Buttercup bake shop

Sent cupcakes to niece while she was staying in NYC at a hotel. She loved the cupcakes, said they were delicious. Thank you!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

The delicious treats that assaulted me as I walked in the door, was almost more than I could handle. Unlike some places, these cakes tasted as good as they looked. I only took two cupcakes with me that day, but I know I'll come back and satisfy my sweet teeth with other treats! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

I went to this bakery on the recommendation of a good friend. I have bought banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery and I must say with no malice intended they are neck and neck in taste. I bought a 32 oz banana pudding from Buttercup and was not disappointed. I will be a return customer to both . More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

This place satisfies my sweet tooth with almost everything available. Delivery is on time and pick ups are ready to go just as quickly. I'd order from this spot more often if cavities were non existent in this world! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Was mighty impressed with their cheesecake.It wasy wife's birthday and I bought her a slice of cheesecake.Quite steeply priced at around 12 dollars but it tasted out of the world. Its right across the next street of Hilton Midtown.They seemed to have a nice seating and good breakfast being served although we couldn't make use of it. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

The lemon cupcake was amazing and the red velvet cheesecake was so rich !! The staff was very helpful with helping us pick out the best dessert

Reviewed on Google Maps

I came here with some friends that love how I met your mother, since this is the bakery Victoria from the show worked at. We had to get cupcakes but also tried the banana pudding . The cupcakes were great with the frosting being the best part but the banana pudding was FIRE! By far the best item in the store. Fun place to stop if you are a fan of the show or just in the neighborhood. They accept credit and debit cards. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

I was craving some cake and took a whim on this bakery and ordered on ubereats...BABY THAT CAKE WAS MOIST!! Big ole slices that I had to save for later! This was my first time ever trying Buttercup but they know what’s up! Just delicious, you will not be disappointed. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

A great spot to stop for dessert after a show given the location. The cupcakes are pretty good, but it's the frosting is definitely the best part. They have a few other treats, cookies and brownies and the like. Prices are good for the area and the staff is friendly and helpful. They even have nice to go containers to keep you cupcakes looking nice. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Tried their lemon raspberry cupcake!! Was absolute delight!! Loved the suggestion by the lady there :) must try if you’re around there!

Reviewed on Google Maps

More than you expect. Red Velvet cupcake and cookie are delicious!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Very nice little bakery. Will definitely return every time I come to New York

Reviewed on Google Maps

My niece and I topped off our fun day together by finding Buttercup Bake Shop. Shanta gave us excellent service! The cupcakes were so very moist, filled with flavor and perfect guilt-free size so you can eat more than one at a time. Which I did and would do again. The triple chocolate cookie was soft and rich. I ate that later and wished I had bought more for the next day. We will return! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Really friendly place and the oreo cup cake was beautiful! Recommend!

Reviewed on Google Maps

The girls were pleasant there. It was empty on a Saturday night so I took my time and they were helpful when asking questions. They don’t have a TON of options but enough if you are just looking for something sweet. I got a cookie dough cupcake. Very moist cake. Good experience! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

This place is amazing! Do yourself a favor and try the little parfaits of heaven! The cookie dough brownie custard one is probably the best dessert I have ever had. The cupcakes were moist and delicious. My favorite was the salted caramel and cookie dough cupcake. The staff was fabulous answering questions and giving recommendations and I will be a regular here! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Wonderful and delicious cupcakes! They look really lovely and taste like a piece of heaven ;)
Definitely coming back!

Reviewed on Google Maps

My cupcake was just a tad dry but the flavors were great. The woman behind the counter was delightful. :) I'd go back again.

Reviewed on Google Maps