Hopefully next time I can get more options from the menu.
Sweet cheese pierogies are amazing
They are good but a little pricey
Best restaurant Polish food I have had. Stuffed cabbage, perogi, cabbage and noodles and potato pancakes today. I live 2.5 hrs away but will be back. So happy to have found Perogi Square. More...
In my opinion one of the best polish places in the area. I've tried almost all their pierogi flavors and they have all been great. And they are always getting new ones and offer a flavor of the month or season. They also offer the classics stuffed cabbage, sausage, potato pancakes and more. Highly recommend More...
The pierogies were absolutely amazing!!! The ladies were also very helpful and accommodating. We will definitely be back!
Homemade while you wait good food . Order ahead though cooking. from scratch takes time.
Absolutely the best place for Polish food around. Just like Grandma used to make. Everything is homemade and delicious. The owners are wonderful. My family and I will be back here often. We had a big order tried a little of almost everything. My kids loved it. Thank you very much. More...
Amazing! We ordered stuffed cabbage, and a variety of perogies! The stuffed cabbage was amazing and the red sauce was to die for! My favorite perogies were the sweet cheese, loaded potato and buffalo chicken!! Even the kids enjoyed it! We will definitely be coming back for more! More...
My dad and I thought we would give this establishment a try, and I AM SO GLAD WE DID!! Pierogis have been my favorite food since I was a tot, so I consider myself a bit of a pierogi connoisseur. The taste of these perfect little polish dumplings blew me away. I'm already looking forward to the next time that we get to come back! Why go to the pierogi fest when this one goes on throughout the year! More...
My husband and I decided to visit Pierogi Square for the first time at their restaurant today. It was amazing! The staff was friendly, the place was spotless, and our food was excellent. We had leftovers and still ordered frozen pierogies for later. :) We loved it and are looking forward to our next visit! More...
Went here for the first time today and was pleasantly surprised on how good the potato and onion ones were. I have had many pierogi’s in my life but these are definitely the best I’ve had.
Everything I have tried here has been delicious!! I love how you offer traditional pierogi fillings and lots of new ones...like buffalo chicken or pizzeria...so good. Also had the grilled cheese and Polish meatballs which were totally yum! I'm so happy to have a Polish place like this so close to home. More...
This is a Must Visit place if you're ever in Crown Point... This family-owned restaurant should be talked about! The pierogies are excellent, the people who work there a friendly and helpful if you're having difficulty making a selection, and the food is made fresh. But I think my favorite is the sauce that comes with the meatballs... They could bottle that and sell it by itself!! I'm definitely going to be going back there... Soon! More...
Stopped by today for the first time. Picked up some pumpkin pie and apple pie pierogies. They were so good!!! I will definitely be back to get them again. I also picked up the jalapeno cheddar potato and the buttered cabbage ones but haven't tried them yet. Was taken care of by Ann and I have to say she was very informative and very nice person. More...
Billie Jo Gradowski-Wojtysiak
First time here and it won't be the last. Everything we ordered was delicious!
This is a must try!! We went there today for lunch and the food very fresh and everything was made to order and the flavor was awesome. we had a stuffed cabbage, polish sausage and krout, and the pierogis we got were potato onion, potato cheddar, garlic chicken, and sourkrout everything was amazing and we will be back for more. price is not bad either. More...
Olivera Lela Vasiljevic-Jensen
The apricot pierogi were delicious. Will definitely have again.
My husband and I have been wanting to try Pierogi Square for a while, but our schedules just didn't match up with their hours. Boy, was it worth the wait!
We just loved all of it! The food was so rich, filling, and just hit the spot! We tried the pierogis, Haluski, Globlaki, and meatballs with the richest sauce!
We even bought some frozen pierogis to take home.
Cannot wait to return and try even more of this delicious food! It really reminds me of a meal that you would eat with family, and tastes homemade.
If you are on the fence or want to try something new, give this place a shot--you won't regret it. More...
Ronda Jackman Hussey
I went to Pierogi Square for the first time last week, it definitely did not disappoint! We loved it!! We went back the next day for more! The Pierogi's were amazing especially the sweet cheese. They were very friendly and helpful. Enjoyed visiting with the mom and son and chatting about football while we waited for our order. Great to see a family owned business in the area! Can't wait to try other food they offer! Definitely will be back! More...
Stopped in for the first time yesterday and had a great experience! Ordered a variety of regular and vegan pierogies. Love that they have vegan options! They also offered to make any of the other flavors vegan. Prices were reasonable and the entire staff was so friendly. We felt like part of the family while there. They were even doing face painting for the kiddos! Our son loved it. Thanks for a great experience- we'll be back very soon!! More...
Had your pierogies today from the St John farmers market... seriously, the best pierogies I've ever had!! They are incredible! We can't wait to try more flavors.
Best customer service I have EVER received! Pulled up and wasn't sure if they were still on winter hours (meaning they would be closed, as it was a Monday.) The owners were outside and I asked them. They told me they were closed but to come in and they would make me a fresh batch! I told them I didn't want them to go out of their way for me, but they insisted. Invited me in and made me a great lunch! They didn't act inconvenienced for even a second. Truly some of the nicest people I have ever met. Will definitely be back! � More...
Angela Mandujano Moore
Didn’t feel like driving to Pierogi Fest so stopped by Pierogi Square. They were slammed with only one worker due to large catering order. The waitress/cook was awesome under pressure and very friendly. Although we waited for 45 min for our order, it was worth the wait. The food was phenomenal. Had a little bit of everything. Haluski was on point as was the polish (Misch’s!!!) my husband had. The owner was extremely nice and gave us free cookies for our wait and a gift certificate because I helped buss the tables...lol. Definitely be back again. More...
Great food and great service you have to go there. I’m going back again and again I can’t wait to go back with my grown boys and I know they will agree with me it was absolutely perfect I am ordering food to take home and will always go there to talk to the people that own
The best place ever!! Great friendly ppl run this place. Cheerful and happy . Food super fresh and delicious! I even dream of the perogis!
Bought some at the farmers market and made them at home. OMG! AMAZING. Best in NWI!
The only reason i gave 5 stars is because 10 wasn’t a choice! This is my second time going there and the pierogi are great and the staff/customer service (Mandy) is awesome!I will tell everyone about this place. Vegan pierogi is delicious!!! I will be back! More...
The pierogis are homemade and weree delicious. Nice variety to choose from
Best Polish Food! All made from scratch!
Marilyn Michelle Strong-Koontz
So tasty! Everyone there was super friendly, and the pierogis are top notch. I highly recommend the sauerkraut ones and the Reuben ones, as well as the pumpkin pierogis when they carry them seasonally. So, so, so good!
Excellent-will be returning for sure!
Delicious!!! Small place, great food. Definitely will come back!!
Authentic pierogi's made with a variety of awesome fillings. You can't go wrong with any of them. Sandwiches are great as well. Food is made with care. Lucky to have this place in CP!! More...
Great food! Good customer service. They also have vegan options! It's a winner!
I'm not sure why Google allows obvious negative review brigading from users that don't even leave a review with their single star rating. My experience was nothing like some of the negative reviews here either.
Anyways, we stopped here on the way home after Christmas shopping to see how they compare to all of the other pierogis we've had, and these are definitely the best. I wanted to pick up a frozen dozen but they were (understandably) backordered at the time. We didn't try the other non-pierogi menu items, so I can't speak for those yet. I'll definitely be back though. More...