Please wait ...

Brothers Pizza on rt.33 logo

Brothers Pizza on rt.33

Mercerville-Hamilton Square, New Jersey

Brothers Pizza on rt.33 logo

Brothers Pizza on rt.33

Mercerville-Hamilton Square, New Jersey


Reviews (20)

Leave a review

Lisa Cairo

Personalized family run business that provides quality service and a wide array of delicious menu items at reasonable prices.


Kim Carroll

Recently diagnosed with a wheat and dairy allergy and thought I'd never be able to eat pizza again. But got a gluten free tomato pie. Brothers are really good with the cooking process (i.e. keeping gluten free completely separate) and they even give you your own pizza cutter.
And most importantly it tasted absolutely delicious.


Hal English

30 years of watching this beautiful family grow into a generational restaurant that never fails to disappoint! Great pizza, dinners and staff! Love that they keep experimenting and adding new dishes to the menu to please their customers. More...


Justine Mazzilli Doan

Great food. Great company. Always feels like home. �


Pete Lieggi

The first time I entered Brothers Pizza was February 1979 after a party in Ewing,
which was pelted with beer bottles lol! The pizza is the same as it was. It's called consistency and I can tell you this they rival the other three big name pizza makers in the Hamilton Area! The staff is very friendly and the young girl did not have to bring me my single pie slice, but she did and she deserved the tip she got! A lot of people don't understand the business and the server has the most difficult job. These girls are and the outside dining layout is outstanding! More...


Celeste Lucci Daily

We love Brothers Pizza!!! Great pizza...great service and some special memories have been made there!!


Susan Faye Schindler

Vegan cheese wins me over every time. Thank you for including the folks who #DitchDairy. Spreading the word.
#NJVeg #BurlCoVeg #VSSJ #PBMVeg


Gregg Wexler

Brothers has the best Vegan Pizza in NJ. Get in there and try it.


Joyce DiBenedetti

The food (pizza, pasta, salad, rolls) was all delicious. We sat outside on their back terrace on a beautiful, sunny day. I loved it!


Lisa Nicole

Clean restaurant, friendly and attentive staff, and we love their dairy-free pies!!!! Will always order our pizza from here!!


Monica Kurutz Kosinar

Been going to Brother's since they opened. Thumbs up! I live out of town now, so when I viisit family or friends, I stop in.
Highly recommend their clams appetizer, spinach and arugula (sp?) salad and Fri diablo.


Danielle Nicole Holman

Just had the vegan pizza and even my non vegan husband loved it!! Thanks so much for adding this option!!!! We � Brothers!!!


Nancy J Taylor

Always can depend on Brother's on 33 when we are going to have a house full and lack the energy to make homemade. This is the closest thing!
Chicken Florentine, we tried this time, with all our regulars, was a big hit. Pasquale was very attentive to all our requests, as usual.
Of course when we go to the restsurant, it is always great too. A pleasant casual family kind of place.


Joe Dunn

Brother's has been the landmark pizza in Hamilton for decades! Why? The food and service have been wonderful through the years. I am very happy to see that the younger family members are following in the footsteps of their parents. They will keep the great tradition going for another 45 years. Thank you Brother's Pizza! Joe Dunn More...


Mel Adenosine

Went there for the first time today and ordered the fig pizza which was excellent.

Oh and...

*Have vegan cheese :) Ask to speak to Pasquale if you have any questions!

*have outdoor seating :)


Michelle Sutton

Really great pizza and a fun place for the whole family! This place is a great recommendation for the whole family to enjoy <3


Cody Obropta

Brother's Pizza is one of the many fantastic pizzerias in the Hamilton area. There is ample seating available and the staff is very polite and helpful. I was happy to find such a large assortment of slices to choose from behind the counter. This is a big plus in my book.

I ended up going with a plain slice and a tomato pie slice. Both slices featured crispy crust and base. The plain had stretchy cheese and a pleasant saltiness with a delicious sauce. The tomato slice also benefited from a rich, flavorful sauce with plenty of spices and a pleasant onion / olive oil taste. The crust and base on the tomato slice were exceptionally tasty.

Overall, this is a great spot to try and I would definitely recommend it.


Jayna Brown

The catering, superb service, and great food was thoroughly appreciated by Girl Scout Troop 70335 tonight! The delivery service to our meeting place, portion sizes, setup and interaction by Anthony with the girls as they practiced their table manners and social etiquette was awesome! I highly recommend this establishment and its catering services! Aside from the food - the attention to detail, positive attitudes, and customer service continues to keep us coming back for more!!!

In the spirit of practicing my etiquette, I’d like to give a big THANK YOU to all that helped make this a yummy and great lesson night for our girls!!!


Cindy Oertel Boyden

Alex, my waiter, is a sweetheart. Excellent service and food. I sat outside and it was a gorgeous day. Liked the music that was playing. Very relaxing lunch. Was by myself and loved it. Will go back at night when live music is there. More...


Steve Boo-Steve O Bousquet

I grew up here in Hamilton and joined the Air Force in 1995. I am a still in and am here for the airshow. I had to bring my guys into town and take them to Brothers. And they were blown away. Thanks to Alex (hope I got your name right) our server and props to Kevin their best employee killing those box making skills. Thanks so much for having us! See you all soon again I hope! More...

Photos (5)

See all