Loading...

Please wait ...

Reviews (789)

Leave a review
M

monica l.

5 September 2019

Lunch at the outside bar on a beautiful Saturday afternoon.  The food, view and service were great.  Who knew a kale salad could be so delicious, I ate every last bit!  The restaurant is beautiful and looks like it would be a great place to hold a special event.  Can't wait to return! More...

C

Caitlyn T.

5 September 2019

Exciting menu and fantastic service! It was our favorite place we ate while visiting the area. Everything was cooked perfectly and the staff were all so helpful. Only downside was the parking, but the food more than made up for it. More...

H

Hilary Moody

2 September 2019

Great views, good service and yummy food! I had a really good crab cake BLT.

M

Melanie D.

2 September 2019

Although walking in without a reservation isn't a good idea, i was happy to seat myself at the bar and created my own table! The drink selection is minimal in my opinion however the food was excellent. I had the grilled scallops on rissotto and was blown away. I then understood what the hype was about!Sure the bill was pricey but youre in the hamptons. More...

L

Luanne L.

2 September 2019

Best steak I've ever had. Great atmosphere and service. Open year round which is nice.  Bar area upstairs good for drinks and appetizers.

L

Lauren K.

31 August 2019

This place is amazing! The outdoors is so nice and they have lounge chairs to sit! They have a bar outside and it's right on the bay. I love everything about this place! The service was so good and the food was the best! I have zero complaints! If you come on a weekend, come earlier because later in the day it gets more packed. They have valet parking which is a major plus. My favorite spot! More...

S

Sophie C.

31 August 2019

Yummy food with great view! Very relaxing spot. Recommending coming a bit earlier if you are here during the weekend. We arrived about 4:30 and after 40-min wait we got an amazing bay-view table . Chill relaxed vibe no need to over dress. From the menu, the lobster roll, swordfish, and the giant cookie we pretty good! More...

T

Tricia Tom

31 August 2019

Awesome food and the view was beautiful! Our waitress was amazing and would definitely recommend Cowfish to all

J

John Savarese

29 August 2019

Great food , view and service... yesterday was a beautiful Long Island day - enjoyed the experience! �

C

Candie Hassall

29 August 2019

Great place for a nice lunch and cocktails

L

Lucy Cortese

29 August 2019

The restaurant has great food but the view is amazing. Great atmosphere.

L

Luanne Bell

29 August 2019

Excellent experience buffalo shrimp is Devine followed by walnut crusted salmon with a dijon sauce delicious

S

Sal Ferrante

28 August 2019

Great atmosphere. Great food. Highly recommend and I will definitely be going back

F

Fred R.

28 August 2019

Great location at the marina on Shinnecock Bay. The views are amazing. They were kid friendly but served very good food. Nice outdoor space to have a drink while you wait for a table. More...

B

Brandon J. Lloyd

28 August 2019

Great food. Great drinks.

C

christopher jehle

28 August 2019

Great views, food, cocktails, and service.

C

Claire Nolan Kockos

27 August 2019

delightful surroundings. Great staff. A little pricy but delicious food!

V

Vibhor Makkar

27 August 2019

Great atmosphere, great drinks, great crowd. I would have given this place 5 stars but we ended up waiting two and a half hours to be seated for dinner. Yes, this place is very busy and they do not take any reservations. First come first served.Once seated, the staff is extremely courteous and very quick and getting all of your food on the table. More...

R

Rob Resti

26 August 2019

Food and ambiance were awesome..... Melissa's service was phenomenal with excellent for recommendations from Michael....Would definitely recommend!

J

Jacob K.

25 August 2019

5 stars all the way. Let's start with the ambiance, which is why many people come here in the first place. Cowfish is set right upon the bay, with an outdoor area where you can hang at the outdoor bar and take in the surrounding water. Great way to start before being seated. The indoor restaurant is great as well, fashioned like an old school boat house, with an outdoor deck as well. Now, many places that focus on these vibes often fall short on the food. Especially when we're talking about the Hamptons, this happens all too often. But not here. The food was as good, if not better, than the ambiance. You could tell there was a team in the kitchen that was really taking pride in what they put out. We started with the spinach artichoke dip, hummus, cornbread and a couple sushi rolls. Honestly, all were amazing. One of the best spinach artichoke dips I've ever had. The cornbread was crack. The sushi rolls were fresh and delicious as well. From there, lots of touch choices for entrees. I went with the ribs which did not disappoint. They are cooked for 8 hours and they were as good as bbq ribs get in my opinion. Served with great slaw and fries. Top notch, fell off the bone. The rotisserie chicken and filet mignon were both excellent entrees too, had a bite of those as well. All in all, it was a fantastic evening. We ended up going back outside after dinner and played cornhole on the water. I would go back for the food in a heartbeat; the excellent vibes and ambiance made it that much better. Bravo!! More...

J

J E.

24 August 2019

We had a very early Sunday dinner. Mike, our waiter, was knowledgeable and helpful in guiding us to the best Cowfish had to offer. My newly turned pescatarian from vegetarian fully enjoyed the sushi and the salmon over kale. I had the scallops over risotto and it was wonderful. My date had the NOLA shrimp and he loved it. The drinks were mighty fine too (Montauk brewed suds and some signature cocktails.) And make sure to leave room for the chocolate chip cookie served in a cast iron pan, "rare", with ice cream and caramel sauce. Good for 2nd visit, an early Saturday night, and our server was Carmen. Still 5 stars! We had the Maui Wowie roll and the Surf and Turf. Oh. YES!!Then we had the trout special, the Danish baby back ribs and some more risotto and scallops. Nothing disappointed us. For dessert we resorted to a tried and true favorite, the hot chocolate cookie in a pan and the hot fudge sundae (we're talkin real whipped cream!). Pure Heaven. Thank you Carmen and Robert! This is our Go-to place in Hampton Bays! More...

L

Linda Swiatocha

23 August 2019

The food was delicious.

E

Edison Mcclure

23 August 2019

Would certainly recommend visiting this place. Fantastic ambience, delightful dishes, great customer service. Kudos.

F

Frank Clementi

23 August 2019

Very crowded little area that commonly gets gridlocked for some odd reason.

K

Kwame Rogers

23 August 2019

Yep

D

Donna Tison

23 August 2019

The crab cakes were fabulous, the staff was great and helpful with my sister using a wheelchair

T

Tony Guggino

23 August 2019

The drinks are all amazing and delicious! The Rum Punch is the go-to, along with the Berry White and both are 10/10 with great bartenders! The guac and spinach dips are both great too! More...

M

Michael Quinn

23 August 2019

Great food' Chefs are up to speed & on point!

R

Roy Pfleger

23 August 2019

Great food and atmosphere!

M

mitchell rakita

23 August 2019

No better water front views in a restaurant. 4 for dinner. Appatizers: deviled eggs with bacon, great. Maui wowi sushi, also great. 4 different entries equally good. Banana cream pie for dessert. Will absolutely be back soon. We ate outside upstairs. Best of all was the nicest professional waitress Lindsay. More...

E

Elizabeth G.

19 August 2019

A few days later since we had dinner here and I'm still drooling thinking about the seared tuna I ate and the burger is stole bites of from my boyfriend. I didn't try the shrimp or the sushi but my friends said it was unbelievable and I'll take their word. To top off the dinner, the cookie skillet was honestly incredible. I'd plan a trip back to the area just to eat here again. More...

L

luis castillo

16 August 2019

Good food great ambiance

S

Steven Steinbaum

16 August 2019

The food is excellent as is the setting.

S

Samuel Liounis

16 August 2019

Beautiful place, grounds were nice. The food was very tasty and well done for your taste.make sure you get there about early the place gets full very quickly. Wait time gets to be 30 to 45 mins. More...

E

Elise Maguire

16 August 2019

Great food . Nice staff

C

Christopher Marinus

16 August 2019

Place is amazing, as well as food and staff

K

Kay H

16 August 2019

Lovely bay views..just stopped in for quick drink..good bartenders..lovely views..nice visit

E

Elyssa G.

16 August 2019

Absolutely amazing view, service and food.I ordered the tumbleweed roll and the chicken casear salad.  My boyfriend ordered the clam chowder and the lobster roll.

S

Sam R.

13 August 2019

Great views, great service, great food! They have outdoor seating on their second floor that overlooks the water with unbeatable views. Every time I've gone every hostess, server, and manager has been incredibly friendly. And the food is super fresh and yummy. Will be going back soon! More...

C

Courtney C.

