Loading...

Please wait ...

C

Colleens Cakes

Keller, Texas

(141)

Get a free quote from this professional

Get a free quote from this professional

Reviews (141)

Leave a review
5/5

141 customer reviews

Loading...
6 November 2019

Colleen was AMAZING! From our phenomenal tasting to ease of communication to the final product, all I can say is “Wow! ” Our cake was GONE! Everyone loved it, and so did we! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

11 December 2018

Colleen is truly amazing!! Our initial consult was so much fun trying all the different flavors. I swear this was my husbands favorite part of wedding planning, the cake tasting! Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and so so so delicious. All our guests kept talking about how awesome our cake was! Thank you so much Colleen for not only the best wedding cake ever, but for truly being so sweet and helpful during this planning season! You are the best! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

27 November 2018

Colleen made the wedding cakes for my son’s wedding. They were amazing. Thank you Colleen! My daughter-in-law and son sprang 2 extra people (me and my boyfriend) on Colleen for the cake tasting and she was very accommodating. Oh My Goodness there were so many cakes to taste and all of them were so delicious! I couldn’t wait for the wedding so I could have more. I’m definitely recommending her to any and everyone I know. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

26 October 2018

I’m so happy I ordered my wedding cake from Colleen. As you have probably read in other reviews, she runs her business from her home and we got to do a cake tasting there. Everything went so smoothly and her home is really nice. You can tell she’s a pro and knows what she is doing. She provided like 20 different flavors to choose from (and got to take the leftovers home). All were delicious but we ended up going with pink champagne, red velvet, strawberry, and key lime. The pink champagne is a must! I was so excited to finally see my cake in person after spending some time with Colleen during the tasting discussing how we wanted it to look. It ended up surpassing my expectations. It was so beautiful and most importantly, delicious! Her pricing is also super reasonable! When looking at pricing for different vendors, I was surprised at how much wedding cake can cost. We also got to take home some cupcakes of each flavor from our cake. My husband and I ate them on our wedding night since we didn’t get to eat some cake during the reception (except for the bite we got during the cake cutting). Our guests loved the cake! We even got calls to check if we had leftovers, but it was all gone except for a small piece we gave to my parents! I highly recommend Colleen! I am looking forward to ordering some more pink champagne cake for our 1-year anniversary! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

28 September 2018

Colleen made our wedding cakes almost a year ago and I can't stop talking about them! They were amazing!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Colleen was amazing and easy to work with. She is so professional, talented, and did such a good job on our cake. We sampled three other bakeries and all her cake flavors, filling, and icing topped them all! It was so delicous, beautifully done, and we got so many compliments. I cannot wait until our one year anniversary just to eat more cake! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

26 May 2018

I contacted Colleen with a picture of a gender reveal cake I wanted for our gender reveal party. Colleen made it exactly how I wanted and it was delish to boot. I will be needing a wedding cake soon and know exactly where to go. I will recommend her and so happy I found her! Thank you Colleen More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

26 May 2018

Cakes taste AMAZING! I am not a sweets person at all and I could eat her cakes all day, perfect balance and natural flavors. I can't wait to order from Colleen again. Colleen is so friendly, easy to work with, and knew exactly what we wanted I cannot praise her enough. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

26 May 2018

Colleen made our wedding cake and groom's cake for our wedding on 6/9/17 and it was amazing! Her cakes are the best that I have ever tasted. Not only were our cakes delicious, but she made my wedding cake dreams come true with a gorgeous design that was exactly what I wanted. Many of our guests have also said it was the best cake they ever had and complimented the design. We are so happy with Colleen's work and will for sure use her in the future for all our cake needs. Thanks Colleen for the wonderful cakes! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

26 May 2018

Amazing tasting cakes

Reviewed on Google Maps

7 July 2017

Colleen did both of our cakes at our wedding and they were amazing! I was very pleased with their appearance and the taste was outstanding :) It's nearly impossible to pick a flavor because they are all so tasty, so I'm glad we got to put 5 of her signature flavors in our cakes! From the first cake tasting to the big day, and all of the communication in between - it was a joy to work with Colleen! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

20 January 2017

Colleen is fabulous, friendly, and simply fantastic. I could find other superlatives to use, but I like the theme. I was a bride planning a wedding in grad school and it was a lot for me. I saw pictures of cakes that were very elaborate and over the top, and I didn’t want a lot of things going on with the cake. Our wedding venue planner told us about Colleen, and we decided to check her out. We went to one lady before and I was appalled by the lack of customer service and enthusiasm. You won’t have to worry about that with Colleen because she truly loves and is passionate about her craft.

