Bay City Restaurant
Midway, Pennsylvania
(136)
Midway, Pennsylvania
(136)
136 customer reviews
Craig R.
Had lunch there today -- great crab cake! Sat at the bar and the service was excellent!
Reviewed on Yelp
Brandon Ross
Stopped in for dinner while in the area for a function. Staff was very friendly! I got the Chicken Parmesan for dinner and it was absolutely delicious! Almost couldn’t finish the plate it was so big of a serving! Yum! We’ll be back next year! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lora C.
Great fish restaurant. Love their fried scallops. Look past the tired decor and you will get a great meal.
Reviewed on Yelp
Sandra Snyder Grant Zumbrum
the best shrimp salad, still!
Reviewed on Facebook
Roger Anderson
Good food, attentive service
Reviewed on Facebook
Michele Pecora Lane
we like the all u can eat crab leg Sundays... And I like their blue cheese dressing I buy it by the quart.
Reviewed on Facebook
Kelby Miller
The cucumber Collins drink was delicious!
Reviewed on Facebook
Michele Weiss
We absolutely loved this restaurant! The waiter was one of the nicest and best waiters I think we’ve ever had. he’s been there for quite a while and he knows what he’s doing and he made our evening a memorable one along with the delicious food. We will go there again. I would highly recommend this restaurant. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Denise Wible
The Crab Imperiel was so good!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Faye Rinker
The food was awesome! definitely will be back
Reviewed on Facebook
Robert Stein
Enjoy our meal service great and prices are good for want you get
Reviewed on Facebook
Christine Kinkade
awesome polite server fast service and great food
Reviewed on Facebook
Mindy Weakley
Never been disappointed when I eat here their food is amazing great music on the deck and the owner put on an apron and helped out the staff because they were so busy Last night.
Reviewed on Facebook
William Hudson
The atmosphere was great and the Seafood Nachos are delicious.
Reviewed on Facebook
Joshua Dunham
great food great prices it was amazing
Reviewed on Facebook
Teia Mathias
It was okay wouldn’t come here often....
Reviewed on Facebook
Jasmine Runkel
awesome food and good service
Reviewed on Facebook
Duke Yingling
Always great people, servers and food!
Reviewed on Facebook
Joe M.
I have lived in Hanover for 45 years, this is simply the only place for great seafood
Reviewed on Yelp
Sarah Marie
Food is always good. Went to a Comedy show and only complaint was the long wait for drinks ( waited 50 mins for first drink) recommend more wait staff and putting a cash bar inside ballroom
Reviewed on Facebook
Desirae Tyson
Awesome place... waitress was great
Reviewed on Facebook
Andrew S.
I Have been coming here for 30 plus years. The service has never changed. Inconsistent is an understatement. ( Really slow to perfect) food quality has not changed. It has always been good to great. Prices are with in reason. I can honestly say that there is nothing on the menu that I tried and didn't like. In thirty++ years I tried everything more than once. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Melody M.
I attended a party last evening in one of their private rooms. The staff could not have been more attentive or accommodating, and always with a smile or a kind word. The food was fresh, prepared well and plentiful. Being in this business myself, I was pleased to see their attention to details. . . crisp linens, polished silver and not a smudge on a hurricane globe to be seen - Well Done! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jules L.
I had their wonderful shrimp special. Portion was huge for $13. The blue cheese dressing on my salad was extra lumpy with roguefort sooo yummy. Bar tender was friendly and attentive. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Rebecca Wilson
yes! it’s delicious yummy seafoods specially the Alaska legs crabs and oysters raw and cooked this is my favorite restaurant in Hanover, they’re employees are awesome, their always help you out right away and beautiful smiles! ! Merry Christmas and happy new year everyone’s!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
John Grim
food and service could not have been better
Reviewed on Facebook
Sandra Mansfield
The food and service are always great
Reviewed on Facebook
Lisa LaRay Brown-Stanton
Visited this fine restaurant for high school banquet tonight the service was superb. The food was delicious and seasoned to perfection. Overall great experience. I give it 5 ⭐️ The Maitre D was warm , friendly and very accommodating to our unique situation!!! I highly recommend Bay City Restaurant and Seafood . More...
Reviewed on Facebook
S B.
Enjoyed a nice lunch here today. Hot bowl of crab soup. Perfect for this rainy day. Delicious crab cake as well.
