Sarge's Delicatessen & Diner

This place is amazing! You must have the pastrami sandwich or burger and the fries and cheese dip were also good. This place is open 24 hours a day, it is so good after a long day and night of drinking. Our server was wonderful as well very sweet, nice and attentive! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Always excellent food. Matzoh ball soup is a must

Reviewed on Facebook

Pastrami was perfect. Shared the Robin and crinkle fries, our friends had the sweet potatoes fries which were also crispy and delicious. Free pickles and cole Slaw. Nice and attentive staff. Will definitely be back! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The inside looks dated and it wasn't too busy for holiday time Saturday afternoon lunch (2pm). Wasn't as big as i expected (about 30 seats? )We were seated (party of 4) after 5 minutes. The older diner type lady server was pleasant and overall service was good. We all had the half sandwich and soup combo. The pastrami on rye was very good. The various soup were pretty tasty especially the matsa ball soup. Overall experience was good although I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here again. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Fantastic. From New Hampshire visiting NYC for the umpteenth time. Had a bowl of matzoh soup, and a pastrami and corned beef with swiss on rye. Sandwich was 4 " thick and  absolutely phenomenal. Been to a few NYC delis. Sarge's is by far the best and most reasonable I've been to. Please try it out, you won't be disappointed. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Doesn't look like much but got great reviews, so we went for it. It does not disappoint. Food was great and portions were HUGE. I couldn't even finish half of my sandwich. Some of the staff weren't the most friendly, but, I wasn't there to make friends. Anyways, super good. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

We tried this deli for the first time this trip and ordered corned beef, pastrami and a triple decker club.  My favorite part of the meal was the turkey club and cheesecake.  Little overpriced for 2 1/2 sand and 2 fries and 1 slice cheesecake imo but I get it everything is higher in New York More...

Reviewed on Yelp

A little expensive but so worth it. The food is of best quality and very tasty, also huge portions. The corned beef and pastrami plus the new York cheesecake are a must try!!

Reviewed on Yelp

Worth the hype. Really an amazing place. Entrees are big enough to split. Great pastrami, burgers. Every bit as good as Katz, Perhaps even better.

Reviewed on Yelp

I don't care what anyone says, Sarge's has the very best Corned Beef/Pastrami on Rye in all of Manhattan.   They cure and cook their meat, sliced thin and piled high with Russian dressing and Cole slaw.  Wow was it juicy and delicious.  Expect to be stuffed when you finish.Good service from a nice staff.  I wish I were back in NYC. I'd be there eating now. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The food was good. I had the turkey with mashed potatoes and corn on the cob with stuffing. The stuffing was just meh but the rest was nice and hot and the gravy was particularly tasty. Their prices are outrageous however which knocks a star off. $38 for lunch with tip, cost of delivery etc. Not unless I'm desperate. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I wish I could give Sarges six dollars this is a great in NYC deli as soon as my wife and I walked in we were greeted with huge plate of coleslaw and two kinds of pickles which immediately please my wife and myself then since it was lunch we order off the lunch menu I got the Joubert Junior Ruben and it was bigger than two people could eat came with Sue came with a beverage the service was excellent I couldn't ask for a better price if you go try to go for the lunch as the sandwiches or more reasonably sized if you want to really big sandwich before people order off the regular menu otherwise this is one of the best places ever and

Reviewed on Yelp

The food quality is excellent here. Portion sizes are very generous. The cheesecake is a must! The serving of cheesecake is easily enough for two people to share. I highly recommend Sarge's and will definitely make this a tradition on my trips to NYC! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

This place is true NYC.  I've eaten in and had take out several times.  Epic sandwiches, all the fixings.  Sensational chicken consommé / bone broth that is well packed when sent for delivery.  The staff are kind to you if you are kind to them.  They are fast with water (nice with ice) and coffee (its bottomless for a reason, drinkable but not for coffee snobs).  Haven't tried the extensive reaches of their menu but their breakfast, brunch, sandwich and soup options are all top notch.  Plus the sides of fresh pickles, slaw and its seems house baked rye bread are hearty and authentic.  24 hours is a classic NYC, pro for the close! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

There hours are convenient, 24 hours, & the sandwiches are big, fat & delicious. The service is also very good

Reviewed on Facebook

Found this place on Yelp and later found out it was one of my uncle's favorites. Much quieter and not nearly as crazy as Katz's deli but still a good spot for a good pastrami and ny cheesecake. Matzoh ball was light and fluffy but broth was a little plain not like in the pics posted. Overall a good solid deli. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