13 August 2019

so let me preface this review by saying I don't think their food is worth a 2.5 hour wait, or even an hour wait at that, but the views are!!! Their outdoor bar is the best place to have a drink, order a snack, play some cornhole, people watch and take in the view. I have been here a couple times now and had a great time at the outdoor bar both times. On this occasion we ordered the tuna poke (great and good portion!), the guac and chips (ok but overpriced, especially for how little guac they give you), the buffalo shrimp (GET THIS, favorite thing so far), and the hummus (delicious with huge chunks of garlic, yum!).For entrees, I tried the north fork salad which had great flavor but, as with most brussels sprout salads, was kind of hard to eat (you have to chew a lot to mash up the tough parts of the sprout). My husband ordered the clam chowder (just OK) and the special of the night, crab cakes, which were delicious. We also tried a sushi roll, the lighthouse, which I really expected to be fresher... Their service is pretty good and they are pretty accurate about their wait times which is good. The outdoor bar gets really crowded but the staff does a great job keeping up and we never waited for more than 5 minutes to place an order! my one tip: avoid the upstairs back room as much as possible- it's an enclosed patio that overlooks the outdoor bar/marina but you really can't see out and it has no ambiance! all the other dining areas are good though. More...

A

Arthur Meyers

9 August 2019

The service was excellent but it's hard to find

P

Pine Apple

9 August 2019

Get a homewrecker

M

Mark Norton

9 August 2019

I love this place! Awesome food with an even better view right on the canal. I recommend making a reservation if you can but you can always hang out at one of the several bars while you wait. Will definitely be back!

S

Seth Lounsbury

9 August 2019

The guacamole is amazing.

C

Cecelia McGrath

9 August 2019

Lovely place on the water. Lots of different seating choices, drinks are well made and the food was delicious. The New England clam chowder was amazing, I have had it in different places all over the east coast. The steak was grilled to perfection. We had a great time can't wait to go back. More...

L

Lisa Buckley

9 August 2019

Delicious seafood. Lobster roll is fab. North fork salad with salmon so good! Great service and very scenic restaurant/bar by the water. Great for groups and dates

B

B Reader

9 August 2019

We just go for the bar scene and the happy hour drinks and apps. Check out the shrimp app and the brussel sprouts, a great appetizer. Enjoy the view and the friendly bar help. Valet parking. Take the free boat ride to Rumba, their sister restaurant with Caribbean menu and drinks. When in Patchogue check out Rhum their latest endeavor. More...

G

Guilherme F.

9 August 2019

Awesome place, great view! Always enjoyed food every time I went there. Also perfect for afternoon drinks. Only reason for not getting 5 stars is pricing - nothing absurd though.

S

Seth Ryan

9 August 2019

Great outdoor area. Our group had a wonderful time. Suggest the guacamole.

D

Denise Raphael

8 August 2019

Love the scenery, warmth of the waitresses. Will definitely be back

R

Rick T.

5 August 2019

As good as it gets, water-front views, superb hospitality, and the food and drinks were so good. We will be back.

A

Alexandra D.

4 August 2019

Excellent staff, excellent food, excellent views!I fell in love with Cowfish over brunch and recently visited for dinner. I brought my mom who's literally always a hand full; she's got a big personality! She was ecstatic and enjoyed playful banter with the staff-- this was so rewarding you have no idea how difficult it can be to please her. 5 stars to the staff! The lighting is so crisp and bright. The rooftop has a beautiful view of the sunset. The environment is like fancy farm but relaxed. Every angle is beautiful and a photo opp! The BUFFALO SHRIMP is L I F E. My next plan is to just order one as a side for every course. The deviled eggs are so smooth and easy to eat. YUM! The ribs melt off the bone-- butter! I'm sure I could enjoy anything the chef works up.I honestly feel like they could enhance their bar with a specialty cocktail menu (I've been spoiled by Tululah's mixologists). The Run Punch is an easy sip and tip. Absolutely love this place! More...

A

Alexa O.

4 August 2019

Such a cute spot. The service was great, the food was delicious, and had a great view of the water. Our waiter on the outside deck was hysterical. He kept us laughing the entire time. I will definitely be back here again. More...

P

Patrick R.

4 August 2019

I took a friend here on a Thursday night and we ate at the outside bar. Stunning ambiance, very friendly people around you and bartenders knew the menu inside out out. Mostly feasted On the sushi which was inventive and incredibly fresh. Also had to polish off the sea fare with some good old fashioned turf and went with the Cowfish burger. Amazing on all levels. This place has it all and will be taking my family here for dinner often.... it just has a place for everyone at any age less the pretensions of Hampton dining you can get at other places. More...

N

Nicole M.

3 August 2019

I came here for the first time today for lunch. I've been wanting to check this place out for a while and finally made the time to go. Valet was quick. Beautiful outside right on the water. They have plenty of inside seating but it was a beautiful day so we sat upstairs outside . View from the table was even better. Full bar upstairs also. Our food was good we tried the cheeseburger , Rueben and a Cesar salad. Our waiter was very funny , kind and checked in with us just enough and didn't make us feel rushed at all. My friend had the rum punch and we were disappointed we didn't get that instead of wine! It was very good. Would love to try another time for dinner. I Definitely recommend for lunch and to even have a drink with a pretty view! More...

M

Michael Jon deMo

2 August 2019

Great food and fun. Beautiful, right on the water! Lots of great art and design. So relaxing

P

Peter Macaluso

2 August 2019

What a great atmosphere. Perfect place the see the sunset. Food is ok but the location knocks it out of the park. You can even take a small boat to another local restaurant across the bay. Everyone there has always been extremely friendly. A must in the summer time. More...

J

Jill F.

2 August 2019

Just updating to say 5 years later, I still love this place!Food is delicious, location is great. Staff are always friendly and efficient.

V

Virginia Tan

2 August 2019

A venue for special occasions liked my birthday a belated celebration I feel i am VIP with my boss and kids having a lunch date , the view from the top is amazingly wonderful and food is excellent and the service as well thanks I will bring my daughter and his husband soon cheers for more power

T

Tom M.

31 July 2019

Beautiful setting...great food and drinks, lively fun crowd....Rob the manager made us feel at home w everything

J

Jack Shepherd

29 July 2019

Great food

C

Caryn Russman

29 July 2019

Food is very good, as are the drinks. Service generally a bit slow. They have an outdoor bar by the water that is really nice as well.

P

Peter Kantor

29 July 2019

Real good food and atmosphere.....

G

Gabriela E.

28 July 2019

Great atmosphere and the boat to rumba was so fun! My friend loved the lobster roll and my salad was great. Would definitely come back. Drinks were strong!

S

Suzanne F.

25 July 2019

Food is excellent.  We had tuna and sword fish. Highly recommend both. Bottle of wine and coupe of side  sales.  Views are breathtaking. Service started off slow but waitress ended up being great. Highly recommend this place.  We've been here before but only for drinks. Happy with the food.  Going to hop on the pontoon boat and head across to rumba for a drink More...

K

Karen Wright

24 July 2019

The food was amazing I went to a wedding recently and had such a fantastic time in the private room above everything staff was very helpful !

H

Howard rothbein

23 July 2019

Scenery and great food

K

Ken Coenen

23 July 2019

Good meal, good drinks, great views

R

Russell Scott

23 July 2019

The views are fabulous. Not to mention the food. Our waitress Barbie was great. She couldnt give us any more attention.

R

Richard Andrews

23 July 2019

Great food and service

N

Nora F.

22 July 2019

This summer we decided to revisit the Southhampton. However, we didn't like it as much compared to the last time we were there. So, we decided to move away from it and check some of the restaurants near the Hampton Bay Area. Cowfish restaurant came up on top of the list.We called to ask about a table for two. Since it was late afternoon and early evening, the person who took the call said not a problem. After a few mins we arrived at the destination (sounds like Waze!). The parking area is big, valet parking too! While entering the restaurant, it felt like entering a nice garden with a beautiful home overlooking the water and the boats all around it. In short it means a beautiful place! We got a table by the window right away, nice! We ordered the Brussels sprouts for appetizer but this one was a bit salty. We also ordered Swordfish entree for me and and Cowfish burger for Hubby. We had a nice waitress, Allegra. She handled our needs really well. Of the two entrees, we thought that my swordfish was madd perfectly in terms of the taste and presentation. It came with corn, white beans and couscous, healthy as it can be! The burger was all right, maybe between average and above average but not more than that. The fries was kind of homemade style, not average fries. It had salt and pepper taste to it. I took a bite! Get the swordfish if you like fish!After our late lunch we took a walk outside by the water to enjoy the scenery and the boats. We miss the boat, especially during the summer. Hope everyone enjoy the restaurant as much as we did. Thanks! More...

S

Sphindile Mthembu

21 July 2019

I had an amazing experience in Cowfish From the moment we entered the restaurant we were welcomed and seated, the staff is really friendly, I must say the staff is well trained and the food was great from presentation to taste and I like that our drinks and appetizers were served immediately and I’m definitely coming back, I love the views and it’s great and accommodating for everyone even kid friendly I love it ✨

C

Chelsey F.