We arrived at Colleen’s house and she had everything ready for our cake tasting. I can’t even remember how many flavors we were able to taste, but I am pretty sure we tasted every single one since there were many cupcakes in front of us. Colleen puts the filling inside the cupcake so you can get the full effect during the tasting. Colleen took down notes, got to know us, and even sent us home with leftovers. We walked out of her house and knew immediately that Colleen was the lady for us.

Colleen and I chatted during the rest of the year and up until the wedding to make sure that everything was good to go. However, on the day of the wedding I gave the cake topper to my venue coordinator and didn’t even see Colleen! I walked into the reception and was immediately drawn to the cake. THE CAKE WAS SO BEAUTIFUL! It was exactly what I envisioned and hoped it would be. Simple, elegant, classy, chic. I absolutely loved it and everyone couldn’t stop raving about how great the cake was.

I can’t thank Colleen enough for helping make our wedding the best day ever!
More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

18 July 2016

Colleen is actual AMAZING. As in literally amazing. My mother and I had completely different views she was able to incorporate something everyone loved and turned out better than I would have ever expected. The FLAVORS!!!!!!! oh my goodness! fantastic! i will be calling her soon for my daughter's birthday! Colleen is so sweet and truly truly talented. It was the best! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

15 June 2016

Colleen was awesome to work with! Out of all of the bakeries we met with, Colleen provided the best customer service. She had about 12-15 cupcakes for us to try and sent us home with the leftovers! YUM! So my parents and friends were able to get in on the cake tasting action. Her cakes were by far the most delicious and the flavors the most unique. She got our vision and our cakes the day of were beautiful! And amazingly delicious!!! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

26 January 2016

Our daughter had a Marvel Comic themed wedding. Colleen was able to decorate her cake exactly as she envisioned with marvel comic ribbon and marvel comic flowers and she was able to take the scene from "Deadpool" character wedding and put on the grooms cake. We had 4 layers (ginger pear, strawberry creme, red velvet and key lime cake) for the wedding cake and chocolate, chocolate chip for the grooms cake for 150 guest. There was hardly any cake left it was so delicious!!!! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

8 December 2015

Colleen put together our groom's cake and she did a phenomenal job. She was very responsive and the cake was absolutely beautiful! ! Everyone complemented on how gorgeous and delicious it was :-) More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

23 November 2015

Yummy, delicious, and decadent cake is an understatement. We actually dropped our check the day of the tasting because not only was the cake great, she also fell well within our price range. She came highly recommended to us by our florist and personal friendand boy are we thankful. She loves baking cakes and you can see she it in the way she presents the flavors which are not your normal vanilla and chocolate cake. We had amaretto (my fave), key lime, and turtle (crowd fave) just to name a few. We picked 7 flavors! Did I mention that some flavors had fresh fruit or mousse inside !! AND THE BEST PART, she had cupcakes of all the flavors waiting for us after the wedding because we got ONE bite that day. She warned me of this but I was in denial lol.
The cakes were beautiful. I showed her what I like and she designed it beautifully.

In summary, good value, delicious taste, and a sweet person. She is definitely giving you an experience.
More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

15 June 2015

Update to the review below---My husband I and LOVED our wedding cakes. It was absolutely perfect. Our guests went nuts for it. The cakes were also beautiful and exactly what we had asked for. I wish we'd ordered more so I would have had more left over! We will definitely be using Colleen again for other major events in our lives! Original review: My fiancé and I tried a lot, and I mean A LOT of cakes when trying to select the perfect wedding cake for our upcoming wedding. (I love cake.) Colleen is the BEST. Save yourself the time and send her an email before trying the rest of those bakeries :). She has been incredibly flexible in working with me and her cakes speak for themselves. Many of the other vendors I had tried didn't seem to really understand my vision or tried to convince me that I wanted something that I knew that I did not. To make things even better, she's reasonably priced and has a FANTASTIC personality. Colleen has been doing this for a long time and I feel comfortable trusting her with this important part of our big day! Call her ASAP :) More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

