Loading...

Please wait ...

Reviews (39)

Leave a review
C

Christa S.

26 May 2019

Love this place! Always great service and great baked goods.

V

Victoria Franklin

25 May 2019

I contacted Taylor's to have gender reveal cupcakes custom made and they did a wonderful job! Not only were they delicious but the inside pink filling was discreetly concealed! I will definitely be back!

R

Rekke Ray

22 May 2019

Don't get to go as often as I had in the past. I would go very often at least 2 to 3 times a week when it was closer to downtown. The best bakery in Indianapolis IN. Reminds me of a bakery in California. Now that I've posted . I feel I must make and take the time to go at least once a week. Enjoy More...

J

Jeannine Waldock

22 May 2019

I have been a loyal customer since 1977. You cannot beat their cakes. Period. Which is why they have been in business since 1913, I believe. You have to go there. Beyond belief!!! More...

R

Roxanne Wolf

29 April 2019

Are you kidding? Everything is great here!
Place is clean, staff are as sweet as the sweets their selling!

T

Tom Parker

29 April 2019

Just plain GREAT, NUFF SAID.

J

Jessica Cockrum

29 April 2019

This is a nice bakery. There are a large selection of baked goods in the case. There are common items, like chocolate chip cookies, beautifully decorated sugar cookies, eclairs, cupcakes, donuts, etc to more exotic items and traditional seasonal bakes, like Hot Cross Buns at Easter. There is always something new you are going to want to try. The angel food cakes are delicious and they have different flavors that cycle through. My kids love the sugar cookies. It's definitely worth checking out! More...

L

Lori Grant

30 March 2019

We recently purchased a specialty birthday cake from Taylor's. The service was friendly and quick, and the cake reasonably priced for the detailed work. As with anything we've had from Taylor's, it was fresh and delicious. Everyone was raving about how perfectly it looked and tasted; it made a special celebration even better. More...

A

Ashley Maue

30 March 2019

This is THE best donut I've ever had in my life. And I've had my share of donuts. (Their cakes are amazing, too.) I can't recommend Taylor's enough!

P

Pam Hannin

30 March 2019

Best donut holes in town!!! Friendly service. I've never bought something I didn't like. Cakes are great, breads, cookie, pies, ice cream, candy, it's all fantastic!It's a must for all my family and friends that come to Indy❤ More...

S

S. Carter

30 March 2019

Extremely friendly staff. Very helpful assisting me in selecting an anniversary cake. Cake was very pretty, tasty and decorated perfectly per my instructions.

S

Shelby Brooke

28 February 2019

I was NOT expecting what I got today at Taylor's! It was DELICIOUS! Very flavorful and baked to what seemed like perfection to me! The lady who helped me was very kind and even let me sample a donut hole. I was in baked heaven More...

C

Charity Wimmer

29 January 2019

Baklava yum, they have great bakery items, and must have more than one location, because I asked about a business card to get pricing on wedding cakes, but she said I'd have to call the other shop for that...other than that they had so many yummy goodies to choose from! More...

J

JS Williams

29 January 2019

Only the best. Seriously, it’s the best. I wish I could give it more than 5 stars!! Love this place!! They are beyond kind each time I walk in.

N

Neena H

29 January 2019

Amazing quality and always the friendliest service. Everything is DELICIOUS. They have the most perfect tiny birthday cakes about 5" across. You need to go there!

T

Tarik Rabie

31 October 2018

We used to Taylor’s Bakery to cater a small cake and donuts for our wedding. I can't say enough good things about Taylor’s Bakery. They've been around for over 100 years and it's clear they have it figured it out. We put in our order 2 weeks before the wedding, the whole process took less than an hour, and was very affordable. They even had a donut stand we could rent, when other bakeries typically require you to purchase/rent your own. This made everything so easy for us. We ended up with a small carrot cake with custom Harry Potter decorations on it and a variety of donuts and donut holes for our guests. Taylor’s staff arrived at the venue on time and helped set up the donut stand. This was one of the biggest hits at our wedding, as you would expect everything tasted delicious! I'm so glad we chose Taylor’s Bakery for our wedding I highly recommend them for any of your dessert needs. More...

B

Barbara Martyn

9 August 2018

Have been going to Taylor's for at least 40 years when it was @86th&Ditch and before. It has always been wonderful & your employees are the nicest of any in Indy. Thank u. Wouldn't go anywhere else for any Special occasion or just 1 donut or cookie just because it is "Tuesday". More...

L

Lisa Hastings

9 August 2018

Would recommend them for any event!! They were happy to save my daughter's wedding cake delimma and made a beautiful cake in just a week's notice!! It was awesome....moist and delicious!!! They delivered outside the city...on time...and had a very friendly employee!!
Thank you Taylor Bakery!!!
More...

