Preble, Wisconsin
74 customer reviews
Kathryn Laabs
Tiffany made our wedding cake and it was beautiful and tasty too! She took my inspiration photo and it was exactly what i wanted. And you made my husband so happy he got funfetti cake! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Lisa Dorner
Tiffany sent me cookies for teacher appreciation they were so delicious and looked so cute. She has made cupcakes and cakes in the past for me and they are by far the best tasting. They are also so beautiful. She is so creative and easy to work with. This is the only place I order cakes from. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tina Martin
Beautiful cakes with delicious flavors.
Reviewed on Facebook
Kelly Walters
I ordered a cake for my husbands new job, looking around at bakeries and specialty shops I wanted something special and unique for him. . and that is just what I got with Tiffany. Tiffany kept in constant contact with me on what I wanted... and it was perfect. The cake was awesome... cant wait to try some of her other goodies. Will definitely be contacting Tiffany again. Thank you so much Tiffany. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Josalynn Marie
Absolutely blown away by Tiffany and her work! The attention to detail was amazing!! The Lemon Blueberry cake/cupcakes were to die for!! Highly recommend!
Reviewed on Facebook
Stephanie Vine
Hands down, BEST cake I've ever had, not exaggerating. Everyone at my wedding was raving over how delicious the lemon blueberry cake was. Tiffany was incredibly accommodating and flexible. She decorated the cake with a beautiful grey and white granite pattern and hand-painted metallic gold accents. I'm wondering if I'll even be able to save any to freeze and eat for our anniversary because I can't stop eating the leftovers! So happy with Tiffany's excellent service and talent, highly recommend! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Amber Meghan Kiesling
I have had cupcakes and cake jars from Teddies so I ordered my son's birthday cake from here. everybody LOVED it and kept asking where I got it. It was delicious!! Thank you so much!!! Will definitely order future cakes, etc from here! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Taylor Naylor
They did an amazing job for my best friends baby shower! I was coming in from out of town to throw the shower and googled to find an awesome place to make the cookies and cake. .. they did not disappoint! Thank you so much for your fast response and yummy treats. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Julie Sizemore
I had to stop myself from inhaling my raspberry cupcake, yuuuuuuummm!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Addy Vieth Vandermuse
Picked up some Stuffed Peanut Butter cupcakes today and they were amazing!!!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Emily Savetwith
Purchased adorable personalized cookies for my daughter's soccer team. She was fast, friendly and they were so adorable and tasty.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cristey Leigh
Cake in a Jar - Funfetti, Chocolate & Red Velvet!
Reviewed on Facebook
aasha suarez
We received an amazing cake from Tiffany! she was able to keep in contact every step of the way and made our cake a great gift to share for our family. We will definitely be pursuing more business with her in the future (: More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Aasha Arriaga
We received an amazing cake from Tiffany! she was able to keep in contact every step of the way and made our cake a great gift to share for our family. We will definitely be pursuing more business with her in the future (: More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Ashley Carter
Teddies creative cakes are absolutely amazing! The cakes and cupcakes are delicious and they make your celebration even better! Our family enjoyed every part! Definitely would recommend everyone to try teddies creative cakes. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sylvia Flores
Our guest LOVED the cake so much they went on the site to see what else was offered. The design was great. We stopped by a bake sale she was having and fell in love then. Thank you so much ♥️
Reviewed on Facebook
Amber Lee Kettenhoven
Muffins are delicious and her cream puffs OMG or the BOMB!!
Reviewed on Facebook
missy barker
A super cool 3D dinosaur cake words can not even describe it!! The cake itself was soooo good!! Amazing person to do business with! I would order another cake in a heartbeat!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jill Dombroski
Thank you so much for the amazing cake and cookies. It turned out great. Taste was great. Cookies were amazing. The kids loved them! ! I would highly recommend creative cakes. Tiffany is Amazing to work with. She responds quickly to all messages and is very creative. Thank you so much:) More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Missy Barker
I would order another custom cake in a heartbeat!! After a long search for a 3D dinosaur cake I had almost given up hope.. .then I came across Teddies Creative Cakes in a google search. I reached out to her on messenger with a pic of the cake I was looking for within minutes I had a baker!! She responded quickly, stayed in contact with me through messenger, and sent me a pic of a dinosaur at the end which I couldn’t wait to see in person! Now let’s comment on the cake! I picked up the cake the day prior to the party...my whole kitchen smelled of yummy cake!! Taste...AMAZING!!! Everyone at the party commented on the cake how cool it was and how great it tasted!! Thank you very much! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Becky DeJardin
This cookie cake from Teddy's Cakes was beautiful and tasted AMAZING!! A lot of us do not care for overly sweet frosting so this was perfect! I think it might be her new favorite and for this picky eater that says a lot! I cannot forget to mention how accommodating she was especially with my short notice! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nikki Benzing Stapleton
amazing cake! the Teddie E ringinal with cream cheese frosting was a family hit! I highly recommend!
