Toothpicks Catering

We have used them twice as well as the Wednesday dinners. Always excellent food and generous portions. Always professional and cheerful.

Reviewed on Facebook

I highly recommend Toothpicks Catering for: Wonderful food! Great packaging. Every detail is included. Responsible and professional.

Reviewed on Facebook

Toothpicks catered a drop off baby shower for me on Sunday. The food was delicious! Everything was homemade, delicious and presented beautifully on china platters and wicker baskets. The disposable bamboo plates were awesome! My guests really appreciated taking home the leftovers in the to go containers that were supplied. The service was prompt and attentive, an overall excellent experience! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Our first time ordering, absolutely outstanding ✨

Reviewed on Facebook

I can't rave enough about Sarah and Toothpicks Catering. We hired them for our wedding at the Maxwell Mansion in Lake Geneva, WI on 12/15/18. We went with a buffet style and the food was outstanding (and hot!). The beef tenderloin sliders were a huge hit, along with the chicken and waffles. My only regret is that I wish we would have ordered more cheese for the cheeseboard because our guests annihilated it within what felt like minutes - Wisconsin cheese is no joke! Sadly we barely ate due to nerves (hear this is how it usually goes) but what we did we loved and most importantly our guests were full of delicious food and compliments about it. The cherry on top of this sundae is that Sarah is amazing to work with. She is warm and professional, we simply like her as a person. What more can you ask for More...

Reviewed on Yelp

We worked with Toothpicks on East Troy Train Line. The food coming out of the tiny kitchen was phenomenal! Hot, fresh, and delicious. The home made bread pudding was amazing! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

We ordered some dishes for Thanksgiving from Toothpicks and I would highly recommend them. The food was fresh and there was plenty for everyone. Very easy to order and pick up. We will be ordering from their Christmas menu next month. Thank you Sarah and crew! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Tonight's meal I think was my very favorite!!!! Took this meal to Carroll University to enjoy it with my daughter and her roommate and they devoured it! !!! This was fantastic. Thanks for hooking this mom up!!! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Fantastic high-end cuisine!

Reviewed on Facebook

We used Toothpicks for both our wedding and baby shower, fantastic food, fantastic people!

Reviewed on Facebook

Recently my husband and I had Toothpicks cater our Anniversary party. Toothpicks allowed us to customize our own order. The quote was reasonable. The experience was great. It was dropped off at the time requested and all laid out for our guests. The toothpicks employee described everything to me and how to replenish everything. The food was great and we received lots of compliments from our guests. Many guests went back for seconds. We didn’t have much leftovers except buns and the chicken and some salad. Overall super pleased and will use them again for upcoming parties. It is really nice to not have to worry about the food or ask guests to bring something! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Toothpicks catered our son’s outdoor wedding and it couldn’t have been nicer. The presentation, food and service was exceptional, especially on a sauna hot day. ..Thank you Sara and crew for making this celebration special. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

THE BEST!!

Reviewed on Facebook

Amazing food

Reviewed on Google Maps

My family and I have enjoyed Wednesday night dinners! A convenient and high-quality meal solution for busy families!

Reviewed on Facebook

We have used toothpicks for numerous special occasions! They do not disappoint!

Reviewed on Facebook

Held a bridal shower there and the food was amazing. Especially loved the assorted treats and desserts that were served after our meal. Service was great.....the whole team is easy to work with and very accommodating. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

We held a 16-person bridal shower at their location by the grocery store in East Troy and the space was beautifully decorated. It felt like I walked into a room that was sponsored by Pinterest (and done right). We had a meat/cheese platter for snacks, then enjoyed a sit-down lunch that included a salad with the best dressing I have had in a long time and a slider/chicken salad sandwich combo entree. The desserts were to die for, including a raspberry cream cheesecake, a pastry puff filled with cream and fruit, and a whiskey-infused chocolate cupcake. The serving staff and chef were very professional and friendly. I would highly recommend using their services if you have a party you would like to host. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Love the Wednesday night family dinners. Wonderful food and great people! Highly recommend Toothpicks.

Reviewed on Facebook

We have tried Toothpicks for their Wednesday night family meals and the food is amazing. We would highly recommend to anyone looking for a great family meal with fresh/healthy ingredients.

Reviewed on Facebook

Absolutely AMAZING! I live in Atlanta but I was in Wisconsin for Thanksgiving. They catered our dinner on Saturday night. EVERYTHING was so Good ! From the appetizers to the dessert. Homemade caramel sauce was to die for. All three of the women were super sweet too! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Got the Wednesday night family dinner to go. Outstanding food ready to serve. Pork roast roumalade, fresh vegetables, baguette, potatoes,  butter pecan custard and butter cookies. Everything was delicious. A great value when you consider your time used to shop, prep and cook. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Toothpicks recently catered a birthday party for us. The food was phenomenal. The mac and cheese bites were to die for. The stuffed jalapeños are always a crowd favorite and the pepper tenderloin skewers were delicious and gorgeous. It was a wonderful spread both visually and flavor wise. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

The Toothpicks team recently catered a party for my family and it was absolutely perfect! From presentation to taste, Toothpicks nailed it.

