Old Bethpage
98 customer reviews
Amy M.
This place is close some friends, so I stop in occasionally for lunch. It's always busy, but the service is good and the line moves quick. The people who work there are really good at keeping things moving.They have a great selection of food, from pizza and Italian dishes to sandwiches and hot paninis. It's a deli with hot food and Italian choices, which is really nice. They have good salads too. The atmosphere is a little noisy, but it's a busy lunchtime deli, so it's not unexpected. They have a casual dining room too, which is a great option when you want to sit in and eat. I never think twice about going there, it's really a great place to stop in for a tasty lunch. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jay M.
Love it here. They have soo many food options, a bunch of different types of sandwhiches, plus hot food, pizza, Â burgers, a salad section and the foods all really good :)
Reviewed on Yelp
Ray N.
This is still one of my favorite lunch spots. The paninis are a really good deal. They have a big assortment of already made paninis ready to heat and they are all good. I do notice that they have been getting stingy with the chicken on the onI order most "the Bistro" and I'm guessing that goes for the other ones also. Don't think people don't realize! Some bites don't have any chicken and the cutlets are now really thin. Just raise the price if you have to and don't skimp. Update 10-25-19: Not sure what's happening to this place. It seems like everything is dirty. Cash register is dirty, bathroom is disgusting with thick grime and dirt on the door, and last 2 times, no soap in Men's room. The dispensers didn't even have a bottle in them. This is troubling since the employees use the same bathroom and don't wash their hands with soap. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Joseph S.
I've been catering food from here for years now and the food and service is outstanding. Â The people there are very nice people and the service is excellent. Â Everything is freshly made and great quality. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
John V.
Great Sandwiches and salads. Been coming to this spot to get turkey panini for over 10 years it is so good. They are very fast too which is good on work days. Great drink selection
Reviewed on Yelp
Sam H.
The longwood sandwich is my favorite as well as the suburban pasta!! We also used them for my daughters 1st birthday party and order the gourmet sandwich package. They cut the sandwiches into 2 or 4 pieces depending on the type of bread used and organized it beautifully in a basket. You can get a variety of sandwiches to mix it up, there's no minimum of a type of sandwich you have to order. Ordering was easy and they also deliver! I've also had the bolognese rigatoni and garlic knots when we had another party and it was EFFIN DELICIOUS!!! If they offered it on the regular menu (it's on catering only) I would be there every day...well every Saturday for cheat meals...and maybe a Wednesday here and there, because i have no self control. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Drew Y.
We had a party for 60 people. Did there catering menu for Traditional BBQ. They were right on time, setup, kept pumping out the food, in a perfect timely manner. Helped clean up the food after they were done. All the food was very good. Pulled pork, burgers,hot dogs, and bbq chicken. Â All the family and friends enjoyed the wonderful food. Â Â Â Nice job to Alex and Victor the two chefs. They made the day that much more special. The price was right on point. We felt the money spent was worth it. Thanks guys for a excellent time. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Ray N.
This is still one of my favorite lunch spots. The paninis are a really good deal. They have a big assortment of already made paninis ready to heat and they are all good. I do notice that they have been getting stingy with the chicken on the one I order most "the Bistro" and I'm guessing that goes for the other ones also. Don't think people don't realize! Some bites don't have any chicken and the cutlets are now really thin. Just raise the price if you have to and don't skimp. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Alyssa Squillace
Order from here multiple times a month for my company lunches. Food is always delicious !!
Reviewed on Facebook
John Sohn
Ice cold Jumbo Iced Coffee!
Reviewed on Facebook
Stacey Shotland Altman
Ordered for Thanksgiving and it was a hit!
Reviewed on Facebook
Robin Robbins Brooks
This morning we had our office catered by Suburban Eats. They did a fabulous job! The food was fresh and delicious. We got the Warm Sunrise Breakfast and the omelet station. The chef that cooked the fresh and delicious omelets was fast and kind. Thank you so much for making our retirement party so very special! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Carol F.
Catered brunch and a 6' hero on their focaccia bread made in-house. Everything was delicious! Â Guests were raving about the food and lined up to bring home what was left over! Â Would highly recommend Suburban Eats! Â Excellent customer service as well. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Kevin J.