Reviewed on Yelp
Barb McClain
It’s a great place to eat �
Reviewed on Facebook
John Wentz
Great service. Plenty of good food. Ok
Reviewed on Facebook
Sheila Moran
I just hosted my sons wedding I could not be more pleased with the evening and the food was delicious. I am so thankful for everything Baycity provided it exceded all expectations if you are looking to host an event please consider our local restaurant that I can’t give enough credit for superb service and food it they made this a night to remember I can’t thank you enough
Reviewed on Facebook
Sharon Hillenbrand McCloud
Saturday was our first time eating at Bay City and the whole experience was just wonderful. Service and food were amazing thank you Harmony for being an outstanding waitress. We will be back and will be telling out friends to go here. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
DaveLisa Schmidt
Always a great time and spectacular food at Bay City. Everyone there is friendly and professional too! Superb customer service.
Reviewed on Facebook
Mike L.
Food was great. I'm from Annapolis, AKA crabtown and very picky about my crab cakes. Almost all lump meat, seasoned perfectly, old Bay at the ready, I was in heaven. Waitress was attentive and kept everyone's glass full and was quite cheery. Price was very reasonable for lunch. Definitely will be back next time in town. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Mike Stoops
Quiet dinner on the deck, nice breeze, cool music and terrific food. That's a typical Bay City Restaurant experience for us. Been going there a long time and recommend to anyone! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Annette Hufnagle Colgan
Really good food. Great service. Nice atmosphere
Reviewed on Facebook
Eddie Vales
Good food, good atmosphere, good service, very nice place to eat at. We drive from Eldersburg Md to eat here.
Reviewed on Facebook
Sandy Vales
Really enjoyed our experience. Great food and great service.
Reviewed on Facebook
Ken Shoemaker
I called yesterday morning and received some info about the auce package. Myself and my wife and friends met there and had a great time. Service was good and the food was good as well. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Carrie Cassetta
Great Family owned restaurant! Wonderful people to work for!
Reviewed on Facebook
Kelly Faircloth-Lady
Never a disappointment. Staff and food is always spectacular!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Amy McElwain Glenn
Ate here for the first time tonight for my husbands birthday. Cream of crab soup, crab cakes, ultimate feast, surf n turf all phenomenal! Will definitely be returning! Even got a free piece of cheese cake for the birthday boy. And that was excellent too! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Wayne Kuhn
They were 10 of us in our group The service is very good, the waitress handle everything with efficiency. Everything was serve timely and all the food looks really good. I had stuffed shrimp and they were excellent along with a cup of clam chowder which was very good. No one had any complaints and I want to sing them join them selves had a good time and the food was very nicely served and prepared very nicely. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Tommy Knight
Awesome food. Love going there This is not fast food but worth waiting for. If you like seafood this is where you want to come. Burgers are awesome
Reviewed on Facebook
Sandra Snyder Grant Zumbrum
For many years they have served a shrimp salad bowl that is delicious. I have it every time I go!
Reviewed on Facebook
Mary Archer Oakes
We held our son's wedding rehearsal dinner here on Friday, in a private banquet room. It was a very lovely time. The food was great and the room was tastefully decorated, creating a wonderful atmosphere. Thanks especially to the very attentive staff. Bay City is my favorite restaurant in Hanover so I was especially happy with our banquet experience. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sean Ruddlesden
It was amazing food and Monday night was shrimp night and it was fanastic went there last night the waitress were good and the food was amazing recommend to go there again
Reviewed on Facebook
SP F.
Had lunch there on a Saturday. The service was great. Not slow. We did not wait a long time. The place was busy.I got the steamed clams and my wife had the oyster stew. Side note, oyster stew is usually made with milk, butter, oysters, some of their liquor and some salt and pepper. Once it is in the cup or bowl, the butter will float to the top. That is what butter does. They also put a little old bay seasoning in theirs. My wife thought it was wonderful. My clams were cherry stones and were plump and full of flavor.We both got a burger. They grind their own hamburger meat and mix in some of the trimmings from the steaks that they also cut there on the premises. Needless to say, this makes a great burger.Served on a poppy seed and sesame seed roll that was toasted.Worth the trip, we drove up from Baltimore, and we can easily see ourselves coming back.This is a family run restaurant and it shows. Nothing cookie cutter about the place and that is what makes it good. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Penny Kinkade
The server and hostess were so persoanable (a complete joy and pleasure to interact with) and our glasses were never empty! The service was awesome and the food was delish! We will definitely be returning ❤️ More...
Reviewed on Facebook