20 July 2019

Very pleasant experience when we stopped in this past Tuesday. Service was on point and the ambiance of the restaurant being on the water as well as the blooming hydrangeas was nice and relaxing. The item I would point out as standing out was the cornbread- best I've had. There was ample fresh corn kernels throughout and it was not dry at all which happens a lot with cornbread. The honey butter dolloped atop made it even more addicting. The Cajun fish was good and the slaw perfectly dressed- creamy and tangy. I also recommend the clam chowder. More...

J

John C.

19 July 2019

Went to Cowfish for Happy hour sat upstairs to the lounge started with a Rum punch and and a margarita we then ordered several appetizers buffalo shrimp guacamole and chips and a spinach dip the staff was friendly and prompt the drinks were full strength yet half priceHad several more drinks then took the last one outside to enjoy the boats going by in the Adirondack chairs waterside Will be com I'm ng back very soon

V

Vicki S.

19 July 2019

I love this place! I love the atmosphere, I love the view, I love the set up, and I love everything about it. The staff is great and food comes out fast. There are multiple levels of different areas to eat or drink inside and out. They have a free shuttle pontoon boat down to Rumba and back if you like a little spin before dinner and there are plenty of great outdoor waiting areas with beautiful views! The food was fantastic, I highly recommend the clam chowder! I will definitely be back again and again. More...

S

Steve Ellers

18 July 2019

Great food. Great cocktails. Great service. Great atmosphere. Great views. And a free 5 minute boat ride to a sister bar/restaurant if you want. Excellent experience.

D

Danielle J.

18 July 2019

Went during restaurant week for my birthday (April) and the menu was amazing and the food was so fresh. My boyfriend and I loved the red pepper bisque. Brought family with us again that same week, everyone loved the atmosphere and food. Went again for our anniversary in January and something was lacking in the menu and food. I definitely think this restaurant thrives in certain seasons. Wouldn't go again in the winter time for sure. The service was also better the first time but overall very kind, helpful staff. The staff was setting up for what seemed like a party for the next day (moving tables around, etc.) so that kinda ruined the atmosphere a little bit. Like I said the first time was amazing so thats why I said 4 stars, would be 5 if not for the third experience. More...

J

Jose Marmol

16 July 2019

Well what can I say. Exceptional place to go. I was there with my family with a 5 yr old and 3yr old. They have a boat at the entrance were they played after we ate. We sat down on the lawn chairs they have. Exceptional view. Food, service, experience A+ More...

M

mjv1985

16 July 2019

I have personally been to this wonderful restaurant about 10 times now. This place has plenty of room for any occasion, such as, weddings, birthdays or just a nice family outing. The seafood is very good and FRESH! There are other nice options like the bbq bacon cheeseburger with fries and it's delicious. The service is good and very friendly, but the busier it gets its wise to order a double beverage. The entrance to the restaurant is a bit tight, but when you arrive at the restaurant there is valet parking, which is very accommodating. There is an outdoor pirate ship for the kids to play on. The outdoor bar is very spacious with plenty of seating. Overall, this is the place to go on a beautiful summer day. Take care and God bless! More...

J

J.T. Doscher

16 July 2019

Delicious specials!

J

Jeffrey H.

16 July 2019

Great place and atmosphere. The boats and water is a beautiful setting

J

Josie Vargas

15 July 2019

The food is amazingly fresh and the prices are priceless ��

S

Sharon Strang Castillo

15 July 2019

The food, service and view can’t be beat!

L

La. S.

14 July 2019

Was a bit of a wait. But the view and ambiance was lovely. The drinks are very good. A little tricky to find. But worth the experience.

J

J E.

14 July 2019

We had a very early Sunday dinner. Mike, our waiter, was knowledgeable and helpful in guiding us to the best Cowfish had to offer. My newly turned pescatarian from vegetarian fully enjoyed the sushi and the salmon over kale. I had the scallops over risotto and it was wonderful. My date had the NOLA shrimp and he loved it. The drinks were mighty fine too (Montauk brewed suds and some signature cocktails.) And make sure to leave room for the chocolate chip cookie served in a cast iron pan, "rare", with ice cream and caramel sauce. Good for sharing. More...

B

Ben L.

13 July 2019

So the burger I ate here this afternoon was one of the best I've had in my life!!! The French fries were nice and crispy and the blue cheese was to die for it tasted homemade. The only thing that was too weak was my Bloody Mary it didn't taste like it had any vodka. Aside from that all was good,  nice service and amazing food. More...

V

Valerie Leigh

13 July 2019

absolutely beautiful scenery. excellent service and delicious food. you can't go wrong here!!!

K

Kaitlyn K.

12 July 2019

Their burgers are so good. Whenever I'm craving a burger this is my first stop. The cookie dessert is also great. So yummy. Ambiance is perfect for the tropical summer vibe. Right on the water and they sometimes have live music but they need more of that in the Summer!! More...

S

Sigurdur Runolfsson

12 July 2019

Not your ordinary seafood place Get ready for a spectacular experience in this waterfront restaurant. Just breathtaking and ribs to die for !

R

Regina Brennen

10 July 2019

great menu beautiful location

J

Jon Riecke

9 July 2019

Never disappointed here, even if the wait can be long! The cornbread and cookie dessert bookend any of the fish and burger entrees.

M

Michelle Papajohn

9 July 2019

Love the location! VIL program is a great perk for locals. Fave dishes for our family are Rotisserie Chicken. Filet with loaded baked potato. Blackened fish sandwich. Salads and apps are great too. Get the big cookie dessert! Yum! Recently attended my nieces bridal shower here and it was beautiful! More...

G

GREGORY ANDREA

9 July 2019

Excellent and the drinks at Rumba were some of the best I've had anywhere. Andrew and kara are great mixologists. Im alterting my crew.

A

Arthur Don Meyers

9 July 2019

the lobster roll was delicious

D

David G.

7 July 2019

The menu is nicely balanced with many seafood and "land" options available. The ribs were deliciously tender, and the tuna was generously portioned and well seasoned. I like the casual marina ambience on the Shinnecock Bay and highly recommend; I'll will be back again! More...

L

Leo Barthelmess

5 July 2019

Beautiful place and delicious food!

C

Christopher C Creel

5 July 2019

Great food, fantastic service. Beautiful views.

J

jahoomus

2 July 2019

The best Hamptons dining experience ever. Yachts trawling by, Adirondack chairs to lounge in and catchup in...and a menu that will win any award, hands down. The BEST Lobster Roll on the island. Cowfish is the Hamptons. More...

K

Kerrianne S.

30 June 2019

Absolutely stunning restaurant! I went there on a Thursday night around 6 and had to wait about 30 minutes for a table for 2. The views are incredible and make sure you get a table outside overlooking the water. It is a really relaxed atmosphere and it's very family friendly. This isn't one of those restaurants where you pay for the view. The food is also delicious and they have a nice cocktail list. We shared buffalo shrimp, Cobb salad, tuna tartare and ahi tuna and everything was amazing! Hope to return soon. More...

S

spice girl.

30 June 2019

Great food, great waterfront views, and great cocktails.

M

Matt Bernath

30 June 2019

Awesome service and BEYOND Awesome atmosphere. Food was spectacular and our waitress was spot on. I had 2sushi selections and my wife had the prime rib dinner special...amazing! Can't wait to go back for more. More...

M

Mark Alonso

30 June 2019

Great waterside location. Very family friendly. Delicious and huge lobster roll. Great burgers and fries.

L

Lawrence Levite

30 June 2019

I went there on my anniversary: on a Friday around 4 pm, Place was not busy (yet) Had the CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTS for and app and the REUBEN "LIKE NO OTHER" for an entree. Food was delicious! something you would see from the Food Network. The flavor, ingredients and portion sizes were perfect.. Would def go back! More...

P

peter wyscher

30 June 2019

Living in Austria, spending holiday on Long Island, we always love this place. Great place, friendly service and excellent food - what else one want? We'll be back, for sure.

A

Amy Halsey-Cohn

30 June 2019

Always order the special house sauce! Yummmm

W

W Olszewski

30 June 2019

Valet parking is complimentary. We had great, fall off the bone ribs and an out of sight pancake. The pancake was served in the skillet it was cooked -- it actually tasted like bread pudding. Delicious and we ate upstairs in the bar, in a comfy booth. The ice tea had a subtle peach-like after taste. The place was crowded at 1pm on Sunday. More...

N

Nancy Romano

30 June 2019

Clean and helpful staff

T

Todd Koppel

30 June 2019

Our go to place before our drive back to reality. Busy but never a long wait to get a table. North folk (Brussel sprout) salad w/ chicken is insane. Can’t imagine the work that goes making it. Food is fresh and delicious, and can’t beat the bayview. Also reasonably priced. More...

K

Kareen Jones

30 June 2019

Great food, great food and amazing views!!!

C

Christopher E

30 June 2019

Beautiful. It looks out on a boat dock. Ustairs and downstairs. HUGE bar outside. Great views on the second floor. I went for a catered wedding so I didn't try the food.

