Pizza Casbah

Pizza was good. They forgot my drink, I called them and they said sorry but they are very busy and they are only human and mistakes happen. Seems like they had that apology used often. Our chicken wings were not fully cooked. When you bit into a wing and you see red and pink meat, it is gross. I called the 2nd time to explain this. They said there is NO way they are raw That they check each wings temperature to make sure they are fully cooked. I doubt that. They kept explaining there is no way they are raw. I offered to send a pic that I took of them and they insisted it could never happen. After them putting me on Hold and muting . They offered me a refund. their pizza was good but wont be ordering from them again. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

The pizza is always good and the service is always kind and attentive.  Dine in is a little small but not bad, I prefer takeout since they have plenty parking and I can enjoy a beer while I wait.

Reviewed on Yelp

Pizza Casbah was great it was huge delivered to our room I have not tasted better pizza casbah five stars

Reviewed on Yelp

Good staff good pizza, try the spicy ranch

Reviewed on Google Maps

Kind of the whole in the wall college experience that pops out the absolute best pizza in Fort Collins. Anytime someone comes to town we bring them!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Tasty, fresh ingredients without expensive prices

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best pizza in Ft Collins!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Pretty good pizza. They have single slices which is dope

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great NY style pizza!

Reviewed on Google Maps

One of my favorite places in Fort Collins! Love their pizza and gyros. The staff is super sweet and helpful. Their menu is surprisingly packed with tasty pizza styles. If your nearby you have got to stop in. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Easily best tasting pizza in town. Only thing close to anything from New York. They’ve also got a decent gyro that goes great with a slice. Great location, always quick, and always consistent. Some decent daily deals to lookout for as well. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Largest pizza in town!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Fantastic New York style thin crust pizza. Highly recommend!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Tasty thin crust style pizza. The wings are super awesome too.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best pizza in fort Collins hands down

Reviewed on Google Maps

The pizza was great they need to keep it up! ♥️

Reviewed on Google Maps

Pizza was fine reminded me of average jersey pizza which is better than most. Soda was flat machine needs repaired that killed experience. Good flop for large slice good cheese great texture. 7.1 on one bite scale More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Traditional hot wings are DA BOMB! Really great New York style pizza. The old building has a great 80s vibe going on and the staff is a bunch of friendly pizza dudes! Thanks guys!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Love it!! One of my favorite places

Reviewed on Google Maps

I've been rockin' Pizza Casbah since 2005 - back when it was in the old location down the street that me and my buddies affectionately called "the closet". I've taken a lot of friends and family there over the years. Everyone I know loves it - my kids even request it by name. The high quality pizza and staff haven't decreased.If you are looking for a giant slice of pizza, fully customized with all the toppings you want, hot out of the oven - then wait for your name to get called, sit down, fold the slice, and enjoy.My suggested order: 1 slice with barbeque chicken1 slice with artichoke hearts, spinach, and sun dried tomatoes1 order of garlic knotsDisclaimer: I have never had delivery. Why would I? I like going in, checking out all the posters for upcoming shows, listening to the random music from the staff that day, soaking in the "hole in the wall" atmosphere, and getting it straight out of the oven. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

My daughter and Iove Pizza Casbah. We love the pizza and the atmosphere.

Reviewed on Facebook

Super tasty, huge, mouth-watering slices. Cold beers, cold sodas, music, college atmosphere. Good experience!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great selection of gourmet pizzas, terrific atmosphere. Nice neighborhood 2

Reviewed on Google Maps

Some of the best pizza I've had in Fort Collins, well actually anywhere!

Reviewed on Google Maps

This place is heaven. NY style pizza! You may not be find in NYC as well.

Reviewed on Google Maps

David was super helpful

Reviewed on Google Maps

Excellent

Reviewed on Google Maps

Nobody else comes close in Ft Collins. East coast done right

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good pizza. Real busy carry out or done in don't know if they deliver. But what pizza store doesn't. Ya New York style pizza 4 sure

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great food and awesome atmosphere! I will definitely be back

Reviewed on Google Maps

Pizza was awesome! And not busy at all on a Saturday afternoon.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Finally! A great NY style pizza place in foco. Fast and friendly service. Fun mini arcade was a hit too!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Jenna J.! I would have bought that pizza from you.  You have horrible tastes!  this is the best NY pizza in town and has been since they opened.  Don't agree?  Fine.  idgaf what you think.   Better than crazy carl's.  Love the gyros.  Also, Jenna J, I feel sorry for you if you actually do eat processed garbage from 7-11.  I'd have to go all the way to NYC to get something similar.  Maybe you have 4th grade cafeteria taste.. al good jenna but you still have horrible taste. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

It is a very good place to eat the people are nice there too we moved from Alabama to up here to Colorado

Reviewed on Google Maps

Always great.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good pizza, friendly staff.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Top 5 Pizza Joints on planet earth....

Reviewed on Google Maps

Absolutely delicious! Legit New York slices! Friendly! Fun hole-in-the-wall! Harley was an awesome employee and very helpful! Highly recommend!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Absolutely delicious! Legit New York slices! Friendly! Fun hole-in-the-wall! Harley was an awesome employee and very helpful! Highly recommend!We tried four different kinds of pizza and two types of wings with a happy-hour beer :-) More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Great New York style pizza. Great find for my daughter who is now attending CSU!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great place to eat kid friendly great staff and the pizza was amazing

Reviewed on Google Maps

Awesome New York style pizza.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Always good service, the staff are very proactive about their jobs and it shows in their work. I live in Denver, and any time I'm visit friends or family up in Fort Collins or Cheyenne I make it a point to grab a pizza on my way back home.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Favorite pizza place in town hands down nice and thin!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Quaint little place, had yummy pizza and super friendly staff.

Reviewed on Google Maps