I absolutely love this place. It is a New York City institution. Fact that you can get such high-quality food 24 hours a day is just amazing. All the old-school Jewish food is just incredible. Pastrami corn beef brisket potato pancakes kreplach matzoh ball soup and knishesJust wow! They also have the best desserts my personal favorite is the chocolate cream pie and a cheesecake is outstanding. If you're up late and looking for some amazing food there's no better place to go in New York City. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Sarge's is a Murray Hill staple. Some love it, some don't. I LOVE it. Delicious sandwiches and huge portions. Is the staff the friendliest? No but the food makes up for it. I recommend getting hot corned beef or hot pastrami sandwich. If you aren't in the mood for either of those options, I recommend the bacon burger or boneless chicken sandwich. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Very classic NYC.  Signed autographs on the walls, lots of menu options, and warm atmosphere.  The hostess was a bit slow to greet us (and not exactly chipper), but we were happy to chat and be out of the cold until seated.  It took even longer for the server to see us, but she was very pleasant and had good suggestions.  My friend had the Hungarian goulash which was good, but she felt it was lacking the usual flavoring of goulash.  The stew meat was in very large chunks - like pot roast - and it's flavor overwhelmed the dish.  It was $25, so I think she may have regretted the choice.I, on the other hand, had the most amazing knish of my life!!  Knish stuffed with corned beef and a smear of brown mustard.  Delicious!  I also tried the spinach knish.  Tasty, but not nearly as good, and a bit cold.Finally, we both had cheesecake - one original and one with berries.  Both were amazing. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

This was THE BEST pastrami sandwich my husband and I have ever had! On our recent trip to NY we could have ate this every meal, but understand that's not idea. .. right? Now I'm back in NC and wishing I did in fact do that because Sarges sandwich is still on my mind! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Their brisket sandwich is the best I have had in the city. It has always been consistently great even when delivered late night. Their soups are wonderful too.

Reviewed on Yelp

We love coming here on our annual visit! Just an Uber or Lyft away and back. Some of the most tender non-fatty corned beef and the pastrami is terrific. The Rye bread is so fresh then the Matzo Ball Soup!! Light fluffy Matzo, broth is steeped in flavor. Staff is efficient and very friendly. And, they SHIP - New years eve here we go We even had them wrap an order for the plane trip home More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Tender, lean pastrami without being dry.  (My husband prefers Katz which is fattier and saltier.) The debate goes on... I really like the chopped liver, which is studded with glistening caramelized onions.  But what will keep me coming back are the chicken soup with matzo ball and the fluffy cheesecake. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

It was delicious, service was awesome!

Reviewed on Facebook

I salute you Sarge's. Absolutely delicious eggs Benedict. Even Despite the sheer hazard of delivering expertly poached eggs to my home. Sarge's delivered an eggs Benedict with not two, but, three creamy egg yolks. Accompanied by a judicious helping of their flavorful and properly viscous hollandaise sauce. The home fries were good but, not memorable. I missed the crunchiness and bold flavors from the potatoes. The English muffins were fresh, toasted, and adequately buttered. Solid breakfast. I can't wait to try other menu items. Tips: Get the Eggs Benedict More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Service was very nice and deli sandwiches were solid. Pastrami, corned beef, and French dip sandwiches are very good. Highly recommend trying this place. Cozy neighborhood hangout feel.

Reviewed on Yelp

Order This Half Pastrami Sandwich Half Matzah Ball  Soup! Square Knish , Hot Dog w/ Kraut with A Side Of Fries. Tell Them Mr. Throwback Sent You

Reviewed on Yelp

I decided to update my review and change to 5 stars. The delivery fees have gone down which is nice or if you order from them directly, you get a discount which offsets the delivery fee. The prices may seem a bit high but the portions are very big. The Bronx sliders are still among my favorite but I sometimes have a problem where they add onions even when I don't want them. Some of my other favorites are the rack of lamb, French onion soup, and black out cake. I do wish they'd use a bigger container for the slices of cake because they tend to show up crushed against the lid and for $8 for a slice of cake, you'd expect it to show up in tact. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Always stop here for a sandwich before you hit the road to go home. Well worth it. Top notch Deli. Out standing staff and service.

Reviewed on Facebook

I had the pastrami sandwich. Excellent flavor and high quality ingredients. Highly recommended.

Reviewed on Yelp

Best sandwiches ever! Flew all the way from Oregon for this!!! 5+ stars

Reviewed on Facebook

The soup and sandwich deal was exactly what i needed when i was sick on my trip. Quick prep and helpful considering i couldn't' talk properly due to illness. Mixed Turkey on white rye with swiss and mayo and mustard. Chicken soup with matzo balls - something i was determined to give a go while in the city. Picked up 1 of each sour and regular pickles - EXACTLY what i was looking for! For a no-nonesense in and out deli in the hub-ub of the city, Sarges made my weekend :) More...