J

Jessica Sweten

30 June 2019

Five stars from start to finish. Every single person in our party of 12 was blown away. Our wonderful servers Allegra & Mike L (L for lover) went above and beyond- however, based on what I've seen it seems to be the standard at this place. Great service, great food. This place works like a well oiled machine. Highly recommended Cowfish for any occasion! More...

M

manuel polanco

30 June 2019

Great place to hang out. Food wise needs to get better.

R

Reginald J. Cordé

30 June 2019

Great service. Amazing food.

C

Charles Dinerstein

30 June 2019

Fresh food and sea air Beautiful Long island

K

Katrina Cunningham

30 June 2019

We love Cowfish. Got married there AKA Indian Cove. Celebrating our 30th wedding anniversary tonight!!

S

Sarah Jones

30 June 2019

Always our first stop on our way out to the Hamptons! Love love love!

A

Alexander Gredysa

30 June 2019

Cowfish is a fantastic restaraunt and bar situtated on the water with Marina. Great food and service would highly recommend this fine establishment.

J

JoAnna Ambrose

30 June 2019

Food is excellent

J

juan martin Peri

30 June 2019

Lovely place!!

M

Mark Lewis

30 June 2019

Great venue for outdoor dining & drinking for all ages.

K

Karen Heck Harris

29 June 2019

I had a fabulous wedding here and we love coming back every year

E

Elisabeth K.

27 June 2019

Came for lunch with my sister. We loved the mains which were amazing with lots of flavour, very impressive for a fish restaurant.But the service was below average and the chips were too terrible to finish.When we arrived at 1.40, we had to wait 20 minutes while they got our table ready. OK, so we didn't have a reservation, but the restaurant was only half full. There was no reason to make us wait at all. More...

S

Sara G.

25 June 2019

I've been to cowfish a few times now and I have absolutely nothing bad to say. The food is great (I generally get the kale salad with chicken, the guacamole appetizer and/or the french fries). The dressing on the salad is nice and light. The chicken isn't bad - I'm extremely picky about my chicken and will almost always only eat it grilled/blackened. The fries are amazing. The drinks are strong. The service is great. The views, especially during sunset, are absolutely breathtaking. I come for it all. More...

K

Kristine Milano Segreti

23 June 2019

Loved it! Delicious dinner and excellent service! Beautiful location. Staff was very friendly and attentive. Can’t wait to come back.

L

Lorraine Maloney Curry

18 June 2019

Had a lovely leisurely lunch here on this rainy Tuesday. Great food and excellent service. And the view isn’t bad either. Try the lobster roll and scallops

K

Kat L.

17 June 2019

I love coming here even though it is a bit of a drive. The wait is also VERY long for 2, it was 45 minutes for the outside. Luckily we did not mind eating inside. The food is delicious, I get something different each time because they never disappoint! The scenery is gorgeous as well :) More...

E

Eileen Mahon Gruse

17 June 2019

Wonderful happy hour with live music. Dinner menu is fabulous. Always a great crowd.

P

P. G.

12 June 2019

Four for dinner on a Saturday nite. They take reservation only for 10 or more.  Arrived around 6 told the wait was 45 minutes. Given one of those beepers. Outside bar was not very crowded as it was a foggy and windy night. Considering the fog it was still a nice view.  Naturally inside bar was jammed. After a little more than an hour we were seated. Restaurant has an open floor plan so it was a bit noisy but we not bothered by it.Can't recall waitress name but she came over in a couple minutes. Took drink order. Came back for appetizer. Clam chowder and salsa with nachos which came in about 5 minutes.  Chowder was delicious. Plenty of clams, stocky and hot. Not salty at all. Salsa is salsa ,chips were fresh.Dinner order: swordfish, ribs and 2 orders of shrimp. Maybe 15 minutes out comes food all together.  All meals were excellent. I had the swordfish which was unbelievably fresh and delicious. Everyone enjoyed their meal.Restaurant was clean. Tables are close but not overly so.  No debris on floor. Never felt rushed. Excellent service.  Met one of the partners I believe Eric. Thanked us for coming in.  He seems to be hands on which most successful restaurants need. He explained wait staff is throughly trained before they are permitted to wait on tables. It certainly appeared so. No one was standing around looking at their cell phones. Entire staff was involved in taking care of guests.  Valet parking.Great place definitely will be back.  Not a cheap meal but consider the quality of food, professional wait staff and cleanliness of the restaurant, its worth the price. Regarding the wait , there were numerous tables who sat well beyond their check so naturally this jammed things  up.  Bring your patience and enjoy the view it's worth the wait. More...

L

Laura Hale-Doyle

12 June 2019

Great atmosphere and service

L

Lorraine R.

9 June 2019

The best place in the Hamptons! Great food great people great sunsets!!!! Love it and love Eric, Gerald and all the gang!!!!!!!!!!

L

Leslie Parisi

9 June 2019

Awesome place with great views!! Fun!! Loved it!

M

Mikheil Karanadze

9 June 2019

Exceptional food and superb service

F

Feride Zoraya

6 June 2019

The food and the service is amazing!

E

Erin Johannemann

5 June 2019

Great views, great people, great food!

C

Christina Gianella Mason

3 June 2019

Beautiful view and food was delicious!

D

Dee Lamb

1 June 2019

Great atmosphere, food, beautiful views

A

A O'Neill

30 May 2019

Would not recommend for vegetarians. This place was great though for my friends that eat meat. They really enjoyed their food, especially the ribs. I also loved how the restaurant used paper straws and locally sourced hand soap in the bathroom. But for a restaurant that is already taking steps towards sustainability, I was surprised they did not have hot vegetarian or vegan options, like a veggie burger or Portobello burger. They had salad, but I was looking forward to a hot meal. And I understand this is not a vegetarian restaurant, but I was just surprised. I was told by the wait staff I could order sides so I ended up ordering 3 sides for 16 dollars: Spanish rice, mushrooms, and broccoli. The kitchen put it on a plate for me and it was fine but it wasn't the same because it wasn't necessarily curated by a chef to go together. It all tasted fine but the meat eaters definitely enjoyed their food more. Staff was nice and even though it was busy I felt like they had enough staff for the number of tables because I don't think it was a long time for food to come out at all.If my friends wanted to go there again, I would probably eat before I went and just have drink. But if you eat meat or seafood you should try it because my friends really enjoyed their food. More...

J

Jose Lugo

30 May 2019

Loved the food and the view. We had the salmon and ribs both were tasty. Service was top notch. Definitely going back.

R

Robert Carstairs

30 May 2019

crabcakes very good and excellent service.

P

Pat Cervi

30 May 2019

The food and service we're noteworthy

P

Peter Fallon

30 May 2019

Great food. !!!!

J

James Edenfield

30 May 2019

A Pricey menu that you don't mind because the atmosphere and ambiance. Chef Erick does a nice menu and they have a sushi bar that rocks! Always fresh seafood.

D

Danny Torkos

30 May 2019

Love this place, great service and fantastic food.

J

Jacqueline Vita

30 May 2019

I have dined in this spot for years. But this latest transformation called Cowfish is a win, win. The night here was packed like Oscar night at the Red Carpet. It would be an hour plus wait, so with so many people here, we opted to stay and taste the food. At first, we sat under a large tree filled with white twinkle lights and settled into our Adirondack chairs by the water. It was already after 10:00 PM and a beautiful night, so we were making the best of the wait. Our good fortune was seeing a small boat run between Cowfish and RUMBA, another restaurant. So we quickly followed the path to the dock and made an inquiry. Cowfish and RUMBA transport guests back and forth. So as we had yet another hour wait ahead, we gladly boarded for a quick sail on the Shinnecock inlet. Truly a delightful ten minutes. Our trusty captain helped all locate the planets, and on our return trip she cranked up the music, and we all sang Aquarius, Let The Sunshine In. At one point we all learned a tad too far as some got up to dance, so best to remain seated for safety reasons. Just magical and we haven't even eaten yet. I imagined a creative man could buy a single run and propose right under the stars as it was just so beautiful. We returned and were seated right away. For an appetizer, we enjoyed the Skillet Cornbread. Just out of this world. I opted for the Rotisserie Chicken and Spanish Rice. The chicken was moist and tasty. My husband opted for the pan seared Diver Scallops with Risotto. The meal was both plentiful and delicious especially the Risotto. While we had little room for dessert, we just had to try their Iron Skillet Cookie that was worthy of asking for a tall glass of milk. Talk about a treat!! So plan your next date night or celebration here especially if the boat is running — just a wonderful time. More...

V

Veronica T.

29 May 2019

We were a very large group (10 people) on the night before Memorial Day. I called the day before and they told me they didn't accept reservations and that only walk ins would have been welcome. Understandably - it was very busy and we were told there would have been a 1 hour and 45 minute wait. We decided to stick to this place because of the stunning location and got a table after an hour and a half we were there. Definitely recommended for large groups, but also couples looking for a cute romantic spot where to hang. The owner owns another bar on the lagoon and there is a BARGE! Yes, a barge! Transporting people from one bar to the other. Very charming and nice :) I'll be happy to go back! More...

