Loading...

Please wait ...

About

Bespoke catering by Tutoni's: Creative spins on traditional standards rooted in our region’s abundant agricultural scene and crafted from scratch.
Whether it’s a sit down family style meal in our farm to table Italian restaurant, an intimate chef's table, or a stand up mingling event off-site, let’s get together and create an experience that you and your guests will remember.

Reviews (184)

Leave a review
B

Brenda G.

10 September 2019

Food was excellent. I had the potato gnocchi. Great gravy sauce with ribs. Wine was excellent also.

M

Mark M.

6 September 2019

We had a variety of the Tapas and they were delicious and unique! I enjoyed the selection of spirts on tap. The staff was very friendly and service was excellent!

M

Maury H.

3 September 2019

I had the grilled shrimp with pasta. It was one of the best dishes that I ever had. The shrimp were grilled perfectly, and the pasta sauce was delicious.

M

Mike D.

19 August 2019

This review is long overdue. Tutoni's is hand down, the best Italian in the area. I lived in the NYC area most of my life, and have been in York, PA for 4.5 years, and I have not had a bad meal here... I have not even had an average meal here. Everything is exceptional.You will not find stereotypical faux "Italian" dishes drowned in red sauce and cheese here.Pasta is homemade, ingredients are fresh, and dishes are created in such a way where you can truly taste the various flavors. Service is friendly and professional. Thank you Tutoni's for doing Italian cuisine the right way, and creating a truly memorable culinary experience. More...

D

Daniel Barker

4 August 2019

great food...great drinks...great bartenders! what else could I ask for!?

F

Food Review Crew ..

29 July 2019

Had a great experience here! Girlfriend and I have been wanting to try this place for a while and it was definitely worth it! Pork belly appetizer was very good! Pasta mains that we got, linguine and the raviolis were darn good! Can definitely tell the pastas are made fresh/in house. We'll be back! More...

S

Syd S.

27 July 2019

Just had my first visit to Tutoni's this evening. Extremely fresh and you can taste it. Pasta, sauce, meat, just fantastic. Nothing out of a can here!! Service from Vanessa was exceptional. The flow of the meal was perfect. Would highly recommend Tutoni's. More...

T

Taylor Burch

26 July 2019

Stopped in for dinner this evening a bit on a whim...only to realize -after- ordering that they were close to closing. Our server was phenomenal, extraordinarily pleasant and kind and didn't even bring up the closing time to us. We never once felt rushed or out of place, and even at the end of the night our food was still fantastic. The cocktail menu has creative fun drinks alongside sure-bet classics, the style and presentation of everything is impressive, and the service we received was stellar. The menu is diverse enough to present options for most diets, without being overwhelming. I could not recommend this place enough! More...

D

Deanna Taylor

4 July 2019

The food was fabulous!!! Highly recommend!!!

B

Beth M.

4 July 2019

Someone at work suggested this place and they were absolutely correct!!!  Wonderful food, wine and atmosphere - will definitely go there again when I'm back in town.  You NEED to try this place !!!!

L

Lisa D.

30 June 2019

The food & service are always phenomenal. The cocktails are unique & delicious. And we love the tiny desserts...just the right size to top off an excellent meal.

M

Mohammed K.

19 June 2019

Place is always great food is just right and service is excellent!!!!!!! One the the better dinning Experiences in York. Drinks are also superb and prices spot on !!! You'll really enjoy this place we always do More...

J

Jess S.

13 June 2019

Exceptional food and first rate service. Our go to place for sharing with friends and introducing them to the great things York has to offer.

L

Lauren L.

2 June 2019

I've been to Tutoni's many times and have always been impressed.The bolgenese is super flavorful and I enjoy it. If you want something so flavorful and unique, please order the potato gnocchi. It has to be one of my favorite dishes I have ever ordered anywhere. They should highly consider adding it to the permanent menu because it is just that good.Nice wine selection, great speciality cocktails.The tapas bar upstairs is also very tasteful and great for sharing with friends (or for yourself!!!) More...

A

A S.

8 May 2019

Lovely cozy restaurant with a great bar. Menu is Northern Italian inspired using fresh produce from locally sourced farms. Signature dishes include Pasta Bolognese and Pomedoro, lamb shank and mussels. More...

M

Michelle A.

4 May 2019

Food is amazing!! I had the chicken, hubby had the steak and we were both truly satisfied. Mashed potatoes...superb!

L

Lynda G.

3 May 2019

We love Tutonis.  Food, atmosphere and service is always excellent.  Bussell sprout appetizer is my 12 year olds favorite!

T

Tiffany S.

20 April 2019

Had a wonderful dinner experience.The hosts and waiter was very nice and helpful.Was our first time there, we took my father n law for hes birthday.We also took our 1 year old little girl along. Was very accomadating to seating us. I did call to make reservations as well, very easy to do. Everyone enjoyed everything. The food was amazing, loved the homemade pasta.The mushroom bruschetta was amazing and I got the shrimp with pasta and tomato sauce. Very delicious, cant wait to go back and try more. More...

M

Maura McGrath

14 April 2019

While in town on business, my colleagues and I ate at Tutoni's for dinner and very much enjoyed ourselves! The selection of wines was out of this world, and the food was so deliciously rich. The smaller room and darker ambiance reflects the trendiness of the restaurant. We also absolutely loved the farm to table concept! More...

S

Shawna M.

3 April 2019

We happened upon this place and were blown away by how fantastic it was. All their pastas are made in-house, and their foods are all locally sourced. We had amazing brussels sprouts to start, with pear cosmos. Then a cheese tray that was amazing. I then had plain spaghetti and meatballs - there was nothing plain about it! My friend had the gnocchi with spare ribs - best gnocchi she's ever tried (and she's from Jersey!). Great decor, small and upscale. We lucked out without reservations, but it was a Tuesday night. More...

K

Katie A.

31 March 2019

Delicious pasta, great wine selection, and super cute desserts (served in a tall shot glass for individual serving) all wrapped up in a gorgeous atmosphere. The caccio e pepe and the bolognese were our favorites. More...

S

Steve M.

23 March 2019

Love love love the food at this place! I would highly recommend this restaurant for the ambiance and the food! Service is always great and the food is even better! Parking can be a challenge in down town but I am willing to walk for the food here More...

H

Heather V.

15 March 2019

Great ambiance.  Service was excellent...tapas good.  Beverages very good and dinner was amazing ..But the best part of the night... the King George!

F

FirstName L.

12 March 2019

Excellent Italian eatery.  Very interesting drinks too.  Try the Brussels Sprouts Starter, also the Cheese and Meat app was great too.We all enjoyed our dinners, Duck was excellent, the Rigatoni pasta dishes tasted great.Easily worth a repeat visit! More...

J

Jack J.

26 February 2019

A York Classic. Very upscale and worth the wait on a Saturday night.

R

Rod Seifert

23 February 2019

What a great experience. Not only was the food delicious, but the service and cocktails were equally as good. Definitely a great spot to collect thoughts with someone or just to hang out. Excellent vibe throughout the entire establishment. More...

K

kate t.

7 January 2019

Very good homemade fresh pasta.  First floor is cozy and inviting.  Second floor has the bar and is much louder.  We try to eat here when we're on York; a nice addition.

M

Molly B.

