Loading...

Please wait ...

C

Carnegie Catering Co LLC

Syracuse, New York

(134)
C

Carnegie Catering Co LLC

Syracuse, New York

(134)

Reviews (134)

Leave a review
K

Kathy Fiello

7 September 2019

Great food

H

Hailey Blodgett

31 August 2019

Yummy Food

T

Thomas Hayduk

22 August 2019

This is the hidden gem of Syracuse. I had to the lasagna and it was to die for. The portion size was large which made for a great lunch the next day. The meal came with salad and bread. I friend got the scallops and she loved them. The restaurant was clean and neat and nice ambiance. I highly recommend Nick & Angelo's! More...

W

Will

8 August 2019

Really feels like a nice small town place

M

Marianne F

8 August 2019

We are from out of town and called a few places to have food delivered to friends that just lost a loved one. After calling a bunch of places I remembered eating at Nick and Angelo’s in one of my visits so I called them. The girl that took my order was sweet and pleasant and confirmed my order would get to tour friends home on time. Everyone loved the food delivered and it went a long way. Thank you for your amazing food and for accommodating us with the order and delivery! More...

G

grace ann Herrick

1 August 2019

The wings are great! And Friday night music with DJ Dave is fun and upbeat!!

M

Marty Mauro

29 July 2019

Food is great and wait staff is right there to help everyone . have been there around 10 times and service and food have always been great

D

Donnie Whaley

29 July 2019

Huge servings, great staff and delicious food and drinks. Can't go wrong with this place..

J

Joe Luteran

29 July 2019

Great date night location.

M

Mike Mead

29 July 2019

Erica is a delightful waitress. Food was excellent!

M

Michael Petrilli

29 July 2019

We arrived at the restaurant around 5pm on Tuesday, 8/2/19. We were greeted by a smile and seated immediately. The waitress (Monica) was at our table within seconds to get the drink orderAlthough it is apparently listed as dress attire,we went in the spur of the moment and were both dressed in shorts and a t-shirts. We were made to feel welcome regardless. We ordered the following:Utica Greens - Escarole sautéed with prosciutto, shallots, garlic, cherry peppers with a romano bread crumb crustVeal Parmigiana - Fresh cut veal cutlets, house red sauce baked with mozzarella served with penneSicilian Scallops -Seared scallops with tomatoes, kalamata olives and shallots simmered in white wine scampi sauce topped with pepperoncini rings and served over linguini asiago over linguini .The portions were appropriately sized and they were wonderful - taste and presentation. I will make it a point to return and and to bring folks with me. Monica-thank you for an exceptional experience. You’re awesome! More...

T

Timothy McCarthy

29 July 2019

Great place. Food was great. Will be back again.

L

Linda Feola

29 July 2019

Great eggplant

K

Kalia Obey

29 June 2019

Awesome food

H

holly goods

29 June 2019

Best Italian food ever

J

James Crocker

29 April 2019

Great food great service lasanga was juicy not dry chicken parmesan was big enough to satisfy any hunger

B

Betty Donvito

29 April 2019

Food excellent, accoustics uncomfortable.

M

Mark Murray

29 April 2019

Very nice good food and service!

M

Matthew Snyder

29 March 2019

Loved this place

W

William Prindle

29 March 2019

Great

C

Cin Ellison

29 March 2019

The best

A

Adrian Wilson

29 March 2019

Food was great! However, wine selection was limited.

J

John Frost

28 February 2019

Very awesome food great customer service

P

paradise gamer

28 February 2019

The food is absolutely amazing.

C

Cheryl Ann Bilbo

28 February 2019

My family and I LOVE Nick and Angelo's. We go quite often. Great portions, great taste, great service. One thing I wish...greens and beans on the menu every day. Mediterranean chicken is my favorite!! More...

R

Randy Snyder

28 February 2019

Need a reservation...

C

Connie Tompkins

28 February 2019

It was just wonderful. Loved the atmosphere and the food was superb! Our first time there but we're going back soon!

M

Maria Depergola

28 February 2019

Had a great time. Oh and the food was great too!