Reviewed on Yelp

This was a big and welcome surprise visiting New York last. Always looking for a good deli and to find such a great one just several blocks from my hotel on lower Park Ave. Made it there for breakfast and lunch and looking forward to it again so many delicious things on the menu to try. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Friend of mine brought me a sandwich from Sarge's and it was truly fantastic. I live in Rhode Island and it's more difficult to get great pastrami here. It is it my priority list for next time I'm new in New York City More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Save room in your belly for Sarge's Deli!  Every time I visit NYC, I think this to myself - I've been here in numerous occasions and at various times of day, and have never been disappointed with the quality of the dishes, the speed of the kitchen, and the portions are very, very generous.  Today, I came with my daughter for a late morning breakfast, which is the busiest I've ever seen it.  As they're known for their Nova Scotia, my daughter chose to order a Nova bagel platter, and I chose a garden omelette with a side of well done bacon, and we shared all of the above.  The Nova was the best I've ever had, and the law people know how to do bacon right!  My all-time fave from the past, however, is the open Reuben, which is startling in size when they set it down in front of you, and is just an incredible sandwich (enough for 2 people, though!) More...

Reviewed on Yelp

4/5 food3/5 service 3/5 pricing I've dined at Sarge's twice for lunch and once for takeout. First time I had the twin rolls special - one pastrami, one corned beef. I choose to have Russian, Mayo, and mustard on the side. The waitress looked at me funny but hey it's my choice lady. The chicken noodle soup, pickles, and coleslaw were good with the lunch special. Second time I had the Pastrami half sandwich with barley soup special. Very good. Service- the gentleman who brought me my beverage was very kind but the place didn't feel welcoming in general. The waitress both times was unfriendly. For delivery one night at my job I ordered a pastrami on rye extra lean first cut. Came with pickles and coleslaw. With their delivery charge the sandwich came to $35!The pastrami is excellent but dang, this is a once in a while treat for sure. The sandwich wasn't that big to me either. Could definitely finish it in one serving. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Came here last Sunday with my parents, the food was fantastic!! The dinner special was a great deal, $28 for a soup or salad, meal and a drink. I had the Ceasar salad, brisket with kasha varnishkas and brocoli, mom had knockwurst with baked beans and fries and dad had matzo ball soup and pastrami sandwich. My meal was amazing, and the portion was huge, I had 3 meals out of it. The brisket was so tender and the kasha dish was a pleasant surprise, never tried kasha mixed with anything might be my new favorite comfort food. And the gravy was delicious. The pastrami was so tender, cut a little thinner than what you expect from a Jewish deli but delicious anyway. The dressing on the ceasar salad was very light which I liked. I can't wait to come back and try more dishes on the extensive menu. I've lived in NY my whole life and this is by far the best Jewish deli I've been to. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Went for a late breakfast on a Saturday. Seated right away, but service a bit slow. Food made up for it, huge portions, everything was right, and tasted fantastic. We would go back in a second.

Reviewed on Yelp

Great food and great service

Reviewed on Facebook

The pastrami had great flavor and was so tender. The dinner specials are a great deal. $28 for a Ceasar salad, brisket with kasha varnishka and brocoli,with a drink. Everything was good especially the gravy it came with. Huge portions. and the pickles and coleslaw for the table were delicious. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

The bagels and Sandwiches are delicious.The portions are plentiful and great quality ingredients are used.

Reviewed on Facebook

I love the classic feel to the place when you walk in. The pickles & cole slaw they serve as a welcome bite are delicious. Really good matzo ball soup & chopped liver. Portions are very large. Service is quick & friendly, though the waitress always seems sad. A perfect slice of New York City! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Best turkey sandwich ever! Sliced straight of the frame! Love the complimentary coleslaw and pickles. Yummy

Reviewed on Facebook

After a visit to NYU Langone for an appointment with my Orthopedist, I was heading back to Staten Island.  I had just moved to New York about six week's ago and always wanted to go to Sarge's to compare to other great delis in New York.  Only a five minute walk from the doctor's office I went in around noon to order some take-out for dinner.  $116 later, I entered both the subway and then the Staten Island Ferry with a heavy shopping bag of some of the best pastrami and corned beef I have ever eaten.  What a treat!  The pastrami was cured perfectly and the corned beef was superb.  Add in some knishes (kasha), some great tasting cole slaw and condiments and you have one of the best tasting old fashioned deli food I have ever had.  The service was excellent and dinner was divine.  This deli is far superior to Katz's, in my opinion, and the location and the fact that it is open 24/7 is an added bonus.  Although $116 may seem outrageous for cold cuts, once you taste the quality of the food you realize it was a bargain.  If you are in the mood for some good old-fashioned Jewish deli food, you won't be disappointed. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Always at the top of my list! The food is a bit on the expensive side but the quantities are HUGE.

Reviewed on Yelp