A

An H.

28 May 2019

Have been wanting to come here for so long and we finally made it!!! It was really nice outside and it was crowded at 3:30pm on Saturday but only half filled inside. We opted to sit inside in exchange of no wait.Homewrecker: 5/5 refreshing cucumber flavor and not so sweet Brussel Sprouts: 4/5 I expected brussel sprouts to be crunchy but some part was really soft...just not what I expected but not too bad. I wouldn't get it again though...Scallops: 5/5 Fresh scallops with bacon risotto. so so so yum~~Seared Ahi Tuna: 4/5 The tuna was really fresh but the pineapple fried rice was saggy... the texture is more like oatmeal and not a lot of flavor to it... the side dish definitely ruined this...Carbonate Mushroom: 3/5 very very very very very salty....I can see how this can be a delicious flavorful dish if the chief didn't decide to dump the whole can of salt in here....Jumbo Buffalo Shrimp: 2/5 Imagine having buffalo wing but instead of chicken you get huge shrimp...with shells on ! not something we would order again....Fried Shrimp Kids Meal: 5/5 This is actually the best deal!! The shrimp was the same size as those jumbo buffalo shrimp and tasted SO much better!! You also get a drink and an ice cream what!!!! We should have gotten this for both of our kids~Overall it's not bad but also not as good as I expected. I still need to come back for dinner and brunch before I decide this place is a keeper or not :) More...

D

Deborah Martin

28 May 2019

A favorite for waterside dining!

M

Michael Natoli

28 May 2019

We have been going to Cowfish for many years now. Always a great place for amazing views, good food and awesome staff. Recently our friend Subi from #Latenightdetailing suggested we share a wonderful Memorial Day dinner with our family here. Very happy that we did that!

A

Al Walter

28 May 2019

Great waterfront location. Great food. Drinks and staff

B

Brenna V.

26 May 2019

Five stars from start to finish. Every single person in our party of 12 was blown away. Our wonderful servers Allegra & Mike L (L for lover) went above and beyond- however, based on what I've seen it seems to be the standard at this place. Great service, great food. This place works like a well oiled machine. Highly recommended Cowfish for any occasion! More...

F

Frances Broderick

26 May 2019

CowFish is Good... service medioka ....some people get served-on the grass while others don’t... (depends on who you talk to) ... that’s kind of annoying... they don’t serve clams on a 1/2 shell... but atmosphere is beautiful... people are friendly... can’t make reservations even though it says you could... weird!!!!! Anyway, “out of the blue” is right near by and they are AWESOME!!!! More...

K

Karin Schlee

24 May 2019

Beautiful view & great service!

D

Dani M.

14 May 2019

The Reuben is amazing!!! For mother's day we also tried the apple cider donuts- too good!!!

F

Frank F.

13 May 2019

Great service and food. I mean the views really can't hurt. Surrounded by water and nice landscaping!

C

Charlene Clark Rosante

13 May 2019

Wonderful lunch. Staff so nice. Thanks again for the thoughtful gift certificate on Mother's Day

V

Victoria M.

12 May 2019

The service is incredible! Great Mother's Day spot!(they give a gift certificate to the mothers- a great touch)The pastrami is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! My whole family ordered it! Never disappointed when we come hereAlso- Apple cider donuts for dessert is a must! More...

C

Cosmo Murabito

12 May 2019

Awesome food great service

E

Ellen P.

11 May 2019

Had another great experience at Cowfish and booking through Yelp was very easy. We had the sushi to start (such fresh fish!) and the North Fork salad is our favorites. They honored the reservation and were seated right on time! We will see you again this summer! More...

A

Alessandrea V.

9 May 2019

Went here for the first time last night. Food was great & service was very attentive! Beautiful view! Salmon was great, scallops were to die for & Hampton oysters were delicious!!!

R

Rima Makhoul

9 May 2019

Absolutely beautiful place n food is amazingly delicious, my daughter Mia is the manager there n I’m so proud of her .

C

Corin V.

6 May 2019

Such a yummy restaurant, prices are a little higher but the food is delicious so I don't mind, the waiter was very sweet and attended to my picky needs her drink just right attitude. Definitely going back, once Ive saved enough for dinner More...

M

Melissa L.

5 May 2019

WOW. HANDS DOWN THE BEST STEAK I EVER HAD IN MY LIFE!!! If you're in the area, I highly recommend you eat dinner here. The atmosphere is cute, high ceilings lots of light and wood, the outside makes for great pics as long as it's nice out. Our waitress was fantastic, the drinks were strong and the food really was fantastic. More...

T

Traci Stagnitta Fallon

5 May 2019

Amazing service. Delish food. Great drinks

J

Judy Giedra

30 April 2019

Awesome great view friendly

J

Jenny P

30 April 2019

Great location with a 4-star view of the water. Food was a success, gourmet twists added to our favorite restaurant staples. Drinks were memorable, well-crafted and worth a return visit. We appreciated the staffs hustle, doing their best at handling the influx during peak hours. Will definitely return. More...

G

George Pammer

30 April 2019

Great brunch especially off season.

M

Miriam Clifford

30 April 2019

Highly recommend this place. I had a salmon dish. Dessert are delicious. Atmosphere, young and hip. Service, extremely attentive and friendly. Also a great Summer hangout.

I

Imran Ali

30 April 2019

Good salmon special and fish burger. Thin fries, fresh coleslaw. Great hummas. Worth a try! Service was great!

M

M L.

29 April 2019

Just had a great meal here. Stopped by on the way home from east Hampton to the city off of a friend's recommendation. It happened to be restaurant week and they had a great thee course meal deal for 29.99. Very high quality ingredients. We had the tuna tartare, "north fork" Brussel salad, Chilean seabass with broccollini. Everything was cooked to perfection. The fish was moist and flavorful. The tuna tartare was a huge portion of fish! Our waiter provided us with great service ( Manager hope you are reading this). When we first got there, there was a good buzz of people having drinks and eating in the bar area upstairs for a Monday night.  I saw a promo on the bar for their happy hour from 4-6 on weekdays. I was there in the evening but it looks like there's a great view of the water and the landscaping is well done. There's a fort for kids to play in as well. Will definitely recommend to our friends and tenents. More...

V

Vivian R.

27 April 2019

Thank you Yelpers! I Made a reservation for a restaurant with an amazing view & delicious food. We didn't know we would end up with two delicious specials. The Prime Rib was so tender & perfectly cooked. Salmon was amazing with rice & red pepper sauce. The portion are a nice size for the price & it includes a delicious salad. More...

S

Siobhan M.

27 April 2019

We had a great time! Made a reservation and it was ready right away.  The food and drinks were great! Our waitress was amazing! Everything came out hot and fast and I have no complaints! The scallops were delicious! Spin and artichoke dip was ok. More...

D

Deborah Dalia Silverberg

23 April 2019

Good service. What a view

E

Ed Panama Arguello Jr

22 April 2019

As always the food was on point and service top shelf . Respect to Eric and Gerald for taking care of us as always . Love fellas !!

C

Chris M.

14 April 2019

We took a ride over to the South Fork to Cowfish after some recommendations from friends. Saturday 6pm table of 4. We were seated early for our reservation  and from start to finish everything was excellent.  Cold Tap bottled water put on table and drinks from the bar all around. The appetizers of the cornbread skillet and brussel spouts were hot and delicious. The menu is sure to please any palate.  We dined on crabcakes, coleslaw and fries scallops with rissotto and salmon on rice. The only problem we had was we left no room for dessert. It was starting to fill up and we moved to the uostairs lounge with half barrel shaped couches and great views.  We had a nice time,  all of the staff we encountered were pleasant, friendly and willing to please. We look forward to going back again soon. More...

G

George Pammer

13 April 2019

Best in the off season!

P

Patrick Conley

9 April 2019

Great atmosphere. Awesome views.

R

Rhonda Juliano

7 April 2019

Great atmosphere, delicious, family friendly

P

Patricia Doyle

4 April 2019

Great location, excellent food beautifully presented. Very pleasant staff, attentive but unobtrusive. Chose from the Restaurant Week menu which had many choices and it was hard to decide. Our party of four were all delighted with their selections. Would highly recommend . Chose the Macari Rose wine which was excellent. Thank you Cowfish fora memorable meal! More...

S

Shannon H.