M

Melanie Harvey

29 January 2019

This was a nice little gem we found out about from a friend. The staff we had, offered great reccomendations and the food seemed fresh and tastey. Im a stickler about my marinara and their recipie is great (not too sweet like other places)! We had the steamers, fried calamari, pasta pescatore, and chicken parm. Awesome! More...

M

Mary Vandran

29 January 2019

Excellent! Fine dining experience,great people place! I highly recommend it!

S

Sheri Cartner

29 January 2019

Thank you, thank you, the service and food was excellent.

K

Keith Lesh

29 January 2019

My wife and I have not had a bad experience since their opening. We like the wings and the Utica Greens, and their pizza crust is our absolute favorite. Decent beer selection, but need an amber ale, my choice would be Syracuse Pale Ale, or Bells Amber Ale, or fat tire. Bill, the owner has been in the restaurant and catering business for many, many years, and really found a sweet spot with Nick and Angelo's. Our waitress Kara, is excellent and has the best personality! We will keep returning. More...

L

Laterese Vandyke

29 January 2019

This is the best authentic Italian restaurant's I've been to in the Liverpool area. I had chicken riggies. Not to spicy it was just right. The homemade Vinaigrette was delicious. The staff made me feel like family. Nachelle showed me around the place and let me know about the events that they have there. I really had a great experience here. I highly recommend. More...

N

Nikki Lynn Vale

29 January 2019

Delicious! Family for days, left overs for another day of not cooking. We will be back and often. Just a piece of advice. they are people who have way to much free time on their hands and only can feel better about themselves while others feeling down. You don't need those people in your life or your restaurant. Positive grows positive. More...

C

Central NewYork

29 January 2019

best salad in the city hands down, an amazing wine selection too!

T

Tanya Carter

29 January 2019

The service is excellent, the food is wonderful and the portions are huge!

J

Jeremy Raymond

29 January 2019

Good food, nice people. But I waited a super long time for take out after being told to be there at a certain time. Like 45 min wait. From order to leaving was close to 90 mins.Food was awesome and this wont deter me from ordering again. I will just make sure I get a better pick up time More...

R

Reginald Powley

29 January 2019

Nice relaxing bar. Friendly staff and customers. Bartender Marissa is excellent. She is attentive, great positive attitude and makes u feel comfortable. I will b back and recommend to my family and friends. More...

M

Michael

29 January 2019

Had an amazing new years eve dinner here. The chicken riggies are amazing and the mashed potatoes are incredible. Our server Michael was awesome. Great experience!

Y

Yvon Lessard

29 January 2019

Great food, huge portions. You will not go home hungry.

D

Doan Prajna

29 January 2019

Good atmosphere pleasant staff reasonable prices and excellent food

H

Heather Andersen

29 December 2018

Server was good. Portion was large. Food was luke warm. Average priced.

J

Jason Pilato

29 December 2018

Love this place. Great food and a ton of it.

S

Sugarplum Marie

29 December 2018

Fantastic meal in a fun decor setting. Definitely plan to return.

K

Kevin Moriarty

29 December 2018

Great Italian food , parties of any size accommodated.

M

Michael Preminger

29 December 2018

Great food, friendly staff, reasonable price. Will definitely be back.

E

Elaine Crary

29 December 2018

Very quaint food was very good

M

marian nora

29 December 2018

The restaurant was very good ,food was excellent, the staff was friendly. The prices were reasonable. I really liked it there

M

Marie Martinez

29 December 2018

Friendly staff. Comfortable surroundings. The food is high quality and delicious. We have eaten there 4 times and have been highly impressed every time. Love seeing the owner coming from the kitchen with apron on....makes the experience personal. More...

S

Sean Scullion

29 December 2018

The food was good and the service even better.

S

Sharee Coon

29 December 2018

Great lunch with our oldest son.

K

Kevin Moriarty

29 December 2018

A very good Italian Restaurant at very reasonable prices ! Awesome staff , great menu options , perfect ambiance for casual dining . Very accommodating for groups of any size. One of our "go to" places ! More...

