoenix for my Father-in-laws 80th Birthday in Greenwood and it was moist, and the decorations of a golf theme were unique and included a plastic golf cart and clubs! It was a hit at the party!

S
25 July 2018

I ordered a 50th birthday cake for my dad and when I got there to pick it up, the order for the cake had accidentally been put in wrong. It was put in as a Walking Dead cake instead of super hero themed which was actually pretty comical. They were nothing but professional and apologized and re-made the cake within a half hour. Mistakes happen and I was so pleased with how the situation was handled and how the final cake looked and tasted! I have had two other cakes from here in the past that were phenomenal as well! Thank you so much! More...

L
25 July 2018

The most delicious & beautiful cakes around! Fairly priced & aways friendly service. I have never been disappointed by Piece of Cake - from my extravagant wedding cake that was made there to the random last minute birthday cakes we order! They are always fantastic.

B
25 July 2018

My husband and I ordered our wedding cake from A Piece of Cake. They were very affordable and the cake tasted amazing. We had white, chocolate, and lemon flavors. I was especially impressed by the presentation of the cake. We had envisioned our wedding cake, but had to describe our vision using multiple Pinterest photos. The cake was just as we had envisioned it. We will use A Piece of Cake for all future cake needs. More...

M
25 July 2018

We were very picky about our wedding cake, it had to be funfetti flavored! A Piece of Cake worked with us and our indecisiveness to make us a beautifully decorated and delicious cake! They truly helped make our day special! More...

M
23 July 2018

Wonderful cake! Great people to work with for a wedding! Delicious and a great price!

Y
4 June 2018

Been ordered 3 times worth of every dollar. They are perfect in baking and taste..

S
5 May 2018

Excellent gluten free, dairy free cakes... Worth the money!

D
19 March 2018

i love this place it has eggs and pie and jelly

B
26 January 2018

I got my 18th birthday cake done here and it was amazing! Great price, great quality and great people to work with!

B
22 January 2018

A Piece of Cake / Debbie Cake
Is like having a Roslyn Bakery cake but better.
Highly recommend this amazing cake company.

L
15 October 2017

Just ordered our 4th and last wedding cake for kids weddings!

J
3 October 2017

An excellent place for cake trash, it's cake that is leftover from the bigger cakes they make. In the times that I've gone I've gotten chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream frosting, very good

E
26 September 2017

Great service! Great taste!!

A
13 September 2017

Nothing but love for this bakery! The staff was attentive, friendly, and flexible, accommodating our wishy-washiness and working with us when we completely changed our mind on what kind of cake we wanted. We bought a simple, two-tier white wedding cake for our wedding in Indianapolis, but it still had nice little touches and flourishes. The cake itself was rich and moist, simply delicious. Will go back and would definitely recommend! More...

V
30 May 2016

We LOVED our first experience with A Piece of Cake for our little boy's first birthday. They made the most adorable cake, with a smash cake included. The staff was very friendly and made the cake exactly how I asked. Oh and did I mention it was super moist and delicious! We had several guests at the party ask who made the cake because they loved it so much. Thank you all for a wonderful job, will definitely use you in the future! More...

Photos (5)

See all