26 December 2018

My husband and I were in on a Saturday a few weeks ago and things just seemed off service-wise, not our usual experience there. For one thing, we opted to go from 4pm - 6pm because the website said that even on Saturdays, they have a cocktail menu with specials during that time period. When we asked what the specials were, we were told that was only Mon - Fri. We were disappointed, but didn't want to push, so we just ordered the cocktails and tapas we wanted. Also, it seemed like even though they don't open until 4pm, the staff was still prepping things and setting up and so it took awhile to get our order taken. Once we were settled in and had ordered, service and drinks were wonderful. I love their cocktail list and the tapas items were delicious. We will definitely be back! More...

L

Laurie Terese

20 December 2018

Our food was excellent! Only downgraded to 4 stars due to extra loud atmosphere. So loud that it was hard to hear across the table. Too many hard surfaces so sound really travels. Best spinach salad I've ever had. Mushroom cannelloni was insanely tasty! Please carry a domestic � beer since my bf really wanted a Budweiser and couldn't get one. More...

L

Lynda Sheckells Stout

20 December 2018

The best! First, downstairs in the King George SpeakEasy...then upstairs for a fabulous dinner. Toni welcomed us, took the time to chat with us, and Dylan served us with a smile! We can't wait to go back, and next time, make it to the 3rd floor! We will be back...and often. Tutoni's is our new favorite York City restaurant! More...

T

Terrence Freeman

20 December 2018

Well first let me just say that I live in New York City and being that my great friend @ShaneDeGaray told me about this place. He shared with me on his FB LIVE a plate of the So I will give you five stars and I have not even in there yet but I will see you soon ladies and gentlemen! More...

J

Jasmine Hirt

20 December 2018

You have amazing food! Thank you so much for such a great dinner!

D

Dorothy Fabie Negash

20 December 2018

My daughter and I enjoyed a wonderful evening there on Thursday. Ambience on main floor, where we dined, was excellent. Food was beyond amazing. Fresh and full flavored. Dessert melted in my mouth. According to my daughter she could have existed for the rest of her life on the bread we received to start off the meal. To top it all off we had the most professional , attentive, and handsome server there. How do I know this, he is my son, Zeg! More...

K

Krissy Whiski

20 December 2018

The pasta is delicious. Great service from Pete, he was so attentive, and we had our 3 year old and 9 year old with us. He helped keep the kids happy by making suggestions for their picky tastebuds, and even had their food out first. Also have to add that the upstairs tapas bar has such good brussel sprouts and the best cocktails in York! This place is certainly a gem. More...

M

Mark Gajdosik

20 December 2018

I can not express enough how amazing both the meal and the service that we experienced was. It was our first time there but will not be the last. I can count on one hand the amount of times I have had a meal that tasted as amazing as that meal. The food was out of this world! I tip my hat to all who made that experience ! More...

M

Marisa Donnelly

20 December 2018

Our party of 6 made reservations for a late Valentine's Dinner. We were treated like royalty by @mandyschriver! The restaurant is nice and our food was amazing- (6 different dishes were ordered)! The cocktails were freshly made, appetizers were perfectly sized, and the desserts topped off a fantastic meal. I can not wait to go back. Check out the Speakeasy room if you just want to stop for drinks. It's cozy! More...

K

Kathy O'Toole

20 December 2018

Tried out another one of the restaurants on my #YorkYummies list last night... we decided to go Italian! I liked the atmosphere a lot... very old world Italy feel inside! And the food was pretty good. For an appetizer, we had a charcuterie board, and for dinner, we went with a couple of their classic dishes... I had the bolognese and my brother had the Bucatini & Meatballs. Our waitress was very friendly and later on in the evening once it slowed down, she shared some of the history of the restaurant and its owners with us. Did you know that the name of the restaurant comes from the owners who are a married couple named Tony (husband) and Toni (wife).... get it, Tutoni's... two Tony's? Mangia Mangia! � � More...

T

Teesh Thompson

20 December 2018

Food-excellent!
Wait staff- professional
Alcohol- great

Have been there twice and both times food was excellent!

My only complaint is the music. It is way to loud for dinner. I can’t hear my waiter or waitress tell me what the specials are. It’s even hard to talk to the people at your own table because the music is so loud.

Turn the music down and it is definitely a five star � from me.
More...

J

Joe Rivellino

20 December 2018

Amazing!! Atmosphere, hosting, dining experience, personal touches.... This is a gem of a find!! Kudos to everyone involved. The staff, chef and owner truly get it!!! Thank you so much. More...

D

Don Burton

20 December 2018

There were three of us and everything was phenomenal!!!! I will definitely revisit if ever find myself back in York, Pa!

A

Amanda Hertzog

20 December 2018

My new favorite restaurant. The potato gnocchi with short rib is perhaps the best dish I've ever eaten. They have the best calamari-- so tender, & the spices on it are phenomenal. Some cocktails are better than others, but the atmosphere & food are absolutely fantastic. We love the waiting staff & bartenders as well. More...

D

Daniel Abramson

20 December 2018

Being from out of town, we only had the pleasure of dining with you ,once, your food is amazing, the effort you’ve put into serving quality meals is commendable, thank you for a great experience, we will be back

A

Alex Kelly

20 December 2018

The food was incredible, great atmosphere, and our waitress was pleasant and knowledgeable. If we had questions she couldn’t answer she went and got it. The only thing stopping us from giving it 5 stars was the condition of the carpet on the 2 staircases. More...

T

Tracy Ng

20 December 2018

Good food and great service but both seating areas at dining room ground floor and upstairs were slightly tight and narrow, Love the bar on 1st floor, great service too. My 1st time at this restaurant. Will come back again. More...

A

Adrienne Williams

20 December 2018

Tutoni's was gracious enough to have a handful of vegan tapas and an entree for a meetup last night. The tapas were AMAZING. We had the flash fried brussel sprouts, white bean hummus with garlic rubbed crostini and baby bok choy in a spicy sauce.. all were delicious and I would highly recommend everything we got.

Would love to see vegan options regularly on the menu. It's so much easier to choose where to eat when you *know* there will be an option for you. Sure, asking if they can accommodate you is fine but when you don't have to do that, choosing where to eat is made easier.
More...

C

Christina Pennington-Caplinger

20 December 2018

Love their pasta but, not the service.

Delicious pasta but, service is very slow. This is the 4th time in a row and I was hoping it would improve.

T

Tara Goodrich

20 December 2018

This is my new favorite downtown spot. The upstairs bar has a wonderful atmosphere, and James is a fantastic bartender.

The tapas are original and oh so delicious!

I will definitely be going back!
More...

D

Deborah L.

2 December 2018

This was our first visit and it was s real treat. Decor and ambiance is amazing.  Service was-friendly attentive.  My husband had the short rib w/gnocchi and I had the sweet onion ravioli with duck confit - delicious! It's a great place for before or after a show downtown.  We are looking forward to the tapas.  Just be aware the stairs are a challenge for those with disabilities. More...

S

Stephanie B.

2 September 2018

Delicious food and the atmosphere is outstanding! Great place for a wonderful dinner with your favorite person or a girls night out!

E

Ella M.

15 August 2018

My husband and I went there tonight and we can't say enough good things about this restaurant. The atmosphere was nice. Our appetizers, entrees and desserts were all great. Our waitress was very patient with us and our dietary restrictions. The manager spoke to us several times as well. We can't wait to go back! More...

D

Darlene C.

6 August 2018

superb... can hardly afford it but top notch. i highly recommend this place

T

Tara Goodrich

5 August 2018

This is my new favorite downtown spot. The upstairs bar has a wonderful atmosphere, and James is a fantastic bartender.

A

Amie S.

27 July 2018

Came in to meet a friend from high school for drinks. It was a cool setting, the bartenders were all fun and friendly. Had a good time I would go back again and try some food.

