Loading...

Please wait ...

Buttermilk Bakeshop logo
B

Buttermilk Bakeshop

New York City, New York

(24)
Buttermilk Bakeshop logo
B

Buttermilk Bakeshop

New York City, New York

(24)

Reviews (24)

Leave a review
A
20 May 2019

Loved this place from the first taste. Nothing but great experiences here. Prices were good for how much you get. This place has positive reviews for a reason.

B
18 May 2019

This made the best cake for sons birthday 10/10 would come a again

L
25 April 2019

Popular and rightfully so. Good quality ingredients, friendly, patient, helpful staff. Delicious!

J
25 April 2019

Oh my! You can smell the magnificence of this bakery floating out onto the street and it's like a dream. This is actually a bakery and not a shop with dessert delivered from a factory, aside from a small section in the front for ordering, the rest of Buttermilk is bakers making magic behind the counter. The Whoopi Pie is the best I have ever had. The flavor and texture of the cake itself is almost indescribable, rich in a way all cakes should be and fluffy as a cloud. And do not be scared by the vegan, gluten free, crispy peanut butter bars, they don't taste free of anything, it's pure indulgence. And the chocolate chip cookie, again, a cookie ascending to greatest not known before --no run of the mill anything here. Oh, the croissants must be tried, fluffy, dense, yeasty delights. More...

K
25 April 2019

One of my favorite bakeries. So good!

D
26 March 2019

First time I smelt the deliciousness from the restaurant next door and had to go in. Their cookies are delicious. My favorites are the peanut butter and harvest cookies. Second time I was having a house warming party and ordered a cake. Their Black and White cake was to die for. 3 layers of Vanilla and Cholocate heaven. Everyone at my party loved it.. I had to hide a slice for mysfelf for the next day. Friendly service and delicious treats. I do not it live in Park Slope but this place is worth the trip!Debbie More...

J
26 March 2019

Cake was yummy I would recommend this place any day. Bakers are very talented.

K
24 February 2019

This is the best tasting vegan cake place ever they did my daughter 1st birthday cake and it was the best I got a small smash chocolate on chocolate cake then I got cup cakes that was made into a princess dress everything was so moist to the point that it was maybe almost a week later and the cake was still moist and I've never had a cake that tastes so good in my life and it was vegan

F
24 February 2019

DeELICIOUS CAKES!
THEY CAN USE A BIT MORE FILLING IN BETWEEN THE TWO LAYERS, BUT ALL AND ALL THE CAKE TASTES GOOD.

P
24 February 2019

These cakes are so good. You need to try it! The people were so nice.

T
5 July 2018

How many ways can you say GREAT.

N
13 June 2018

Cookies are delicious but their customer services is none existing. I felt like I was a huge bother when I placed my order each of the two times I went there. I won't make go out of way to go back. May stop by if I am in the area. More...

N
13 May 2018

Their Salted Nutella and Bananarama cookies are scrumptious! Plenty of gluten-free and vegan options. Everything in the shop looks amazing!

A
6 May 2018

Words can't express how great the cake for our co-ed baby shower was!! It was totally AMAZING! EVERYONE raved about the cake! ! It was the hit of the party!! Not only did it look SENSATIONAL but it tasted AWESOME, too...DELICOUS; very moist cake layers (Funfetti) and the chocolate filling "rocked!" The chocolate filling between the Funfetti cake layers as well as the white buttercream icing that was on the top and sides of the cake were perfect; not too sweet and just the right consistency.

I greatly appreciate the time Katie took to discuss the details of the cake (decorations and flavors) and it came out even better than I had imagined it would look and taste! In addition, I had asked that the cake be delivered by Buttermilk at a particular time and it was at the venue, as promised, when I arrived. I highly recommend the custom cakes Katie and her staff create at Buttermilk Bake Shop!
More...

M
29 April 2018

They made a beautiful (and delicious) cake for my daughters birthday!

H
10 December 2017

Ordered a cake for my daughter's birthday. Very easy to work with, extremely affordable, and DELICIOUS.

W
2 December 2017

This cute little bakeshop has a wonderful assortment of sweet pastries with a few savory croissants thrown in the mix. The staff is friendly and if you can grab one of the four seats, the people watching is prime.

O
8 October 2017

I have not had the pleasure of having their pies, but their pastries are definitely tasty.

A
23 August 2017

Buttermilk pie 10/10. Other stuff, less so (but still by no means terrible). Also, limited seating, so don't make a trip of it.

A
23 July 2017

The baked goods here are great. We went in to taste some of their cupcakes and plan to get our wedding cake from them.

R
17 July 2017

I had a Buttermilk vanilla cupcake with vanilla frosting yesterday at a friends birthday party and it tasted like a million vanilla bombs went off in my mouth and gave me a cupcakegasm. (Also, as a kid I mixed baking vanilla with sugar and ate it by the spoonful when my Mom wasn't looking so i'm bias.) That is all. More...

J
13 July 2017

Great breads and fits the budget. This is my favorite place to be when it comes to baked goodies and pastries. I will highly recommend.

D
10 May 2017

Great experience with my son with your baking classes. I highly recommend.

J
9 March 2017

Fantastic woman-owned small business. I bought a strawberry lemon meringue pie for a birthday party, and it was a huge hit. It was equally beautiful and delicious. Can't wait to go back. More...

Photos (10)

See all