3 April 2019

*East End Restaurant Week Price Fixe Menu Review- Delicious Food, Beautiful Location, Mediocre Service Cowfish is a place I've been wanting to come and try for quite some time now. I thought what a great opportunity to come during the Restaurant Week Menu and try a variety of dishes. They Offer a FREE boat ride from Cowfish to Rumba during the summer which is intriguing for me and would love to visit in a few months. In the summer they also have an outdoor bar & live music playing. Located on a beautiful part of the canal. The views were drop dead gorgeous. Easy to find as it's right on Montauk Hwy but might not be as easy to drive to. This area gets extremely crowded during the warmer months so keep in mind the traffic may be heavy at times. There wasn't any Valet while I was here (in April) but I'm assuming they do offer valet during the summer? The lot was all gravel so be careful walking in those heels. Don't get Cowfish confused with the Fish Store you'll see right as you pull in. Keep driving and follow signs to Cowfish which is located in the far back of the property. The Prices are great, especially for being located on the East End. Make your Reservations right on Yelp. Check In for a Discount! The vibe was smart casual- Some people were dressed up and some weren't but it was all very laid back which I enjoyed. The Restaurant itself had so much natural sunlight coming in and I even got to watch the sunset without leaving my seat. The restaurant was very clean and well decorated. The Service was mediocre at best which unfortunately made my overall experience bump down 1 star. Ticket times were long in the beginning and after I felt rushed throughout my meal. I don't like when the servers attempt to take away my plate while there's still food on it because they assume I'm finished. I also had to ask multiple times for drink refills which got aggravating. I felt that the Restaurant needed more servers. The Food was delicious and I will be reviewing what I tried:Unfortunately there were no bread baskets offered, no chips, NOTHING complimentary which was a huge blow. I typically like to sit and snack on some bread while I wait for my meal to come out but not here...especially if I'm spending $$$ like I did. -Corn Bread App (Not included in Restaurant Week): Definitely an acquired taste but it had my name all over it! The bread was moist, served warm with melting honey butter on top. I loved the subtle jalapeño taste in the bread. Great for sharing between 1-4 people. Would order again. 5 out of 5 stars-Lamb Sliders (Price Fixe App Serving of 2 Sliders): Loved them! The lamb was juicy and the tomato jam complimented the meat perfectly. 5 out of 5 stars-Tuna Tartare (Price Fixe App): Nice sized portion! The tuna was well marinated and had a light refreshing taste. The Guacamole mixed well with the fish. The chips were crispy and seasoned well. Great for sharing. 5 out of 5 stars-Wedge Salad ($8 Add on to Price Fixe): Nice and satisfying portion. Fresh Crunchy Lettuce with a homemade savory blue cheese dressing. Loved the Sugared Bacon crumbles on top! 5 out of 5 stars-Filet Oscar (+$10 To Price Fixe): Juicy and beautifully cooked 10oz Filet Mignon topped with Lump Crab Meat & Hollandaise Sauce. The Crab was in fact crab and not imitation which was a relief to see. The Hollandaise Sauce mixed well with not only the meat but also with the Garlic Mashed Potatoes & Seasoned Asparagus. 5 out of 5 stars-Banana Cream Pie (Price Fixe Portion which looked like half of what is regularly served): Very Decadent with a fruity flavor. I absolutely loved this dessert and thought it was the perfect portion without being overwhelming. The Pecan Crust was definitely the star of the show! 5 out of 5 starsOverall I'm glad I came to Cowfish in Hampton Bays. I had a 4 star meal which is pretty much almost perfect. Sadly I wish the service wasn't rushed and lacking. I would love to come back in a few months to ride to boat to Rumba! Thanks East End Restaurant Week for this phenomenal Price Fixed Promotion! More...

P

Paul C.

2 April 2019

Excellent food. Clam chowder is excellent. Scallops were well-cooked with unique flavor profile. Wonderful service. Great view.

A

Alexandra Stefany

31 March 2019

Brunch is great! Cocktails are fierce!

R

Randy Jackson

30 March 2019

Excellent brunch

F

Flyboard HAMPTONS

30 March 2019

Best Ruben sandwich I’ve ever had! Service and ambiance is top notch. Highly recommend!

R

Russ Lake

30 March 2019

Food was our of this world

K

Kay Mckinley

30 March 2019

Fabulous Hampton Bays rustic wharf marina ambience. Delicious Sea bass with crab sauce and brocolini entree cooked perfectly. Chocolate cake dessert for lovely birthday dinner. Recommend. More...

P

P C

30 March 2019

Excellent food, good service and a wonderfully relaxing vibe with great views. Open year round, but reservations are recommended.

S

Sean B Murray

30 March 2019

No holiday crowd or other events to contend with today, just an off-season Sunday for brunch/lunch. Six of us were seated at a perfect window corner table, and all happy with the views and more importantly the food. Lox eggs benedict was terrific, and table shares of french fries and roasted brussel sprouts in a balsamic reduction were also mighty tasty. Disappointment was the Bloody Mary. The departure from the classic included cucumber vodka which changes the taste too dramatically, especially if one is expecting the flavors that made it such a classic. But the eats were a treat for all. More...

L

Lawrence Mannino

30 March 2019

Excellent fresh food, great view, good service

M

Michael Shokry

30 March 2019

Best food and service ever

A

Alexis Rae Graf

26 March 2019

Pretty much the best Restaurant on Long Island! Our family LOVES this place. Great for kids, meeting new friends and eating delicious food. 5 stars in my book ;)

J

Jeanette Jacquin

26 March 2019

We go to Cowfish all the time! Special shout out to Rita, who not surprisingly makes the best Margaritas! Love this place!

I

Irene Novelli Pedota

24 March 2019

Love everything about it, especially the friendly staff and beautiful view!

D

Derek H Thomas

20 March 2019

Jaw Dropping Waterfront Restaurant with top quality cuisine. Dont hesitate

M

Mark G.

19 March 2019

Good food, great view. I really enjoyed coming here for a bite when I was visiting South Hampton. Get the lobster!!!! You won't be disappointed.

M

Monica D.

12 March 2019

Outstanding in every way! The food is something our family talks about fondly. Whenever we are in the area, we make a point to go.

C

Celine Ancelet

10 March 2019

Very good food, relaxed atmosphere, friendly service and fantastic view.

K

Kathy Shkinder Downey

7 March 2019

Great food and atmosphere. Gorgeous views! Most importantly the manager Derek and our server Jessica were TERRIFIC! Great people make a for a great experience! Thanks again! Bill and kathy

T

Ted Matozzo

1 March 2019

Had a great evening tasting some of Palmers best wines along with Cowfishes wonderful paired food menu

S

Stephen Palmer

28 February 2019

Great food

E

Emmett Carey

28 February 2019

Restaurant week! Food never fails! NOLA shrimp. Pleasant server. Best Blue Cheese ever!

C

Cynthia Capalbo

28 February 2019

Friendly waitstaff, cornbread was awesome. Fun time

S

Steven

28 February 2019

Came here on our motorcycle on a winter Sunday afternoon, so no reservations were necessary. This is the sister restaurant for Rhumba restaurant, so the food and menu are essentially the same. New England clam chowder was done really well, and the Caesar salad was just as good as the one I had at the Rhumba restaurant. More of a restaurant feel than the Rhumba, which is more of a bar with a table area ( and outside seating as well). Food was great, service was great and very friendly and professional. It was a great destination to go to, and we'll be back soon. More...

B

Brett Bar

28 February 2019

Great place over looks the water service was great people were very cool to talk to Food great, hummus maybe a little bland but the develed egg and the shrimp were greatWine list is greatBeer list very good , needs 1 or 2 moreBut I will be back, hopefully a lot

D

Dave Brown

28 February 2019

Never disappointed here food and drinks are great..

J

Jessica H.

25 February 2019

This place is so cute food on the water bar on the water, take a boat to the restaurant across the water or just take the boat with a drink in hand and enjoy the views

D

Daniel W.

15 February 2019

Cool place, excellent food, clean, very friendly staff... never rushed.  Cow Fish and Rumba, run by the same owners, are the best restaurants in Hampton Bays... my wife and I have lived here year round for 12 years. More...

A

Amy Carron D.

31 January 2019

One of our regular restaurants though going in the warm weather and sitting outside is far superior to the winter. Love their Brussels sprouts!

W

Winn R.

31 January 2019

Me and my family come here a lot, so it is no surprise I rate this place five stars. The property is amazing, and the food is fantastic. The staff is very nice so dont feel afraid to ask them questions. It is a good place to bring younger children because they have a pirate ship playset for them to burn of energy. So you really have to go. I can tell you that this place will forever be a favorite of mine. More...

K

Kevin Meyer

30 January 2019

If you like perfectly cooked potatoes in a variety of forms and impeccable proteins to go with them, this place is for you.

J

jamms Bolton

30 January 2019

Love the atmosphere and the service. All around great place.

J

JD Rawlins

30 January 2019

Always a wonderful experience

R

Robert Mackay

30 January 2019

People and food amazing can not wait to go back

J

Justin D.

27 January 2019

Always a pleasure. Expect to have a drink or two at the bar as a walk in customer on just about any night. For this is not a quick bite place. You will wait to be seated. Handmade drinks are solid. Tap beers are good. Dinner is always of good quality. Room to roam on the property. A boat ride is part of the fun if you choose. Service is fair. For a upscale night off the track, this might be the place for you. More...