Z

Zack Cochran

6 July 2018

Farm fresh to table and a very sophisticated atmosphere serving up the best antipasti and entrees that can get you closer to the real Italian coastline than any other mainstream Italian eatery.

M

Mark Ahlers

19 June 2018

This place can be a little on the pricey side but it is worth every penny. The source locally and try to make everything from scratch in house. You can taste the difference. The staff is great and takes good care of you. More...

M

Melissa C.

17 June 2018

Finally had the opportunity to eat here, for a business dinner. Wine selection great,  wait staff knowledgeable,food extremely fresh, to have Italian food accommodate gluten free diet, especially locally to this area, is rare. I will def be back with my family.

R

Robb Graves

4 June 2018

Amazing food, exceptional service. Highly recommend. Atmosphere is unique and enjoyable.

N

N L S.

27 May 2018

Exceptional menu, incredible service, and amazing atmosphere. I love this place. It is not for the typical Yorker...the thrifty spaghetti and meatballs, salad and breadsticks Olive Garden goer. Be prepared to spend some loot on a high quality dinning experience, you won't be disappointed on any level. Here you're investing in your health and our local community by eating higher quality food that has been locally sourced, not lower conscious, big industry agriculture crap, like the big chain restaurants serve everyone. I digress... I simply can't say enough about thIs place. It's in heavier rotation for us. More...

E

Elayne B.

24 May 2018

One of the best meals I've had in a while.  Totally appreciate as well that they have a list of delicious mocktails!  I had the fish of the day which was grouper, husband had buccatini with meatballs.  The grouper was amazing!

P

Peter Hill

18 May 2018

Great atmosphere, went upstairs to the bar area. Bartender was great, highly recommend the house punch. Local produce and handmade pasta made this a definite place I'll be returning to...

B

B K

14 May 2018

Exceptional services, waiter was attentive but not annoying, very informative feedback regarding the food. Wait time was appropriate for what was ordered. Food was excellent, exceeded my expectations. More...

L

Linda L.

5 May 2018

Gave my husband a surprise 70th birthday party at Tutoni's. Twenty four people unanimously agreed that their dinners were fantastic. From the steak to the gnocchi and the ravioli, I heard nothing but rave reviews. The service was excellent, also. Dealing with Amber to plan the event went smoothly and she was there to make sure everything went as planned! More...

C

Christina Pennington-Caplinger

26 April 2018

Love their pasta but, not the service.

M

Mike R.

16 April 2018

Great little restaurant. Authentic Italian food. Took my wife their for her Birthday. The food we had was amazing with the fresh pasta and sauces definitely will be going back! You can tell they take pride in their dishes! As a chef I can appreciate the hard work they put in to their dishes. More...

F

Fuud G.

15 April 2018

Definitely a step up from my average fare. We decided to do some fancy Italian and Tutoni's did not disappoint. Portion sizes were nice, sometimes they aren't in the pricey places. Love the atmosphere, and the check didn't make me break out in a flop sweat. Will definitely be back! More...

S

Scott K.

18 March 2018

Fresh, everything is home made. Wonderful, friendly, smart service who cares about the food. Will definitely be coming back.

J

Jolene T.

11 March 2018

Celebrated my husband's birthday at Tutoni's on Friday night. Everything was lovely! The food was top notch and they had a few little surprises for him. I asked them to pick a special bottle of wine out for him and the choice did not disappoint. Perfect place for a special dinner! More...

T

Terri K.

16 February 2018

Best Calamari in town! We loved the hand made pastas, and the steak was mouth watering.Service was perfect....we will be going back.

D

David F.

6 February 2018

Very nice restaurant with knowledgable staff! Ps a bit chilly upstairs.

B

Brooke K.

9 January 2018

Expensive but worth every penny, you walk in and forget where you are. Great service, great food, great ambiance, great drinks... I could keep going.

B

Bryan R.

25 November 2017

Our go-to for a drink or fine dining in York City.  This gem has led the resurgence of high-end night life in York.  The upstairs wine-bar is super hip with fine wines and creative cocktails. The cuisine is a contemporary takes on Italian comfort food.  Service is decent but could be better for the price.  Fun urban row home meets hand-scraped barn boards ambiance. More...

K

Kristine S.

18 November 2017

Great little Italian place in York. I didn't know York had such little gems. I also had grilled cheese during grilled cheese week and brought my kids here for a family meal. The server was SO good with handling my kids picky choices. They did an excellent job of making cocktails as well. A little pricey but I'd say it's worth it if you are looking for an exceptional place to dine in York. More...

J

Jacqueline Bortner

11 November 2017

Birthday dinner with my son this evening. The lamb, rib eye and scallops were all delicious!!! Love the atmosphere and fabulous service!!!

J

Jessica D.

4 November 2017

Tutoni's is absolutely amazing! If you need a restaurant to take your significant other for a special date night or anniversary this is the place you should go! Super fresh ingredients, staff is friendly, the artwork on the walls is great. I can't wait to return! More...

P

Pinky C.

1 November 2017

LOVED this place so much. We went for dinner upstairs at the bar. The atmosphere was definitely romantic and quiet. We had such a good time there because the staff was so friendly and recommended some wines that went with our food that night. Our favorite was the confit potatoes. The pasta was cooked to perfection, not too soft, not too hard. We also had the steak here which was phenomenal. The wines paired our food so well and we had a delightful evening. More...

T

Travis Hiden

22 October 2017

Our waiter Mike, and the food, made our anniversary perfect! Mike was very knowledgeable and the food was great. The atmosphere made it a truly special occasion. After dinner, we enjoyed drinks at The King George. Thank you for a memorable night! More...

E

Eric N.

28 September 2017

Stopped for a couple drinks and some small plates at the upstairs bar, service was fantastic, really great craft cocktails and tapas choices! Can't wait to go back for a full dinner, menu looked great! More...

F

Frank A Splain Jr

21 September 2017

EXCELLENT!! A First Time Visit CLASS-A All The Way Atmosphere-Food-Customer Service! Also HATS OFF To "ZEG" Our Waiter EXCELLENT Job!!

N

Nikki Case

14 September 2017

Emily made us the most amazing whiskey sour in King George! I haven't been here before, but James upstairs ..and Emily downstairs..make me want to come back. Thank you!! Great food, drinks, and people! More...

M

Melissa Imrich Lumsargis

16 August 2017

Excellent anniversary night sampling wines and talking with the sommelier! Loved hearing his travel experiences and how he picks the wines! Can't wait to go again!

D

Dellas Edmisten

24 July 2017

Tutoni's continuously delivers a total culinary experience with a very course. It is present with the staff, the chef and the deserts! Farm to table is a delightful concept, but delivering it is a commitment to the customer. Well done! More...

B

Béatrice Picavet

28 June 2017

Un restaurant très cosi avec une très bonne cuisine et un excellent accueil !! De plus nous avons eu l'agréable surprise d'avoir une serveuse parlant français !!

D

Douglas Knight

24 June 2017

Favorite place. Favorite place. Favorite place. Food... amazing. Atmosphere... wonderful. Owners....beautiful people. Experience... memorable. You come to York, you must visit Tutoni's. More...

B

Britney S.

18 June 2017

Went for Fathers Day. It was a specialBrunch menu with signature cocktails. Everything was fantastic. We tried their French toast, ricotta pancakes, bacon, potato gratin, and beef rib hash with the house punch, Bloody Mary and the "Dad Jokes" cocktail. Service was perfect and friendly. We made reservations which they manage through Yelp which was convenient. Even got a chance to go to the upstairs bar and taste different wines. I'll definitely be back to try their dinner menu or just to catch a drink upstairs as it's that warming. More...