R

Richard Perkins

29 November 2018

Good food. Server was outstanding.

J

Joe M

29 November 2018

Great homemade food! From the pasta dishes, pork tenderloins and outstanding calzones. Casual atmosphere and great service.

J

Jennifer Husenitza

29 November 2018

Really excellent Italian food here - especially the chicken riggies. They always do a great job with the Haddock as well. The family style salad and bread as a starter is a welcome delivery at the beginning of the meal. Service is always pleasant and prompt. A great choice for Italian in Syracuse. More...

B

Brian Beverly

29 November 2018

Food was very good, so was staff. I love the look of the inside of the place as well.

M

Mary O'Neil

29 October 2018

Very good Italian. Nice neighborhood place.

M

Mary Eidt

29 October 2018

Excellent food at a reasonable price. Large portions, great menu.

L

Linda Sura

29 September 2018

Excellent food and service

B

Ben Johnston

29 September 2018

Very Good Authentic Italian restaurant. They Give you bread and Salad I absolutely loved the prime rib ..... Hannah was are waitress she was great too....I will be Back Try it you will love it and it was better then chain restaurant More...

J

Johnnie Who

29 September 2018

A really good place to eat. Reservations not required but sometimes there's a wait.

P

Phil Gregory

29 September 2018

My wife and my 1st visit here and we look forward to many more. We waited a little bit for our entrees but it was well worth it. The food was absolutely incredible and our server Mike was very attentive and professional. We enjoyed the atmosphere look forward to our next visit. They have a great menu with a lot of choices. We highly recommend Nick and Angelo's. More...

5

50pontiac

29 August 2018

Food delicious, service excellant.

R

Reginald Cannon

29 August 2018

Very nice, quiet and cozy dining. Friendly, upbeat staff and great menus choices. There is a full accommodation bar area that is accessible from the main dining area that can be accessed directly from the outside for those that want a little less formality with drinks and meals. The restaurant is never overcrowded though many go. I have never had to wait to get in. Reservations are not required, but if used , reserved accommodations are prompt. It is a nice place to dine alone or as a group or simply with that someone special. Very nice decor. Great wine selection. More...

M

Martha Schond

29 August 2018

Always welcome you like Family! Food is the Best in town! Sure is a Favorite stop for us!

K

Kenneth McDonald

29 August 2018

We go there for their excellent haddock dinner but I'll bet everything else is just as good dinners come with endless salad and Italian bread !

J

joy king

29 August 2018

Great place to eat &/or get a drink!

T

Terri Andrews

29 August 2018

Best Italian restaurant iv been to in years. Loved it. Definitely will be visiting again.

K

Karraie Burton

29 August 2018

Pretty good portion of Food whole family had some to bring home very well cook calamari but you could definitely fill up on the appetizers and bread

D

Dan C

29 August 2018

Good food. Fair pricing

L

Lloyd Weigel

29 August 2018

Love the food and atmosphere!!!!

P

Phyllis Henderson

29 August 2018

Wait staff friendly ,efficient. Food good tasting and good size portion. Could not give a 5 because I did not order from the bar and was not able to rate the beverage or service from it this time around.

G

Georgia Nemecek

29 August 2018

AWESOME

L

Linda Henry

29 August 2018

Picked up Stuffed Eggplant dinner which is my favorite. Very friendly staff and great food.

N

Nic La Val

29 August 2018

Love this place! Great family atmosphere, great food❤️

A

Aaron Clifford

29 August 2018

came for Easter had a huge part had 25 or more guest. food was amaaazing service was excellent had a great time

R

Richard Dannan

29 August 2018

Generous portions, great Italian...service with many smiles!!

C

Chris S

29 August 2018

Food was delicious and wait staff was pleasant and friendly.

L

Leanna Armelino

29 August 2018

Great atmosphere

R

Ric Bond

29 August 2018

This is our very favorite place .... they only use the very best of everything. ... there is not a thing on the menu that isn't great!!! Try the Margarita pizza ... wow.