Choose your own type of salad bar. Â Pick your greens then go over to all the fixins and add to your healthy heart's content. Â Choose tossed or chopped. Â FYI, chopped is the only way to go. Â Everything is then in small pieces and each bite is packed full of every flavor. Â I had the spinach with too many add ons to count. Â As I walked up towards the counter to pay I noticed the roasted brussel sprouts. I know, you're probably thinking, Ewe that's gross. Â But try 'em. Â Be adventurous, live life to the fullest. Â Go for it!!! Â They are delicious. Even though lunch time is prime time for them, wait wasn't long at all. Â Was able to get our food quickly and find an open table. Â Definitely a few more options I will check out there next time in town. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Daniela M.
Was in the area today & stopped by for a quick bite to go. I ordered a chicken cutlet with lettuce & tomato on a roll & my husband ordered a roast beef sandwich. Decent sized sandwiches & lots of meat on the bread. The only issue I had with my sandwich was the chicken cutlets were very over cooked/burnt on the edges. I normally like a crispy cutlets but the edges were inedible. Prices were reasonable. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Nikki L.
Love this spot for lunch! They have everything: pizza, make-your-own-salad, hot food, heroes, paninis, breakfast... you name it! Because this is such a hot spot during lunch time, it can get pretty crowded in there and service can get backed up a bit. If you're going on your lunch break during the rush, might wanna call ahead to avoid the chaos! Try the jr special panini! Mmmm More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Cristie G.
So I stopped in late one afternoon and got the best service I have had at a deli in a while. And honestly calling this place a deli is a bit down playing it. This is more of a cafe with paninis and wraps, even hot food choices. Since I just took a job around the block I def will be back.The cuban was really good and the owner was too friendly not to go back More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Robert Mitchell
Awesome bacon, egg and cheese sandwich. Best breakfast sandwich in the area.
Reviewed on Facebook
Andrew C.
We have been customers of this Deli for a few years for mostly catering salad packages and sandwiches for special events such as home parties & BBQs. Our experienced has been good and their prices are reasonable for what they provide. I happened to have a small gathering at my house and I only needed eight wraps. They would not provide me with a sandwich basket unless I paid more for the sandwiches. But I with a little help from my casher friend, she provided me with a decorated plastic plate with a paper cover. She was very helpful compared to others in some cases I have experienced. But that has not stop me from selecting this place for catering my parties or just for a quick bite. Â Good food, good selections and sometimes good service. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Joseph T.
This a gourmet deli. I ordered chicken cutlet in a roll with lettuce, tomatoes, and roasted peppers. The roll had golden brown color with seeds on it; it wasn't that ordinary beige roll without any flavor. The veggies had bright, radiant colors which made it evident that they were fresh well before I bit into the sandwich and confirmed the freshness. The chicken cutlet was juicy and flavorful. This deli is definitely better than many of the ordinary delis in the area. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Rachel Brenner Levenberg
Catered in sandwiches for my daughter's birthday, and everything was delicious. I got lots of compliments, and there were hardly any leftovers. All of the staff was very friendly and patient while taking my order and answering my questions. Delivery was prompt as well. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Kenneth Reese
I loved the food, always fresh and tasty. Thats why i drive there from my job on my lunch break. I would give the deli a five if one of cashiers would smile, use eye contact, and talk a little bit. The other cashiers treat me well so thats a plus. Overall everytime i go there if that certain cashier is there she always seems to have an attitude and quickly rush me off the register. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Shannon Rogan Bottari
The food is amazing! I have used Suburban Eats for many catered parties and I am always impressed with the food and service.
Reviewed on Facebook
Angela Marie Frangione
I have gone to Suburban Eat's many times throughout the years and I love it there! I always get a Cobb salad with their amazingly delicious honey mustard dressing. There is such a great selection of food, snacks and desserts to chose from. The place is always very clean and the staff is incredibly friendly! Suburban Eats is definitely the place to try while you are in Farmingdale or the Melville area! You will not forget it! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sarah H.
i love these guys! Good food and fast service. I usually run in there at 8:45 am on my way to work and am still at work with my bagel in hand by 9:00 am.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jenny S.
I ordered catering from Tim at Suburban Eats for a brunch baby shower and they did an outstanding job! Tim and his staff were wonderful when I called to update the order. Day of service was also wonderful! The food was great and everything was included. One note- the paper goods and cutlery were very basic, so I would advise purchasing that stuff for a fancier event. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Aaron B.