R

Rich T.

12 June 2017

We had a thoroughly enjoyable 'date night' experience at Tutoni's - our server was friendly and eager to make certain that we enjoyed our meals, which we did. When deciding on which wine to choose, we were offered the option of sampling a few, which we also did - very nice. Tutoni's will remain in our 'rotation' of special night destinations. More...

A

Alyssa S.

5 June 2017

I adore this place. One of the very best restaurants in York PA. Get any pasta dish off the dinner menu and you'll love this place too!

J

John Mervine

27 May 2017

Fantastic Tour of Italy. Food and wine were spectacular, paired perfectly.

C

Corey Allen Carden

23 May 2017

Excellent food. Excellent drinks, and cheaper than we thought!

D

Dina T.

17 May 2017

The word was that there was nothing to do in York. But that was so wrong. York was a little foodie enclave. Tutoni had some excellent Elite reviews and that always gets my attention. The atmosphere is cozy & sexy. Our server was attentive, knowledgeable and overall just delightful. For drinks we had the Purple Rain & The Saint and they were both epic, slow sipping goodness. As an appetizer the Spring Pea Bruchetta was incredible, fresh, complex and flavorful. Our mains were highly memorable. We had the Octopus Jalapeno pasta & the Branzino. I'll say this, nothing could be improved upon. Everything was just right! Can't wait to return. More...

J

John G.

29 April 2017

Tried this place for the first time as a date night with my beautiful wife.  The atmosphere was delightful and the food was also wonderful.... especially the shrimp polenta appetizer!  The service was quite accommodating even when we asked for something not normally at the bar.  My wife had the ravioli and she absolutely loved it. More...

K

Kelly Breneman

21 April 2017

My husband and I have been here two times, and we will continue to come back. The atmosphere is very relaxing and romantic; perfect for date nights. The service is great, and I feel we didn't wait long for our food/drinks/check. We did, however, go on week nights both times. The food is amazing! It tastes fresh and is presented very nicely. Both times I picked something I was unfamiliar with, and was not disappointed. � More...

S

Stephanie Hunter-White

11 April 2017

We were enticed into this restaurant simply by Google and It was absolutely wonderful!! I had a simple baby lettuce salad with marinated cauliflower, toasted pine nuts and Grilled Jumbo Shrimp...Oustanding!! Simple and Elegant flavors that blended perfectly with the French Chardonnay I'd ordered. The only complaint I had was that they didn't serve their homemade bread with Lunch. We will definitely be back!! Recommend it Highly!! More...

P

Patrick M.

9 April 2017

I'm newer to york dining and this place has been good both times.  A little pricey but we knew thy going into it.  "Farm to table" usually means a few extra bucks per plate.Everyone at out table enjoyed there food. More...

C

Charlotte Albert

8 April 2017

Atmosphere, excellent service, and phenomenal food! We will be back soon. Thank you for a lovely dining experience.

C

Charles S.

7 April 2017

Went yesterday for dinner before a performance at the Strand-Capital Theater which is about 100 feet away. Great pre-theater location. Our food was suburb and the service could not have been better. It's a small venue with a real feel of dining in Italy. I agree with the previous comment about the small amount of wine served on the "by-the-glass" menu: it's probably no more than 2 ounces. We usually order a bottle of wine and finish it off through appetizers and entrees. But I was taking meds and refrained so my wife ordered just a glass. I'd have knocked it off in one swallow. Too stingy a portion. But overall a delightful meal. More...

J

Joe Martinoni

2 April 2017

Brilliant. Excellent service, delicious food. Successful farm to table dining.

K

Kayla B.

13 March 2017

This was my first time having dinner in York...Tutoni's food was perfect, and the staff knew the menu inside and out! I can't wait to come back again!

T

Tim Raio

3 March 2017

Excellent food and ambience. Staff strives to make your dining experience special. One recommendation - serving size for the entree could have been a bit larger.

D

Deb Althoff

25 February 2017

Food & service was exceptional! Will definitely go back!

A

Abeer Srouji Allen

22 February 2017

Beyond impressed. Excellent service, exceptional food, beautiful venue. Was my 1st visit but will not be my last.

B

Bre S.

21 February 2017

Tutoni's is one of my favorite places in York. The food, beverage selection, service, and environment are phenomenal. This place is a great example of people taking York to the next level. Whether having an intimate dinner in the dining room, or girls night out at the TT Bar, the staff always makes sure to take care of you! They are also very helpful when pairing wines and cocktails with dishes! Make sure to request Lauren when dining, she's the best! More...

K

Ken Hoyler

18 February 2017

Enjoyed the Bucattini and Meatballs very much. The downstairs dinning area was very lovely and the waiter was good. Would have given them 5 stars but for the fact that in our group of 8 we received 6 meals together but the last 2 arrived a good bit later. Waiting to eat until they received their meals ment the other 6 were a little cooler than they should have been. More...

R

Ramesh S.

15 February 2017

One of the best farm to table restaurants I have eaten at. Great evening. Amazing cocktails, food and ambiance.

R

Rachel D.

15 February 2017

One of the best meals I've had in York. Came with my fiancé for Valentine's Day and we shared a winter squash bruschetta appetizer which was so tasty and also quite a large portion size for a low price! Then he had Sardinian gnocchi which had a unique and lovely flavor while I had the Chilean sea bass which was cooked perfectly with a slightly seared and crispy crust. We finished with a homemade cheesecake which had a nice texture and pleasant flavor. More...

F

Frank P.

15 February 2017

The food was delicious! We went there for Valentine's Day and everything we had was so good and hot! It's been a long time that I have Had food served toMe still steaming hot. Although I'm giving 5 stars I do recommend that the servers check on their customers more. We waiting for almost an hour for our food but it was worth waiting for ! More...

M

Mallory K.

15 February 2017

Bomb hand crafted food. Made with love. Always outstanding. Lack many vegetarian and vegan options though.... I always have to get the same dishes usually 1 or 2 to choose from, but of course they are amazing. Since I come so often, I'd love more variety. More...

K

Kim Lien

13 February 2017

Our son lives in York and invited us for dinner at Tutoni's. We were treated like royalty by Mandy and our server, Amber. The restaurant is lovely and our food was amazing! P.s. The pear cocktail topped with cinnamon was amazing!!! More...

K

Ken M.

12 February 2017

It was delicious. I enjoyed the pasta and meatballs. Interesting menu. I would like to go back soon.

G

George K.

11 February 2017

I can't say enough. Great staff, wonderful food and a terrific atmosphere. Their wine is on point and perfectly paired with their entrees. A wonderful addition to downtown York. More...

K

Kristopher Accardi

11 February 2017

Service was friendly and server knew the menu, made great recommendations. Food was delicious, and atomsphere was relaxing. Had a dinner meeting there with some colleagues, and Tutoni's provided the perfect atomsphere. More...

N

Nikki Brandt

5 February 2017

Great experience as always. The Bolognese was amazing. Drinks were yummy. We brought some friends from Harrisburg and they loved it. Thanks for a great evening!

T

Tracy Ziebarth Asah

4 February 2017

Lauren gave us excellent service & the ravioli was to die for, my first visit was wonderful...will definitely be back

C

Cheryl Epp

4 February 2017

It was absolutely a wonderful dining experience! Our waiter gave us the best service and was very knowledgeable. It was the best service I think I've ever had without being in a snobby environment. The food was fantastic! Very impressive and we will be back! More...

A

Ali B.

