Columbus, Ohio
217 customer reviews
Amy Ortegon
It is the first place we go to eat, the minute we come home to visit from Utah! They are simply the BEST!! Great pizza, and LOVE their special salad. You won't be disappointed!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Tjugganaut
Extremely juicy toppings on a fantastic, hot pizza. Friendly and fast staff complete the experience.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Robert Scott Robinson
Great place close to home. Friendly staff and pizza and salad are both exceptional. Relaxed atmosphere and a good selection of beers .
Reviewed on Facebook
Jennifer Russell
Great pizza & service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
TLMRock669 fangirl
One of my hometown favorites. Great conversation and wonderful pizza.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Janet Vanson
Garlic cheesy bread was out of this world. Loved the pizza too. Great thin crispy crust. Wasn't a fan of the area but you have to go at least once. The food is worth it.
Reviewed on Google Maps
wes campbell
great food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Betty Donahoe
Our favorite pizza. We have been going here since the 80s. Love the pizza and salads. Carry out or eat in. Separate seating area with bar. Outside patio.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dalton Snyder
We ordered a pizza from Emelio’s after having been disappointed by another local pizza place. The half cheese, half pepperoni was really great and worth every penny. The crust and pepperonis were crispy and the sauce was unique and flavorful. Well worth your money if you want to support an excellent local restaurant. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Teri Gussler
Yummy..love the special salad and pizza is pretty tasty.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Niki Lee
Best pizza around. We love it
Reviewed on Facebook
Victoria Ann Cochran
This is our third time here, I think. We love it. Nice people, great TVs, great pizza and very responsible prices!! And it’s practically at our back door!
Reviewed on Facebook
Denise Overcash.
Pizza was awesome as ever! I've come 1,000 miles to taste this pizza again.
Reviewed on Google Maps
charlee ruppel
The salad is my favorite. The dressing is phenomenal and the saltine crackers served on the side are the perfect accoutrement- we come for pizza and salad usually once a week & Dominic one of the brothers of the family takes really good care of us -as has everyone else that we've encountered- this place is a hidden gem for sure
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alyssa Griffin
The team at Emelios is truly a hidden gem in Columbus. From our initial tasting to our wedding they were there every step of the way to answer questions and provided top notch service. They came and set up the event space, helped us refine details for our big day. Their staff assisted us in every facet, creating a great atmosphere where our event could thrive. The food was delicious & they accommodated every dietary restriction we needed. I loved their attention to detail and they really helped our event shine. More...
Reviewed on WeddingWire
Nicole Marie
Great pizza, friendly environment and nice staff!
Reviewed on Facebook
Joseph Ottaviano
They've been around for 60 years. That says it all. Pizza is fantastic. I love small mom and pop places and this is tops on my list. Small attached bar to have a cold beer while you wait, or done in. Try the special salad it's delish. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Raymon Durham
Amazing food and amazing people!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ashley Blakely
Such an efficient and friendly staff. The food was delicious, especially the salad. I would definitely recommend them to a friend!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alicia Ansley
Emelio’s Catering went above & beyond for my wedding! From the linens to the table settings to the amazing appetizers & food! Highly recommend them to cater any wedding!!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Scott Cooksey
It is a fantastic place to eat. It has been there for many years. I have just been introduced to it within the last 2 years. I have eaten here three times and each time I've had the salad and pizza. The salad is really good and the pizza is not your regular cardboard flavored pizza. Great crust, sauce and plenty of cheese. lots of small pepperoni. You should eat here once because you will come back More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Netty M
Very good pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dee Snedeker
Our daughter and her fiancé selected Emelio's after a taste testing session. They made their decision based on the food selection and the friendly personnel at Emelio's.
As the mother of the bride, once the big day got closer, I had the opportunity to work directly with Abigail from Emelio's to confirm all details. Abigail was professional, flexible and kind in her dealings with us.
The night of the reception, everything was perfect. We received many compliments on how tasty the appetizers and the dinner were.
Without any hesitation I recommend this catering service. Thanks to Abigail and the entire staff for all you did!
More...
Reviewed on WeddingWire
David Stone
Good service, friendly staff, great pie ...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jack Rose
Good thin crust pizza. Pepperoni is zesty
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matthew Langstaff
Old.school and awsome!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tai Staton
Great, super tasty gluten free pizza! The best we ever had. Their special salad is to die for. Friendly and quick service. We will definitely come back!
Reviewed on Facebook
Tai Staton
On time, super clean and careful. THE best catering I have ever had. My guests were wowed, and everyone was talking about how great everything tasted. I've had catering before where some things weren't good, but with Emelio's EVERYTHING was over the top excellent. The best service and food I ever had! Highly recommended. More...
Reviewed on WeddingWire
Robert Slatzer
Great place and staff and food are always great
Reviewed on Facebook
Betty West Swetland
Best salad and pizza around. Friendly staff. Great prices and cozy atmosphere.
Reviewed on Facebook
Dakota Stewart
Great taste, great price, great service. They have a small menu of classic pizza and subs.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joyce N
This was our first time visiting Emelio's. Setting outside on the patio with the umbrella open, 77゚,with just a little bit of sun popping through the fence. Our visit was a delightful and pleasant atmosphere. Order a meat pizza and salad, and let me end here by saying YUM! P.S. the staff was friendly with smiling faces. Make a point to get here soon. . More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Billy Maynard
The same Great place For 40 years
Reviewed on Facebook
Steve
Great pizzas and salads
Reviewed on Google Maps
Donald Lohouse
Awesome pizza and good beers. Great dinner with friends.
Reviewed on Facebook
Pamela DeMatteo
The special salad with fried pepperoni, pizza, and a couple porch pops...all worth the 45 minute drive from Delaware.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Literally Yams
Easily the BEST pizza place in the state of Ohio, competent staff, reasonable prices, clean restaurant, amazing food, this is my go to place if i ever wanna take someone on a nice date, these guys know what they're doing. 6/5 stars
Reviewed on Google Maps
Chris Schneider
just your little local pizza and pub its old union pub, pizza and subs, salad's at it's best theyey have a catering service service
Reviewed on Facebook
Patricia Addis
The BEST pizza in town.....60 years in business and still killing it!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amy Reeder-Till
Best pizza in ohio
Reviewed on Google Maps
Filippo Gavagnin
Nice place
Reviewed on Google Maps
Amy Happ
Get the special salad. Trust me.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mark Morris
I thank it's the best
Reviewed on Google Maps
Doug Grayson
Very very good pizza! Will definitely be back!
Reviewed on Facebook
Roger Atkins
Great pizza friendly staff ! !
Reviewed on Google Maps
Karen Brunton
Ain't nothing like it anywhere else. Special salad is awesome and pizza's to die for. Highly recommend.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jeff
Special salad and pep pizza is the staple here. Do yourself a favor and stop in for the greatness.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michelle Fulmer
Best pizza ever
Reviewed on Google Maps
John Schnell
Great pizza and salads
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dee DeVore Hoffman
Awesome food great place to celebrate
Reviewed on Facebook