Reviewed on Facebook
Chris Graham
Love everything that comes out of this company amazing!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jamie Frizzo
Tiffany of Teddies Creative Cakes was fantastic to work with! She got back to me quickly after contacting her. She was willing to work within the budget I had for cookies. My son’s birthday cookies were adorable and tasted delicious! I will definitely call Tiffany again! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kathy Stephenson
Ordered cupcakes for a retirement party. They were ready on time - no hassle and everyone loved them. Looked AND tasted wonderful!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jamie Frizzo
Tiffany was very easy to get in touch with and got back to me quickly. She gave me a price range and was willing to work with me on price. Cookies looked better than I imagined and tasted delicious! She is super friendly and I will definitely use her again. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kristin Staszak-Knight
I ordered a custom Batman smash cake for my son's 1st birthday. I gave her free rein and she did an amazing job!!! The cake was delicious and sooo cool!! I would highly recommend her!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Len Hansen
Tiffany make a cupcake arrangement for our grandson’s confirmation. It was beautiful, DELICIOUS and her service was wonderful!!!! What a great experience!!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kellie Johns
I won 4 cakes in a jar. I received them today. I live in Tennessee too. they were absolutely awesome. well..I haven't eaten them all yet. .just one. it was so delicious. makes me wish I lived next door to this business. lol. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kaylee Johnson
ordered a smash cake for my sons first birthday, baby shark themed! he loved it, and the cupcakes were a hit with the guests.
Reviewed on Facebook
Jenny Peterson
The cupcakes are delicious The frosting is the BEST I have tasted. Sweet but not too sweet, it kind of melts in your mouth!
Reviewed on Facebook
Scott Wendricks
My wife won a dozen blueberry muffins a few days ago. They were excellent in taste. We will definitely becoming back to see Tiffany and her desserts.
Reviewed on Facebook
Lex D.F.
Wonderfully delicious! Every time we get something, it is absolutely wonderful and everyone loves it.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Susan Heath
unique, delicious, get what you want!
Reviewed on Facebook
Chad Wilson
want to send a big thank you to Tiffany for creating an amazing unicorn cake for my daughter's 8th birthday! she absolutely loved it! Tiffany was able to successfully model a cake after one of my daughters stuffed unicorns,"lucky," and as a result was able to give her a birthday memory she will remember forever. thank you so very much! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Peggy LaCombe
I had one of Teddies Bear cakes for my birthday...Best. Cake. Ever...and was very cute to boot...lol
Reviewed on Facebook
Emily Schnell
I love her Teddie’s ‘E’rginial flavor! I asked her for Disney cupcakes & she made the most adorable Dumbo & Mickey n’ Minnie cupcakes! The fondant was awesome, for anyone who has ever said they don’t like fondant try hers cuz u will like I promise! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Suzanne Arroyo
I could not get to the farmer's market yesterday but with a frantic flurry of messages, this beautiful lady was able to secure 8 mason jar cakes, little cake pops, and a few peanut butter cookies, and get them to me yesterday! !YAY! I got to be the hit of the party because of all of these amazing fun treats! Everything was so tasty, beautifully prepared, and just downright wonderful :) I got all of the compliments from friends, so I am just passing them along to the person who REALLY deserves them. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lacy Lee
got my daughter's birthday cake done at Teddies creative cakes this week, we absolutely loved it, !!!! the muffins and cookies are just as sweet and delicious as her cakes are, she knows exactly what she's doing...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kara Janelle
All of their baked treats! Or any customized products for your special occasions.
Reviewed on Facebook
Tyler Giese
beautiful cakes and wonderful service
Reviewed on Facebook
Mackenzie Piper
I love the blueberry muffins Chris Graham gave me one to try they are really really good they taste good and aren't overly sweet best blueberry muffins I've ever had
Reviewed on Facebook
Nicole Marie
She made me the best cupcakes I have ever had in my life I will only order from here from now on
Reviewed on Facebook
Benjamin Rayome
The cake was gorgeous and tasted even better than it looked! Moist cake, amazing buttercream frosting - just delicious! Thank you for making our day!
Reviewed on Facebook
Benjamin Rayome
Great cake! Beautiful and absolutely one of the best cakes I have ever tasted. Perfect for our wedding.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Robert Joepeck
it's all delicious I had a golf birthday cake from there I had some lemon cake from there
Reviewed on Facebook
Natasha DeAnn Lentz
Although everything I tried from here was absolutely AMAZING.. I am totally in love with the Reeses loaded fudge, and the Red Velvet cake jar, they both are to die for! !! Absolutely amazing. Highly recommended!! ❤ More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Christopher Graham
just picked up a half dozen of these blue berry muffins! normally I get them from the store! not no more! teddies creative cakes gets my business from now on! my honest opinion perfection not to sweet but right there not rich but right there simply amazed! great job! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Raul Padilla
BEST CAKE EVER!!! My mom has a cake and cupcakes made for my cousins baby shower! It was soooo amazing
Reviewed on Facebook
Lucy Lee
Our cake for our son’s 1st birthday from Teddies was AMAZING! She delivered exactly what I wanted (with a matching smash cake included). The cake was so delicious and moist and everyone commented on how great it was. We will be using her in the future and would highly recommend Teddies! Thanks again More...
Reviewed on Facebook