Elm Grove, Wisconsin
212 customer reviews
James Beaudry
Great food great service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike O'Krongly
Great seafood, service and environment...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Peter Hertzberg
Always great atmosphere, friendly staff, and good, fresh seafood.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Karla Bockholt
Had the walking tacos & they were amazing
Reviewed on Google Maps
Westley Brennan
I visit this spot a lot since I work in the area. I must say the service is always fantastic and they keep the place clean constantly. Prices are reasonable and they serve big portions. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brian Staude
Excellent food and staff!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rick Roulet
Good menu and good service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sam Stair
Bar service was slow but they were busy with happy hour deals. Dinner was very good, lots of options and prices aren't insane. Large portions
Reviewed on Google Maps
jane lewinski
Wonderful food great service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Teresa Turner
I had my continuation 62nd birthday celebration/holiday weekend dinner there with some family on Sunday, December 1,2019! My dinner was GREAT/perfect as was dinning atmosphere
Reviewed on Google Maps
Courtney M
Excellent food and service! One of my top restaurants. Very classy atmosphere inside. Love their mixed drinks as well.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Pam Groce
Nice
Reviewed on Google Maps
Boris Mudrik
Enjoy every time I visit
Reviewed on Google Maps
Phil Wilson
The service here is great (had a seat at the bar) the wines are top notch and the food is 1st class. A great place if you are craving seafood!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Donna Bell
The food was decent but not the best meal I have had
Reviewed on Google Maps
mary winter
Good service and great food!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Karla Micklos
We celebrated my son-in-laws birthday today. The lunch menu was great!!! All the food was delicious, as well as the kids’ choices. Loved the Sharkfin dessert, but not a Baby Shark for sure! Our server Heidi was just as terrific serving our group of 10. Highly recommend this restaurant. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kirsten Willford
Had the oysters and duo it was tasty!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sandra Jurena
The food was absolutely delicious. Service was also very good. Definitely recommend this place for special occasions or just a nice dinner.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rachel Ewert
Love Mitchell's Fish Market. The food is always great and they have the best desserts!! Their carrot cake it out of this world.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Raymond Diggs
The food was pretty good. The server botched our order, but she was attentive and made amends for it. I had the sixty south salmon, cedar plank roasted, ceasar salad. It was all pretty good.
Reviewed on Google Maps
john charleston
Superb food and excellent service without fail every time.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Preston
Over the past year, my wife and I have been there at least six times. We get started with the daily happy hour and then have a great dinner. If you have room for dessert, they are over the top. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
John Arneson
The food was delicious and reasonable and our waitress was awesome informative and attentive.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sarah Sector
Great selection of fresh fish. Steaks and appetizers were good. Friendly wait staff. Good place for a business dinner.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dave Ferguson
I did the 20 for 20 shrimp and was more than full when done great price and good food great valur
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bob Janowski
Oyster special is terrific
Reviewed on Google Maps
Suzanne Baczanski
Always excellent service and food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amphay Douangvilay
The happy hour is amazing! Drinks and food selections top notch.
Reviewed on Google Maps
adBidtise
Great place for delicious seafood if you are out in the burbs! Lunch is a must no waiting, friendly staff and great good!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jon Reid
Good salmon
Reviewed on Google Maps
KELLY HENDRIX
The steak was amazing and I love their sourdough bread. The carrot cake was ridiculously large, but good enough to still want to eat it all in one sitting. I almost made it, but have enough for lunch tomorrow. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Anne Burmeister
Went for our Anniversary.Service was great. I had the Salmon and it was delicious! Nice place for special occasions.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ben Gutkowski
Great menu and delicious food.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike Stebbins
I had the Big Fish Sandwich for lunch and it was delicious. Perfectly cooked, hot when it got the table, and the tartar was excellent. The coleslaw was also outstanding and I have a difficult time finding good slaw. I ate at the bar and Penny provided great service and was a pleasure to chat with. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
scott olson
Food for all ages
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alfonso Cruz
Great food and fresh fish. The scallops are awesome. Great service and plenty of parking.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike S
Wow! This place is the only reason you need to visit one the last remaining malls in this world. Everything is about 1-3$ more than I would expect. But it’s worth it. Everyone from the hostess to our awesome waitress Hiedi were great. The swordfish was very very good. Blackened. The Seafood Sampler was good, but the scallops were a little more sandy than I’ve experienced ever before. Id still get it again. And the Angels Manhattan, holy cow. Get that. Go there just for that. We live super far away, and can’t wait to go back. Ha. We went for lunch and were able to get out of there for less than 90$, with desert drinks and cocktail. Worth it. I really hope this place stays around and I regret taking this long to find it. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Kline
Our dinners were delicious and the service was outstanding!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike Neary
Excellent
Reviewed on Google Maps
Margaret Czerniejewski
Delicious trout.mmm. possibly the best margarita ever.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Judy Dougherty
Great food awesome service
Reviewed on Google Maps
Aaron Gesicki
Great food, excellent service. Definitely a place we'll frequent.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kari L. Hendricks
Absolutely delicious fish, lobster, lobster bisque, key lime pie and cheesecake. Amazing friendly service. Highly recommend!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shayla Zarate
This was my first time eating here . The food was plated very beautifully and tasted very good.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brian Leggero
Excellent food, service and atmosphere
Reviewed on Google Maps
Julia Strobos
Always liked this place. Always come here when I am in town.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Pastor Greg Moser
Always great food. The grilled oysters are absolutely delicious
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michael Sippy
Very good place to eat. All of their food is super fresh and the prices are reasonable. The decoration inside is also really good and the waitress that I had was very knowledgeable about what everything was.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marj Kozlowski
The Shanghai Sampler is awesome. I had a house salad with it, and I was very full when I left.
Reviewed on Google Maps