Sgt. Peffer's
Omaha
(252)
Omaha
(252)
252 customer reviews
Rick A J.
Been there many times going back soon they got dam good food definetly would recommend.
Reviewed on Yelp
B G.
We've been going to Sgt Peff's for probably 27 years, visited all 3 locations, mostly Saddle Creek, sometimes Millard, and occasionally Carter Lake. I usually hit the Millard location for lunch. In the years we've been going, I've eaten only 5 items, they are all fantastic - hamburger pizza, minestrone soup, ravioli with half white/half red sauce, chicken Florentine soup, and grilled chicken salad. Their house dressing and homemade rolls are delicious and the food is always piping hot! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Brad H.
Today I had a catering order that included their fantastic rolls. I thought they were included in one of my bags. When I got where I was going I discovered they were not. When I called in they apologized and drove the 25 minutes to where I was to complete my ordered. This type of customer service is what sets this place apart from the crowd. Thanks so much Sgt Peffers for making sure we got our roll fix! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jon Herms
Wonderful food. Pizza is amazing, great meatballs. Quick service.
Reviewed on Facebook
Myles Tickle
I thought their pasta dishes were my favorites, but then my son couldn't finish his kids pizza so I ate that and that was my new favorite. But then on our next visit, I thought I would try something different - The Roast Beef Au Jus. The sky was now in full Technicolor and the birds were singing a Mozart opera. Everything became clearer, brighter because the best Roast beef au jus has been found in Millard made by Sgt Peffer. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Carol Rich
Excellent gluten-free pizza. Also, the grilled chicken salad is a favorite of ours.
Reviewed on Facebook
Chad K.
Good affordable Italian cuisine in Millard. You order at the counter, have a seat, and then wait for your food to be brought to you. Their lunch specials are great. You can get a good sized portion of baked pasta, a roll, a salad (or soup), and a drink for around $10. Not too bad at all.One complaint: They make their own Italian dressing and it's just never good. I think it's because it separates and people don't realize it. So they pour some out and get mostly oil. Then they realize it and shake it up, but by then the oil to vinegar to herb balance in the container has been thrown off. I know. I know. I've put way too much thought into it. It would help if they shook up the container thoroughly before handing it to the customers.The "taste like it's out of jar" crowd of reviewers cracks me up. I'd love to get 5 jarred marinaras and 5 made from scratch ones and do a blind taste test and see if they can actually pick out the 5 jarred ones. I'd bet good money they can't. Everyone thinks they're an expert in Italian sauces. It's not from a jar, people. Now my eyes hurt from rolling them.For those into Omaha restaurant history, Sgt. Peffer's owners are the same people who were behind "Pefferoni's Pizza & Etcetera" back in the 1980s. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Sabrina D.
Sgt. peffers is an Omaha favorite for a reason: it's so dang good. Their pastas and salads are fresh and tasty, but I come mostly for the pizza. Specifically, either the veggie or the four cheese white. And gosh, they are so so good. If you've never been, throw out what you think you know about good pizza and order a four cheese white and thank them later! It's a creamy and savory delight! They also offer a drive thru pick up spot if you've been wise enough to order ahead! The dine in space at this location isn't huge, but it can certainly accommodate you and your family! Delicious. Quality. Friendly. Tried and true. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Caela Henley-Huddleston
Such a great little place. Owner is super nice guy. Everyone was super nice and helpful.. great customer service. Would recommend for sure..
Reviewed on Facebook
Amanda Jimerson
I love this place!!!!!!!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jexa Knobbe
The best! The five cheese pizza and the decor are my fav! Beatles forever!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Marion Goulette Kirk
best pizza in town we love all their food
Reviewed on Facebook
Tori Healey
Best pizza in town! They deliver to our neighborhood, but whoever answers the phone is never sure, so they ask the delivery guy, Larry. Larry always gets on the phone, knows exactly who and where we are and delivers our pie hot, quick and with a smile! Highly recommend. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Katey S.
They get five stars for delivering pizza to The Homy Inn across the street! Definitely a pizza that stands out in Omaha. It's a little hidden so prepare to be confused. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Rebecca Paige McMahon
Larry is an amazing delivery driver and has been delivering to us for years. We appreciate the friendly and person service we get every time he delivers!