10 June 2015

My daughter wanted a 5 tier metallic gold wedding cake with each tier a different flavor of cake. We had the best time sampling cakes at Colleen's house & had a hard time selecting only 5 because all of her flavors were to so so good! !!! I loved Colleen's enthusiasm helping us create what we wanted!! She is so creative & her cakes were the best I have ever had!! And the groom's cake...beautiful & fabulous!!! I'm glad I have 2 more kids that are not married yet, because I will call Colleens Cakes again!! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

1 June 2015

I CAN NOT express enough how wonderful and amazing my experience with Colleen's Cakes was! She was the first cake tasting I had scheduled, and I knew from the minute our tasting started I was going to use her! From her bubbly personality, to her DELICIOUS cakes, right down to the design of the cake to make it our own. Of course, I had other tastings to attend, but NONE came even close! If I could give more than 5 stars I would! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

15 April 2015

Best wedding cake ever!!!! Not only was it beautiful, it was so delicious that I was receiving complements about it for months after the wedding!

Reviewed on WeddingWire

21 September 2014

Colleen was so easy to work with. In the initial meeting, she allows you to try all 15 cake flavors. Even though they are each exceptional, she still allows you to create a custom flavor. Our guests raved about our cake and were even upset that they didn't get to try all of the flavors. She also gives you a free top layer to share the night of the wedding or as an anniversary cake. More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

13 November 2013

Colleen is definitely my go to person for awesome cakes!!! she made my wedding cake which was the talk of my wedding. she has made my husbands birthday cake which was also a big hit at his party. I look forward to using her services in the future!!!!! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

27 August 2013

My cake was beautiful and it tasted absolutely amazing!! It was the best cake ever!! :)

Reviewed on WeddingWire

17 July 2013

Loved working with Colleen, and the cakes tasted amazing! We met with Colleen in Keller, which is quite a drive from Dallas during traffic, but it was so nice that she let us try so many different flavors, and they were all so unique! The hardest thing was to choose just three flavors for our 3 tier cake. I ended up getting an extra 9" cake so that I could get the blackberry lemon flavor (tastes like blackberry cobbler!). I had about 10 people tell me afterwards that they ate 3 pieces of cake just so they could have all of the flavors! Delicious! Definitely one of my favorite vendors! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

18 June 2013

Colleen makes the most delicious cakes and they are so unique. We chose two two tier and one three tier cakes and each of them being a different cake. When Trey and I went for the tasting we had such a hard time choosing just one so we dicided to go with three different ones and I'm so glad that we did. She did such an amazing job and we couldnt be happier. Thank you Colleen! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

10 June 2013

OMG!! My wedding cakes were soooo goood that people repeated, and there was nothing, absolutely nothing left:-)!! I used to think that wedding cakes were the worse part of a wedding, found them always, dry, plain, bland and blah. .. Then I tried Colleen cakes. These are by far the best wedding cake I have ever had!! I went to different places for tasting, and they usually give you 4 different flavors to try. When I went to Colleen's she received us with somewhere between 16-20 cake flavors!!! They were all excellent, fresh, with fresh ingredients, just delicious!!! We had really hard time to choose our flavors, because it was a little too much to have a 20 tiers cake;-). Let me say this, I don't like chocolate at all, and this baker somehow made chocolate cakes for the tasting that I truly enjoyed. In addition to that, all the other bakers gave me hard time regarding the design and colors I chose for my cake (tiffany blue and red), saying that the red would bleed on the blue. Colleen was the only one that reassured me my design was doable, and that I had nothing to worry about my red bleeding. Anyways, after we chose her, the thing I was looking forward the most, on my wedding (other than saying I do) was the cake. And my big day came, my cake design was exactly as I requested, and the red stayed exactly where it was supposed to be. And just when I thought that it couldn't be any better, we cut the cake and it tasted even better than I remembered. All flavors were magnificent. People were telling me they have never had a more delicious wedding cake in their lives. In a blink, my cake was gone. Everybody loved it!! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

8 May 2013

Colleen's cakes are amazing! I've used her for several cakes in the past, and our wedding cake did not disappoint! She was able to incorporate our vintage theme into exactly what we wanted, and she is so easy to work with ... highly recommended!

