Nancy's Cake Appeal
Burlington Beach, Indiana
(16)
Burlington Beach, Indiana
(16)
16 customer reviews
Deborah Watson
Nancy’s is great!! The desserts here are AWESOME! I ordered a dessert bar for my wedding, so we got a little of everything. All of my guests loved it! Needless to say, there were no leftovers. Great people to work with and very easy! She showed up the day of the wedding at the venue as scheduled and organized the dessert table beautifully. The cake was everything that I had imagined! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cheryl Galetti
Nancy was great. Explained everything and gave you many options. Many flavors for cakes and fillings.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kelsey K
Nancy’s has made my wedding cake, and cake pops for a Halloween party I held recently. Both were out of this world. Decently priced and friendly staff. She can do almost any design you can imagine. Definitely will be going back. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Suzanne Keller
I recently ordered a birthday cake for my grandson's first birthday. It was going to be a special memory making day and the cake was to be the centerpiece of many pictures.
The cake exceeded my expectations! Nancy and her assistant listened to what I was asking for. I brought along a party napkin and some photos to explain what my ideas were.
The cake was delicious, was perfect for my grandson's day and I was proud to serve it to my guests. I will be ordering from Nancy's again and highly recommend this bakery.
More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Paul Rossman
Delicious cakes and treats, plus supplies to make your own specialty cakes.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kimberly Filipas
Loved Loved Loved the cookies that Nancy did for me - with very late and very little notice. It was something very unique that I needed and she did them and had them ready for me right on time! Very friendly to work with as well and accommodating. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Miranda Smurdon
What a great place to have locally! Nancy is wonderful! Anything you want you can order, everything is fresh and homemade. Great customer service... Definitely coming back for future goodies!!!! Yumm. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
absfjab dfhdfe
FIVE OUT OF FIVE, EXCELLENT
Nancy was so incredibly friendly and kind. I ordered a Tres Leches cake and it was so delicious, it was devoured in days.
I had so many different people trying it and everyone thought it was divine. I do not order cakes often, but if for some reason I need to again, I will come here. Thank you Nancy's Cake Appeal!!
More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marsha Anton
Love Nancy's cake appeal everything I have had at Nancy's was wonderful ......I highly recommend Nancy's ...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jason Ciesielski
First time ordering a cake for my mom's birthday. It was very fresh and delicious. Customer service was warm and friendly. We will come back for sure.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jason Wilkinson
I'm from Chicago !! Amazing place !! Met Nancy !! Loved it !!
Reviewed on Google Maps
george gatewood
I am a Father of a grad student attending Valpo U. I live in Las Vegas and His birthday is this up-and-coming Saturday. I wanted to do something other than just send a card or a care package. I called quite a few bakeries in town to have a cake or some goodies delivered to him without any luck! God Bless Nancy and "Nancy's Cake Appeal"!!!! She not only said yes to delivery she didn't hesitate or ask where it would be going, as many of the other bakeries did. thanks again Nancy!!!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
jeanna jordan
Great service fairly priced wonderful product
Reviewed on Google Maps
natalie simic
I have been going to Nancy's since she opened everything I have gotten has been amazing from cakes to cookies to custom orders. The cakes are amazingly moist and very tasty. The customer service is outstanding. I would recommend Nancy's to anyone needing a cake for any occasion More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Laura Dienes
Nancy is not only sweet but her cakes are AMAZING!!! I haver order from her multiple times & each cake is better than the last, not only in flavor but techniques too! ! She is always staying up to date on the newest & latest trends in the art she creates!! I higly recommend going to Nancy's Cake Appeal from your not so everyday cupcake to your wedding cake dreams!!!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Carlton Bishop
Used them for mom's birthday cake. We did an all white cake with buttercream frosting. It was amazing! It was like eating a very high-grade wedding cake for our birthday party. Simply Delicious. Definitely recommend Them! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