Reviewed on Facebook
Greg M.
Real good! We got their Meatlover's pizza(The Prime Cut), and it had good quality meat toppings and they didn't skimp. Overall, the flavor of it was perfect! I will be back to order again soon. Definitely 5 stars from me! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Angie Martin
food is always delicious no complaints there. I will say we were pretty disappointed in the attitude of the staff. we came in w a medium sized group, place was empty anyway, service was quick so that was nice. a few of is stayed around and chatted, when we left we said thank you, the kids said thank you but not one of us got a friendly you're welcome, we got a nose in the air with dirty looks. we were quite confused.... we then noticed we stayed about 30 min past closing time. So yes our fault but that didn't deserve the rudeness we were given. they could have politely said we close at 8. no one would have been upset. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jean Crary
Great gluten free pizza.
Reviewed on Facebook
Kristi C.
Great Italian pizza and the white sauce is the best I've had. I've been going here for years and their quality is always consistent. Love the 5 cheese white pizza! Our family also gets the cheese tortellini with white sauce. I've come to really like the rest of their pizza options as well with the red sauce. The red sauce meals are not quite as good. I also really enjoy their wheat buns. They are just a little sweet. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jane McClurkin
Excellent and family owned. Always good and always feel welcome
Reviewed on Facebook
April Hogan-Forte
Everything on the menu is great
Reviewed on Facebook
Debbie Gochenour
Love love Sgt Peffer’s. Great Food. Always excited when we do a benefit auction like today and Sgt Peffer is doing the catering.
Reviewed on Facebook
Judi Larsen Pedersen
Somewhat difficult to get there, but worth finding it. All items we had were great .
Reviewed on Facebook
Tracy Podany
Every meal I have eaten at Sgt Peffer’s has been outstanding. Taste. Temperature. Choices. The staff is always friendly. Would recommend this place in a heart beat. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Haryl Denkens
I will take all the girls I wish I could ask out here. haha Best Italian homemade food I've had in a long time in Omaha.
Reviewed on Facebook
Jim Homan
Love the food, especially the Italian Sausage.
Reviewed on Facebook
Chris Wingate
The food and staff are second to none.
Reviewed on Facebook
Sherri S.
LOVE LOVE LOVE their food. However, never go through the drive through. They pretend not to see you. We tried ordering ahead three different times for drive through, and it took about 30 mins sitting in your car. It wasn't even rush hour time. Happened every time. They would refuse to look up and see you, even if you knocked on the window. They would finally answer and then make the meal that you had called in for. We have loved all the sandwiches and baked dishes. Found their spaghetti a bit bland, but WOW on every thing else. Soups are great too! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Raye Sullivan
I’m having “one of those days”, I drove past Sgt Peffer’s and decided to stop for lunch. I grew up in the neighborhood and it used to be one of my favorite places to eat. I don’t make it down that way very often so I don’t eat there much anymore. I ordered my own made up pasta dish. The staff was very friendly and made my order exactly as I requested. The entire meal was delicious and the minestrone is the best I have ever had! Thank you for being a bright spot in my day. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Elizabeth Miller
Everything I have tried from Sgt. Peffer’s has been great! Love the pizza and grilled chicken salads.
Reviewed on Facebook
Susan Grady Bristol
Chicken &cheese tortellini is wonderful (and plentiful!) Salad with shredded chicken on top with their wonderful salad dressing.
Reviewed on Facebook
Kristin Caniglia
My food has always been really good when I’ve eaten there. My two favorite there are the white cheese pizza and a grilled chicken salad. Their dressing is so yummy and the chicken is seasoned so well! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Laura E.
Skip the garlic bread and salad. I've had more garlic on a PBJ, and the salad is straight out of an uninspired bag. That said: good gracious, eat some entrees! We love the ravioli, and the meatballs in red sauce. So, so good. We're excited to dig into the menu more and see what else we can fall in love with. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Tammi H.
