Borrriello Brothers

Borrriello Brothers

Borrriello Brothers locationElsmere, Colorado

(15 Reviews)
Borrriello Brothers Reviews

Borrriello Brothers Reviews


Review of Borrriello Brothers by darron worden
1 08/07/2018 darron worden

Very disappointed. I waited for an 1 hour 48 minutes for my delivery. Which you get charged for. I called them 4 times. And got the answer it's on the way . The driver left. Things like that. I only live a mile from the store. I could have walked and returned faster than my delivery. Than the pizza was luke warm if that. Uneven toppings and not very "special" New York pizza was not any better than your chain stores for sure. I will never ever order from them again. Managment really needs to get their stuff together at this store for sure. Totally disappointed. 1 hour 48 minutes later. That's ridiculous. They dont even call or text you to tell you out of courteous that they are very behind. You have to call them and than get misled. Never again.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Ryan Hunter
5 11/06/2018 Ryan Hunter

This place is usually delicious and tastes like authentic New York style pizza ????.

I've been coming here off and on for several years now. Tonight, the staff was friendly, including the lady working the front counter. The pizza itself surprisingly wasn't as good as it usually is, but what can you say?

I still wholly recommend this place still!

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Daniel Leach
1 18/04/2018 Daniel Leach

So sorry to see this place go down hill in food quality and service. Placed and order to go.. told ready in 20 min. Got there in 20 and was told we just turned the oven on. Had to wait 25 more minutes there. The order was wrong. The guy brought it out and dropped it on the floor, it was very small portion, and didn't taste very good.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Kyla Gonzales
5 17/04/2018 Kyla Gonzales

I love this Pizza Place, talk about phenomenal pizza! The toppings are always fresh, overloaded, and evenly distributed. I love the dining in experience at this location, except for when parents bring their children and do not manage them (it is not an arcade, it is a restaurant)! Our pizza builder was so sweet he assured us that he would make it special for us, it really made our experience stand out, big props and thanks to Josh! We will most definitely be returning to this Boriello Brothers location!!

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Catherine Roberts
1 08/04/2018 Catherine Roberts

I asked for a godfather's pie. I expected everything to be on the pizza, but there only cheese and ham on the edges. They told me that the rest of my pizza was there. Looking into a to go box there was salad covered in vinegrette. What's so hard about putting all the toppings on my pie, and they didn't even give me the correct ones. Don't put yourself through this situation!!

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Michael Hilden
1 07/04/2018 Michael Hilden

If you are looking for a good slice unfortunately this is not the place. Upon buying the price is fairly reasonable but the pizza itself is very plain. The crust is chewy like a Little Caesars pizza and it has no flavor. The slices themselves are large but that does not make up for the blandness of the slice. No flavor in any part of the pie. There are only two choices. Pepperoni or cheese. No variety whatsoever. So if you are looking for an authentic slice of New York dont fall for the false advertisement and look else where.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Michelle Snively-Gonzalez - CDHS
1 11/03/2018 Michelle Snively-Gonzalez - CDHS

Took the family out for the slide with kids but service was SLOW and got our pizzas first and appetizers last. Staff was rude, calzone was made wrong just wish staff would understand we work hard for our money and like to spend it without the hassles by staff that don’t care

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Robert Rodgers
2 10/03/2018 Robert Rodgers

Restaurant was at a slow period, which is maybe why the employees were slow in getting my pizza out to the table. Took 20 minutes to receive both pies. 1 was burnt, so I took it back and showed it to one of the employees. He told me this is the way it normally looks like when the pizza is cheese only. Well, I have been to many other Borriello Brothers restaurants and the pizza was great. At the time of this post, I am still waiting for the second cheese pizza to replace the 1st one. Took an additional 20 minutes to get the second one. Highly recommend going to another Borriello Brothers. This is by far the worst service I have ever had.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by T W
1 08/03/2018 T W

I went to this pizza place with some friends and our children. We had heard about “the slide” and figured the kids could burn some energy. All I can say about that is yuck. Same goes for the pizza and the ambiance. Very thin crust, large slices, but the bottoms seemed to be burned. I had ordered a calzone which came out under baked and the wrong filling. They absolutely were understaffed, flustered, blaming one another for the mistakes made, calling one another names. The tables were not being bussed and we all vowed never to go back.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Olivia Reed
2 04/03/2018 Olivia Reed

Came in around 3:30 on 3/4/18, two guys working. They didn’t have their traditional wings, one guy under his breath says “I don’t think I have enough to do 6” and didn’t even offer us what they did have left. The guy taking our order hardly said a word to us and was rude and could hardly understand him because he was talking so quietly and not at all engaged in what was going on. Last time we weee here we had problems with the wrong food as well as cold food. When they dropped off our food this time he didn’t say a word and just tried to squeeze the tray of food in between us. Very unpleasant experience and unnecessary.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Mark Knecht
1 17/02/2018 Mark Knecht

If you like noisy screaming crying kids this is the place to go. Called in an order, walked in and paid and waited 30 more minutes before approaching the counter only to find out that my pizza had been in the warming bin the whole time. Terrible service by the counter staff.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by William Lyons
4 05/11/2017 William Lyons

Good new York style pizza.
The garlic knots were tough and not appetizing.
Service was slow and they forgot to place an order for a salad we asked for.
The kids slide was cool but several of the game room games were either not working or were packed so tight that they're impossible to win.
Prices are very competitive though which was nice.
Overall I recommend.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Johnny Shoots
4 24/10/2017 Johnny Shoots

If you want some delicious pizza here is the place! Super casual atmosphere. Reasonably priced. Staff is alright. Appropriately clean. If you’re looking for a good deal I would strongly recommend their appetizer sampler. They also have a small arcade. They are located right next to a gas station. So if you’re on a road trip this is a great pitstop.

Review of Borrriello Brothers by Andi Propst
5 13/10/2017 Andi Propst

I love the pizza but it's also a great place to bring big groups and kids to hang out at. They have a really cool indoor slide that keeps kids entertained while the pizza is being made. Also...did I mention the pizza is really good?

Review of Borrriello Brothers by robert brooks
5 30/08/2017 robert brooks

Live right behind this place but have never been. Just got their specialty pizza deal and I am impressed. Wait was so so but living so close I don't really have an opinion on the wait time. Really good ny pizza!

Borrriello Brothers


Click to rate:

Find companies like this!

Whatever your requirement, Bark will help you find local companies like Borrriello Brothers.
Just post your project to Bark and we'll find the most suitable companies for you.


Are you sure that you want to leave?