The NY Slice
Edgewood, Indiana
(31)
Edgewood, Indiana
(31)
31 customer reviews
Sheila Joseph
Love their pizzas
Reviewed on Google Maps
Laquita Pickett
Great customer service and food is amazing
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cordero Ball
amazing crust wonderful toppings
Reviewed on Google Maps
trina flake
Pizza us amazing
Reviewed on Google Maps
Alex Swihart
Good pizza, good salad, understaffed. Will try the margherita when I go back. The pics looked good.
Reviewed on Google Maps
loyshay boone
This pizza is truly authentic, all the veggies are fresh. Very very good pizza, however it is expensive. They only have large and extra large. Please try it, they also have an extended menu as well! Absolutely love it! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Thomas Ritter
Very excellent pizza, plenty of toppings and they fix it the way you want it. It is an very delicious pizza to eat I give it a thumbs up because I love to eat very good pizza.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michelle Fultz
Great pizza!
Reviewed on Google Maps
JH Russell
Oh my God... Fuhgetaboutit... This pizza is the Tits!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Zip Howard
Good pizza, friendly service. Good local place to support.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tony Magna
Great sandwich. Great price. Had the chicken parm.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Treva Caster
What a discovery we made tonight! Best NY pie and calzone right here in Indy! Dan is super friendly, Great service and awesome food! We’ll definitely be back!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sacul Arts
Great service and food
Reviewed on Google Maps
millie parke
Good pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jakim Bialek
As a native New Yorker, having lived in Indianapolis since 2003, this is THE BEST pizza I’ve had since living here. Especially if you want pure New York style pizza, go no where else. The sauce is perfect and the balance between toppings and cheese and sauce is perfect - no matter what type of pizza you get. Creative and delicious additional menu items as well. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Vanessa Bach
Thank you! As a transplant from Eastern PA, it's been difficult to find truly delicious pizza and lost hope till I found this pizza shop. You hit it right on the spot! Huge pizzas, generous toppings, foldable slices. It's perfect! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Fred Erdmann
Awesome place. It tastes just like NY pizza does.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Bryan Hubbard
Friendly staff, clean restaurant, and good food. Took my son in to enjoy it and were definitely pleased.
Reviewed on Google Maps
David Clark Gumz Jr
Now this is true New York(Deli) style pizzaClean,Fresh Tomato,Light Airy Crispy Crust, and A professional friendly staff to match.Welcome to Indy! I❤️NySlice
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sarah Schilling
The owner is knowledgeable and friendly AND the pizza is so delicious. The red sauce is mouthwatering and he adds some great flavorings along with a delicious crust!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brandon Reese
I was in Indy for a week and I was like hmmm... I low key kinda want pizza. So I went the NY Slice and got a slice. Than that’s when I took my first bite and my LIFE CHANGED! If you’re looking for the best Indy pizza we’ll you’ve found it! I More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Trent Moskwinski
Great food, friendly service. We called in ahead of time, he told us 30 minutes, however we showed up about 15 minutes early. We were more than okay with waiting, but we were still brought free breadsticks for our wait. Top notch place. Great service. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ruth Bertling
Love their pizza, handmade crust, clean and good service. I will definitely be going back
Reviewed on Google Maps
Michael Moffatt
This guy knows what he’s doing. This is very authentic and quite tasty. Fast service and reasonable prices. Support local!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tabitha Lowery
As East Coaster myself this was a little taste of home in the midwest. Add to it the friendly atmosphere and great sense of humor the owner has and you cant pass this up! Come check it out!
Reviewed on Google Maps
uhm awkward
After visiting Chicago and having a slice of New York style pizza I became obsessed with trying to find a place that served similar pizza near me. While this place isn’t necessarily close, I still drive an hour here once a month or so because I enjoy the pizza. It’s exactly the kind of pizza I love and I’m thoroughly in love with it. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Coty Mccollum
This is one of the only places in Indianapolis that you can go get a taste of New York. The atmosphere is very friendly and local. I would definitely recommend this to anyone. Very tasty pizza I especially like the crust More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brandy Clary
This place is amazing. Really good pizza, and the salads are just as good!
Reviewed on Google Maps
CJ Fowler
Excellent pizza by the slice. Little off he highway but well worth it. Authentic thin New York style. Take the time and try this!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mrs Huxley
Really good pizza and salad. A bit expensive but it's worth it if you want something other than franchise pizza. My family and I will definitely be back!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Erika Kemker
Stopped here on a whim. The pizza was fantastic - great to see some New York style pizza in a land of deep dish. The crust was soft and crispy, thicker on the edge than under the toppings; very flavorful. The cannoli was amazing, too. Spoke to the owner - great guy, very down to earth. Will be back for sure. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