1 February 2017

We had a great time at a local restaurant tonight--We took a friend out to Tutoni's for her surprise birthday dinner there. Not only was our server, Emily more than accommodating, but the food was amazing! I have a food allergy and a lot of restrictions and she made sure I got exactly what I wanted!! They brought our cake (which they kept in back for us) out with the candles lit, and everything was perfect. I'm so very impressed. Thank you for the fabulous service. More...

M

Mallory Marie

1 February 2017

Best restaurant in York by a milli. Appreciate how they support small, local farmers, and put love into every single drink and dish. Go Tutoni's. Only thing I would recommend is more vegan options! � More...

B

Barry Schmidt

31 January 2017

Best place in York. Great people great food!!!!!!!!�����

B

Brittany Gracey

30 January 2017

The wine bar upstairs and atmosphere is wonderful. We had an enjoyable adult night out.

R

Rhada H.

21 January 2017

Wonderfully authentic farm to table cuisine in York City. Valet service. Cozy atmosphere. Engaged owners. Lovely wait staff. Interesting cocktails and a diverse menu. Three floors that cater to a variety of tastes and appetites; and, a fourth coming soon! My party of four will definitely return. I would highly recommend this restaurant for a lovely romantic night out or for a group of friends who enjoy great food and drink. More...

A

Adrienne Williams

20 January 2017

Tutoni's was gracious enough to have a handful of vegan tapas and an entree for a meetup last night. The tapas were AMAZING. We had the flash fried brussel sprouts, white bean hummus with garlic rubbed crostini and baby bok choy in a spicy sauce.. all were delicious and I would highly recommend everything we got. More...

M

Marleny Diaz-Gloster

16 January 2017

Farm to table deliciousness. If your in town, a must try! You will not be disappointed.

S

Stephanie Sue

8 January 2017

Atmosphere is great! Food even better! Service fantastic!! Awesome place to enjoy an evening out as a couple, or a group of family or friends! Our drinks and meals were awesome as usual!! More...

M

mollie mollie

4 January 2017

The staff, ambiance, cocktails and of course the food was impeccable. As a first time it left a lasting impression. Will definitely return.

J

Joseph E.

2 January 2017

Just had our first meal at Tutoni's and it was outstanding!!! Reasonably priced with a great atmosphere. We will definitely be going back soon!!!      A++

T

Tommy Delauder Jr.

1 January 2017

Great food and drink and good service I would recommend this place.

M

Melanie Ferree-Wurster

31 December 2016

The quality of the food and drinks are exceptional! We love the atmosphere and the staff is very attentive. Thank you Tutoni's for another wonderful experience.

L

Lloyd Akris

31 December 2016

THE FOOD WAS BETTER THAN MY USUAL FAVORITE CARRABBAS!! WISH THERE WERE MORE OPTIONS THE MENU WAS TEENY TINY FOR MY PICKY WIFE WHY DON'T YOU HAVE GARLIC BREAD THOUGH MY WIFE LOVES THE STUFF WOULD REALLY BRING ME BACK

J

John T.

29 December 2016

Had the Burata salad (sp?) appetizer and the black spaghetti with Lobster.   It was fantastic.  Now it was $25 for the entree and $15 for the appetizer, but it was very good.  Service was good and the wine bar is cool (upstairs).   My wife had the Gnocci Alla Romana which she said was ok.  Note it is not typical Gnocci, it was more like a large round base and it was more like Polenta than typical Gnocci. She would give this place a 3 and I would be a 5; thus, the overall a 4. More...

K

Kelly Lawrence Hobbs

29 December 2016

Gnocchi with braised short rib was off the charts!

A

Al H.

28 December 2016

Fantastic!...That says it all!...What wonderful food and staff!...It's starts with a warm and caring owner Toni...She and her staff made our night besides the food being terrific!...The Brussel Sprouts dish with their own sauce on top is a must for the table..In fact I ordered Frutti del Mare as a main dish and they had no problem substituting the Brussels sprouts for the pasta ...It was delicious!...Black Spaghetti with lobster was so good . And for those who are squeamish about black ink pasta; "Get over it"..it's so good...Get over the name , be open to something different! There is a charming "Speak Easy" cocktail room in the basement...Unfortunately it was Closed  but was treated to a tour of the room ...I would go back just to have fun down there! My daughter who lives in this area    Is in love with Tutoni and insisted to treat us to something special for my birthday...Boy was she right  about this place!!!! More...

S

Scott Bradfield

27 December 2016

Little slow to start, though one person for entire upstairs. Food was then awesome and service was also great. This place is now on my rotation

G

Glenn Medice

24 December 2016

Food is fantastic, but it's much more than that. The service is just as good, and the atmosphere brings it all together! It's more than dinner or lunch! Oh and they know their stuff when it comes to wine pairing. More...

M

Matthew P.

17 December 2016

Incredible meal! My wife had a version of chicken marsala and I had the braised short rib gnocchi...both phenomenal! The staff was knowledgeable and friendly...also we took the time to have a pre dinner drink upstairs, highly recommend their scratch cocktails! The owner Toni came around and shared her passion for the business and food with us...can't wait to go back again and again! More...

H

helen b.

28 November 2016

Thoroughly enjoyed dinner there. The food was great, locally sourced if at all possible. Pasta made on premises. And squid ink pasta, very difficult to find outside of certain regions in Italy. The eclectic style, right down to leather aprons on the waitstaff was terrific. I do not know if we caught them on an off night, but we were frustrated by having to repeat our drink orders several times to several people. I really would have liked that glass of Cab when the meal arrived, but it wasn't the end of the world. Since we were there to attend a concert at The Strand, and had expressed our deadline several times, we were concerned when we were down to the 15 minute mark and were stopping anyone we could to get the bill and get out. We will go back, but we will make sure we don't have plans for the rest of the evening, just in case. More...

C

C. Ben P.

24 November 2016

I took my wife here specifically for the gnocchi and when the server tells us about the menu, she regrets to inform us that they ran out of gnocchi.  So that was a bummer.  Otherwise, this might be one of the nicest and most authentic restaurants in all of York. More...

W

William F.

14 November 2016

This place is gorgeous and the food was even better! Service was spot on also. I had the rigatoni Bolognese and if licking the bowl was appropriate in public I would have, this the best Italian I had since Verona, Italy. Yeah its that damn good!

T

Tracy M.

20 October 2016

The atmosphere and vibe at Tutoni's is awesome!  Ive enjoyed both a quiet dinner downstairs and a more relaxed night of drinks and tapas upstairs at the wine bar!  The house made pasta dishes are amazing, and the seasonal bruschetta is ALWAYS delish!  Owners Toni and Tony truly put their heart and soul into this place! More...

A

Ayosike A.

19 October 2016

Their chicken gemilli is divine! Service could have been a bit better considering that we were ordering "to-go" while on a road trip pitstop. I would definitely come back again. More...

E

Erica F.

9 October 2016

Great wine list and drinks in general. There food is a hit or miss. Felt like our muscles were way over salted but entries were delicious. Will def being going back and trying new items!!! More...

C

Chelsea E.

1 October 2016

This place has an amazing ambiance. Their charcuterie and cheese board was amazing and I'm not even a big fan of cheese. The service was good, took some time but we didn't mind. Food was good, my fiancé ordered the bucatini meatball me loved it. I had the lamb paradelle. Noodles were amazing but the lamb was meh. To me. More...

M

Maria S.

30 September 2016

We was visiting the city for a couple of days and, luckily, we was able to find this culinary gem... Excelent service and exceptional ambiance. They proudly serve local produce and have an innovative list of cocktails. I love the decoration of the place. Also, you can appreciate fine arts from local artist while you are dinningMaking all that a five star experience... More...