K

Katie L.

24 January 2019

I came here with my boyfriend's family back in November, and loved it! The parking lot is kinda sketchy, especially at night, but don't be fooled- an excellent restaurant is back there! We had a reservation, but it was a busy Friday night, so we had to wait in the bar for a table. No problem- the bar area is gorgeous and there was a lady playing guitar and singing. They had a prix fixe menu for restaurant week- I had the butternut squash soup, the lamb bolognese and pumpkin cheesecake. All amazing! Everyone else at the table really enjoyed their dishes as well. I couldn't drink that night, but they have an awesome beer/wine/cocktail menu with a few good local wines. I'm really dying to go back when it's nice out so we can see how close we are to the water, and so I can see what their normal menu is like! But as far as restaurant week deals go, Cowfish was really awesome! More...

V

Vera747 ..

18 January 2019

Five stars. Never disappointed. Never had better kale salad, oh and the cornbread. Yummy.

F

felice w.

13 January 2019

I absolutely love this place. I have never eaten anything bad here and always leave satisfied. From sushi at happy hour to lunch or dinner with kids the food is amazing and the service is even better. I can't wait to try their new all you can eat brunch More...

J

Joanne Riggs

11 January 2019

Wonderful service! Great wine!

E

Erik H.

6 January 2019

Beautiful restaurant right on the bay.  Nice menu, professional service.  I wish I'd have come here sooner.

J

Jose M Vides

6 January 2019

Fantastic place, great food

C

Christina S.

2 January 2019

I've been going here for years with friends and decided to get married here as well! The service down to the event planner (Kait) was spectacular! What a beautiful place to have your special day or event. They also blew me away with the food selection for our wedding day. Highly recommend More...

K

Kerry Wilkie

30 December 2018

The buffalo shrimp is a must try!

T

Tony Lo

30 December 2018

Sweet

P

ps92swft

30 December 2018

First time going here today....I have to say...Reuben was really “like no other”. I think this was one of the best reubens I ever had! Not kidding!

C

christian minchala

30 December 2018

Fancy great food.

L

Louis De Kerillis

30 December 2018

Awesome! Food and atmosphere is always a sure thing.

M

Marc Andre Chiffert

30 December 2018

Great for company Christmas party or other corporate events.....great views, ample parking and very friendly staff....very good value....

M

McGregor Madden

30 December 2018

Had my rehearsal dinner here. Very nice people!

D

Denise Bornschein

30 December 2018

Loved the Diver Scallops and the musician upstairs was fantastic!!

T

Tara E Toolan

30 December 2018

Absolutely loved this place! The décor, the service and the food is stupendous!!!

L

Lina Patino

30 December 2018

Good food all year around , kind and friendly staff . Awesome food and wine pairing , One of our favorite restauras .❤️

J

Jessica James

30 December 2018

Good food, fair prices, gorgeous location, pleasant staff. What's not to love?

D

Dean S.

27 December 2018

The name is very fitting. They make great steaks. They make great fish. The ambience is the best. An old boat house on the canal, with a cozy attic bar up top, deck seating to take in the views, and then a seasonal outdoor bar with a great albeit limited menu. Seating can be tough in season.If you ever have a chance to do one of their wine pairing dinners off season, do it! Come hungry and thirsty, and consider a cab ride home.I think one of their chefs left and took with him one of their best dishes, the cumin encrusted mahi. I'm a tough reviewer, so there goes a star.Must haves: buffalo shrimp, prime rib (I think it's only on Wednesdays?) skillet cookie. Enjoy! More...

A

Augustine S.

15 December 2018

Amazing restaurant! The scenery is beautiful. The staff are attentive and know the items on the menu. Our server was absolutely wonderful. The food was top notch! Would recommend it to friends and relatives! More...

A

Amy E.

14 December 2018

AMAZING!  From the food to the service.  So attentive and kind.  They kept making sure we were set, pleased with everything.  This is how restaurants should be.  All should be modeled after how Cowfish does it, esp in the Hamptons.  We were impressed with how attentive everyone was.  From the hostess to the waiter to what I believe was the manager?  All were great!  A must go.  And make sure you get the scallops because YUM! More...

D

Dorothy Dean T.

10 December 2018

Love love love this place!  And I bet it's gorgeous in the summer time.  Went here for restaurant week with some friends.  Food was good.  Service was great.  People so nice and welcoming.  It's a bit loud so don't go if you're hoping to have deep conversations with anyone remotely hard of hearing. I can't wait to go back! More...

K

Kelly Pollock

9 December 2018

A hidden gem! Hands down, best Sunday brunch. The Bananas Foster French Toast is so amazing! Their burgers are also fantastic, and the service is fast and friendly!

J

John J.

8 December 2018

Just down the shore from Rumba this larger restaurant offers a more traditional dining experience with nice views of the canal being right on the water. The waits can get out of hand in the summer but there's a great outside bar and plenty of room to just hang. Also accessible by boat. Only a few docking spaces though. More...

M

Mike Casimiro

30 November 2018

Delicious food, great location on the water!

J

Jessie Conklin

30 November 2018

Delicious!

G

Gail Zwerin Katz

26 November 2018

Love the views the wait staff is wonderful the food is to die for I love the Nola shrimp and the banana cream pie heavenly

A

Alyssa V.

25 November 2018

Went here for brunch on the weekend and the food was incredible, not to mention the view of the bay. Everything we ordered was cooked to perfection and the service was great as well. Will be definitely be back and highly recommend! More...

L

Louise LD

25 November 2018

Great views and food! Fantastic night with friends.

T

Tammy Ashley

18 November 2018

Forks and Corks is a great way to enjoy fabulous food with wine pairings.

J

Jackie B.

11 November 2018

This place screams summertime and it's hidden gem located on the water surrounded by boats. I love the atmosphere and food is very well executed. Outdoor bar and lounge area is a plus and very comfortable feels like your at home. If your in the Hamptons this is the place to check out they also own Rumba right across the way and give you a free shuttle boat over to it from Cowfish it's such a fun experience highly recommended! More...

C

Caron Reilly

10 November 2018

Amazing dinner! Great food and atmosphere! ❤️

C

Connie T.

5 November 2018

Our family had an amazing meal at Cowfish restaurant. The service was great and the waitstaff was very accommodating!

B

Betsy Brennan Boyle

31 October 2018

Great food and location. Service was very good!!!

M

Mike B.

28 October 2018

On a lousy weather day when a group of us decided to hit a few wineries in Long Island, we decided we wanted seafood for lunch. We found Cowfish down in the Southampton area, and were glad we did. Most in our group had the clam chowder, which they all raved about. We also had the iron skillet cornbread, which was outstanding. I had the blackened fish sandwich, which was one of the best I have ever had......anywhere. The food was so good that a couple of the people in our group, actually went back again the next day! A definite must if you like seafood. More...

C

Chris Scholl

28 October 2018

Awesome food, Great service and views.

J

John J.

20 October 2018

This was my second trip to Cowfish and it was just as good as I remembered. Great location with a nice view, and the food is delicious. We had scallops and steak as our entrees, and were very satisfied. What really made the experience even better was the service. The staff was very polite and accommodating, which added to an already great dinner. I will defiantly be coming back in the future... Also, do yourselves a favor and get the cookie skillet for dessert. More...

K

Kristy King

19 October 2018

Great food and great atmosphere

D

Doug Cunningham

15 October 2018

Wow! This past Friday we celebrated our daughter Olivia's wedding at Cowfish. The ceremony and the reception were both held there and their event coordinator Kate Mallozzi was spectacular. The entire process was smooth as could be. Pre-planning stages were handled with ease. Advice for the big day was spot on. Kate was there with us every step of the way. Glitches were handled immediately and professionally. The food was unbelievable. Everyone loved it and there was more than enough for our 150 guests! Highly recommend this place for your wedding or special event. Going back for dinner asap! More...

D

Derek T.

14 October 2018

An awesome restaurant that deserves 6 stars. Had the fillet mignon with lobster tail and baked potato. Great lounge area and outside bar on a canal, they even have a barge that will sail you up the canal to their sibling restaurant rumba which is a Caribbean get away, drinks are strong and cold! Great experience with family, must go! More...

M

Maria Roset B.

11 October 2018

The server was really nice and so attentive. Even if we had to wait for almost an hour just to seat down( mind you this was during the summer). The food is okay prices aren't too bad. More...

R

Rob B.

10 October 2018

Can't even explain how good the food was. My buffalo chicken app was OUT IF THIS WORLD. Great happy hour selection. Best restaurant in Hampton bays!!!!! Beautiful scenery as well. Could not have picked a better restaurant to celebrate my fathers birthday. More...

S

Stephanie R.

8 October 2018

Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Possibly the best scallops I've ever had and the kale salad is fresh and delicious. Great cocktails and overall wonderful place for a date night or a group outing. More...

T

Tmm S.

