Pizza Payaa
Bloomington
(36)
Bloomington
(36)
36 customer reviews
Colleen ZS
The bourbon buffalo bacon blue-cheese collab pie with Pop Up Chicken was legendary. The smokey, tangy, cheesiness of it all 🤤 and just the right amount of heat 👌 I would fight someone for this pizza.
Reviewed on Facebook
Laura Ullmann-Reynolds
Wonderful pizza! Very friendly staff. Thank you!
Reviewed on Facebook
Pamela Taylor Cather
Hey if any of you are Gluten-free you have to try Pizza Payaa homemade gluten-free crust. It’s more than just something to hold your pizza together. It’s absolutely a delicious part of the experience. Wish I had a pic of it before I ate it. But it’s all gone! 😊 Everyone was super friendly too. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sarah Fletcher
Love Pizza Payaa!! The bacon ranch pickle pizza was amazing! Their gluten free pizza dough - you can’t even tell it’s gluten free. It’s really tasty. And they have amazing customer service. This is my go-to place to treat myself to delicious and unique pizzas. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Karyn Racutt
The staff that welcomed me at Pizza Payaa were super friendly and nice!! The pizza I ordered was delicious and I would definitely go here again. Thank you for the great customer service (: More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kelly Redd Luedtke
Awesome pizza! Even my husband who says he only likes very thin crusted pizza, said he would order from here again. Also loved the hot honey sauce.😋
Reviewed on Facebook
Mackenzie Phillips
Haven’t had anything I haven’t liked! Especially the burrata 😍🍕
Reviewed on Facebook
Jessy Snyder
Crust not great, little sauce supplied. Just overall not great.
Reviewed on Facebook
Ziyad Hasan
if love was a pizza it would be called PIZZA PAYAA
Reviewed on Facebook
Izzi Demara
Hands down the best pizza in town! They make a delicious NY/Sicilian style pizza- the crust has a great crispy layer but the inside of the dough is light and airy. Both their garlic sauce (white pizza) and their red sauce are rich and flavorful- yet they don’t over power the pizza toppings. Run, don’t walk here… and what ever you do, DO NOT FORGET THE HOT HONEY! 🍯 More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Tym Kerns
no menu.. they want ask my info and I don't even know what they have to sell and if I want anything.. nope nope nope
Reviewed on Facebook
Lilly Blackmon
Omg amazing! If you have to eat one pizza in BloNo make it this one! I wish I could share a photo but I literally couldn’t resist eating it! We got it to go but next time I’ll definitely eat in. The vibe was immaculate. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Monica Mascote-Flori
So good! I highly recommend! The sweet honey sauce. Off the charts!
Reviewed on Facebook
Debby Uhlenhake Schell
We ordered gluten free pizza. Seriously the best gluten free crust we’ve ever had. Super high quality ingredients, house made jalapeños and hot honey. Amazing! So happy to have this gem in Bloomington More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Chris Schell
Best GF crust I have ever had. Pizza Payaa is our new go to. Love the homemade jalapeños and hot honey. Quality ingredients and a friendly staff!
Reviewed on Facebook
Ken Chiu
Excellent pizza!! Enjoy them very much!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Ruby Nicole Barnett
This place not only has amazing pizza, the customer service is excellent. Tonight, in a huge rush of orders, one of the staff let me know that they had another pizza cooking for me as they had overcooked the first one. Then, my perfect Burrata pepperoni pizza was ready to go, and they gave me the overcooked one, too! Always above and beyond. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Melissa J. Lockwood
Um, I thought the tomato with epiphany farms tomatoes was killer. Until we tried this In N Out pizza. Holy mother of god it’s delicious!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jamie Todd Spratt
We ordered the honey badger, sausage, and dessert pizza!! It was awesome; best in town. I highly recommend it!
Reviewed on Facebook
Gwyn Denney
Best pizza in BloNo. The weekly specialties are amazing.
Reviewed on Facebook
Karalee Cimadomo
Seriously the best! My husband and I don't make it down very often, but it has always been so worth the drive when we do. Pizza Payaa is our favorite pizza place by far, thanks to the incredible crust, high quality/delicious cheese, and that hot honey drizzle ! All of the toppings we've tried have been TOP quality and taste. We love the pepperoni - loads of flavor without being spicy - and that white garlic sauce is what pizza lover's dreams are made of 😍 Thanks so much for the "free pizza" code this week! We were able to try the Bad Boy for $5. You guys have really outdone yourselves. Looking forward to next time already! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Emily Serapin
I haven’t been able to enjoy Pizza Payaa with the rest of my family until you made the Vegan with dairy free cheese! Thanks so much for making a dairy free pizza for us lactose intolerant nerds! I got mine with pepperoni, but it would be great if your incredible sausage was an add on! Thanks again and keep up the good work. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Calyn Witte
Best Pizza Around! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟Staff was friendly and welcoming! Can’t wait to try more options in the future!
Reviewed on Facebook
Dave-Lisa McCommons
Having eaten pizza all over the country and Across the pond , our first Pizza Payaa pie was outstanding ! Among the best we’ve ever had! The freshness of ingredients , paired with the incredible crust is an experience not to be missed ! When it’s time for pizza at our home it will be Pizza Payaa! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Molly Robinson
The best, most delicious pizza I’ve ever had. The crust is just *chef’s kiss.* You’re doing yourself an injustice if you don’t try this place!
Reviewed on Facebook
Matthew Kuntz
Best pizza in BloNo! I’d drive an hour or more to get this pizza…thankfully we live much closer!
Reviewed on Facebook
Bj Henderson
Amazing!!
We drove from Washington, IL just to try your pizza and we will do it again! The most perfect pizza crust we have ever had!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Kylie Bishop
Pizza Payaa has been my favorite pizza place in town since opening. I got my pizza today, and they gave me an extra cheese pizza for free. Every time I’ve been in there the owner and employees have been extremely nice and truly thankful for everyone’s business. I highly recommend them! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jackie Powell
ordered on Sunday, for pickup today. Totally worth the wait! YUM!
#pizzapayaa #cheeseburrata #hothoneydrizzle
Reviewed on Facebook
Julie Kubsch
Hmmm…yes very good. But ordered two thinking we’d share with our son/daughter in law/2 boys age 2 and 5. It was like appetizers. $47 of appetizers. Pizzas are small but delicious and a bit pricey. This picture is 1/2 of each pizza and the half is about as big as a large hand. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Pennie Gray
I had the sausage and mushroom pizza tonight. It was absolutely delicious! Can't wait to have leftovers tomorrow!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jorja Lieding Molnar
So delicious!!! everything I anticipate and more!!
Online ordering on Sundays; find a time, pay ahead, and pick up at your time!!
Very easy!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jaz Kates
Amazing pizza! Great experience. Highly recommend, my mouth is still watering! 10/10 🙌🏼
Reviewed on Facebook
Kris Walker
Just had the honey badger for my first experience here.. it was phenomenal!! 10 out of 10 stars, would eat here again, and possibly order the exact same thing….
Reviewed on Facebook
Chance Clemons
Awesome people. Great pizza
Reviewed on Facebook
Nancy Lanier
The good and the …..
I’m Italian. I have been making my special pizzas for years. My family loved them until now… they have tasted PIZZA PAYAA pizza and now my pizza is in second place.
😢
My husband and I have been to Italy ten times. We have had a lot of delicious pizza but PIZZA PAYAA ranks at the top for best pizza!!
Thank you for a job well done!!!
More...
Reviewed on Facebook