D

Doug M.

24 September 2016

Great dinner tonight in York, PA. Farm to table with wonderful fish and pasta entrees. The squash soup was fantastic and our server, Santana was the best. She knew of the music group by the same name because her parents liked them. We didn't bother telling her Santana played at our college homecoming concert/dance in 1971! More...

J

Jim H.

22 September 2016

My wife and I have come to Tutonis since their opening. We especially love the upstairs bar as it has a classy and intimate vibe. The food and wine are delicious and the bartenders are top notch, James being the best. More...

L

Lois D.

12 September 2016

Just what York needs...an innovative farm to table restaurant that offers great food adventures.  If you're not up for the full dining delight, try the tapas and craft cocktails in the upstairs bar.  Their wine offerings are varied - something for all wineophiles.  So if you enjoy food and beverage exploration, Tutoni's is the place for you.  You will not be disappointed! More...

M

Michelle C.

1 August 2016

Excellent! The food is fresh, light and perfectly prepared & served. They are worth the price, which really was reasonable. But dont leave without sampling dessert. I would return for that alone! More...

J

Jen P.

10 July 2016

Excellent service and food in an enchanting atmosphere. The staff is exceptionally attentive. There's a sultry and dimly-lit dining room. It feels like you're walking into a rustic castle. But there are many modern elements that will surprise you. Some of the table tops and bar upstairs are made concrete with fig or olive leaves imprinted on them. The menu is impressive and there are some more creative dishes to choose from along with tradition Italian options. They serve seasonal dishes based on what is fresh locally.Go here for romantic, candlelit meals with finer options. Their upstairs tapas bar is very alluring and we can't wait to try it. We ordered: mussels, beet salad, carbonara and some mushroom pasta dish. I loved my goat cheese and golden beet salad. So delicious. My husband raved about his mussels and the carbonara. My mushroom, truffle pasta was very satisfying, but I'll eat a lighter option next time. It was too good to not eat, but very heavy. It came with a poached egg on top and it was quite decadent.Everything was favorable and perfectly seasoned. They make their pasta in house. It was so delicious. They even gave me a cute, free dessert for my birthday. I could choose from 4 tall shot glasses with diverse cakes, creams and mousses.  I chose brownie and chocolate mousse. It was delightful. Went back two weeks later for tapas, was less impressed. Stick with the main menu. It is greater. More...

C

Courtney H.

26 June 2016

I was in York for the first time and Tutoni's was recommended by a local. I'm so happy we went. The food, service, and atmosphere were fantastic. I had one of the best old-fashioneds I've ever had. Enjoyed the salmon tartare and the carbonara bucatini with an excellent blackberry dessert. Would highly recommend for anyone looking for a sophisticated and delicious meal. More...

T

Tracy C.

17 June 2016

Great - take your own tour - wine selection and delicious food. Highly recommend the cheese and charcuterie board.

M

Michael S.

4 June 2016

Wonderful place! Very accommodating to our gluten allergy. Replaced the pasta with rice. I had the truffle dish tonight. My husband had a chicken and sun dried tomatoes. Thank you to Molly for our wonderful service!!! More...

A

Alisha S.

7 May 2016

My fiance and I just visited Tutoni's for the first time for wine and tapas. Our experience was fantastic! The bartender, James, was educated from a master sommelier and was very friendly, helpful, and made some excellent recommendations. All the tapas we ordered were amazing!  Our favorite part may have been the self serve wine machine where we were able to taste many excellent wines! More...

M

Michael B.

29 April 2016

Very fine homemade food. The noodles were perfect the best I ever had. This is a small quite place to eat. The upstairs has a great bar with small food plates. Must try for York PA.

C

Chris S.

24 April 2016

I went on a Saturday night with my wife. Exceptional experience. We sat at the bar upstairs and had a great time. The atmosphere is great with a butcher block bar with mason jar lights. The bar has a special cocktail menu, we tried the King George and PA Club, both were great. We had the Carbonara and the Meatball Bucatini and both were exceptional. If you are looking for an adult, upscale relaxed place, this is it. Bartenders were friendly and made great drinks. More...

E

Elliott M.

26 March 2016

Wonderful service and wonderful food. The dishes were not out of this world, or particularly interesting, but they were yummy and just right for a nice (but not too nice!) night out. We had the Bolgonese and the Chicken Gemeli and were impressed by their quality. We were visiting from out of town and had a great time. Great Sangrias! More...

M

Marvin S.

19 March 2016

Traveling east and choose to stay in York, PA.  Had recommendation to eat at White Rose. Got there and realized it was St. Patrick's Day. Oops! Left with no plan and drove by Tutoni's. I had seen a review on Yelp and though we would give it a try. Awesome. Walked in and found a warm welcome and a very chic upscale restaurant. We were seated and a most memorable meal began. We started with the beet salad, mandolin sliced pink beets with baby yellow beets and dollops of goat cheese.  A mix of spring greens, perfectly dressed accompanied the beets.  BTW Chef does not put salt or pepper on the table. He is that confident in his seasoning profile.  Next we had our entrees. I had the steak, which sound boring but was heavenly. Locally sourced beef cooked perfectly and presented beautifully. My wife had the cannelloni.  Filled tubes of an ethereal ground meat mixture and a great sauce. We ate everything and then had dessert, a frozen chocolate wonder. Run don't walk to this gem of a restaurant and give homage to a fine chef! More...

V

Vivian K.

20 February 2016

Just left Tutoni's on George street in York pa. For restaurant  week They are offering 3 course meals for $40 You could also choose to eat off the menu. The food tonight was AMAZING!!!!!I had both appetizers the leek soup. It was green and luscious. I also had the fried goat cheese salad. Both starters were really great. My main dish was cod over a bed of orzo. The cod was delicate and perfectly cooked laying over a bed of delicate orzo with a hint of briny capers very very enjoyable. For dessert you could choose from tiramisu or the olive oil cake with macerated cherry. You can't go wrong with either one. If you haven't eaten here yet. This little jewel is a must try. Beautiful ambiance and fabulous food. Not to forget our great waitress. She worked hard to make sure our experience was great. She got us to the show on time!!Thank  you Tutonies  job well done!!!!! More...

E

Erik N.

17 February 2016

My evening was perfect. They have a all from scratch kitchen. The waitress was quick to tell me what farm the food came from or the style in which a specific kind of past is made. I'd recommend this restaurant  to anyone. BYOB at the moment. More...

N

Nikki B.

2 February 2016

Finally had an opportunity to eat here and it was fantastic.  I enjoyed the house salad and beef tartare for lunch and both were amazing.  Looking forward to trying dinner here soon! Ambiance and decor are awesome.  Definitely recommend! More...

Y

Yoko N.

17 January 2016

It was the first time dinner at York. Such a great food and service!! We love to come back again.  Just need to bring own wine.

C

Chuck L.

9 January 2016

I've been waiting to write this review for years. York has been looking for an "Italian" restaurant like this for a long time.One with an eye on tradition and a focus on contemporary and local ideas.When I ate there early last year, Tutoni's hadn't hit their stride yet. With two dedicated owners, Tony and Toni, they have put a great eating establishment on the York map.My wife and I ate there tonight and were very impressed with the service, which was outstanding but the food was great too.We started with a Monkfish crudo,Delicious! followed by a Parsnip soup and Ragu Bolognese over house made pasta, Outstanding! Then came a Risotto with truffles, Wonderful! and we finished with Seafood pot pie with several types of fish in a puffed pie shell and an (off the menu) Timpano with a house made marinara sauce dotted with pesto, Spectacular!What a great meal. Thanks for being in York Tu Tony/Toni More...