30 September 2018

Great food! Great service! Great outdoor bar with Corn-Hole games outside! ... Even took a shuttle boat to their partnered Rhum Bar! Was awesome!  would definitely go back anytime More...

R

Robert Bugdin

25 September 2018

One of our favorite spots to dine with friends and family. The staff, including the hostess, bartenders, waiters and waitresses are extremely friendly and engaging. The chef is on point with his menu and the food is always over the top. 10 out of 10. More...

C

Claudia Crossett

23 September 2018

Beautiful location and amazing food! Loved our time at Cowfish! Staff were fabulous!

J

Jake S.

19 September 2018

My favorite summer time restaurant we always have a good time with friends and family.. the food is exceptional and service is fast and friendly! Love going out after dinner to the outdoor patio and have few drinks and listening to music. I recommend this place to anyone!! More...

S

Sheila Bokina Davies

16 September 2018

Most Amazing View! Our favorite place!

A

Aissa R.

13 September 2018

First time and was pleased with the whole experience. Great environment, good vibes besides being with my people, the atmosphere was pleasant and the food was on point. I would definitely recommend this place to others! More...

M

Mary Jo R.

12 September 2018

After taking the train to the Hamptons from NYC, my boyfriend and I were looking for places to eat and celebrate our anniversary. Cowfish came up on Yelp as a suggested spot, and given its high rating and reviews, I thought it was worth a shot. Plus, I love to eat anywhere on the water/with a view. When we showed up, we were blown away. Both the interior and the exterior of the restaurant are decorated beautifully. The inside is cozy and romantic, and the outside is very inviting and casual. We were also crazy about the food--we ordered the spinach and artichoke dip as an appetizer, which was absolutely to die for. I ordered the rotisserie chicken and my bf got the shrimp. Both of us scarfed up our meals and felt very satisfied. Our server was delightful, and one of the other servers offered to put our bags in storage for the meal. We finished our drinks outside, and there was a lovely engagement party taking place in the far end near the bar. Cowfish seems like a great place for a relaxing meal, or even a small party. More...

S

Sammi D.

11 September 2018

I came here with a group of friends for our final dinner while visiting the Hamptons. The service was great and fast, also quite attentive. The location was also beautiful and tucked back behind a bunch of buildings, so you wouldn't expect it! I ordered the seared ahi tuna which was amazingly cooked. However it came with fried rice which seemed to have been made with freshly cooked rice, which make it a little gluey. Besides that, everything was delicious and I'd highly recommend a visit! More...

P

Paula L.

10 September 2018

I went here yesterday on a rainy Sunday afternoon at 2:30pm with a small group of 3 total. They do not do reservations for groups under 10. We were told there would be a 25 min wait or we could order at the bar upstairs. Do we went upstairs. We all ordered the Ruben. We had clam chowder, fresh guacamole with chips and the buffalo shrimp for apps. We also had a rum drink. Everything was very good. Very solid. Excellent ingredients and execution.  The pastrami on the Ruben was succulent and delicious. The bread was delicious too. I can't wait to go back and order the sushi. I was told that they serve it Friday-Sunday starting at 4:30PM. The staff are Professional yet friendly. The atmosphere is lovely with the property being beautiful. More...

C

Christina Medina

10 September 2018

Great food, awesome view and customer service fabulous. Thank you Mike for making our first visit awesome. I will be back with more friends and family.

M

Melanie Reames

10 September 2018

We recently had our wedding at cowfish on their outside lawn. It was fabulous! Kait, who is in charge of catering, was so helpful and made the planning and the day of, a breeze. She had excellent communication, was very accommodating, and professional. My guests are still raving about the food, the service, and the beauty of the venue. I would recommend cowfish to anyone looking for a beautiful, classy, and memorable wedding venue. Kait is so easy to work with, and you can trust that she will take the lead on your special day, and make sure everything goes as planned. We were very happy with our entire wedding experience there! More...

T

Tina T.

9 September 2018

I love this place. Loved it since they first opened!  Service and food has not changed top notch ! I recommend Cowfish to all my clients who haven't been here yet. The only issue I have is valet. They always have smart ass comments and every time they move the seats, mirror and radio station ! Your parking a car, a brand new car that has back up cameras. If you need to move things then put them back to how they go and have a better demeanor or get a different job ! My visit ' s here have been less for this reason so it's disappointing. Food, ambiance and food service I give 5 stars ! More...

E

Eddy Jennifer Gonzalez Cedeno

5 September 2018

The steak and drinks are amazing and staff is friendly the veggies are amazing and my husband is not a veggie eater. I recommend this place all their food is great. #CowfishHamptonBays

A

Andrew Kaye

5 September 2018

Great view, we sat and ate at the bar outside on the water watching boats. Food was excellent and service was on point.

J

June N.

4 September 2018

I got the ahi tuna dish and it was really good. The view was also pretty during brunch as well. My friend got some steak and eggs brunch dish and the steak was cooked and seasoned well

S

Scott Felenstein

4 September 2018

Simply the best! Great food from fish to steak to ribs!

J

Jacqueline Tampori Pollina

4 September 2018

Loved the atmosphere and appetizers. The salmon was just ok. Great location

J

Joshua N.

2 September 2018

Extremely charming dockside American restaurant. No reservations for parties under 10, so the wait can be pretty long especially on weekend nights, but there's live music an a really great outdoor bar with plenty of space around to hang, drink, play games and mingle. After a day of partying and Hampton-hopping I came here with a friend for dinner to round off our day trip to Eastern Long Island. Highly recommend the Lobster Roll, it was DELICIOUS - lobster salad made with creme fraich instead of mayonnaise which made it lighter and airy but absolutely not light on knuckle and claw meat - my lobster roll had 3 claws in it! 10/10 would eat here again.Pro-tip: be prepared to pay  significant dollarage because this place ain't cheap. Seems like it would be a great place for that third or fourth date or an anniversary dinner. Also, good for college partying, bar drink prices reasonable! More...

L

LeRoy Temple

1 September 2018

We planned our date night based on a colleague's gift card. And I am so glad we did. The rumbarge ride with Capt Denise, the rum punch at Rumba and the icing on the cake was our amazing meal at Cowfish. Keep up the great work.

R

Robert Zabbia

27 August 2018

Took a side trip from the Hampton Classic with my wife for an anniversary lunch. We were shown a table right away inside instead of waiting the 30 minutes on a beautiful day. Our server was awesome, made great recommendations and was soo friendly. My wife had a margarita, which was great, and we shared stuffed mushroom and Brussel Sprout appetizers. I got the lobster roll, which was awesome and my wife got the scallops. We will definitely be back for our next trip to the area. More...

R

Robert Z.

26 August 2018

Came here for lunch after the Hampton Classic.  Service was great, the apps and lunch options were difficult to make a choice from and the Margaritas were excellent. Would definitely come back.

M

Meghan B.

26 August 2018

Great food, great service and fantastic atmosphere. We went for lunch- we waited only about 5 min and were given a comfortable table outside. We had a few appetizers and salads, my toddler had the grilled cheese-- all was delicious. Great spot for drinks as well-- definitely have to go back for dinner! More...

A

Ang M.

24 August 2018

Went at 12pm for lunch on a weekday.  Surprisingly there were a ton of people waiting to go in.  Lovely outdoor deck!  Let's talk about the lobster roll.  It's huge and pricey but damn it's all lobster claw with a little touch of mayo and a ton of tarragon and lemon.  It's legit and shouldn't be eaten without a fork.  So now let's talk about the seared tuna.  Holy tuna!  It was some of the best fresh tuna I have had.   Perfect dressing and a delicious side of rice.  I would order that dish again and again!   Service was friendly and helpful. More...

B

Bruno R.

20 August 2018

I went there for a family friends wedding anniversary and it was great! Service was really really good. Everyone was friendly and polite. The view was amazing and the food was unforgettable! Definitely worth the drive out there. I plan on going back as soon as I can. More...

P

Pete D.

19 August 2018

This place was great. Went on a crappy day but there was rain coverage everywhere so it didn't really matter. Place is lit up nicely at night. So the food was amazing. We had the Mowi Wowi roll which looked like nothing I've ever seen before. Been dying for a wedge salad and almost had to split it because when it came out my friends eyes lit up. She was like, I'm ordering that for Dinner. For Dinner, I had the ahi tuna with this orange "type" sauce which was off the charts... Place was kinda expensive but maybe it was the 3 bottles of wine we had... It faces the canal so you still have a nice breeze flowing almost all of the time. I wish I could of ordered dessert but was filled to the brim. More...

E

Ellen M.

16 August 2018

Pros:You can reserve your table on Yelp!Beautiful venue with lots of outdoor space and barPlay area for kidsWonderful to be near the marina; gives you something to look at while you're waiting for your table Extensive beverage menuCookie in a skillet - so good!Valet parkingCons:Wait time can be long, but it went by relatively quickly Swordfish and rotisserie chicken were slightly overdone More...

M

Marcia K.