Reviewed on WeddingWire

1 March 2013

Colleen was amazing! For our tasting, she made us a huge assortment of cupcakes to taste, and the hardest part was deciding which ones we would use, because they were all so good! Colleen makes you feel so comfortable and we really enjoyed our experience with her. We tried some other cake places, but upon meeting Colleen, we made the decision right then to go with her. I didn't get to see Colleen deliver the cakes to the wedding, but when I went into the reception hall- there they were- completely gorgeous with so much attention to detail! And she even had a Darth Vader mask made entirely of chocolate for the groom's cake. Everyone raved about how delicious the cake was, and my only disappointment is that we (the bride & groom!) didn't get enough! We have already talked about getting another cake from Colleen that's just for US to share! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

11 February 2013

I am so sorry that this review is 2 years late. but I LOVE Colleen's Cakes!!!!! She is awesome to work with and the cakes are heavenly. All four layers of my cake were different and everyone enjoyed them. She truly has a calling and I am blessed to have gotten her name to call upon for my very specail day. Since then, I have used her two different times and I am about to call and order another cake! Way to go!!! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

15 October 2012

Colleen did my daughter's wedding cake and groom's cake. Both were beautiful and delicious! So many guests said they had never had wedding cake that tasted so good. Colleen also did a small cake for the Bride and Groom....we got a taste the next day. It was wonderful! Colleen was a pleasure to work with. More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

9 October 2012

The cakes were perfect. Beautiful and delicious and we would recommend her to anyone who needs a cake for any occasion.

Reviewed on WeddingWire

5 August 2012

The cake was beautiful and everyone raved about each of the four flavors we had on the four tier cake.

Reviewed on WeddingWire

17 July 2012

Colleen’s cakes are amazing! Colleen has great customer service. From the moment we walked into her home, we felt welcomed and that she really cared about what we wanted. Her samples were amazing and we could not believe how fairly she priced her cakes! She answered all my questions promptly and I always felt that I could rely on her to get everything done right and that I could trust her opinion.

Our wedding cake turned out beautifully and was everything that we wanted. The groom’s cake was also fantastic. Everyone in the room knew exactly what it was and the guests couldn’t stop talking about it! They thought it was awesome! We really appreciated that we didn't have to use fondant on the cakes. She is so talented that she doesn't have to cover up her frosting with fondant.

The cakes were delicious and we loved that we could pick a different flavor for every tier. Her frosting is the perfect amount of sweetness and the cake is moist and has a lot of flavor. We hardly had any cake leftover because our guests devoured it! The cakes were a wonderful addition to our reception!
More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

17 July 2012

Colleen’s cakes are amazing! Colleen has great customer service. From the moment we walked into her home, we felt welcomed and that she really cared about what we wanted. Her samples were amazing and we could not believe how fairly she priced her cakes! She answered all my questions promptly and I always felt that I could rely on her to get everything done right and that I could trust her opinion.

Our wedding cake turned out beautifully and was everything that we wanted. The groom’s cake was also fantastic. Everyone in the room knew exactly what it was and the guests couldn’t stop talking about it! They thought it was awesome! We really appreciated that we didn't have to use fondant on the cakes. She is so talented that she doesn't have to cover up her frosting with fondant.

The cakes were delicious and we loved that we could pick a different flavor for every tier. Her frosting is the perfect amount of sweetness and the cake is moist and has a lot of flavor. We hardly had any cake leftover because our guests devoured it! The cakes were a wonderful addition to our reception!
More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

5 June 2012

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!! Our cakes are still being talked about 2 weeks after the wedding! We even got Colleen to make us cupcakes for our rehearsal dinner. Colleen is very professional and she would NEVER give you old cupcakes during a tasting. All our cakes and cupcakes were fresh, beautiful, and delicious! We are even asking her to make a smaller version of our groom's cake just for us and our family since we weren't able to have any at our wedding! Can't wait! :-) More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

12 May 2012

My husband and I had a very short engagement (less than 3 months) I had completely forgot about the cake until about a month before. She had no problem getting us in and helping out in that part.

I had tried this cake at my friends wedding and it was amazing so I made an appointment. The tasting went well she is super sweet and has great customer service. I loved that she will allow you to have each tier a different cake flavor (a bonus because we did not want a grooms cake). Howerever, at my wedding I felt like there was so much icing. The cake was amazing but there was more icing then cake. I do not remeber this happening at my friends wedding but I may of not been paying attention. Everyone said it was amazing though.