A

Autumn Starr

29 August 2018

Nice Italian fare, server was super busy

J

Janet Mason

29 August 2018

I HAD A BEAUTIFUL LUNCH ON JAN 2..MEET AMAZING PEOPLE AT BAR. KATE THE BEST MIXOLOGIST. CAN'T WAIT TO RETURN IN SUMMER..

M

Marcia Wickert

29 August 2018

Good food, Jen our server was delightful.

T

Tina Williams

29 August 2018

Excellent food, great service, busy atmosphere.

S

Shaylee Allen

29 August 2018

Delicious mozzarella "sticks." They come in like a calzone shape with an amazing sauce. 10/10 recommend those. I shared a pizza with my boyfriend at the time when I visited here. It tasted delicious.

S

Scott R. Beckett

29 August 2018

Good calamari

C

Cody Harmon

29 August 2018

The environment was relaxing. The food was delicious with huge portion sizes--even the Calamari, along with a vast wine menu. I went with a Peroni, which you out can't go wrong with at an Italian place. Service was excellent too. Very quick and friendly as well as very knowledgeable about the menu. I would highly recommend, especially after receiving complimentary Limoncello at the end of the meal. More...

J

Jen Atkins

29 August 2018

Great selection

D

David Glerum

29 August 2018

Great atmosphere and very good food

T

Ticky Doyon

29 August 2018

Excellent food. Helpful, friendly, attentive staff. Lots of variety in the menu.

M

Mike Pattison

29 August 2018

Excellent good. $ Value for portion. Nice atmosphere. Great service. Menu variety... pizza/wings to full entrees. Burger to seafood dish.

R

Ross Nicholson

29 August 2018

Food was great

T

Terri Muller Castagna

29 August 2018

Super food.monica our fantastic waitress. Had 8 people and all of our food amazing! Check it out!

C

cindy harrington

29 August 2018

First time.Great food and atmosphere!

R

Ronald Casselman

29 August 2018

Great food

A

Ariol Bonasse

29 August 2018

I really enjoyed the pork and bourbon sauce, it was delicious. Also,my waitress Hannah was very nice.

R

Roger Caiazza

29 August 2018

Very good

L

Lilith Masters

29 August 2018

Amazing service, from the time we walked in the door till the time we left. Everyone friendly and welcoming. Even stopping on a very busy night to take pictures for us. The food was perfect. All in all the perfect evening. Thank you we will be back. More...

T

Tiffany Rodriguez

29 August 2018

First time trying this place. Excellent wings and the pizza was good just needed to be cooked a little longer (we took it to go). I would definitely go back and eat there again but I would tell them about the pizza mishap. More...

P

Patti Damon

29 August 2018

Our first visit. The escargot and steamers were wonderful. The salad and bread were so good. Should have stopped there. So much great food left little room for the main courses! My husband relished his seared scallops. My neighbor enjoyed her pasta and sausage. She thought the meatball was just okay. I sent my sampler back because it wasn't even close to hot. When it came back, the ravioli was so good. The chicken parm was too dry. The meatball was just okay ... and the sausage was better than okay. I didn't care for the sauce .. But I grew up with some incredible Italian cooks in my neighborhood... In the 50's. I learned to make sauce with them, and I also learned that less sauce is more. Would we go back. YES we would. But we would limit our dinner to apps, salad and bread. That combo was a meal in itself. More...

R

Russ Pilato

29 August 2018

Good meal, good service.

R

Richard Perkins

29 August 2018

Always had a good meal there.

S

steve henderson

29 August 2018

A little pricey, but very good food and atmosphere

D

Donna Gibbs

29 August 2018

Atmosphere was very nice server very pleasant and food very good!Dessert was home made and very good. I would recommend this place to go,but sort of pricee

V

Vinny Roosa

29 August 2018

Best food in Liverpool, and my waitress not only was so nice but it's like she knew me cu she was on point with everything she suggested. I highly recommend going here.

S

Sue Neyland

29 August 2018

Great choice if you're just passing through, food was tasty and service good.

