Ithaca Bakery

Ithaca Bakery

Ithaca Bakery locationIthaca, New York

(20 Reviews)
  • 50 minutes average response time
Ithaca Bakery Reviews

Ithaca Bakery Reviews


Review of Ithaca Bakery by Julie Palmer Carmalt
5 Julie Palmer Carmalt

My "go to" place for a coffee date, post-yoga breakfast run, gift basket supply run, post-paddle cup of soup, or when I'm in desperate need for a piece of something sweet (which is frequent). An Ithaca icon. Get some!

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Sherry Kline
5 Sherry Kline

Best place in Ithaca for lunch!

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Linda Whittock Tourdot
5 Linda Whittock Tourdot

Loved it!! We had been looking for Cheeky Monkey dipping sauce and you had it!! If you don't know what it is, make sure you grab a package along with a great loaf of bread while you are there!!

Review of Ithaca Bakery by John Henry
5 John Henry

Had the Medusa breakfast wrap and it was delicious! The Earl Grey tea was a good choice to pair with it. Bought a loaf of Tuscan bread to bring home.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Joe Essaf
5 Joe Essaf

Amazing! Fantastic atmosphere with lovely staff members. All down-to-earth. I had a variety of the paninis/sandwiches during my trip & loved each one! The Apple Cider was absolutely perfect for the fall weather. We will definitely return here if we come back to Ithaca.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Jenna Lee
5 Jenna Lee

By far my favorite place to get sandwiches in Ithaca! Their smoked turkey is the best I've ever had- wish I could buy it by the pound! Their soup is always amazing. And I love the fact that you can specialize your order to your own liking

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Brian Charyn
4 Brian Charyn

Inventive menu, friendly staff, but could be a bit better on portions for the price. Or, raise the price, and make sure that sandwich fills me up until dinner.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Amy Rio
5 Amy Rio

Ithaca Bakery became the unofficial caterer of the entire wedding weekend that my friends, family and I spent in Ithaca. We ate it for breakfast on our set up and wedding day. They also ended up baking our cake at the last minute which turned out perfectly and was extremely delicious. And then finally they actually catered our morning after brunch at Treman. We did a buffet of bagels, muffins, pastries, fruit, coffee and juice and everything was wonderful. They came in and set up without me even knowing so when my husband and I woke up everything was ready to go. Our more-than-slightly hungover guests were very pleased.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Christina Renee Smith
1 Christina Renee Smith

I went this morning and ordered a burrito with tofu as I am a vegan. It was the worst tasting I've ever had. Honestly an amatuer cook could have done better. They need to get some help knowing how to prepare that so it is good tasting and not like it is.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Julie Reed Swanhart
2 Julie Reed Swanhart

Have been coming here for the last two years with my kids before school. Not sure what’s going on but the last 5 or 6 visits have been terrible. Simple toasted bagels are taking 15-20 minutes to get. If we ask for anything done special it comes out wrong. Looks like it’s time to find a new spot!

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Mike Episcopo
3 Mike Episcopo

Decent sized wrap but they forgot the feta cheese and went too light on dressing so it was a bit tasteless but after waiting 20 mins I was too hungry to ask. The lemon bars, cup cake and raspberry crisp bar were really good. I would probably return again.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Cheryl Springwood
5 Cheryl Springwood

Great variety of sandwiches, soups, bakery items, salads... the list goes on. My son & I stopped for lunch on our way from Ohio to Boston and were impressed with the quality of our meals. I had a marinated portobello sandwich and he had a Dagwood-style club. We were inspired to take some bagels & cream cheese for the road. Delicious sesame bagels!

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Nicole Burnett
5 Nicole Burnett

We used Ithaca Bakery to cater our family reunion this weekend. It was fabulous! We were all traveling in from different areas of the country and it was so nice to have a delicious meal delivered and set up at Taughannock State Park for the event. They arrived on time, set everything up and were great to work with. I highly recommend them!

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Carmel Macali
5 Carmel Macali

Its hard to find good healthy food and Triphammer area it's real hard. But I took a chance and ask if they could make me a lettuce wrap I was greeted with a smile and the person behind the counter said oh yes we can do that. Thank you so much for your Great Service it was delicious. I will be back that is for sure. Maybe you could add some low Carb things to your Menu! � Thank you, Carmel Macali

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Jessica Silver
3 Jessica Silver

In fairness, I simply had a cup of coffee. Now, could coffee is hard to find, and that was good coffee so I'm writing a review, but I did not eat a thing. It has an enormous selection of food and drink options including beer, wine and hard cider. As a matter of fact, the beer and wine options were extensive, including several options on draft. I've been to sit-down restaurants that have fewer. It got a little busy and a little chaotic, but there's plenty of seating, things like sauces and marinades to bring home and I can't imagine it doesn't have something for everyone.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Dave Alan
5 Dave Alan

The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, brought my sandwich and coffee to a table outside ... when I needed a recommendation for a wine shop, they immediately had a recommendation that was "seconded" by another patron, and confirmed by visit (Red Feet Wines, which also gets 5 stars!).

The brief stop I made in Ithaca on my trip from Rochester back to NYC was made all the better for stopping at the Ithaca Bakery. Great food (the Cuban sandwich), great coffee (Caramel cozy), and a great staff.

Do yourself a favor, and stop by Ithaca Bakery.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Sheryl Vrabel
5 Sheryl Vrabel

Great food...great staff...we go EVERY time we visit the Finger Lakes...

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Michael Meggison
5 Michael Meggison

I am from Rochester New York and I am infamous for giving negative reviews to local businesses because so many of them have such poor customer service. This is the place were terrific Customer Service, terrific food, even the customers are friendly and smile at you, unlike Rochester people. Highly recommended place to eat and hang out.

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Diana Bunnell-Remillard
5 Diana Bunnell-Remillard

Friday mornings at the end of the work week are so much better with a coffee and chocolate croissant from the Triphammer location!
And the atmosphere was great with Tedeschi Trucks Band on radio in the background. Only 7 hours till the weekend! ��

Review of Ithaca Bakery by Deb Grysko
5 Deb Grysko

Super delicious food! Fantastic ingredients! You cannot go wrong having a meal at this place! We are from NJ and we’re visiting family who live in Ithaca. Staff have great personality ! 6 of us all loved our great variety of meals! Just be aware that’s us do popular you might have a time finding a seat. Sooo worth the wait !

Ithaca Bakery


Click to rate:

  • 50 minutes average response time

Find companies like this!

Whatever your requirement, Bark will help you find local companies like Ithaca Bakery.
Just post your project to Bark and we'll find the most suitable companies for you.


Check mark

Attach photos and files
See Quotes Skip
Are you sure that you want to leave?