Reviewed on Facebook

I purchased a Wednesday Night dinner for four yesterday. Surprised a friend who just moved to Mukwonago. I sent the food to their door with a Congrats on Your New House card and told them to take a break from unpacking (not to mention cooking) and enjoy. That was yesterday. At this point they've called THREE times to thank me for the for the thoughtfulness and "amazing" dinner, each time raving about how delicious everything was. I could have claimed to have made it myself, but instead confessed to my secret weapon- Toothpicks. Working in the restaurant business... two things have happened to me- #1. I've developed a discriminating (somewhat picky) palate and hold restaurant dishes to pretty high standards. #2. I've lost interest in cooking for myself and the TIME for for dining out. Toothpicks, and their Wednesday to-go dinners, is the perfect remedy for me. Something I look forward to a couple times a month. The meals are always unique, inspired, well-portioned and absolutely delectable. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Very good, Wednesdays dinner with the family meals are great.

Reviewed on Facebook

Tried the Wednesday night dinner for the first time and it was amazing. My very picky culinary husband enjoyed it as well. Large portion sizes and delicious flavors made tonight's dinner a hit. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Wow, what a great meal I had! Loved that I could pick it up and bring home a fully cooked meal on a weeknight! The family dinner night is a great idea and I'll be taking advantage of this a lot!

Reviewed on Facebook

Bravo Ladies! The food is absolutely amazing! Will definitely be ordering again, and again, and again ;)

Reviewed on Facebook

I love Wednesday night dinner for 4. Great idea. How nice is it to sit down to a hot meal, cooked with love , for those you love. It's becoming a tradition.

Reviewed on Facebook

My daughter and I ordered your family dinner for 2 this evening and I think we are in heaven. This is so delicious!! I truly believe your services are a gift to this small town!!!! Unbelievable!!!!

Reviewed on Facebook

Just finished our first meal from Toothpick's Wednesday night special and WOW! I truly was savoring every bite because I didn't want it to be gone! I had about a 30 mile drive home after I picked it up and everything was still amazing! Fresh bread, roasted veggies, fingerling potatoes, purple kale salad with lemon vinaigrette dressing and for the main dish pork loin stuffed with a three cheese blend and spinach, wrapped with applewood bacon! ��� I will 100% be doing this deal again. Can't wait to try what they come up with next! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Tried the Wednesday night Dinner with Family meal. Oh my goodness how delicious! The price is perfect and the portions could easily serve more than 4! It was incredible! My family loved it. It comes in very nice containers that are perfect to store the leftovers. Kudos to you Toothpicks for bringing a delicious new choice for dinner to East Troy. Can't wait to see what is on the menu next Wednesday. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

We had a delicious meal tonight! We can't wait to see next weeks menu!

Reviewed on Facebook

We thoroughly enjoyed our meal. So flavorful! Everything was so tasty. We will definitely do this again. Thank you!

Reviewed on Facebook

Excellent. Everything was delicious. Can't wait to try other items on your menu

Reviewed on Facebook

Toothpicks catered our bank lunch today and it was outstanding! We will definitely order again soon, thank you!! p.s. Your lemon bars are the best!

Reviewed on Facebook

Toothpicks was recommended to me by a trusted source, and i'm so so glad - we worked with them from afar on a memorial service event. The food for the event was excellent, along with a dinner they provided for a family meal afterward. Sarah and the staff of Toothpicks made the process so easy so we didn't have to worry about a thing (not setup, not cleanup...!) and we could focus on spending time with the people we came to see! The price/value was great, too! I would highly recommend! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Had there hamburger was juicy and delicious I have also tried the blu cheese chicken salad really good we Loved sitting on the outside deck had a wonderful lunch will defiantly go back

Reviewed on Facebook

The food is awesome!!! Best Reuben EVER! My son loves the pizza, the burgers are soooooo good. Mother's Day Brunch was great! The Friday fish is fantastic. I recommend this place, perfect after golf or just because you want a great meal!!! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

The Mother's Day Brunch was outstanding! Although I made a valiant attempt, there was no way I was physically capable of trying all of the delicious offerings. Keep up the great work. You're a wonderful addition to Waterford. I/we will definitely return! More...

Reviewed on Facebook

The breading on the cod was outstanding, service was wonderful and atmoshpere very comfortable. Wonderful fish fry!!!

Reviewed on Yelp

What a hidden gem! Toothpicks took over the previously hideous restaurant and created gold. Chef Adam's creations are always a hit. The fish fry is all homemade. The fish is fresh, flavorful, and portioned well for the price. The clam chowder is the best I've had including the greater Boston area. Leave room for the desert of the day. You won't regret your trip to Toothpicks at Rivermoor! This is the only fish fry my (formerly vegetarian) wife will eat without complaint. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

We had our pool league banquet at Rivermoor/Toothpicks on Saturday, April 2nd. I can't say enough about how great everything was! Not only the food, but the service, and atmosphere were excellent as well. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Friday Fish Fry was great. The fish was perfectly done and the potato pancakes were crispy and  super tasty. The waitstaff were very attentive and quick. We never had to wait for fresh drinks!  Can't wait to try the other menu items.  The decor is so tasteful and the ambiance very fun. More...

Reviewed on Yelp