Another bonus about her is she makes you a top tier seperately so you are able to eat it while you are on your honeymoon or when you return. This was amazing. Perfect amout of icing making me wonder if my cake was a oooppppsss ( which you have to understand do happen)

The prices are amazing as well!!! And I loved the design. I actually was very shakey on what I wanted so I brought a few pictures and she was able to help me. She knows brides and are able to get what you want out of you. She is amazing and so is her cakes.
More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

22 April 2012

We heard nothing but rave reviews from everyone about the cake, which normally isn't the first comment. From the flawless design to the devine flavors of both our wedding cake and groom's cake - we couldn't have been more thrilled. We aren't going to bother waiting for our one year to have the topper - we're busting it open tonight and enjoying it as our reward from coming back from Jamaica. Thanks Colleen!! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

17 April 2012

Let me start this by saying that I am a true cake fanatic and when I tasted Colleen's cakes, I wanted to do a back flip! !! Me and my wedding planner left with a box of cupcakes to taste later, as we couldn't decide on just a few flavors....THEY WERE ALL SO GOOD!!!!!!!!! My wedding was almost a month ago and I am STILL getting inquires about where did we get our wedding and groom's cakes from! People went back for three and four slices, we did not have any left other than what Colleen makes sure to give you to have later. She was a joy to work with, very responsive to my emaills, and created exactly what I envisioned the cakes to look like on the big day! Hats off Colleen, you did a fabulous job! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

29 March 2012

The cupcakes were marvelous. Everyone thought they were a huge hit and fun to have for the wedding.

Reviewed on WeddingWire

9 March 2012

My daughter's wedding was a year ago and still I love Colleen!
I have used her for a number of things across the past couple of years.
I live in Arlington and drive to Keller to pick stuff up from her because she's the best! I have never ever tasted a better cake! I don't know how she does it. Most wedding cakes are dry. I want to scream from the mountain top about Colleen's Cakes. She's making me some themed cupcakes for my Bachelor Finale Watch party! Can't wait. Thanks Colleen.
More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

16 February 2012

Colleen makes fabulous tasting cakes. The toughest job you will have is deciding which flavors to serve because everything she does is scrumptious. She is also extremely pleasant to work with and very professional. More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

6 January 2012

We met with Colleen at her home and made us feel comfortable right off the bat. She presented like 14 mini cakes for us to taste and it was a hard decision to pick what flavor to use for the wedding because they all tasted so good! Her cakes are delicious! The wedding cake and groom's cake she put together for the wedding looked so beautful. It exceeded our expectations! My favorite was lemon blackberry! More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

24 October 2011

The cake was ABSOLUTELY gorgeous and looked exactly the way we had asked it to look. Colleen is not only a fabulous baker but a true artist in her creation. So many wonderful comments about the cake-the only bad thing is I didn't get to eat much of it because it was such a hit! The true compliment to a great cake-nothing left! The chocolate covered strawberries were a big hit also! Thank you. We were so lucky to have found you and I have referred so many people to you already. More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

4 October 2011

Colleen's Cakes is five-star all the way. Not only are her prices reasonable and the cakes absolutely delicious (she let us taste 13 different ones to start! ) but she is extremely passionate about what she does. I haven't told her this yet...but I actually teared up when I walked into the reception ballroom right before the ceremony started and got a peek of the cakes. My wedding cake was the MOST BEAUTIFUL cake I have seen in any photos. She took my simple (unorganized) vision and created a custom cake that was meant for me. I surprised my groom with a custom US Marshal cake that no one wanted to eat because it was a work of art!! I can't tell you how delicious and absolutely perfect everything was. You can't go wrong with Colleen for your cakes. More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire

3 October 2011

I guess I should start by saying that I've never been too much of a wedding cake kinda' girl. You know, the spongy, cement-textured, bland tasting creations from all the weddings. .. before ours!! I was referred to Colleen by my best friend, Morgan, who couldn't say enough about her! Now I'm that girl who can't say enough about Colleen and her cakes! I've referred her to every Bride I know and will continue to refer her! From the cake tasting (which actually turned out to be TWO cake tastings since we had such a long engagement) to the "I can't decide on what the Groom's cake should look like so here is one idea...no scratch that...we want this instead" ;) To the wedding day the only word that comes to mind is Perfection! My 5 layered cake was truly breathtaking and exactly what I had dreamed of. She even made a perfectly shaped coffee-flavored edible Starbucks cup with removable lid for the top of the Groom's Caramel Macchiato cake! Okay, okay, I'll stop now! Colleen, we LOVE your cake!!! :) More...

Reviewed on WeddingWire