Gotham Bagels

Great place

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great bagel shop. Can't go wrong with a super egg bagel sandwich.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great bagels and creative sandwiches. Real flavor of New York.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Food was delicious and timely. Staff was courteous and witty. McDonald's is right down the street! (Inside joke)

Reviewed on Google Maps

Handrolled bagels!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Always packed, but the staff is super friendly, and the food comes out fast. I think they close around 2pm, but great place to stop while traversing the farmers market.

Reviewed on Google Maps

The only game in town for whitefish salad

Reviewed on Google Maps

I had a blast here. The food was yummy and the environment was great!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great bagels - sandwiches and hipster drinks. Needs to be a tiny bit cleaner. Parking very limited. I recommend.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Crowded, busy, loud, delicious bagels, it's like being in New York. Bonus points for having several vegan bagels and spreads. Just go already.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Old fashioned bagle house nearby madison capitol.If you want to enjoy the diversity of cream cheese, this place would fit to you. Also very friendly staffs make guest smile. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

This is the real deal

Reviewed on Google Maps

So good!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Authentic New York style bagels. This is by far the best bagel shop in Madison! Lots of delicious sandwich options - hot and cold. It gets really busy Saturday mornings, but the wait is worth it! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Everything was mostly fantastic, but one cinnamon raisin bagel ended up with cream cheese mixed with some sort of garlic or onion. Made for a nasty surprise, but everything else was perfect! Just clean the knife between cream cheese spreads and you'll be good! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best eaten freshly made, just exquisite!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great selection of bagels. Seems to be crowded all the time. Love breakfast at this place

Reviewed on Google Maps

The best bagels and sandwiches on this Earth Nobody makes better sandwiches. Fantastic recipes and salads. Fantastic catering services

Reviewed on Google Maps

Fantastic bagel. One of the best I've had outside of NY. The olive cream cheese is great. The toppings are on both sides of the bagel, which is super great. Only downside is the line. And the orders move slow. I've never been to a slower bagel shop. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Delicious food

Reviewed on Google Maps

So delicious, the bagel with lox was super fresh and tasty.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Excellent bagels, friendly service! Highly recommend!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Not bad

Reviewed on Google Maps

Local, quick and delicious place for bagels and coffee. I had the lox with scallion cream cheese on an everything bagel and very much enjoyed it. During the transaction i felt like I was being served by an authentic American college student or at least in a college town. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great staff and sandwiches

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great bagels! Takes a little bit to get your bagel, so not great for a last minute breakfast

Reviewed on Google Maps

The best bagel Ive ever had--worth the wait.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Bagels are always fresh. They are constantly making them.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best bagels in town

Reviewed on Google Maps

Vegan cream cheese is amazing

Reviewed on Google Maps

Some of the best bagels I have had in a long time!

Reviewed on Facebook

Gotham Bagels really came thru for us this past Sunday. We live in Missouri but needed to send a Shiva Tray to the family of a dear friend in Madison. It needed to be a Lox, Bagel, Cream Cheese tray. I found Gotham Bagels, the only place online I could find that listed lox rather than smoked salmon, and could handle the size trays I had to order. They came thru including delivery on Sunday morning before the family left for the cemetery. And,a we received lovely "thank yous" from the family commenting on the quality and nice presentation of the food. Go Gotham!! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Bagel and lox and pastrami egg bagel, both were so good! ♥️ cute local spot.

Reviewed on Facebook

The bagel incarnate.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Fantastic bagels, atmosphere and service. A large diverse menu with something for everyone. The salt bagels on particular are magnificent.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Love this place!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Amazing bagels with beyond friendly staff!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Fire

Reviewed on Google Maps

Super great! They've messed up my order a couple times now but also my bad for not checking before I leave! Super delicious, so never a problem anyways.

Reviewed on Google Maps

I love this place!!! I always get the garlic bagel toasted with the tofu scallion cream cheese. In the month of May they have rainbow bagels which I ordered but didn’t receive :( they were super busy so I didn’t say anything but I hope I get one next time.

Reviewed on Google Maps

I've always passed this place with it's long lines while on my to work. I finally decided to take the plunge and see what the big fuss was about. Its true that there's one large line as well as a huge menu with some of the bagels. I got the Greek Freek and I enjoyed it. Hot lamb combined with garlic bagel I got. Holy cow. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great spot to come for breakfast. Friendly staff and fast service. We ordered the famous rainbow bagel and another specialty one. Definitely will be back when in town. Thanks More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Unpretentious, super busy little eatery close to the heartbeat of the Badger campus. Their bagel spreads are scrumptious, try the artisan Jalapeno garlic. ..a bunch of hard-working guys behind the counter that reminded me of a New York deli I once saw... More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Authentic with quick service

Reviewed on Google Maps

The only place in Madison to get real bagels. Source: Grew up in New Jersey.

Reviewed on Google Maps