A

Anthony S.

4 January 2016

Great service, great atmosphere. This is not your quick in and out restaurant. It is a place to spend time and relax. Every course is a must!

P

Patrick B.

29 October 2015

Really excellent dinner before Strand Capitol show. Food, ambiance and service all good. Menu varied and interesting.

L

Lisa M.

21 October 2015

Great find! Delightful waitress, delicious food, great atmosphere and loved the fact they are BYOB - our favorite kind of places but hard to find these days.

C

Christopher C.

13 August 2015

Great time for our date night. York has needed a place like this for many years, thanks for a great experience. We'll be back for sure!

B

Bart R.

4 August 2015

My wife and I really appreciate everything about Tutoni's...the atmosphere, the service, and the food.  It's a wonderful addition to York's downtown.  We went most recently Saturday, July 29.  The waitress (Elise?) was very friendly and professional...and made some great recommendations on appetizers and salads.  We opted for classic pasta dishes, which were both excellent.  Though the restaurant will be getting its liquor license in 90 days we're told, we've really liked the option of bringing our own wine and saving on the total cost.  Unlike another reviewer, we didn't see the BYOB as a "glass half empty."  Tutoni's has some exciting plans for the restaurant in the coming months when they do get their liquor license, and we look forward to continuing to support this great venue.  The owners have high standards and innovative ideas for a restaurant we feel is one of the best in York.  We'll be return customers as long as they're serving! More...

S

Sandy D.

28 July 2015

Love! Love!! Love!!!  this place! Attention to detail is evident from the moment you enter the restaurant.From the charmingly eclectic decor to the attentive staff to the incredibly original menu, Tutonis hits the mark on every level.  Our meal was wellprepared and excellently presented.  Every course was remarkable, thefarm to table freshness evident in every delicious bite. Kudos to the talented chef and owners.  You have something special here!I will return again and again.  Sandy D More...

P

Paul K.

11 July 2015

Dined there 3 times for dinner. All 3 times have been an amazing experience. My wife and I got to talk with the owner and they are doing some really awesome things, especially for a city like York. Highly recommended for someone looking for some fine dining and an incredible and delicious meal. They're in the process of getting their liquor license and have some cool new expansions coming. This is the place to go when you want a good date night, exceptional experience, and awesome food. The chef is on point with everything he makes. We have never been disappointed with anything that came out of that kitchen More...

J

John B.

24 May 2015

Passing through York and was surprised to find this wonderful restaurant that makes its own pasta and uses all fresh ingredients.  It hasn't gotten it's liquor license yet, (coming soon) so we were lucky that we had a bottle of wine in the car. Very tasty dishes and we'll be back again next time we're in York. More...

C

Crystal B.

11 April 2015

We have eaten there several times and they never miss a beat! Their food is amazing!!! Their personnel is incredible, we especially like their server Anthony! His personality shines& he is very knowledgeable! More...

B

Bob V.

14 March 2015

We happen to be passing through York on our way back home from Washington DC. We decided to stop in York to have something to eat. so we sort of lucked out when we saw this restaurant. If you like pasta their homemade pasta is great! Luckily we happen to have a couple of wine bottles in the trunk since it's bring your own booze here. Everything is done high-class including the french-press coffee and desserts More...

C

Chris P.

17 February 2015

Antiquing in York is always a pleasure...and finding a wonderful restaurant makes for a perfect day...well, we found a great place here, Tutoni's! Kind of hard to find a parking spot, as its downtown, but well worth the effort! My wife had the meatball sandwich and I had the panini and they were absolutely delicious...our waitress Sarah was an angel...We'll be back for sure! More...

M

Matt P.

31 January 2015

Enjoyed a evening with the york young professionals it was very enjoyable start to finish with a great atmosphere.  Highly recommended for anyone craving a well above average dinning experience in york.

L

Lex M.

9 January 2015

I met up with a good friend from undergrad (and fellow child of YoCo) here the other day.  Both of us moved away after college, so we were excited to check out some of the new businesses that popped up since our last visits home.  Tutoni's seemed like a good place to start.We met for lunch.  The restaurant itself is gorgeous -- a bit dark, with lots of stone details and a mild wood smell.  All pluses in my book!  The restaurant was pretty quiet with only two other tables filled.  The hostess/waitress had seated the parties away from each other, which was a nice change from being sandwiched against strangers whose conversations you have zero interest in and vice versa.  Based on the proximity of the smaller tables, I imagine there's high potential for (un)intentional eavesdropping during peak hours.We both ordered paninis; I went with the charcuterie and my friend chose the portabella.  Each sandwich came with the option of a green salad or pasta salad; I opted for the greens and she went for the pasta.  Overall, the food was fresh and flavorful and the portions quite generous (disclaimer: neither of us are big eaters).  We were pleasantly surprised that each lunch totaled $10.Also, be sure to try the wonderful tea!  It's from Cherie Anne's around the corner.  Both teas (one was called Snickerdoodle, the other I forget) were so excellent that after we left, we immediately jaywalked across Philly Street to get a stash.  I love the locally-sourced network that's popped up in downtown, and Tutoni's definitely taps into it in great ways.The dinner menu looked dope (Housemade pasta? Sign me up for some of that gnocchi.), so I'm excited to return and try Tutoni's evening fare -- and their wine selection. More...

J

Jamie M.

30 December 2014

The staff was wonderful. Very clean. Decorated beautifully but I was not pleased with how small my meal was. I did leave wanting more on my plate but I am a big eater. I will go back!

S

Stacy S.

17 October 2014

The food and waitress were wonderful. My main recommendation is not to sit at 2 person table. It was as if you were dining with the next couple which was super uncomfortable.

C

Comic R.

26 September 2014

Great food and service. I had the rigatoni which was one of the best pastas I've had anywhere. Highly recommended if you are looking for good food in York. One warning is that the food prices are higher than a "$$" would have you expect - but it is definitely worth it. More...

T

Tom W.

24 September 2014

First visit, we love the concept.  There is something for everyone on the menu.  My brother-in-law was with us and he's pickier than a finicky feline when it comes to restaurant food.  He was able to find both a salad and an entrée to meet his needs.I had the Gazpacho of the day, a Curry Cantaloupe.  Wow, fantastic.  I ordered the last bowl in the restaurant, thanks to the professional hustle of our waitress, Gabrielle.My ordered the Charcuterie plate as my entrée and it was fantastic.  The pate was in-your-face intense and delicious.The restaurant is BYOB but there might be a corkage fee, I'm not sure.In any case, the décor is great, the food is great, the service was great.Very nice. More...

S

Steve S.

23 September 2014

We started with the cheese plate which was very nice. My girlfriend had the scallop special and she loved it! I had spaghetti with meatballs. My meal was great, a little more sauce would have been nice. Bread was very good but they only brought 2 slices.. More...

W

Winnie K.