M

Mary Syrko

29 August 2018

Very good place to eat. Very relaxing

B

Barry Nicholas

29 August 2018

I enjoyed it, good food, good service

K

Kathleen Rushmore

29 August 2018

Cant help wondering why staffing is such a problem there, but otherwise the food is really good, and sometimes the bar is a lot of fun. Ample parking, conveniently located, just a few miles from Destiny Mall, worth the drive for sure. They also do catering for Carnegie Deli from this location as well, so if you want a house party catered, I've seen first hand what a nice job they do with that as well. More...

J

Jon Worthen

29 August 2018

Good eats and service!

B

Bob Belvick

29 August 2018

A little slow service but the food was great. They had fresh haddock for a special and they made me a haddock parm on request. My fiancee doesn't eat meat or cheese and they made her a special pizza that she loved! Service was great! More...

N

Nolan Wiginton

29 August 2018

Food is amazing. Waiter was great. Overall environment is extremely nice.

R

Robb Allison

29 August 2018

Thanks Phil...nice birthday party for the Wife..great food and service..

D

Dr Walsh

29 August 2018

Phenomenal food and a wonderful atmosphere!

T

Thomas Kenealy

29 August 2017

Nice

J

John Wills

29 August 2017

I am from outta town and an over the road trucker. I parked around the block with my rig, (no parking anywhere else), and walked towards this Italian restaurant I see on Google maps. I see there is a grocery store across the street that closes before them. So I go there first. Walk across the street, with my stuff, and check this place out. Very friendly greeter. Sorry, didn't catch her name. She lets me put my things right by the front desk. Sees that I am a weary traveler and says, "Just sit down, relax and enjoy!" I order the sampler plate. Great choice! I get, probably, the best, Pure Italian house salad, I have ever had. Plus the bread tasted like it was fresh. Home made garlic butter soft spread. This was just the salad people! I was thinking, what's the real food like? She brings me out the sampler plate. It's got a huge meatball, chicken parmesan, huge ravioli and baked ziti, all covered in cheese and some of the best marinara sauce I have ever had. I neglected to mention, there is a bar attached, so you can have your choice of drinks. I chose not to as I am a driver by trade. No drinking and driving for this guy. I got done eating and drinking some great unsweetened tea. She offers me four different home made desserts. I had to decline as I was stuffed. It all sounded delicious though. Highly recommend Nick and Angelo's to anyone. More...

N

Neal Tubbs

29 August 2017

Excellent food and service.

L

lynn prince

29 August 2017

Delish

J

Joshua M. Gallagher

29 August 2017

2017 Update - Have had at least 20 great lunches and always great service at the bar. Really seems like my one experience below was just a fluke. Before the name change (or new owners) I visited this location and had a terrible experience, even had a bug in my ice. No apology and then the waitress replaced my drink with another cup full of ice (smart move would be to avoid the ice right?)That might have been a completely different set of management and staff though - so I gave it a second chance. Ordered a whole pizza and an appetizer here ... took forever, service was awful, took 10 minutes to get seated although the restaurant wasn't busy. A Pizza that takes 8-10 minutes to cook took 25 to make it to my table. Waitress didnt stop by for refills. Ended up having to get the whole thing wrapped and leave by the time it arrived. I could have just got a new or lazy waitress.They have a bar side. I think the bartender their is great and you can get a quick tasty lunch on most days.I will try again on the restaurant side one day and modify this if that event turns out to have been a fluke. But the servers, hostess, management all failed hard that day.2017 Update - Have had at least 20 great lunches and always great service at the bar. Really seems like my one experience was just a fluke. More...

T

Timothy Seubert

29 August 2017

Great food

C

Chuck Fortino

29 August 2017

Excellent food very pleasant service

M

Merve Wilson

29 August 2017

I have never written a review on a restaurant. But last night I went for the first time. I only remember it from it being Pier 57 prior (not a fan). Anyways I thought the food was good, reasonably priced and good service. It seemed to be more of a higher quality Italian place, and a nice break from the usual's in the city or other side of town. My only critique is that the physical menus are so big they almost take up the full width of the table. I measured :). Not a big deal but comical. I hope the business continues to do well. More...