I love suburban eats! Salad bar is the best! Lots of options and they're all so fresh! Staff is really friends and are hard workers. I recommend this to everyone!
Reviewed on Yelp
Matthew M.
Coming from Farmingdale, and living in the village, there are lots of options for me to find a place to eat. Even though this isn't very far from me at all, I still find myself coming back here to get lunch here and there. Their "Longwood" sandwich is an absolute masterpiece.As listed on their menu:LongwoodGrilled herb chicken, fresh mozzarella, marinated sundried tomatoes, leaf lettuce & honey pesto dressing on seven grain baguette.I'm not quite sure how many other places have this combo for a sandwich, but its absolutely perfect. Each ingredient compliments the next. (I recommend getting the bread toasted if you want even more perfection!).As for experience inside the actual deli, it is always busy inside, and that is for a good reason.Their food is always good and their service is nice and quick. If you are ever in the area and need a place to eat, certainly check it out. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jay E.
Been a customer for years. Â Food is excellent. Place is clean. Â Lots a daily lunch specials. Â 2 thumbs up
Reviewed on Yelp
June F.
Second visit to this deli and it was equal to first. Â Excellent choice of salads and fresh sandwiches. Â There is ample seating and the place is clean and fast at serving. Â Last time I was here I ordered Caesar salad with chicken. Â Today I had the chicken salad in a wonderful whole wheat seeded roll. Â Both were delicious and both were super fresh! Â I'll be back to this deli. Â I'm happy I tried it! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Bryan L.
This place is fantastic. Â They have by far the best chopped salads on long island. Â On top of that there is such a variety of choices of other food as well. Â Today I came in here and the line was backed up and took a while to get my food as I think there were problems with the registers and receipts. Â The lovely woman behind the counter gave me a free dessert for the long wait. Â That's caring about the customer. Â Small gestures go a long way. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Omar M.
This place is awesome for lunch. Food is good from the "make a salad" to the chicken cutlets. Pizza is also good. They also have already made healthy salads as well. Doesn't get the 5th star bc i always ALWAYS have to ask for someone to help me. Fridays have specials after 4pm More...
Reviewed on Yelp
JL K.
Fresh food, quick turnover, always busy and lots of breakfast and lunch variety. Specialty sodas and snacka, especially for a barren part of the strip. Call your order in, check it before you leave. They also cater. Have gone back lots of times. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Phil M.
Holy cow this place is awesome!!I had a smokehouse turkey panini with bacon, cheddar and chipotle mayo on an onion roll and it was phenomenal. At $7.95 it is great value for your money. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Diana C.
Went here with my co workers two days in a row for lunch. Â Fresh amazing salads that only cost $6.95! Â Very tasty food and a wide variety of selections. . I'm giving it a 4 instead of a 5 bc of the long wait time at the register and also because I saw a fly in the food case. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Kerri M.
Amazing! I have worked in delis my whole life and this one is beautiful with an extensive menu! its also very cheap, $6. 99 for a panini i thought it would be little which was completely the opposite! It was huge and delicious, i couldn't decide so i ordered the tastiest looking one. The to go salads looked so fresh and delicious my friend had the Cobb it was huge! FOR $7 I couldn't believe it! the paninis go easily for 9$ and that salad was a 12$ salad. It was delicious and I loved it ! We will definitley be back for lunch, i was very impressed. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Amarilys M.
Great food and the lines are proof of it. Â Friendly service from everyone there including the owner Tim.
Reviewed on Yelp
Linda K.
Suburban Eats did a BQ at my home for my 60th birthday yesterday. They were prompt and efficient. They brought everything needed with them, down to the condiments and cheese for the burgers. The food was delicious.I highly recommend them. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Brian T.
Salad bar is fresh can get pricey with the fixings tho. Most of the other food tho looks ok salads are your best bet tho.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jared E.
Very good food and really nice staff. The owners son is very cool to. Great salads and sandwich's. The chicken cutlet is awesome and the pizza is even better
Reviewed on Yelp
Doug W.
Best in the area. Best in a lot of areas...Always busy and a bit pricey but, so worth it.A deli with the works, and not such bad pizza, all things considered. Large staff however they lack the appreciation of their customer... endless selection and daily specials, a favorite exists for everyone, go often and figure it out... I suggest calling in your order and allowing plenty of time, they need a larger drink selection but, otherwise, just enjoy.So much to say I'm having a melt down, in fact their only melt down is service. Â It's not always the most helpful, accurate, caring, or kind service but the food is fantastic!I feel I need to really sit down and write a fully immersive and comprehensive review as this was my spot for years working in the area. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Elisa R.