M

Michelle Hinkle

9 August 2018

Love them. Their cakes are awesome. Very talented decorators.

P

Paul Crimmins

9 August 2018

This is the best place to buy donuts...... they are so good.
It is worth the drive from those other places.......

H

Haley Stone

9 August 2018

The frosted sugar cookies are so amazing and fresh everytime! I'm from Cleveland Ohio but family in Indianapolis and my mom always brings 5-10 home to me. The designs are always super cute too! Love � More...

J

John Ibrahim

9 August 2018

Went their yesterday for the first time after hearing a lot about the place, we got cookies and donuts, taste is great and fresh, customer service is outstanding and friendly.
Thank you

A

Ashley Wall

9 August 2018

Service is absolutely great. The staff was very helpful when I ordered my wedding cake and cupcakes. They delivered right on time to the venue and we didn't have any issues. The cake was exactly what I wanted. Best pricing in town for sure! More...

J

Justine Aldridge

9 August 2018

Our cake for our June 24, 2017 wedding was beautiful!!! It was exactly what I wanted. I sent over a picture from Pinterest that I had found of the details I really liked and it was an EXACT replica of the picture I sent them! Any time I ever called or stopped in to inquire about our cake, everyone was very kind!

In addition to our wedding cake, my mom also had Taylor's put together donut holes in little baggy's for our hotel guest bags for our family/friends who were coming in from out of town. My family loves these donut holes and so did all of our guests!
More...

K

Karla Fair Allen

9 August 2018

Oh my goodness!! My sister has been holding out on me! First visit was Tuesday and everything looked sooo good! The lion cookie was awesome!!! The staff was super friendly and the place was busy!! Can't wait to come back!! More...

D

Debra D Craig

9 August 2018

Taylor's cakes are gorgeous looking and fabulous, the mini donuts, donut holes, danish, petite fours just delicious. On your next visit please try Taylor's popcorn if you like cheese and caramel mix you'll equally enjoy the caramel and cheese all on the same kernel and that was her mistake but it is delectably fabulous I just love Taylor's bakery

S

Sarah Cook

9 August 2018

Haven’t tried their cakes yet but I do know their donuts are delicious.

C

Codi Russell

9 August 2018

Your king cakes are to die for. ���� happy Mardi Gras!!

R

Robyn Shelley

9 August 2018

Taylor’s Bakery did an amazing job on my Son’s horse birthday cake. I provided a picture and they made it 10 times better than the picture!

C

Carolyn Elliott

9 August 2018

Have used this bakery since 1992 when I moved to Broad Ripple. I have never once had a bad experience. They are absolutely the best at what they do. Cakes, cookies and special orders .. perfection. Thanks Taylor's More...

M

Missy Goins

9 August 2018

Absolutely beautiful birthday cake for my surprise 50th birthday party! Everyone was amazed that it was a carrot cake (my favorite!) that tasted amazing!!

D

Daniel Jimenez

9 August 2018

I ordered a cake and cupcakes for my daughter’s graduation party. The experience was fantastic! I recommend Taylor’s Bakery to everyone wanting a professional staff and beautiful/delicious cakes! �����

M

Marcy Briggs

9 August 2018

I cannot rave about Taylor’s Bakery enough. Not only is everything delicious, but the customer service is first class. Drew saved our daughter’s birthday party and we cannot thank him and his family enough. Generous and caring people that deliver quality baked goods! More...

M

Melissa Ratliff

9 August 2018

Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! Coming to Taylor's Bakery for our tasting was so easy and stress-free. Not to mention, affordable! I sent them a few pictures of what I wanted the cake to look like and they made it happen. Thank you for being apart of our special day! I will definitely be recommending to future bride and grooms. More...

J

Joni Heredia

1 June 2017

The only bakery I use! Expert bakers and very nice staff. Our graduation cake was beautiful and delicious. I highly recommend Taylor's to everyone.

M

Michael McGee

5 May 2017

It was a wonderful place to buy from. I enjoyed the atmosphere, great customer service, and just so outgoing staff.

D

David Barker

7 April 2017

Love their Eclairs. The closest that I can find that compares to the late Roslyn Bakery eclairs.

B

Bob Geis

19 March 2017

I love Taylor's. We went there after lunch for treats! It was great. Get there early if you want their cinnamon rolls.

C

Claire Stuckey

13 March 2017

Taylor's is by far my favorite. That's where I ordered my wedding cake years ago and just last week bought cakes for my son's first birthday. I was amazed they took a special order the evening before. I ordered his cakes Friday afternoon to pick up Saturday morning.

We buy every family birthday cake there, just out of the ones they have in the case daily. Both the white cake and the chocolate are awesome.
More...