B

Brenna H

29 August 2017

Absolutely loved it!! Sit by the fire though or bring a hat and warm coat. It's freezing.

G

Gail Brenkus

29 August 2017

We had our Christmas party here and it was delicious

B

Brian Liebelt

29 August 2017

Great restaurant. Some of the best Italian food in the area!

W

William Renihan

29 August 2017

A few beers at the bar with the misses. Friendly chatter with the regulars. After 20 minutes on a busy Friday, we were seated.Shared salad, almost like Olive Garden. Decent, little too much dressing.Misses ordered the filet, I got the chicken marsala with the ithaca flower power draft. WOW. Got the mashed potatoes with it (not sure why I didn't get pasta), but it was awesome. The beer challenged the dinner, but the dinner took the cake and I ended up winning. Fantastic!! BTW, the wife loved her steak!! More...

D

Dan DuFour

29 August 2017

Food was soooo good. Service was even better. Monica was an excellent waitress. Very pleasant and attentive.

K

Kathryn Palladino

29 August 2016

We shared the best Utica Greens dish I have ever tasted and an excellent Pizza. The service was excellent and attentative! I would highly recommend this resturant. More...

C

Crystal Rivizzigno

29 August 2016

My fiancé and I went here for dinner on Saturday to celebrate our anniversary. The food was excellent, from the salad to the carrot cake! I loved the salad that came with our dinner, not your normal lettuce, tomatoes and onions. This salad had everything, olives, chick peas, golden raisins, and their house all mixed with their house dressing which was also yummy! It was the best dinner salad I have ever had. I had seared scallop scampi. The scallops were cooked perfectly and were huge! And the carrot cake was very moist and yummy! We will definitely be going back. More...

J

Jason Kazmirski

29 August 2016

Everything here is fresh and done to order daily. Hope everyone enjoys there experience here and spreads the word. CHEF JPkazmirski

D

David Walker

29 August 2016

First time eating there OMG best food ever....

A

Adam Johns

29 August 2016

We enjoyed our dinner very much. We were a party of 4 on a very busy Friday night. A waiting line out the door. Thankfully my friend had made reservations. The two young girls at the door told us they were running a little behind and I began to worry. Has I overheard them tell the party ahead of us it would be and hour wait. They sent us to the bar saying they would come find them as soon as our table was ready. We went to the very busy bar, got a drink and there she was coming to get us that our table was indeed ready. We were greeted and our water glasses filled (later who we found out was the manager) asked if we were set from the bar, we were but starving, do we asked to put an appetizer in, she did and saiid our server would be right with us. A few moments later we were greeted by our server who introduced herself (can't remember her name) she told us the specials and asked if we needed more time, we did. She came back just s bit later with our appetizers and we ordered. She was very helpful in helping us choose from the huge menu. We then had amazing salad. Chickpeas, Olives, tomatoes, raisins and more all with their own house Italian. With impeccable timing out entrees were delivered next. Truly breathtaking. They were all delicious and one better than the other. The girl who put in our appetizers came back to check on us. We told her how much we loved everything. She reccomeded we save room for dessert as her mom made them. We did and melt in mouth desserts they were. All topped off with decaf.. Yes I said decaf espresso. It was an amazing dinner. Food could not have been better. The service was the perfect combination of attentiveness and privacy. The next time we go we will be going with another couple and reserving their family room that looks just perfect. If I have to be critical on one thing I would say that reservations are a must. We really did not care not the bar crowd, but as I said we were not there long. If we had to wait in there for an hour or more as we noticed some did. So they didn't mind them. Not to sure we would have waited. Love love highly reccomed! More...

C

Charles Baker

29 August 2016

Very good food I love the bread we got here on Sat night was packed and still they got us a seat in 5 min thank you for the right tasting and enjoyable food

D

Diane Noffey

29 August 2016

Our first visit was a delicious experience. The food was served hot and tasty. Our server, Monica, was both attentive and friendly. We left with a full belly and a pledge to return. The dessert was the perfect ending. We will surely spread the word! More...