Warmly welcomed. Conveniently  located along route 110, delightful entryway.  Fresh salad,  fruits, desserts, chopped salad of ur choice, I see an oven maybe pizza? Fresh egg, tuna,chicken,  and a must try is their own carrot and parsnip salad Oh my! Temptation  to your palate ....give it a try warm......they thanked me for my visit. What a great way to start a day More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Christopher M.
Lunch can be pretty hectic here but if you order online the food is fresh and well composed. Â Great deli.
Reviewed on Yelp
C. C.
Ever since they opened up Suburban has been my favorite deli in the area. Â It can get a little hectic and busy but for a takeout or delivery, this place is great. Their paninis and salads are all absolutely delicious. Â If you enjoy tasty Asian pasta salads, then you have to try their Sesame chicken & pasta salad.Love eggplant? Â I recommend the Suburban Supreme panini. Looking for a sweet crunchy alternative to a boring turkey sandwich, try the Vermont Maple Turkey panini. It has a touch of almond slivers and some creamy brie... and be honest with yourself, brie makes EVERYTHING better. If no sandwich is complete without bacon, unhinge your jaw and shove their Bistro Panini in it, you'll thank me. This place works miracles. Â They somehow make Brussels sprouts awesome. Â That's right, they got me to eat freaking Brussels sprouts and like it. Â How is that even possible? Â I'll tell you how, they're magic. Â I haven't been able to prove it yet, but I'm pretty sure the house elves from Harry Potter are in their kitchen whipping up scrumptiousness for these guys. Go feed your faces there. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Jovanna T.
Went in early afternoon one Saturday. Impeccably clean, and beautifully set up - as always. I knew what I came for .. my favorite Bourbon St Panini & their amazing fries. What I love about their fries is that the "batter" on them reminds me of Checkers or Popeyes style fries and they never disappoint. I was helped immediately and waited maybe a little less than 10-minutes. I also had to help myself to a damn donut (which I didn't want to admit lol). All-in-all still very happy with one of my fave delis on Long Island! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Tonya B.
My Husband & I visited this spot for lunch this afternoon and we had such a great experience. The inside is clean and organized. The workers were welcoming and the food is great. There were so many options of what to eat it was hard to decide. Everything looked good. We did end up narrowing things down and ordered the Mesa Chicken Panini and the Bourbon St Panini. We shared them and both were very good, better than I had expected. I will definitely come back! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
NewYorker C.
This place is a must for anyone that works in the Melville area. Excellent selection of sandwiches, soups and hot entrees. The chopped salads are wonderful and always fresh. It's owned by 2 brothers who are always on site and making sure everything is running smoothly. Great, great business! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Karen B F.
4 stars for what it is. Â It is a mishmash deli. You can get prepared food or have them create something for you, there are prepared salads or you can pick a lettuce and have them pick from a variety of toppings and mix or chop them all together with your choice of dressing. Â Prepared wraps, paninis, pizzas and the like. Â Hot food and deli style side salads on the hint of healthier side. Â Today I had chicken quinoa salad and a side of roasted carrots and parsnips. Â The food is always fresh and delicious. Â Usually crowded but they handle the registers well so the line moves quickly. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Phil B.
Imagine your typical Long Island deli, but a little fancier. They have pizza, salads, and sandwiches amongst other things. Several pre made options if you are in a rush. Always a fan of the roasted chicken salad in a wrap. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Justin P.
I've been going to this deli for at least 10yrs and while the service is not like it was the food is still really great. They have the best salad bar that I have ever been to. I love to build my own salad and it seems like they have everything there is to put on a salad. There sandwiches and panini's are excellent. I highly recommend three: the Londonport pub, the 110 express, and the bourbon street. The sandwiches are always fresh and if they run out of a certain one they will offer to make one for you. I've eaten there and it's nice but most times I take out. The staff is friendly but the service is way slower than it once was. I will have to take pictures the next time. All said and done this is an excellent way to place to pick up breakfast lunch or a light dinner as there hot food is also very good More...
Reviewed on Yelp