4 September 2014

This was our first visit to Tutoni's. We liked the decor though we were super close to the couple next to us. This is a BYOB place and they do charge a corking fee.  We started our meal with the calamari which was good.  They must have a different preparation nightly for several of the meals so you have to be sure and find out what the details are. The bread and olive oil (we chose the rosemary oil and balsamic) was good but the bread was burned.  I picked the crust off and it was fine.  Our salads were great. I had the fresh mozz. salad and the cheese was excellent. It came with red and green tomatoes. My husband had the stone fruit salad and it too was wonderful. For the entree, I chose the Chicken Gemelli and I really liked it. The portion was large and it had really good flavor. My husband had the steak with potatoes and veggies. He is not one to complain but when I tasted the steak, it was very salty.  This was surprising and he couldn't finish it.  Dessert was interesting in that they offer small servings. This is great since I really wanted to try something but I was full.  I did try the peanut butter mousse and it was great. The coffee comes to the table in a French press and that was nice.  We will return to Tutoni's.  This would be a great place to go with a group or for a romantic dinner.  The wait staff was very attentive and answered all of our questions about the menu. More...

D

Danielle C.

3 September 2014

YAY YORK! This type of restaurant is what York needs. Inside the restaurant is really cool, nicely decorated, great ambiance. Farm-to-table type restaurant which is all the rage nowadays (not to mention supporting locally). BYO which is great. YES there is a corking fee...any decent BYO has a corking fee. I'm not sure why people are so outraged by that. We got some appetizers which were good. The cheese board is very good and includes a little sliver  of heavenly honeycomb. Calamari was just ok. I would say I'm a bit of a calamari snob though. My brother got a salad which I tasted and that was awesome. I got a pasta with truffle oil. SO good. I believe the waitress told us the pastas are made there. I could be wrong about that though. Regardless, the pasta was great. Service was prompt and attentive, informative and pleasant. All around good experience and we will return. I live in Philadelphia so I feel like in comparison to some AMAZING Philly restaurants, Tutoni's did a great job. More...

D

Dick H.

2 August 2014

Very enjoyable experience, creative dishes, novel way of presenting dessert options and pleasant, knowledgeable, attentive service.  Eager to return.

M

Melissa H.

2 August 2014

Pasta made daily and was tender and flavorful.  David had the bolognese and really enjoyed it.  I had the meatballs and they were tender without a lot of filler.  The bread is a sun dried tomato and rosemary which went perfectly with the house rosemary olive oil.This is a farm to table place and use local farmers to sustain support their menu. We had the cheese plate with cheeses from Lancaster and honeycomb that was sweet yet smooth.  The small desserts were a perfect sweet ending with the the Oreo cream being the one to try.It is BYOB for now.  Sarah was a wonderful server and we will ask for her next time. More...

L

Larry B.

8 July 2014

Tutoni's was very good overall.  We were a fan of the prior restaurants in this location and it was pleasing to us they retained much of the decor (which works well for Italian or Mediterranean).Our appetizers (Field Green Salad and Agnolotti) were excellent.  In the Agnolotti the fennel marmalade added a great bright flavor to the light pasta and chicken liver mousse.Meals were great also but also very hot (must have just come out).  First bites were very hot (especially the manicotti) so beware.  The flavors in the manicotti (goat cheese, tomato jam, preserved lemon) were a fantastic flavor rainbow and the shrimp risotto was wonderful and a good size portion (lunch tomorrow).Dessert was the only low spot (lemon curd tasted like bacon...not sure if that was intended - server said no - but it was not a good combo).  The other desserts were great and this is definitely on our return list. More...

C

Chris B.

26 June 2014

Tutoni's restaurant is the most refreshing experience I have had since moving to York. The atmosphere is very intimate and authentic to it's Italian cuisine. I got the Steak meal and was very impressed with the taste of the meat. The steak was cooked perfectly. Also I could recommend the meatballs for an appetizer, they are amazing! The cork fee is $5 for wine, so our bill was much lower than would be expected for food of this quality. While we were there my fiance and I spoke with Toni and she was very happy to answer our questions and accept our praise. This is exactly the kind of restaurant York needs. Bravo Toni/y's. More...

T

Tom S.

14 June 2014

Just celebrated our anniversary at Tutoni's. The food is awesome. We consider ourselves foodies and I'm Italian. The menu has a wide variety of reasonably priced choices. They use local products from greens, tomatos, meat, cheeses, coffees and tea. Staff is very knowledgable but most important, the food is delightful. Thanks for a very nice anniversary dinner!!!!! More...

C

Crystal H.

26 May 2014

The Tutoni's team has done a fine job on this beautiful downtown spot, serving up fresh, seasonal, local dishes.  We enjoyed the meatballs appetizer as well as the bruschetta.  The meatballs were accompanied by a creamy polenta and savory carmelized onions.  It was perfect.  The bruschetta surprised us with its pureed garbonzo bean base.  It was a wonderful light and satisfying dish.  The dinner entrees were no disappointment either!  We ordered up the spring risotto and lobster ravioli, and wow, this place just keeps on impressing.  I  was informed by our lovely server that the risotto contained no butter or cheese, yet it still managed a rich flavor and I loved the accent of the peas and asparagus.  Maybe a splash of lemon would be nice with it?  The lobster ravioli was divine, so rich and creamy.  It was a decent portion, with  homemade noodles.  Overall, we had a lovely dinner experience and will be back again in the near future!  We were also very pleased with the cost of this dining excursion, at just under $50 for dinner and appetizers for two. More...

Photos (12)

See all

Videos (1)

See all

Q&A

Our signature dish is our housemade fresh pasta. With 2 simple ingredients, each piece is made from scratch with love. Our sauces are also made from scratch using locally sourced, seasonal ingredients. We offer a few crowd favorites year round like our Rigatoni Bolognese or Bucatini Meatballs but also rotate seasonal flavors that are ever changing.

We listen! We aren't cookie cutter and we don't want to give you the same experience as everyone else. We want to work with you to make a menu that perfectly fits the style of your event.

We love educating through food and providing big city experiences in our small town. We love to teach our guests about new ingredients or ways or preparation and then teach them about what wines can pair well with those dishes. We strive to provide a unique atmosphere that locals won't find just anywhere around town.

Toni (a girl) and Tony (a boy), owners of Tutoni's, both have family from Sicily and grew up as "pizza shop kids" in their families' restaurants. Now they want to "take it back to the old country" and provide a traditional Italian dining experience but with the fresh twists of modern times.

Passion goes into everything we do at Tutoni's. Our commitment to local farmers and small business carries through in our commitment to making the perfect event for you. We hope that our passion for good food and wine shines through in every bite and sip we deliver.

Twitter

Services

We come to you! Whether it's at an existing event venue or a private home or business, we're fully equipped for parties both large and small. Offering a full range of styles from sit-down plated dinners or family style meals to cocktail parties with small bites.

Looking for a fun addition to your event? Look no further than our new Rig-a-toni food truck! This kitchen on wheels can pull up to your next event to give your guests exactly what they want & need for their bellies. Email us today to book this beautiful truck for your event!

See below for our list of in-house options at our farm to table restaurant in downtown York, PA Mezzanine Our beautiful upstairs dining room offers natural light and a private atmosphere perfect for rehearsal dinners and corporate meetings. Seats 8-10 people for dinner. Optional access to our full service bar. Downstairs Dining Room This intimate space is sultry and romantic. It is also handicap accessible and has easy access to bathrooms. It is perfect for smaller gatherings and most often used for private chef's tables so the chef can come from the kitchen and explain each dish. Seats 20-36. The TT Bar Full service bar featuring Italian focused scratch cocktails using housemade ingredients and a 32 bottle self-serve wine tasting system (a great interactive activity). Can be rented out for private parties, cocktail hours, and other casual gatherings. The King George Club This small, intimate bar and lounge features lavish soft seating, extraordinary beverages, and classy entertainment all tucked away in an old world Vegas style atmosphere. Private bathrooms and exclusive bartenders. More than delivers on the "wow factor." Seats 20 or 25 standing.