This place is Awesome! Both locations I feel could use update but I think the atmosphere is fun. I haven't found anything I don't like! There chicken salad is to die for and it's a huge serving amount everyone must try this salad!! There pizza is great! All pasta dishes are wonderful. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Ruth S.
This is a wonderful surprise oasis in the center of busy Millard. The food is every bit as delicious as they say with special gourmet touches. Their unique brand of service--ordering counter and limited table service---keeps their costs down and that is refreshing! The quality and large portions are the real surprise. The only down mark would be the plastic chairs, but if it helps to keep their costs down, plastic it is! Excellent service. Excellent quality. Excellent bargain! We'll be back!! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Cedric Relford
I ate there often when I lived there. The pepperoni rolls and tortellini are my favorites. Matter of fact, I will be in town next week. Gotta make sure I stop.
Reviewed on Facebook
Tanya Allen Yoder
Delicious, as always!! Pizza just doesn’t get any better!
Reviewed on Facebook
Justin H.
Five stars because of the chicken Florentine soup, if you order anything I recommend the Chicken Florentine soup! Sgt Peffer's has homemade soup daily. They make a different soup for each day of the week. Friday they have Chicken Florentine soup which is the best soup I've ever tasted. Sgt Peffer's has other great dishes, their prime cut pizza is great as well, it's their version of a meat lovers pizza. Their salad dressing is great as well. Overall I'd say they deserve a try. The interior is small, they have have seating for about 30 people. They also have two other locations in the Omaha area. If your ever in Omaha check out Sgt Peffer's Italian cafe. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
M P.
Stopped in for dinner and were pleasantly surprised with the experience. They have a small parking lot that was very filled up for a weekday evening, plenty of drive-thru customers, and a relatively bustling interior. The line to order food moved quickly though and service overall was good. We tried a gourmet veg pizza, the baked alfredo pasta and linguini with clam sauce. All were tasty. The pizza had plenty of veggies and was well-cooked, not burned or oily. The alfredo was nice and thick (could have had a little more seasoning), not runny with a puddle of sauce at the bottom of the dish. The linguini had good flavor from the amount of chopped clams. Overall great food in a casual environment. We'll be back More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Becky Bravo
Their chicken Florentine soup is the best!
Reviewed on Facebook
Kim D Fountain
I got my lunch at the Summit today. I tried Sgt. Peffer’s. It’s very good! I’ll probably save some for later.
Reviewed on Facebook
Tom Millie
Not only a wonderful place to eat, the menu is diverse and made from scratch. The staff and management at Sgt Peffer’s are great people, great neighbors to us. Affordable prices for fantastic food. The homemade soups, chicken salads and the pizza and casseroles are our favorites! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Laurie Nixon
Great Canneloni. I always enjoy it
Reviewed on Facebook
P J Smith Auchterlonie
Yummy gluten free options, generous portions and very friendly staff. Love the Beatle’s memorabilia.
Reviewed on Facebook
Steffanie Barnes Sutton
Everything on the menu is simply fantastic! From soups to pizzas...all great!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jordan R.
My family loves this unique, Italian cuisine, beatles themed cafe! We have been going here for years and have never had an unpleasant meal. The atmosphere is always friendly and we are always recognized by the staff(probably because of how much we dine there). Our regular pie is the five cheese white with pepperoni and hamburger, and my oh my! What a pie! We always bring our friends from out of town or if they've never been before. If you check them out we like to see who can name the most Beatles songs! And just remember, everybody loves Ringo. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Lupe Nymann
Love there food is delicious best soups and pizza and sandwiches and rolls ♥️
Reviewed on Facebook
Mary Ann J.
Their pizza is one of the best in Omaha. They use fresh ingredients and do not skimp on the cheese. The lasagna and chicken salad are good too The restaurant itself has an old time East Coast vibe that makes this Italian Connecticut native feel at home.
Reviewed on Yelp
Diana Peffer
of course, 5 stars ,Tim catered our 40th high school reunion,the pizza is wonderful.. my fave is the "Prime Cut" great food great time. Saint Alberts,,,,,Co. Bluffs.....class of 1978.Thanks again, Tim More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Ivan Reyna
great food and loved all the vintage Italian stuff hanging on walls
Reviewed on Facebook
